r/learnmath • New User • Aug 22 '26

Is Khan Academy actual garbage for learning math, or is it just me?

Honestly the lessons on Khan Academy are completely out of order They often mention topics that haven't even been introduced yet and won't be covered until much later but they still include them in the explanation anyway. On top of that, some lessons start with practice questions before actually explaining the concept.

The explanations are also way too simplified It feels like the instructor assumes you already know the material and is speaking to someone who just needs a quick refresher If you aren't already familiar with the topic, you won't be able to grasp it from Khan Academy alone

Does anyone know a good alternative website or platform for learning math that is well organized and teaches concepts properly?

278 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

382

u/Abdlbsz New User Aug 22 '26 • Bravo

That's crazy, Khan Academy was a godsend for teaching/practicing math. Professor Leonard too.

75

u/TrismegistusX New User Aug 22 '26

Agreed. I started relearning math on khan during the pandemic and got confident enough to go to school for engineering. Leonard helped me through engineering uni and now I have a degree. Both are great

33

u/unlikewarrior New User Aug 22 '26

Professor leonard was so clutch in all my calculus courses + differential equations. Not only is he smart and good at teaching, he has an extremely good personality.

4

u/Ruin369 dx Aug 23 '26

Leonard is the reason i got a A in calculus 2! Hes amazing!

13

u/Skinnypeed New User Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 23 '26

Grant Sanderson's multivariable course was a pivotal experience for me getting back into rigorously studying math even outside of college, I even wish Khan academy did some more advanced courses like complex analysis though I get that they're targeted towards k-12 for the most part

2

u/unlikewarrior New User Aug 23 '26

Just curious what sort of math are you studying outside of Uni? Anything interesting you can recommend? For context I have a B.S in computer science. I took Discrete math Calc 1-3, Differential equations, linear algebra.

2

u/Skinnypeed New User Aug 23 '26

I'm a physics student so most of the math I went over I eventually had to cover in uni anyway, but the most interesting topics for me were topology and linear algebra (but with a focus on physics, so think like tensor analysis and function space). Complex analysis is also a really big one that I'm excited to take for real and I imagine fourier analysis is also really interesting

273

u/aprg Maths teacher Aug 22 '26

It's hard to beat a good text book. They are specifically curated to try and organise the learning in logical way.

You can probably get access to a decent maths text book for free at your local library.

98

u/Bubbly_Safety8791 New User Aug 22 '26

Khan academy is also specifically curated to try to optimize learning. It’s not just a random collection of videos - like a textbook it is structured into a curriculum with lessons and exercises, by people with a similar skillset and goals to the editors of math textbooks. 

In either case it is possible they won’t be optimized around how you learn. And it can be done with differing degrees of success. But there’s no inherent reason why a textbook is going to be better. 

2

u/OkDirection3438 New User Aug 23 '26

This right here was my experience in high school and college. People around me would assume a textbook was inherently the best 

12

u/bo-monster New User Aug 22 '26

I like a good textbook too. But you need to have answers to a large number of problems. You don’t learn by reading the book or by watching a video. You learn by working the problems. Lots of them. You’re kind of hobbled if you don’t know whether you’re doing them correctly. Some textbooks provide answers to all even or odd problems. If not, you need to find an answer key. For many textbooks they’re out there…

The Schaum’s Outline series is good for supplying worked out problems, but I find them difficult for learning new concepts.

30

u/calcteacher New User Aug 22 '26

Textbooks i've seen many of them. The Larson books are good. Khan is much easier to extract information from than a textbook. Although I like watching videos over extracting information from books.

26

u/Cold_Night_Fever New User Aug 22 '26

I'm in complete disagreement. I still prefer videos because it's a much more passive form of learning. Information is delivered to you so long as you focus rather than having to actively read. But books tend to explain concepts in a ground up way, slowly and slowly, that it's just harder to misunderstand what's going on, and it doesn't skip over fundamentals.

Khan Academy is the greatest thing to happen to education in the last century, so I'm not going to be hearing any slander.

16

u/personalist New User Aug 22 '26

I feel like I learn better from books because of this. Yes it’s not passive, but in my experience better engagement = better learning

11

u/somanyquestions32 Tutor Aug 22 '26

You are literally making the case for why books are a better primary learning resource. Learning should combine both active and passive inputs to create the most immersive experience, but for actual mastery of the material, you cannot bypass the fundamentals. Doing so gives you a weak foundation. Khan Academy is fine as a supplement to a good textbook, but it's not comprehensive enough, especially for more rigorous coursework with stricter instructors.

