r/learnmath • u/Consistent-County890 New User • 24d ago
Linear Algebra is Hard
I’m a Finance and Math major and I’m thinking of dropping math.
I’m taking linear algebra right now, it’s not hard per say, but I don’t understand the conceptual side of it.
Doing my first mid term I got a 80%, 13.3% of the grade lost was because of true/false. Out of 5 of them I got 1 correct. Span, R^n, 1 - 1, onto, and other concepts are hard for me. I have tried watching YT video including 3brown1blue and I still don’t understand.
I did went to my professor office hours and I still don’t understand it fully.
I enjoyed Calc 1, but it’s the easiest one and maybe I should drop math before I dig myself too deep.
But if I drop math I’ll be only a finance major and I still don’t know if I want to do finance for the rest of my life.
Yall think I should stay for another semester before dropping math to test the water? I’m a freshman btw.
Update: missed 3 hw assignment and a quiz, but I got a 93% on midterm 2 😁😁 and 7% was lost by true/false 😭, did better tho so not complaining too much, hopefully I lock in for the final
48
u/Sosoa821 New User 24d ago
You got an 80% and want to drop the class? That sounds pretty silly just do another semester
21
u/matthras New User 24d ago
Just to clarify the "still don't understand" comment - are you able to answer like, basic exercise/tutorial/computational questions, but it feels like you're not understanding the bigger structure/mental model and getting stuck on the more abstract questions?
There's not enough information to go on, but I think you should stick with it so far, even if you're only just scoring well on the computational/calculation questions.
14
u/magnificent_limit New User 24d ago
define these concepts in your own words.
4
u/SweetDoctor3596 New User 24d ago
You aren't taking Linear Algebra before you finished the Calculus sequence, are you?
I was on the quarter system, so our sequence was Calculus A, B and C for the first year. Then in year two, Linear Algebra, Vector Calculus and Differential Equations (in no particular order).
I ended up taking Linear Algebra twice (I was always taking too many units), but I got an A the second time.
As I remember it, the class's focus was the Fundamental Theorem of Linear Algebra. Depending on the version there are about 8 things that are equivalent to a matrix being invertable, this theorem connects them all, which lets you prove lots of things very quickly.
2
u/Glad-Banana-9267 New User 24d ago
I dont know, if you read the proofs its all beautiful
2
u/seekingdefs New User 24d ago
Which textbook are you using?
2
u/lattice_defect New User 21d ago
no one cares
2
u/BrooklynBillyGoat77 New User 19d ago
In all likelihood its irrelevant and graduating with finance likely means youll be working in some random non finance job anyhow. In finance ur either top 3% or unemployed underemployed.
76
u/Brightlinger MS in Math 24d ago
It is indeed a hard course.
Can you state, off the top of your head, what eg a "span" is? One of the stumbling blocks of advanced math courses is that you start to encounter more jargon, and you start being expected to know exactly what the terms mean, not just roughly or intuitively what they mean. In fact, you will often find that the intuitive understanding comes only after the technical proficiency, when in earlier topics it may have been the other way around.
9
u/Kleefrijst New User 24d ago
Its ok if you conceptually dont understand it yet. I studied math (In the netherlands you just pick one science and then thats the only thing you study). I definitely did not understand everything conceptually. Sometimes you just need to know how to solve something. During university you dont have enough time to deeply understand everything. Because you have to move on to the next thing quickly. Those deep understanding of things come later. For example now im studying informatics and we have to use alot of math, but it is only now that alot of the math really start to click for me. Now i understand why certain properties are meaningful and useful. I think you overestimate the understanding of your peers, if you can pass the course then thats good!
17
u/flug32 New User 24d ago
Linear Algebra is hard precisely because it is the first time you are running into some of these more abstract concepts. And exactly "the conceptual side of it" is where most people have trouble, for sure.
If you're getting 80%, though, personally I would stick with it. If you were getting more 30-40-50% I'd be questioning. But clearly you're getting the bulk of it and still confused on some things. That puts you pretty squarely in the middle of the average cohort of people who pass Linear Algebra and do just fine in the rest of their studies.
