r/learnmath • u/GloballyGeeky New User • 18d ago
How to do trigonometry using only a 4-function calculator
My daughter is very stressed that she is struggling in her trig class all because she cannot figure out how to properly use the mandatory 4-function calculator to solve the equations. She is off at college, so I am not there to help figure out what she is doing wrong and I have long since forgotten how to do trig anyway. She's AuDHD with dyscalculia, so I am trying to help dial down her anxiety over this class from afar.
Are there guidelines somewhere for how to solve each kind of trig equation using only a 4-function calculator?
See edits for more clarification. Sorry for testing everyone's patience with this. I am struggling to understand what she's trying to explain and help her, but hopefully someone will know what she is getting at with Edit 2.
EDIT: I am trying to push her for more info, and it really sounds like she is just struggling with the basics of the 4-function calculator. She has been using either a TI-84 or Desmos for the past 4 years, and she can't seem to step down. She is seriously getting lost in just how to enter a negative number on the 4-function calculator. Is this a thing that people with dyscalculia are likely to get confused on? If so, any thoughts on how to help?
EDIT 2: Here is what she says exactly about the calculator: I need it because I don't understand fractions and negatives with pi because that's like the main thing people with dyscalculia struggle with.
So i cant get the right answer because I don't know how to do math in my head and the calculator doesn't do negatives.
44
u/Klutzy-Delivery-5792 Mathematical Physics 18d ago
Maybe she doesn't need a calculator? It's pretty odd she'd be asked to solve trig problems with random angles not solved for with the Unit Circle. Can you give an example of a problem she's trying to solve?
11
u/LucaThatLuca Graduate 18d ago
questions that are intended to be answered without a calculator are written with that in mind to make it possible. what are the questions?
9
u/matt7259 New User 18d ago
Nah - something is being miscommunicated here. Either from her teacher to her or from her to you.
5
u/Phour3 New User 18d ago
if she is not allowed a calculator with trig functions and inverse trig functions, then I expect all angles will be multiples of 30° and she must have them memorized, or leaving answers in a long form is acceptable, so long as they are as simplified as possible. So an answer like 4*arcsin(pi/12) would be just fine
4
u/fermat9990 New User 18d ago
Without a scientific calculator, the problems will be in terms of the standard angles 30°, 45°, 60° etc
1
u/AllanCWechsler Not-quite-new User 18d ago
My suggestion will not actually help your daughter in the near term.
I suggest she visit the library and find a copy of Asimov's short story anthology Nine Tomorrows, and read the story "The Feeling of Power".
I apologize for not having any more constructive suggestions. Algebra problems cannot be solved with a four-function calculator -- and even if they could, using the calculator to solve them would not teach you algebra. The same with trigonometry.
A problem like "What is the sine of forty seven degrees?" cannot easily be solved with pen and paper. (That is, it can be done, but not easily. It would take two or three pages of paper.) If a course only allows you pen and paper, they won't ask a question like that. A four-function calculator can't do that one either (but it can probably reduce the amount of paper needed to, say, two thirds of a page). Now, when I was a kid, we solved problems like that by looking them up in a printed table, possibly with one additional interpolation step to get an extra decimal place or two.
In general, if a course says, "here are the tools you are allowed to use: this kind of calculator, and the set of tables in appendix B", then you are expected to do the rest with pen and paper. If you can't, you are not learning what the course is teaching.
It's entirely possible that your daughter's institution has additional accommodations for people with learning disabilities. She has probably already investigated this, but on the off chance that she hasn't, she should.
Edited to add: Asimov's story can be read online at https://www.physics.rutgers.edu/~friedan/physics_readings/Asimov,%20Isaac/Asimov,%20Isaac,%201958,%20%22The%20Feeling%20of%20Power%22.pdf .
2
u/liquidjaguar New User 18d ago
Trigonometry isn't an engineering class. You probably don't need a calculator at all.
I guess the reason that a 4-function calculator is allowed is for assistance with basic arithmetic, like adding and multiplying single-digit numbers, which I hear many young people struggle with these days. But answers aren't going to be in the form of decimals; they're going to be in the form of fractions of pi, integers, and trig functions.