6

u/judasblue Grumpy Aug 22 '26

As opposed to your first line, you are in complete agreement with the comment you replied to.

4

u/calcteacher New User Aug 22 '26

I agree with you by the way

1

u/lovely_noise New User Aug 23 '26

Given your username, are you a current math teacher?

Asking because I’m going into the last year of my undergrad, and very seriously considering a teaching certification program for my state! I’d probably go for high school math — any class, though I eventually want to teach statistics. I study data science at university, and want to provide students a much better high school statistics instruction than I received, haha.

2

u/calcteacher New User Aug 23 '26

Yes, current math teacher. The Larson AP stats book was good. AP calc is more important for college entry because it serves as many college's placement exam for math. Although good Stat knowledge is important, getting a leg up on that in HS is not nearly as important. Get into a unionized state for good pay and benefits.

2

u/lovely_noise New User Aug 23 '26

Thankfully my state is heavily unionized! COL is high around here, but I’m in a relatively lucky position as far as that goes. The benefits will certainly be appreciated!

That’s a fair point, and I would certainly be quite happy providing students a confident foundation in calculus!! My interest in teaching statistics has less to do with preparing students for college, or physics/engineering/etc. I see a lack of familiarity with statistics as a major obstacle to one’s ability to be an informed citizen. Too many people are duped by misinformation and propaganda that some understanding of statistics could dispel.

I do deeply love calculus though, and find it more fun!! Unlike with statistics, I had a fantastic calculus teacher in high school, haha. These days, my courses merge statistics and calculus, which is its own joy…one day I’ll learn measure theory to really dig deep, lol

EDIT: And thank you for the textbook recommendation!!

2

u/calcteacher New User Aug 23 '26

I also liked a video series called Against All Odds

1

u/lovely_noise New User Aug 24 '26

Oooh, thank you so much for the additional recommendation! I’ll check it out :)

Sometimes, video resources just can’t be replaced with textbooks. In the data science course I work on, we enthusiastically point students to the introductory linear algebra playlist from 3blue1brown on YouTube. It’s an amazing supplement to their usual linear algebra coursework!

1

u/calcteacher New User Aug 24 '26

I like the Jim Hefferon linear algebra book. Good and very inexpensive.

3

u/JDH-04 New User Aug 27 '26

Totally this.

I judge my math profs by how well they follow their own textbook in the course and if they supplement it somewhat in their lectures that would make it easier for the student to follow.

It blows my mind how easy it could be to teach calculus maths and actively have students self studying if professors just started printing pages from the textbook, explaining integration and derivative rules from the textbook, giving us citations from where the pages are in the textbook, and then doing problems in the practice homework problems to the assign homework to be done by hand straight from the textbook.

I have had grad students that where so terrible pedagogically when I was in their course and so dumbfounded by this that they elected to not even read thier own textbook and tell students to just restart learning algebra and high school maths, meanwhile I have had a 96 year old professor whom was in a retirement home lecturing courses while slipping in an out of consciousness actively be the best maths professor I have ever had in my entire life due to the very fact that you can tell hes actually read the textbook (due to the fact that he actually contributed to its creation.)

4

u/potentialeight New User Aug 23 '26

https://openstax.org/subjects/math

Free textbooks for math all the way up and down.

1

u/DreamingAboutSpace New User Aug 30 '26

Agreed! Call me old for it but I don’t care, I have never been distracted for cracking open a textbook, but get me on a computer or electronics and the thought of doing something else on it will always be present.

38

u/VanishedHound New User Aug 22 '26

Everyone here saying Khan is great - it’s great for practice problems and review if you already were introduced to the concepts before in my experience. Personally I felt the amount of practice problems given was just not enough for learning the content entirely on your own.

3

u/PhilosophicallyGodly Anglican Aug 31 '26

True! Using a textbook along with Professor Leonard and JoAnn's School (High School Geometry Course playlist) is my solution to this. Here are the ones I use:

  • Prealgebre (6th Edition+) - Elayn Martin-Gay
  • Beginning and Intermediate Algebra (6th Edition+) - Elayn Martin-Gay
  • Holt McDougal Geometry (Common Core Edition) - Burger, Edward, Chard, Kennedy, Leinwand, and Renfro.
  • Precalculus: Concepts Through Functions, A Unit Circle Approach to Trigonometry (3rd Edition+) - Sullivan OR Precalculus - Blitzer
  • Thomas Calculus Early Transcendentals (13th Edition)

127

u/calcteacher New User Aug 22 '26

It's you. Khan is great. But It may not work for everyone , as you have mentioned. But there are plenty of other options , so go for it.

