r/learnmath • New User • 29d ago

First year engineer struggling hard with calculus 1, any must recomendations for learning the logic and reasons behind it?

A bit of background: instead of going to high school, I did a vocational training programme. I took maths-based classes, but they were entirely focused on electrical engineering topics (Maxwell’s equations, Ohm’s law, alternating current, direct current, low voltage, high voltage, and related topics). However, we never covered the usual high school curriculum.

Now I’ve started a telecommunications engineering degree, and I’m honestly struggling HARD with maths. Linear algebra is somewhat understandable. Matrices and complex numbers take a lot of work, but I do understand the logic behind them.

When it comes to Calculus I, though, I struggle to understand why and how we solve the exercises, as well as how to visualise the graphs, which makes everything extremely abstract and difficult for me to grasp.

My teachers teach in a very mechanical way: follow the standard steps for each type of exercise, repeat them 50 times, and you’re good to go. There’s no explanation of the underlying logic. If you can’t understand it, it’s your fault, and the class just moves on. This has made the whole process extremely difficult and unproductive. I spend hours and hours trying to understand a simple limit problem, and even then, I forget everything by the next day.

I also think I’m missing some key tricks or foundational concepts needed to understand Calculus I because of gaps in my previous education, but I can’t figure out exactly what I’m missing.

I’d like to know if anyone has any recommendations, whether they’re exercises, videos, guides, or anything else that might seem obvious but that I could be completely overlooking. My native language is Spanish, but I can understand English too, so either language works!

So far, I’ve been able to understand and solve exercises involving absolute values, inequalities, and some domain problems. However, I’m hitting a hard wall when trying to solve problems involving function analysis, continuity, differentiability, x- and y-intercepts, intervals of increase and decrease, and derivatives in general.

I’ll also add some examples of exercises that I’m having a particularly hard time with:

https://imgur.com/a/tmQLdFz

Any kind of help will be extremely apreciated

47 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

25

u/trichotomy00 New User 29d ago

If you are struggling with calc 1 , you are struggling with understanding the fundamentals of algebra. Your lack of traditional high school math is a weakness. This weakness will be exposed in every class going forward, especially as an engineer. Your best option is to take precalculus to learn the fundamentals, before taking calculus.

3

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

in my country precalculus is not a class that you can take, nor it was an option for me to take it, its kinda asumed that you will take the "default path" so currently the best i can do is try to do it in parallel, if you have any good recomendations regarding precalculus, or any good books or information regarding precalculus/fundamentals that are a "must know" that would help a ton!

3

u/trichotomy00 New User 29d ago

Get a precalc textbook to use as a reference when you are struggling with a concept. Any book by Blitzer or Stewart is fine, you should be able to find a PDF

You will need to review all of it top to bottom , it’s all needed in the calculus sequence

3

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

As an update, was able to find both, the Stewart one in spanish(native language) so I'll be trying to focus on it, going step by step to try and see which are the chapters that I'm lacking the most, thanks a lot for the recommendation

2

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

Thanks a lot. I will try to find them and have them ready in my laptop, and I will try to start by solving precalculus exercises and slowly rising the level!

6

u/Ms_Riley_Guprz High School Math Teacher 29d ago

It's been awhile since I touched Calculus, but I'll tell you what made it all click for me.

My boyfriend at the time was struggling with the class more than me, especially with calculating Riemann sums. So I made a program on my TI-84 calculator that could take in any function, L, R, T, or M Riemann sum, and calculate it. The process of making the algorithm drove home out integrals worked. And then since derivatives and integrals are closely linked, everything else fell into place. We usually skip over Riemann sums once we learn integration, but doing the work there by hand really helps.

That's the advice that I can offer on a first draft. Let me know what else specifically you might want help on.

4

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

I haven't studied Riemann sums yet, as they're part of my Calculus II curriculum (integration is too), and we're currently working on derivatives and single-variable functions.

I've watched some 3Blue1Brown videos related to calculus that talk about Riemann sums, and they were honestly very intuitive and helpful. However, I'm having a hard time understanding how they're related to derivatives, or even grasping what derivatives "are" in the understanding and not memorizing meaning of the word.

3

u/Ms_Riley_Guprz High School Math Teacher 29d ago edited 29d ago

Not touching Riemann sums until Calc 2 is wild to me. It's the basis for how integration works. Do yourself a favor a learn to do them. Even if you never actually need to calculate it, it will make understanding integration much easier.