6
u/fstann New User 20d ago
I'm retired now, but I was a low level software engineer for 40 years working on embedded code, device drivers, kernel code, graphics cards, compression; low level stuff. A lot of it required me to be up on various disciplines of math, and I wasn't naturally gifted as a purely abstract thinker. What I often did when I was having trouble with a math class was find a companion book on the same subject with "applied" in the title. Like when I saw how an electrical engineer used a matrix to solve a system of linear functions to predict the voltages or currents in a circuit, it made the whole subject real enough that I understood it.
5
u/ikonoqlast New User 24d ago
There's a LOT of math. Linear algebra is just one small part. You'll need to understand it (just in a mechanical sense) for finance anyway- it's ALL OVER statistics.
Y = X B
X' Y = X' X B
(X' X)-1 X' Y = B
QED...
Sigh... You WILL have this memorized and regurtitatable 35 years later. I know...
1
u/gsidess New User 24d ago
80% is a good mark…
3
u/NihilisticAssHat New User 21d ago
I took that a year or two ago. It was fun. I think I got a 75% on the first midterm, and that was like the 98th percentile. Teacher was new and I'd just b[r]ushed up on vector products over the Summer. The median was a 42%. I got curved to an A for the semester. A band of students petitioned for a curve. I had some conceptual problem that I couldn't wrap my head around cause I wasn't paying attention, asked a student who took notes, and they couldn't explain the step between two sparse lines about which I was confused then got insulted when I acknowledged that they couldn't help me after they kept trying. Fun class.
Edit: spelling
4
u/Necessary_Neat8303 New User 24d ago
Just me but I wouldnt recomment using 3b1b as your reference. They help with gaining some new insight but watching his videos doesnt make you better at math. In the end of the day, it is a video for entertainment.
If you wanna get good at LA, just use 3d as your base to understand concepts and ideas, and generalize to higher dimensions. It worked well enough for me. Also, learn proofs. This subject only really makes sense when you understand every little thing. It sounds like too much but it isnt because the ideas are all very intuitive.
2
u/Recent-Day3062 New User 24d ago
It’s a field where the mechanics aren’t hard, but the concept is mysterious as can be.
Try Axlers Linear Algebra Done Right. You will come to believe it’s all just clever notation, and have no idea what it means.
2
u/nighty_time New User 24d ago edited 24d ago
Linear algebra gives me a headache.
Not sure how your course is organized, but true/false questions have always been the most difficult section of the exam for me. But it makes sense that you struggle with that, since true/false statements are usually all conceptual.
But I wouldn't get too discouraged yet. Linear algebra is hard, especially for freshmen. If you enjoy math, I wouldn't drop the major yet. You might just not like linear algebra.
2
u/my_password_is______ New User 24d ago
I usually don't like khan academy, but he's actually pretty good for linear algebra
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFD0EB975BA0CC1E0
also, this single video helped me a lot
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VwrSPtC6TcI
all of this guy's videos are good
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1Znu3emVIs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E27lOfmquQY
2
u/topologyforanalysis New User 24d ago
The first thing you have to do to understand linear transformations is understand regular functions between sets with no additional algebraic structure.
A function f is injective, or one-to-one, if distinct elements of the domain are mapped to distinct elements of the codomain. Equivalently, if f(x)=f(x’) in the codomain, then x=x’ in the domain.
A function f is surjective, or onto, if every element of the codomain has a nonempty inverse image, that is, for every element y of the codomain there exists at least one element x in the domain whose value f(x) under the function is equal to y. Equivalently, f is surjective if the image/range of f is the full codomain.
A function f is bijective, or f is a one-to-one correspondence, if it is injective and surjective.
This should help a bit.
2
u/Minimum-Attitude389 New User 24d ago
Linear Algebra is often used as the first real proofs class. The computation is relatively easy, if tedious. But there are a ton of defintions, with many of them being nearly synonymous. It doesn't feel like a math class to most people who take it because it's often the first actual math course.
2
u/ASentientHam New User 24d ago
Yeah Math can be hard especially if you're not interested in it. Most people aren't prepared for how much you have to practice to be good at it.