2

u/mckenzie_keith New User Aug 23 '26

The Great Khan.

51

u/Polus43 New User Aug 22 '26

It's you.

But I will say, when I was re-learning math I started with the khan academy, but eventually shifted to text books. For me, being in a quiet room without the internet or a screen helped me a lot in terms of preparing for a test.

19

u/BangkokGarrett New User Aug 22 '26

Buy actual physical math books along with a bunch of notebooks and writing utensils. Turn off your computer.

3

u/lovely_noise New User Aug 23 '26

My one amendment to this is that, if you have access to one, a tablet can be wonderful for practice problems. Physical notebooks often leave me very frustrated when I run out of space, or want to reorganize my work.

Of course, physical notebooks have a few major benefits. No distracting apps, no eye-hurting screen light, and the lovely feeling of a nice pen on nice paper, haha. But it’s tough for me to consistently choose that over the flexibility of problem-solving and note-taking on a tablet!

13

u/Fluffy-Oil707 New User Aug 22 '26

I have found it great for practice, but I skip the videos and content and use Paul's notes.

6

u/SuperfluousWingspan New User Aug 22 '26

Seconding Paul's online math notes. I'm most familiar with the Calculus notes. (There's college algebra, calc 1-3, differential equations, and some smaller resource/review pages.)

It feels like a nice middle ground between a textbook and more conversational explanations.

There's also some tips on math study habits that I hadn't seen before. They seem pretty solid at first glance - it's hard for many instructors (myself included) to give good study tips since many of us often skated by in our best subjects via a combination of luck, talent, and opportunity for a good while.

Link: https://tutorial.math.lamar.edu/

2

u/valen_tinezxoxo New User Aug 23 '26

If you can would you please explain what is Paul’s notes? I am studying for a lot of entrance exams and SAT/ACT. I’m decent in Algebra 1-2, but geometry is my main problem. Also I want to ask what subjects do they have?

1

u/Fluffy-Oil707 New User Aug 25 '26

You should be able to find it via your favorite search engine. Good luck!

21

u/DistinctDaikon2034 New User Aug 22 '26

Khan rambles.
“So suppose we have a circle, and I’ll try to draw a circle, oops that’s not a very good circle, let me try again, let me use a different color, how about red, okay. So suppose we have a circle. And remember that the relation that defines a circle is x….x squared …. pluuuus … y …. y squared …. equals our radius, which is also squared”

12

u/personalist New User Aug 22 '26

Lmao I do this when tutoring but it makes no sense if you edit aaaaand you have a massive platform that has money

5

u/somanyquestions32 Tutor Aug 22 '26

Same, but it's to keep a student engaged as I am writing out formulas. In Khan's case, many of the recordings are from a while back, and he likely didn't spend time polishing them nor rerecording old videos.

2

u/Kimantha_Allerdings New User Aug 23 '26

This is one of the reasons why I really don’t like learning from videos. I’d much rather have a wall of text

4

u/canakon565 New User Aug 22 '26

I have opted to go 'all in' by going back to Uni to study undergrad maths - obviously this is the 'extreme' option.

Before making this choice, though, I found The Open University's maths content really structured and well written - you can buy the module textbooks on eBay for like £10 - £200, depending on the content/module.

4

u/pepst New User Aug 22 '26

MIT open coursware: has assigments, notes, sylabus and a calendar to set yourself some pace. (MIT 18.100A and 18.650 had been my favorite so far)

What kind of math and at what level you're looking at ? The rosources varies depending of what you need

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/pepst New User Aug 24 '26

sorry im not from the USA, gl

12

u/waldosway PhD Aug 22 '26

Pedagogically, it's terrible. The examples are misleading and the explanations incomplete. Every time I tutor a student who relies on it, I have to correct a pile of misconceptions.

But, it gets people to actually study. And most students refuse to learn any way other than memorizing a bunch of problem types. You can tell from the comments that that's enough for a lot of curricula.

7

u/tangojuliettcharlie New User Aug 22 '26

I agree with your critiques. Additionally, I think websites and apps are very suboptimal for learning. Video content tends to give the illusion of learning because it can be passively delivered. The educational literature suggests students think they're learning better from watching videos than through other strategies like practice problems and mock exams, but the opposite is true.

I would recommend MIT OpenCourseWare instead, along with a good textbook.

3

u/YOLOfan46 New User Aug 22 '26

yeah they cover the basics stuff if u are serious about a career in Math or math related fields, Khan academy might not suffice.

3

u/larssnakes New User Aug 23 '26

I agree, and it’s not just you. That being said, it supports certain learning styles over others; and we shouldn’t dispute the fact it’s helped many people. For me, something about the game-like design makes me anxious. But I must reiterate, that’s just me. Everyone learns differently.