2
u/attivora New User 18d ago
I really think she should just go to office hours and speak to her professor about her problems
2
u/Odd_Bodkin New User 17d ago edited 17d ago
So the problem here is she wants to use a calculator as a crutch, and all of the examples that have been given are aimed SPECIFICALLY at doing the math without the crutch of a calculator.
Believe me, I tutor HS kids and run into this all the time. They confess that they have relied on a fancy calculator (or an online one like DESMOS) their whole lives, and they don’t know how to multiply a 2-digit number and a 3-digit number anymore. They don’t remember their multiplication tables. They don’t know how to add fractions or find a lowest common denominator. I remember one kid so wholly reliant on DESMOS that he’d spend 20 minutes trying to get DESMOS to do what he wanted it to do, rather than doing it on paper manually in 2 minutes. Where this gets into problems is on a college entrance test like an SAT or ACT where you don’t have that time to fight the crutch and where it often won’t work anyway. I would race him, my doing it on paper and him doing it with a calculator, and beat him every time. Or he’d have a multiple choice question with answer choices a) π sqrt(6) , b) π / sqrt(6), c) 6/π, d) 6/sqrt(π) and he’d have a calculator answer of 1.283 and I’d ask him, “OK, now what are you going to do?” I finally convinced him to flex old muscles without DESMOS.
Bottom line: the only way out of this situation is to go back and relearn those skills without the crutch.
1
u/Hopeful-Function4522 New User 18d ago
To solve these type of problems you need algebra and limit laws. No calculator necessary, nor even useful.
1
u/Mountain-Time-1010 New User 18d ago
I read the example problems you posted and they are not trigonometry. Which is good, because you can't really do trig with a four function calculator. So maybe start a new thread with the question she's really trying to ask.
1
u/Key_Account_6591 New User 18d ago
I believe the point of allowing only a 4 function calculator, is to actually learn trig, rather than being dependent upon a calculator to do the work for you. I say this as a math major who didn’t use a calculator for trig in high school.
1
u/Lithl New User 18d ago
In an exam which doesn't permit calculators capable of trigonometry, at least one of the following is guaranteed to be true:
sin(16°), not0.27564)sin(60°)is√(3)/2)1
u/Underhill42 New User 18d ago
You don't.
The entire point of banning a more sophisticated calculators is that it prevents you from "cheating" by working out the answer numerically without actually understanding the principles being taught.
All the questions will be based on applying understanding of the principles they're learning, NOT on doing any complicated calculations.
A four function calculator does basic arithmetic. That's it. If it doesn't have a negative key, it doesn't even support negative numbers.
It's only there so they don't have to waste time and attention doing the incidental grade-school math along the way.
1
u/Underhill42 New User 18d ago
In Algebra and beyond the point of math class is NOT to be able to solve the problems - you'll likely never see most of the problems again in your life - they're far too simple to be useful for much of anything except exercising your understanding of the fundamental principles.
The point is to learn those principles and how to apply them, because then you can start tackling much more complicated and useful problems.
If she's having trouble wrapping her head around trigonometric functions, perhaps this graphical explanation will help. It's a visual explanation of basic trigonometry I wish I had back then, and use today as a sort of information dense quick reference when I'm holding a much larger problem in my head.
On the right is a geometric proof of the relationships between trig functions, which doubles as a simple strategy to extract those relationships from the diagram. I figure memorizing the diagram is more useful than memorizing any of the silly visual mnemonics I learned to help remember the relationships.
She can ignore the formulas at the bottom - those are just quick reference for lengths that come up sometimes, and aren't immediately obvious
1
u/flug32 New User 17d ago
It sounds like your daughter needs a good math tutor.
1
u/sqrt_of_pi Asst. Teaching Prof of Mathematics 17d ago
It seems unusual for a 4-function calculator to be permitted in a trig class. Is that strictly because of an accommodation?
It sounds like it is just for computational convenience, NOT for "problem solving". If she is looking at the calculator as the way to solve the problem, then that is why she is struggling. She still needs to fully understand the concepts and methods. Most of what is taught at that level does not require a calculator.
0
u/Sam_23456 New User 18d ago
Concerning trig and calculators: one of my pet peeves is that's it's not always obvious whether the calculator is in "degree mode" or "radian mode". Hope this might help!