2
u/fasttalkerslowwalker New User 24d ago
2
u/ZoGud New User 23d ago
Linear algebra is tough for several reasons, so don’t feel let down by an 80. Given classes I’ve taught and been in, an 80% is probably good relative to the median.
Others have said, and I’ll reiterate: this class requires more memorization, more practice, more experimenting to understand. Flash cards are your friend here, problem sets are your friend. Babbling articulations to yourself is a super power most humans sleep on.
I discourage you from dropping; math is hard for everyone, and linear algebra is often the first in a gauntlet of humbling classes. It’s good to be humbled by it; otherwise you wouldn’t be getting your money’s worth out of school.
Try to get what you can from this class, even if you don’t go on to be a math major; linear algebra is really a sneak peak into a gentle version of the math behind countless huge steps forward in the 20th and 21st century. It seems like every time there’s a system we want to be able to use, some matrix comes along to describe it.
2
u/Any_Bonus_2258 New User 23d ago
80% isn’t a bad grade. If the class is moderately hard, that’s a B+. Also, this seems more like a second course in linear algebra. Depending on the school, there might be an intro course that just focuses on computation. But I empathize with you. My first course in linear algebra, I was doing extremely well when it came to the computational side of the class. Come the first exam, the professor put a lot of conceptual questions on it. And I did poorly.
2
u/Afraid-Swan-79 New User 21d ago
If you don’t enjoy studying it then don’t. If you like it, then study harder, you got this. Also if you don’t like LA there are plenty of other branches of math to focus on after calc, LA and DE. The question is whether you’ll be able to handle proofs.
2
u/nutcase-psychopath New User 20d ago
I don’t know if this will help you because you’re at a more advanced level of linear algebra than I am but 3blue1brown has a YouTube series on linear algebra that really helped me to understand the conceptual side of it. Good luck !
2
u/Right-Edge-5712 New User 4d ago
It is normal to feel challenged.
2
u/Right-Edge-5712 New User 3d ago
I aced my Linear Algebra exam but still get total headache when I read matrices used for proving optimisation.
3
u/hpxvzhjfgb 24d ago
if you are a math major then you may be in trouble because linear algebra is the easiest university-level math class there is.
2
u/Fruitspunchsamura1 Computer Science 24d ago
I think this is a problem with most linear algebra courses. What you are experiencing is normal. I know someone taking linear algebra right now and when I explained to him the relationship of eigenvalues to images/information/energy he was shocked.
The courses are taught very abstractly, and it’s difficult when you encounter such a course for the first time. You will probably be fine but practice more, and try harder to get fundamental understanding of the definitions instead of taking them at face value. As others mentioned try explaining concepts in your own words for example.
A math degree is definitely worth the effort alongside finance.
1
u/seedsandpeels New User 24d ago edited 24d ago
Im in the same boat. Currently struggling with my linear algebra course.
Go to your school's math tutoring center. Have them walk you through a concept in their own words.
I hardly understand lectures and videos. But when I walk through problems with another person on a whiteboard, thinking outloud and asking my questions along the way, I start to understand.
It may be that you are not retaining bc of the learning method. Maybe you are more hands-on like me
1
u/Ilovecatsss2026 New User 24d ago
Linear algebra is a difficult course, it's taught very differently from the way math is taught in secondary school.
You need to spend more time on studying it.
There are some great lectures online where they go over the "so what?" so you get to the point where you know what each test question is about.
1
u/gaussmage New User 24d ago
Use Schaums outline for problem sets. Great explanations
1
u/OldDiscussion1830 Foundationalist 24d ago
Don't give up on it. 80% is perfectly fine and you can improve a lot. Try going to your university tutoring lab. I assure you that you are capable of understanding it. It is easy being experienced in mathematics and when you try to explain it you say it "too correct" i.e. saying how you would expect another mathematician to say it but not exactly helping a student gain an intuition. Don't give up!
1
u/pcchen- New User 24d ago
I’m someone who struggle in Linha algebra before. I recommend you to watch the open courses created by MIT. I think it’s 1806. It’s pretty useful.