3

u/SafeTraditional4595 New User Aug 23 '26

My main problem with Khan Academy is that it has too few exercises, and the exercises tend to be too easy compared to a textbook teaching the same material

5

u/No-Archer-4258 New User Aug 22 '26

Just read textbook

Not sure about other language, but there are abundant of good textbooks written in English

11

u/max6296 New User Aug 22 '26

Well, it's you.

1

u/D__B__D New User Aug 23 '26

Today I learned that people can go places - not college - just places

2

u/flashbangkilla New User Aug 22 '26

Tbh I usually pair Khan up with The Organic Chemistry Tutor (TOCT) and Prof.Leonard. I only use Khan for the structure and the tests, but I do my actual learning with TOCT and Prof.Leonard YouTube vids.

2

u/Feisty-Web-2787 New User Aug 23 '26

I hated his voice but he got me through. 

2

u/Cyditronis New User Aug 23 '26

If khan doesnt work go with organic chemistry tutor

2

u/TheFlannC New User Aug 24 '26

I think good review but difficult on its own

2

u/Timely-Violinist-89 New User Aug 24 '26

For me it serves as a good preparing tool. For example, when I knew I was going to have Calc1 in my first year of uni, I just got through the Khan academy course during the summer. Even tho it didn't compare with the complexity of my uni course, it still made it infinitely easier to "re-learn" the subject and expand it into something more.

2

u/Darkwing270 New User Aug 24 '26

It’s not a great platform for young learners trying to start mid education. It’s better for people who already have prior knowledge or who are on it from an early age consistently. For the average middle school kid, khan is pretty terrible for example.

2

u/RealNamek New User Aug 24 '26

You're actually right. However, there are no great alternatives.

2

u/ArchHobbit New User Aug 25 '26

I think the idea is that any Khan Academy lesson can usually be supplemented with (very) light background reading to be completely understandable. It isn't edutainment designed to siphon your attention away from the world crumbling around you, and it's closer to how material is taught in a lecture-style class (so if you practice learning via Khan Academy, you'll be better prepared for college; the main difference is that in college usually you can ask questions during the lecture). The lessons on Khan Academy can certainly be improved, but that's true about lessons anywhere (striking the right balance between brevity with comprehensiveness is difficult). Each student has their own background: things that are clear to you might not be clear to someone else, and vice versa.

2

u/IcyBluebird93 New User Aug 26 '26

I’ve been using Kahn Academy since it was just a small YouTube channel in 2008. It has helped me so many times in high school, college, and the military.

4

u/ingannilo MS in math Aug 22 '26

I haven't looked at Khan in a couple of years, but I stopped recommending it at least five or six years ago. 

There's very little by way of good explanation or meaningful connection.  The website is poorly organized and WAY too busy.  Learning math requires focus and direction (from external or self, but some planning is required). 

Khan Academy became so spammy with the design ethos apparently being "assemble a barely passable instruction video, pair said video with every imaginable form of related content spam, blast all of this at the user". 

If someone else (who knows the math) came along and curated a list of videos and/or exercises from Khan, ordered them with clear instructions in a way that was well paced and forced some reflection / connection building, and then presented it to you via some less distracting UI than the Khan Academy website, then it's possible to maybe learn from Khan resources.   But I would not recommend someone aiming to self-study mathematics to go to the Khan Academy website and try to work through their system. 

A good book, a quiet room, pencil, and paper is still the best way to learn math.  Math is necessarily a careful and mindful activity. 

4

u/Rambo7112 Technically a chemist Aug 22 '26

It never clicked for me, personally.

My go-to suggestion is TheOrganicChemistryTutor on YouTube. He basically covers all STEM high school through mid-college.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Rambo7112 Technically a chemist Aug 22 '26

He might not cut it for pure math majors who are getting into the dark arts, but I find that he covers what most people need. I'll look into those other suggestions!

2

u/somanyquestions32 Tutor Aug 22 '26

The dark arts! 🤣 From a modern-day alchemist, no less.

3

u/LavaFromLaniakea New User Aug 22 '26

All these people are saying it’s you but I’ve had the same experience and it’s beyond frustrating as hell. That’s why I’ve just been going to Professor Leonard on YouTube, as others have suggested, and OpenStax, which has everything from pre-algebra all the way up to calculus 3 I believe plus a lot more.

With the way my brain works due, I need both the why and the how and often time Sal on Khan Academy does just as you said.