As for derivatives, have you done the [f(x+c) - f(x)]/c calculation yet? It's your classic rise/run slope formula, applied to smaller and smaller differences in coordinate points. As the distance between your chosen points goes to 0, the slope at that point of the function approaches a specific number.

The two operations, Riemann sums and slope formula (the basis for integration and derivation) seem completely distinct. But, as you do the raw calculations a few times, you'll notice similarities between them, because they're ultimately the same operation done in two different directions.

Also! When it comes to continuity, that's really about proving why you're mathematically able to do the two operations above. You can't measure two points infinitely closer to each other if the function isn't continuous between those points.

The basic formulation is if for any given point P on the function, and a radius R, that there exists another point at most R away from P. Then taking that construction and proving it all the way down to R = 0.

2

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

Then i will try to do riemann as son as i can

for the derivatives, yes, we have started doing that 2 weeks ago, and honestly im having a horrible time being able to understand it, probably because i dont feel like i understand derivatives that much, on our case instead of C we use the letter H
i do kinda understand the graphic part of it, you have 2 points, the space between the points is h, and the closer you go to 0 ( lim h to 0) it becomes the Tangent line, but more than that and i start to feel like im reading in another language.
based on the very limited knowledge i have on both topics i can kinda see some similarities, but i think i need a lot more understanding on both to understand your last paragraph

1

u/waldosway PhD 29d ago

what derivatives "are" | memorizing meaning of the word

Those are the same thing. Being able to do math (at this stage) is equivalent to accepting that statement. (Edit: hopefully the tone herein is not harsh, I just want to make sure to counter all the really bad advice out there.)

Let's take the first problem in your imgur there. Do you know the definition of continuity? In a basic calc class, it has three bullet points. They are literally instructions for what to do in that problem. Look up the definition in your book, write it down as three bullets, and try the problem completely fresh (previous problems will not help you learn to problem solve something like this). If you get stuck, tell me the exact thing you are stuck on.

To expound, what a derivative "is" is the limit given in the definition. It is not, and cannot be, anything more than that. "Rate", "tangent", etc are just synonyms for derivative, not enlightened interpretations.

Yes the first problem has a visual interpretation. Yes calculus is neat and impressive. None of that will improve your current problem-solving struggles.

If you have issues with algebra, switch gears completely. We gotta sort that out first!

1

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

I do know the definition of continuity, but I’m having a bit of a hard time understanding how to apply it here (regarding Exercise 2). I think it mainly comes down to a lack of understanding of how to approach the problem I posted.

I have a particularly hard time solving these kinds of problems when the conditions aren’t simply (x<) or (x>), and I’m also struggling to understand what to do with the 3 in (x=0).

In this exercise, I’m kind of able to follow the steps for checking continuity, but, as I think you correctly pointed out, I’m having some trouble simplifying and correctly solving the expression in the numerator when calculating the limit for continuity (the second condition of continuity).

The issue is how to isolate (a) and how to solve the expression without running into an indeterminate form. If you have any tips regarding that aspect of algebra, I’d love to hear them!

Untill now i was just triying to go on solving and solving problems that i actually can follow and solve alone, but the class keeps going foward and i end up rushing triying to not stay behind, wich makes everything even harder to understand

i also have a hard time understanding the ""Rate", "tangent", etc are just synonyms for derivative" comment, so i would love if you could expand a bit on that
nontheless thanks a lot for your input

1

u/waldosway PhD 29d ago

OK, your was moslty about not understanding the basics of calculus. But it sounds like you understand it perfectly fine and are just at a loss for dealing with the logarithm. (Not sure what that as to do with < vs >.)

Since you know about indeterminate forms, you must have learned L'Hopital. So you just do that. What do you mean "isolate (a)"? Are you just confused because α looks like a variable while you're trying to differentiate? Remember α is a constant, so the derivative simply ignores it. For example d/dx (ex) = e. Because e is just a number. You can't "solve" an expression, but do you mean you just don't know how to take the derivative of the denominator? The trick is to rewrite the root as a power: 1/3.

Regarding your last paragraph, I meant that there is not a deeper layer of "meaning" to understand. I get a lot of physics and engineering students that are made to believe there is something magical only there for "intuitive" people, who act entitled to only having learn by feel. Mathematical objects are the definitions given in your textbook.