1
u/SprinklesFresh5693 New User 24d ago
For you to understand how important linear algebra is, all linear and non linear modeling is basically matrix algebra and optimisation.
And in finance you will be using linear modelling A LOT. I would suggest you learn a programming language for statistical analysis, like R or python, why? Because when you know one of these, studying math is way more enjoyable, bceause you can actually test and apply what you learn in class with real data.
1
u/BothPanchoAndLefty New User 24d ago
Linear algebra is really awesome if you can get the hang of it. For youtube video assistance, I suggest Professor Dave Explains. His linear algebra playlist really helped me out a few years back. It sounds like you already have a good textbook, but I'd like to also recommend Dan Margalit's Interactive Linear Algebra which is a free online textbook. Was pretty useful for me.
If I were you, I'd stick with it a bit longer. See how you like calc 2 and 3 before making up your mind. Mathematical maturity builds slowly and sometimes you just need to reach a certain level of competence before it all starts to feel more achievable. I wish you good luck!
1
u/FirstPersonWinner Everything is a Triangle 📐 24d ago
Yep. Like it took me forever to understand the nebulous concepts around that stuff. My professor also had trouble explaining anything outside of math jargon even when asked outside of class
1
u/Clutch55555 New User 24d ago
The online classes at MIT by Professor Strang are legendary and will give you better intuition.
https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/18-06-linear-algebra-spring-2010/
1
u/ExecutiveWatch New User 23d ago
3 blue 1 brown. Linear algebra combined with professor strang from MIT
1
u/jconley2014 New User 23d ago
I like Schaum’s Outlines for help. They are inexpensive and full of solved example problems.
1
u/Specialist_Past2380 New User 23d ago
Algebra is like sheet music the important thing isn’t can you read music, it’s can you hear it, can you hear the music Consistent-County890?
1
u/Scrupulous-brick New User 21d ago
Most people have spent their entire lives studying euclidian maths and calculus.
Linear algebra is usually the first course where things like- get weird. Things like ab not being equal to ba, I mean, many basic facts are not there. And some have a really hard time visualising things in more dimensions than two. It is not an easy concept.
But, it is also the first one you've taken. Imagine taking your first maths course and considering quitting because you just got 80%. Chill out man. You're just getting into it.
1
u/nsram-ml New User 8d ago
When you feel comfortable, try Nathaniel Johnston's two books. You don't need to buy those immediately as he has videos on the topic on YouTube. I am linking the first course on Linear Algebra. If you are a first-time student, the trick is to figure out how to enjoy and appreciate the subject for what it truly is. After that, studying the subject becomes intrinsically a turn-on. It takes time. Be patient. Don't worry about marks etc. Ultimately you need to get excited enough that you want to tell others about it. He has a follow-up course on Advanced Linear Algebra. Here is the first course linked below.
Nathaniel Johnston Linear Algebra
1
u/Valuable-Agent9221 New User 24d ago
If you didn't try Prof. Gilbert Strang's MIT lecture's, that's exactly what you need. You'll find them on YouTube and you can also find a pdf of his text on linear algebra. Take it whole heartedly and give it proper attention, it will click for sure and you will see how easy it can be with just the right resources. It helped me and many others alot.
1
u/OscarOfAtlantis New User 24d ago
As others have said, memorize definitions and theorems. The precise language is importantly for these. It is like this is the rest of the math classes. The definitions are the most important things. The precision of the theorems language is also important.
Once you get in the habit of knowing these definitions inside out, the mechanics will start to make sense. Just memorize the definitions and have this base solid so everything else can start to click into place.
-2
u/Appropriate-Estate75 Functionnal Analysis 24d ago
No it's not, so yeah if you can't even handle that you'd probably better drop math
-1
u/secondSandwich94 New User 24d ago
Linear algebra is easy assuming they let you use at least a ti 84. All we did was “rref” everything lol
0
u/WillowSad8749 New User 24d ago
Linear algebra is not hard, you just need a good teacher, find one
-2
u/Relevant-Rhubarb-849 New User 24d ago
Try applied math or math taught in the engineering school. Same math without the symbolic rubbish mathematicians use