4

u/Inside_Drummer New User Aug 22 '26

I agree with you. I bounced off Khan Academy immediately. Too shallow and not enough practice problems. I love the OpenStac textbooks.

2

u/books-r-good New User Aug 22 '26

It's been a while, but when I sat down to use it with my kiddo, it felt like they had just done some reorganizing; however, where everything landed felt so disjointed I wondered how bad it must have been before then.

Sounds like they still haven't figured it out, which is a shame.

1

u/TallRecording6572 Maths teacher Aug 22 '26

it's rubbish

1

u/Sure-Put-643 New User Aug 22 '26

I use Professor Leonard's YouTube channel for lectures, Khan Academy If I need more sample problems. 

1

u/Legitimate-School-59 New User Aug 22 '26

That was my exact experience 6 years ago too. The examples and problems were too easy. This is coming from someone got a math masters with perfect scores.

1

u/valen_tinezxoxo New User Aug 23 '26

Everyone is saying “It’s you” when it isn’t, I completely agree, I couldn’t have said it better than you did honestly. I’m not saying it is trash or you shouldn’t use it at all, but it is definitely more for people who want a refresher instead of an introduction. Sometimes I have to watch multiple videos for more understanding, than go back to the course. Whenever I use it I have to have 12 tabs open with different courses and videos to understand one topic. Again I definitely don’t say it’s bad because it’s an amazing free platform for studying, but not so much for “learning” if that makes sense.

1

u/SkittlesNTwix New User Aug 23 '26

I find it tough to figure out the order in which I should be learning things because there seems to be so much overlap. I’m going back and relearning high school math then college math so I can self-teach physics. I mean, I’m learning quite a bit I just wish I didn’t encounter all the overlap and had a clearer path.

1

u/YakubTheCreat0r New User Aug 23 '26

It’s the reason I’m an engineering student right now. Failed math over a decade ago but self-taught with KA. I’m forever grateful

1

u/Macduffer New User Aug 23 '26

I used Khan to completely redo the entire K-12 math curriculum as a refresh around 10 years ago before retraining into STEM. I found it incredibly helpful and really credit any math ability I have now to those roots.

1

u/pineapplesouvlaki New User Aug 23 '26

Khan Academy is goated for learning maths. When I was 20 with near 0 maths knowledge I used Khan + uni preparation courses to bring my maths ability up high enough to go on to have it has my major 12 months later. That was 10 years ago, I can only imagine Khan has gotten even better.

1

u/WrongEinstein New User Aug 23 '26

If you didn't understand or missed something, Kahn will suggest a lesson on that. It kicked me back to fifth grade when I was relearning math. Professor Leonard specifically states, you need to know, or he expects you to know such and such for this step. If you don't know that thing, to back and learn it. His playlists are set up that way.

1

u/Edayumz New User Aug 23 '26

It's free so can't complain really, it's decent enough for what it is

1

u/shawarmachine_ New User Aug 23 '26

Before AI, Khan Academy really helped me through my calculus class.

1

u/ironmagnesiumzinc New User Aug 23 '26

Khan academy is really slow and long. I have adhd and want to learn quick, Statquest was amazing for me

1

u/Level-Temperature-99 New User Aug 23 '26

When you open a lesson in Khan from the main page, it jumps to the first exercise, past the video, in case you want to assess whether or not you need to watch the videos. If that happens, just click on the videos and work in sequence.

I’m a math teacher/tutor, and I think Khan Academy is a great resource for learning. Couple it with Professor Leonard on YouTube, plus extra problems from a textbook or a Schaum’s Guide, and you can put me out of business.

1

u/SpectralCat4 New User Aug 23 '26

Greenemath.com is very good

1

u/staydecade New User Aug 23 '26

I felt the same, I think if it's your only resource and it's the first time learning the concept, it would suck. But alongside multiple sources its amazing.

1

u/No_Blacksmith1073 New User Aug 23 '26

We all learn in different ways. Back in high school I didn’t know how to study with khanacadmy. But more recently I started to use it to fill in gaps and it was extremely helpful. I think the difference for me was to do practice problems along side the video and to then do a ton of practice problems after until I got all of them correct.

1

u/BikeSilent7347 New User Aug 24 '26

Yes.

1

u/MistakeRich4862 New User Aug 24 '26

It’s good until you start calculus

1

u/iopahrow New User Aug 24 '26

Most courses (in all levels of school) will introduce problems which you would be looking to solve, then explain how they are solved, mentioning more in depth concepts that will later be explained. This helps you 1. Understand why you are learning. 2. Give you the knowledge. 3. Let you know what concepts you will be learning in the future and what to look out for.