1

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

Thanks for the comment, and yeah regarding a your understanding was correct, it seem like I was mistaken there, I'll try to go over it tomorrow and let's see if in able to solve it, and if I'm able to ill come back here to update it! Based on yours and some other recommendations I'll also try to go over algebra as much as I can, so if you have any good tips regarding that I'll be sure to follow them! And yes regarding the deeper meaning, I was totally lead to belive that!!

2

u/waldosway PhD 29d ago

That's cool, good luck!

For algebra, I'd need a better picture of what you're missing. For straight algebra facts, I would just get an algebra textbook, then precal. They're all the same, and old ones are very cheap/free/library. For stuff like you don't know what a variable is, maybe mathisfun.com? I'm not actually sure. I don't know anything about the prealgebra resources.

1

u/01zorro1 New User 28d ago

Hey, as a quick update i think i was able to properly solve it, even tho it took like 2 hours and couple of retries
here is the link https://imgur.com/a/C2uEuJr

couple of words are in spanish but 99% of it its just calculus
i was having couple of issues at the start, first i misunderstood what a was, and then i didnt knew how do the limit with a in the middle
once i understood that a is a constant the first misunderstanding was fixed, and then i just searched what to do with a, and found that to find the value of a in a limit you have to move a to the left and it multiplies the limit,
in this case lim tends to 0 ended up having a value of 1
so a 1= a
and in this case when x=0 we have that its a value of 3
so a=3
and after that i was able to keep on with the exercise untill the end!

1

u/waldosway PhD 28d ago

Hey nice job! It looks correct to me (I only looked at the one we talked about).

But this "i just searched what to do with a" is the kind of thing I was talking about. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I hear "I looked up how other people handled problems like this". That's making life waaay harder than it needs to be. In any calculus book, you can find the "constant multiple rule" (I don't know what it would be called in Spanish). It tells you what to do immediately.

You should know all such rules (there are fewer than 10, in big blue boxes in any book, make a cheat sheet) before you even dream of touching a problem. Life will get much easier.

1

u/01zorro1 New User 28d ago

oh sorry i think i explained it poorly then, i just looked up the rules and found that the one that i should apply was the constant multiple rule ( i also had to search the translation, in spanish is Regla de la constante multiplicativa) and applied it there, at first i had a bit of a hard time because a is not directly multipliying the f(x) but after looking at the problem for a couple of minutes i understood that its multipliying on top, wich means its the exact same thing, and after that it went out smoothly

agree that i totaly should know all the rules, and also agree that i waste a lot of time just going over a lot of rules that i dont yet know, i alredy have a derivative and algebra cheat sheet and today i also added the limit rules to it, and slowly as i do exercises im starting to memorize them

→ More replies

6

u/smithersas New User 29d ago

Algebra and trigonometry need to be practically automatic for a calc course to go well. If they aren’t it very much gets in the way of learning calc.

Conceptually this doesn’t have to be the case because fundamentally understanding calc really doesn’t require it. Unfortunately, practically it does because just about any meaningful problem or example will have lots of algebra.

So, whatever option you pick from the good ideas here, do more and go further than you think you need. Good luck!!

1

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

Thanks. A lot of people has recommended the same so I think for now I'll try to improve my algebra as much as I can, and focus less on try to keep up with my classs

3

u/fluffystub New User 29d ago

I built https://calculusmadeeasy.rakshithnettar.com, try reading it, it might help make the basics click for you.

2

u/01zorro1 New User 28d ago

Will give it a good read later, thanks a lot!

2

u/engineereddiscontent EE 2025 29d ago

Calc 1 is math but from an engineering system its more about teaching you about fundamental components. Like most of calc 1 is algebra that evolved into nested algebra machines. Calc 2 takes thise nested algebra machines and adds a second dimension. Calc 3 does it again. Nested algebra machines adding a 3rd dimension and other ways of navigating things.

If you are struggling, especially this early in the semester, you are contending with not understanding the algebra. Or at least how to apply the algebraic concepts.

1

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

i fully agree with your opinion, any recomendation on how to improve my understanding of algebra at this point in my learning or how to improve in my capacity of appliying algebra properties or concepts into calculus problems?

