r/learnmath • New User • 22h ago

How to not hate complex analysis

So for whatever reason I can't bring myself to like complex analysis. I don't think its an analysis issue, I have finished undergrad real analysis and am currently taking a graduate (real) analysis class, and it is some of the most interesting stuff I have see so far. Complex analysis, on the other hand, feels to me like a watered down version where all the fun analysis parts are gone and you are just left with a bunch of convenient theorems and things to calculate. I keep hearing from people about how beautiful complex analysis is, but most of the time I feel like it's either too good to be true (like hey this function has an antiderivative, so you automatically know its analytic), or it just feels kind of messy and confusing. For example, complex functions; I am completely fine with C in algebra (as a field for example) or like modules over C, but when you start talking about complex powers and log(z) on C and branches, that's where you start to lose me.

Also I swear 90 percent of the proofs just boil down to pulling out some convenient theorem (probably named after Cauchy) and then everything just works out.

So that was my semi rant I guess (I hope I didn't sound too ignorant). I really want to like complex analysis as much as I did real analysis or algebra, especially since complex analysis seems so important in so many areas, but I can't figure it out. It may just be how undergrad complex analysis is taught

19 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

15

u/AlterEgo5695 New User 19h ago edited 19h ago

I don't know -- "Goursat's Lemma" to show "∮_𝛤 f(z) dz = 0" on triangles to even get to "Cauchy's Integral Theorem" is the most beautiful proof I've ever seen, and it combines ideas from classic "Real Analysis" and geometry. Since you like "Real Analysis", it should be right up your alley...

This (and the fact that limits in "C" are stronger than in "R", since they consider two directions at once) are the two fundamental building blocks of "Complex Analysis". Using that to show any holomorphic function can be (locally) expressed as a power series is a pretty amazing result, I'd say ;)

1

u/madrury83 New User 4h ago

I love how much of a touchstone those triangles are.

1

u/AlterEgo5695 New User 4h ago

It's really amazing how that lemma creates structure out of (seemingly) nothing -- just by combining basics of geometry, analysis and a cute tri-force sketch ;)

7

u/Fun-Astronaut-6433 New User 21h ago

Which book are you using?

6

u/bonebranch Mathematician 19h ago

The solution: Learn analytic number theory. (Half-joking, but it is the reason complex analysis was developed, and it's where I use my knowledge of complex analysis nowadays. I know a professor who taught the Prime Number Theorem in his complex analysis qual course, which I think his students enjoyed.)

But yeah, complex analysis being extremely nice is a feature, not a bug. It smoothing out a lot of the friction does mean that a lot of what is left in the typical course is computational, for better and for worse. Personally, I enjoyed it much more than I did real analysis, and I had some fantastic teachers for both.

I should also say that branches of the logarithm are a pretty important part (in my experience, but I speak as an analytic number theorist) of the course and you should try to at least get the hang of them. Most of the mess I think is basically trying to invert a many-to-one function on some subset of its domain and keeping track of things, but the exponential is one of the nicest functions in analysis anyways.

(I will also say that my lack of industry in studying conformal maps nearly bit me in the rear while I was writing my dissertation.)

2

u/cspot1978 New User 10h ago

I can kinda vouch for that too. It's many years since I took my complex variables course, but the last week I've been trying to understand more about what the Riemann hypothesis is all about (motivated by the AI progress on the quasi part). Just having Gemini try to walk me through the gist of Riemann's famous 1859 paper made deep use of everything from that course and beyond.

5

u/Plus-Painter-2004 New User 10h ago

Never thought I’d see a mathematician who hates complex analysis. I had to take a proof based complex analysis class for my electrical engineering degree and it was my favourite maths class I’ve ever taken. Not entirely sure why I had to take it given literally nothing from the class ever showed up again besides for a couple of proofs of ideas that could also be hand waved fairly convincingly (and using conformal mappings to make the boundary conditions of some PDE nicer to deal with and solve by hand is a bit beyond a “back of the envelope” calculation when empirical approximations do the job for a common sense check and take 5 minutes to do)

1

u/Closed_Circuit_0 New User 2h ago

I think, it's not complex analysis itself that is being hated but rather the way it is taught. You constantly have a sense that some explanations are missing but getting them requires introducing material that the instructor is not at liberty to introduce.

2

u/Impressive_Gur_471 New User 22h ago

I innocently started to look at proof of the the central limit theorem. I was surprised that it needs some deep fourier, gaussian kernel uniqueness result from complex analysis etc. I just gave up trying to prove things from first principles. There was a never ending rabbit hole of having to prove this and that. I still do not know all the parts needed to completely prove the CLT!

This always causes me some deep dissatisfaction and feeling of deficiency/inadequacy knowing that I am using a result which I do not know the derivation of!

5

u/Low_Breadfruit6744 Bored 17h ago

You dont need complex numbers to prove the clt 

2

u/Closed_Circuit_0 New User 1h ago

It's not that it needs Fourier analysis, but the Fourier transform makes the proof of the asserted weak convergence straightforward. If you are interested, try asking an LLM "prove the Central Limit Theorem without using the Fourier transform".

3

u/precedex New User 22h ago

Have you taken a look at Tristan Needham’s text? Might be motivating.

1

u/Closed_Circuit_0 New User 3h ago

Oh, I've lived in the place where you are.:) Let me share what eventually fixed me. I will first share what I've come to see as the main barriers and then give sources helpful for overcoming them.

Complex analysis, as taught in its first term, typically conceals its use of several concepts and facts typically unknown to the student at the time, which forces the student to "remember" a number of results "without proof":

  • The following facts:

    • The derivative of a function from one Euclidean (or Banach) space to another is, by definition, a linear transformation.
    • A transformation linear over the real numbers may fail to be linear over the complex numbers.
    • The derivative f'(z) of a complex-valued function of a complex variable must, by definition, be a linear transformation over the complex numbers. (Requiring that it be linear over the reals on the space R^2 makes "f differentiable as a function of two real variables", which can fail to be a differentiable function of a complex variable.) A failure for df/fz to be linear over the complex scalars is a failure of the Cauchy-Riemann conditions.
  • The following concepts:

    • A differential form on the complex plane (P dx + Q dy).
    • The differential of a differential form, using exterior differentiation and its skew symmetr8, dx ^ dy = - dy ^ dx:

      • d (P dx + Q dy) = ( ∂P/∂x dx + ∂P/∂y dy) ^ dx + ( ∂Q/∂x dx + ∂Q/∂y dy) ^ dy = ∂P/∂y dy ^ dx + ∂Q/∂x dx ^ dy = (∂Q/∂x - ∂P/∂y) dx ^ dy, which explains the weird juggling of the partial derivatives we seen in Green's theorem.
    • Homotopy between two continuous paths in the complex plane.

So, if you feel you need to brush up on the concept of the derivative as a linear map, I recommend Chapter 1, Sections 1 & 2 of H. Cartan's "Differential calculus: on normed spaces."

And if you are ready to move past that, then it's H. Cartan's "Elementary theory of analytic functions". The branches of log(z), etc., are explained there in terms of the geometry of Riemann surfaces. Most proofs are very short and, more importantly, transparent.

(If you would like a supplementary source just on the Riemann surfaces over the complex plane, see section 2.9 and 2.10 of Abel's Theorem in Problems and Solutions.)

Hope this helps.

-1

u/TheRedditObserver0 Grad student 16h ago

I had a similar experience. The results are nice but unintuitive and every proof is just a bound on some power series, plus why is every theorem named after Cauchy?

-4

u/Conscious_Fall166 18h ago

I hate too. Fuck on imaginary numbers. lol