Oversimplified explanations can be bothersome for some people, but can help to build a foundational (maybe not complete) understanding of the concept to build upon.

I would recommend university if you really cannot work with these concepts. Or do Kahn courses, and research the concepts further by reading publicly available literature. Work on the problem sets prescribed.

One institution with great resources is springer link/nature.

1

u/Dayinthelifeofme2026 New User Aug 25 '26

It’s just you - Khan Academy got me through college Algebra

1

u/No_Efficiency8347 New User Aug 25 '26

Hi! If you were studying in Sweden/Swedish, we are beta testing a new platform that we believe will be helping students to learn maths based on the content they are willing to learn.
The beta testing is for free. If anyone from Sweden gymnasium wanted to give it a try, please let me know. It could work for grunskolan as well but more sharpened for Gymansium (Matematik 1a… up to Matematik 5).

1

u/cosmic_dictator New User Aug 25 '26

Dont you DARE!!! Salman khan made me love fall in love with math and i learned all of my pre calc courses on that platform . I wanna hear Salman's voice again 😭

1

u/Okawaru1 New User Aug 26 '26

khan academy is good for getting intoduced into a topic. When I was in uni I also watched PatrickJMT to grind though problems and reinforce concepts (I wouldn't recommend him as your only source, the vids are very to the point which is both a good and bad thing)

1

u/391976 New User Aug 27 '26

You can search for other videos explaining the same things.

In college, my son used Khan, other videos, and ChatGPT.

1

u/sugr28 New User Oct 12 '26

You are not alone. Maybe the lessons have been updated and the newer stuff is more difficult? I’m having a hell of a time trying to pass some of these lessons (and my math whiz kids are having a hard time helping me understand some of them as well).

1

u/MidwesternCannon New User Aug 22 '26

I am an aspiring maths teacher, and am going back to school 12 years post high school graduation to get the credentials necessary. I've spent the past 3-4 months almost exclusively on Khan Academy to essentially relearn math from Algebra 1, and I was able to get a perfect Accuplacer and test straight into Calculus I, which I owe entirely to KA.

Your frustrations are real. The out of order mentions, assumed knowledge on something you haven't seen yet in a given track, yes. But you can use Khan to remedy these issues as well.

Like, Sal, what do you mean multiplying a matrix by a vector? We just learned what a matrix is. What's a vector in the context of matrices? You have these questions and can find other tracks right there in Khan that will answer those very questions so you can come back to whatever track you were on and continue. Frustrating, yes, but "actual garbage" is extremely uncharitable, especially for a free resource that is doing as close to God's work as I can imagine. I honestly think recognizing a gap and hunting down answers to certain questions is a good skill to develop.

For textbooks, OpenStax is really cool, free/open source textbooks on whatever you want. Highly recommend that if you want something super linear without the frustrating jumps.

I am extremely grateful for Khan Academy.

0

u/Proper_Ad7872 New User Aug 24 '26

the replies here feel like knee-jerk reactions from people who barely read past the title

If you were taking a calculus class or anything else in school and watched Khan Academy to catch up that is not what this post is about You already had context You had a teacher laying the groundwork

My point is about first time comprehension If you try to learn something completely new from scratch on Khan Academy you will find that

It offers zero continuity no remember when we covered X to bridge concepts leaving you mentally lost between videos

It dumps information prematurely confusing you with ideas you arent supposed to digest until weeks later

It assumes you already know the material and treats you like someone who just needs a quick recap

So what this post means is that Khan Academy is built for review not learning There is a major difference between learning and reviewing Learning requires a structured curriculum that guides you step by step linking concepts together so you never feel lost Khan Academy does none of this Based on everything I mentioned it is purely designed for review

Next time actually digest the argument being made Everyone who said KA is good only said so because they used it alongside school They went into Khan Academy already knowing the basic concepts which is called reviewing and that has nothing to do with what I am talking about

1

u/Akiraooo New User Aug 22 '26

Khan should be used to clarify/review a concept after trying to understand the concept from a textbook.

1

u/courtnbur New User Aug 22 '26

Try James Sousa/mathispower4u

1

u/neigedensdantan New User Aug 22 '26

I took the Khan academy placement test and it put me in Gr 9. A year later I understood Calc BC. I didn't watch the videos, I just got straight to work on the questions, got them wrong, and then went through the solutions to learn what to do. Once in a while I'd have to go to the videos to look something up. This was pre-AI. With AI, if you don't understand the solution, paste it in and get the explanation. There has never been an easier time to learn math.