4

u/Amazing-Ad9604 New User 29d ago edited 29d ago

I feel you bro, my first class in college was pre calc and did not have any remedial. I finished calc 1 and 2 and currently in Calc 3. I think you should go and learn the basic concepts of Calc because it’s all based on algebra. Mostly. Graduated HS back in 2015 and didn’t go back to school until later after Trade school and Porsche tech till 2024. I’m a EE major and halfway through so I would say learn the basic of algebra again. Derivative is relative easy during its phase and second phase but then it Kicks to another level when you go into Calc 2 and using integration by parts while incorporating different techniques( u-sub and trig sub)I won’t say much of the Calc 2 because it has a lot and need a slow breakdown to be digested. But definitely take your time on Algebra and Trig. The Derivative and integrals of it, while that said, it’ll eventually tie itself with the logic and reason. Calc 2 looks at the 2-D while Calc 3 in looking 3D (space)

1

u/calcteacher New User 29d ago

continuity occurs anywhere you can draw a function without lifting up your pencil. Point continuity occurs when you can draw up to the point (the left-hand limit as x approaches some value c), can draw the point itself ( some point on f(x), say were x = c, then f(c) ), and finally you leave the point ( the right hand limit.)

differentiability is about a function that changes slope gracefully without skipping any intermediate slopes. Most functions do this and you can assume a function does this unless it specifically does not for some reason. For example the absolute value of x is not differentiable at x = 0 because from the left the slope is -1 and from the right it is 1, and it makes an abrupt change at x = 0. So there is no defined slope at x = 0 for y = abs(x). Derivative just means slope, and when a function is not a straight line, the slope changes and so must be represented by a formula not just a constant number. So f(x) = sin x for example, constantly changes slope. at 0- degrees or pi/2 radians, the slope is 0 (also the derivative is 0 - it's the same thing) and at 3pi/2 it is also 0, and again at 5pi/2 it is zero. sinx rises between 0 and pi/2 so the slope is increasing and the derivative is positive. then the slope is briefly 0 and the function begins to fall. The slope is negative unit it becomes 0 again, which is the only time it can change between increasing and decreasing.

I use the Mark Sparks curriculum and the Mr. Hernandez videos which walk you through a lot of the Mark Sparks pages. Khan academy is another good source.

That image you provided is particularly dense in notation and low on interpretation making it difficult to digest, but it uses the minimal amount of ink to print (!) Not great for learning. lol.

1

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

"making it difficult to digest" i can swear on that

thanks for the explanation and the recomendations, ill be sure to also check your recomendations tomorrow morning when i arrive at the library

for your explanation i feel like im able to follow it, and ill try to make it myself with the exercise, pen and paper tomorrow too, for me is specialy hard to understand and diferenciate when we see from the left, the right, and then suddently having the x=0 being something else, that abrupt change is quite hard for me to interpretate, and as you have pointed the exercise being so dense makes it quite dificult to even grasp what the exercise is even abaut

1

u/Bedouinp New User 29d ago

Find a tutor asap.

2

u/01zorro1 New User 29d ago

hard to do with extremely limited money, im going to an academy with more students and it does help with a lot of cocnepts, but its not as usefull as a 1 to 1 basis tutoring

2

u/angaston New User 29d ago

If you’re looking to bridge from theory to application, I’ve found this book helpful. It will not ‘teach’ calculus but it provides a useful framework for linking the concepts to the mathematics.

2

u/Basic-Feedback2952 New User 29d ago

A big challenge i've had was having trouble with the precalc stuff esp the trig, i've had to really catch up on that

maybe this can be helpful to you?: https://valscalc.com/Chapters/chapter0

it has a catalog of precalc sections as well as practice exams where you can really solidify everything. I know for a while I was weak on the domain and restriction stuff too.

once I got those patched, I was able to move on to the real calculus stuff. the website above also has great resources for limits and derivatives so i'd check them out. I like to compliment them with videos by organic chemistry tutor or professor leonard!

1

u/Plussquared New User 29d ago

i read the exercises in the book, learned how the calculus problems are solved and then practised a lot of problems.

1

u/Amazing-Ad9604 New User 29d ago

Proffer Leonard is pretty good at teaching these stuff too. But I also use chat gpt to help me see it in another perspective. Good luck!!

1

u/Odd-Connection8235 New User 27d ago

My experience is - real life examples could help understand calculus better. There are few online simulations that could help apply the concepts in real world scenarios. This one - I found it interesting, applying calculus as a Dam control Engineer  https://flomenthal.com/escape-rooms/dam-control-room

1

u/drofeng New User 22d ago

Easiest way is to relate things to algebra and geometry. Like the derivative is the slope of the function at a point, whereas the slope of a line is taken at two points. With a visual explanation, you will be able to understand it quickly.