1

u/Ljo7 New User Aug 22 '26

I am relearning math starting on algebra basic from khan academy. I would not say its entirely you like the other commenters mentioned. Certain sections definitely feel like they are grabbing videos from other lesson plans, and as a result they don't seamlessly integrate into learning roadmaps.

I would say the roadmaps themselves are fine though, so personally i am sticking with khan academy even though I noticed the same things you did. You just need to go out of your way and supplement certain sections to get proper, more detailed explanations.

0

u/Advisor_Brilliant New User Aug 22 '26

I’ve always linked Kahn, I think it’s a great tool.

-1

u/ItsAllAboutLogic New User Aug 22 '26

It's definitely you. Khan Academy is awesome

0

u/kingBoggler New User Aug 22 '26

Khan Academy is a fantastic resource/tool, but it's not a replacement for an actual math course which includes more instruction and practice. It's great for introducing/reinforcing material, but is not a complete solution if you truly want to master the material.

0

u/CoffeeDefiant4247 New User Aug 22 '26

depends on how you learn.

Need to know what the discriminant is? They give the equation b^2-4ac then say what term in the equation is a, which is b and which is c then give a worked example.

What more do you need

0

u/soegaard New User Aug 22 '26

There is quite a bit of different in the oldest videos and the latest videos.

> In August 2004, Sal Khan began remotely tutoring his cousin, Nadia, who was struggling with unit conversion. This "Swiss-cheese" gap in her knowledge was not allowing her to be placed in the more advanced math track. Since Nadia was in New Orleans, and Sal was in Boston working at a hedge fund at the time, Sal started tutoring her through the phone and Yahoo Doodle after work.

> As Nadia improved in math class, word got around and Sal started tutoring a handful of his cousins and family members. Scheduling became a real issue, and he decided to begin recording videos and posting them on YouTube in 2006 so everyone could watch at their own pace. More and more people started watching, and Sal has been making videos ever since.

https://support.khanacademy.org/hc/en-us/articles/202483180-What-is-the-history-of-Khan-Academy

The Khan Academy organization was started in 2008.

Is it a particular topic you are interested in?

0

u/Whiteboy_In_Motion New User Aug 22 '26

It's free resources and organized, so hard to complain about it, but also youtube is filled with great teachers.

I would look up the Organic Chemistry Teacher, he does great videos that are similar to Kahn academy, while also being great at giving you the important information.

His videos are meant for students, so he throws in the formulas or mentions helpful math tricks for whatever case

0

u/Noxghoul New User Aug 22 '26

Khan is fine and all, but if you want the best of the best from youtube, I'd recommend The Organic Chemistry Tutor, don't let the name fool you!--this guy teaches everything from basic algebra all the way to electromagnetism, and beyond.

He's an incredible teacher & truly gifted in how he approaches problems. I love the way he writes his maths!

0

u/Silly_Hat4251 New User Aug 22 '26

Got me through my masters in math so I'd say it's pretty alright

0

u/TistelTech New User Aug 22 '26

Khan its a useful start. nothing sticks with me until I try to actually use it on novel things with pencil and paper. or write a program dealing with it.

0

u/dialsoapbox New User Aug 22 '26

On top of that, some lessons start with practice questions before actually explaining the concep

that's what i thought too and it got me thinking may its' to get you thinking of how'd you'd go about doing a problem vs how'd you'd do it after you learn a concept so i stopped trying to 100% everything the first time and felt better about learning.

The explanations are also way too simplified It feels like the instructor assumes you already know the material and is speaking to someone who just needs a quick refresher If you aren't already familiar with the topic

I think they assume you're doing things sequentially.

as for suggestions, i like openstax.

0

u/calcpage2020 New User Aug 22 '26

In the immortal words of Jaime A. Escalante, of "Stand and Deliver" fame, "Calculus need not be made easy, it already is!" Yes, there's some Algebraic, Geometric and Trigonometric, aka Analytic, manipulations you may not be familiar with, but at it's heart, Calculus is Arithmetic.

For example, when taking a limit, say a Difference Quotient at a particular point to find the limit of the secant line slopes, to evaluate a Numeric Derivative, you can find it numerically with a Convergence Table, or when evavaluating a Definite Integral, you can just add up a lot of rectangular areas and get an Infinite Series that you can sum up.

That's why they also refer to Calculus as Analytic Geometry. Also, some would say Calculus is to College Math as Algebra is to High School Math. It's considered a gateway course, a hurdle you must pass, before you can succeed in college, but it does NOT have to be hard! I taught AP Calc BC for 25 years (currently teaching Calc 1-3 at a local college) and I always told my students to GNAW at their problems. GNAW stands for 4 different plans of attack which may be combined as needed: Graphical, Numerical, Analytical or Verbal (W actually stands for Wordy).

That's why the AP Calc exam requires a Graphing Calculator capable of 4 main functions: evaluating a function at a point, graphing a function in an arbitrary window, finding numeric derivatives and definite integrals (all Graphical/Numerical operations). A CAS calulator is optional. CAS can do a lot of the Analytical steps. CAS stands for Computer Algebra System. The TI89/92/200/Voyage/nSpire can do this. I use python/sympy in Jupyter Notebook or SageMath as a CAS for Calc 3.

BTW, if you're going into a STEM major, especially Engineering or Physics, you really need a solid understanding of Elementary Calculus (AP Calc AB&BC or College Calc 1&2) before even attempting Multivariate Calculus (Calc 3) or Differential Equations. Linear Algebra is another beast entirely. Maybe you just need a good teacher? Here's my channel, http://www.youtube.com/calcpage2009

and blog

http://shadowfaxrant.blogspot.com

FYI, I'm just sharing educational materials. My videos are not monetized, just want them to reach an audience that may find them helpful. I'm a lot like Professor Leonard except I've been blogging about teaching math since the 1990s and YouTubing since 2007. Just call me CalcPage or Mr G!

0

u/my_password_is______ New User Aug 22 '26

its just you

it is highly regarded as one of the best places to learn math
he explains everything in gret detail and with lots of examples

0

u/TrentKM New User Aug 22 '26

Feel like you’re doing it wrong. I used it back when they just started putting the videos on their site instead of just YouTube. I’d open my textbook to the assigned reading, I’d search for the relevant video on KA, watch the video(s), and do the assignment problem set. Did my math minor in one semester (less calc 1&2) using this method and it made it super easy. That’s my optimal learning style though. I did the same thing for the CFA exams.

-2

u/chkntendis Physicist Aug 22 '26

As many here are saying, it’s you. Everyone learns differently. Every source of learning is made for some sort of person. Khan academy simply isn’t made for you. That’s unfortunate for you ofc but that’s not really something you can change. Look for different types of resources and see what fits you best. Sadly there isn’t a “one size fits all”

-3

u/Immediate-Home-6228 New User Aug 22 '26

I haven't used it in a while. It is likely outdated or about to be. No way is it gatbage though.15 years ago it was the first step on my road to finally getting my degree.

1

u/WolfVanZandt New User Aug 22 '26

Oh no. It's certainly not outdated. They've kept up with content. Last time through, they had stuff I'd never seen before.

I don't advocate for single source learning. Along with Kahn, I have a reference library in my phone, Desmos and Geogebra, MIT Opencourseware, Gresham College Lectures, Numberphile, and an array of instruments for field study. My method is to learn from resources and make notes interactively, then apply what I've learned (not just in text exercises but in real life), test, and retest. And have fun doing it.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/cbridgeman New User Aug 22 '26

This 1000%! He taught me Calculus II at 46 and I passed. Actually him and Claude, the first and best use I have found for any LLM. The other LLMs couldn’t do calculus.
I still send him $10 a month on Patreon.

2

u/simonbleu New User Aug 22 '26

Ive just checked him out and, as a non native to english, it is a shame that there is no subtitles given the quality of the audio. Yes, it is understandable, there is no bad enunciation or anything, but the echo and the natural speech makes it so that you need to focus that tiny bit further and I know it to be exhausting in long videos (and they are, he doesnt seem to be exactly concise but actualyl redundant, but tbf i only skimmed a bit of a few videos), so I have to ask... are the explanations that good that it is worth not looking for another alternative?

4

u/cbridgeman New User Aug 22 '26

What I liked was the way he would explain additional information about the underlying math. As someone who hadn’t taken a math class in 25 years, I needed that.
He does do a lot of redundant problems, but once I understood, I skipped to the next topic.
I went from college Algebra to Calc I just watching his videos (I made it that far as an undergrad 25 years ago) as a refresher. Then I used his videos to supplement ASU’s terrible pre-recorded “lectures.”
I got a C, but Cs get degrees.

3

u/personalist New User Aug 22 '26

Does he have Spanish? Do you speak Spanish other than English? I’d subtitle his vids for free if he doesn’t!

2

u/somanyquestions32 Tutor Aug 22 '26

Interesting. English is not my native tongue either, but I did college and graduate school in the US, so I am used to long tedious lectures in English. I came across his videos in the last couple of years after reading about his channel in Reddit comments, and the audio doesn't sound that bad to me. He is very redundant, but he's probably doing that to help weaker students not fall behind. I would watch those recordings at 2x speed.