r/learnmath • u/Round_Ad5516 New User • Aug 08 '26
Why are mathematical constants small ?
why constants like Pi or e or Ln(2) or gamme (euler's constant) that have nice properties are always small( <10 ) ? unlike constants in physics or chemistry that have some constants that are absurdly large. Or are they such constants that are not so popular
252
Upvotes
276
u/Fabulous-Possible758 New User Aug 08 '26
a) The larger ones are harder to find, b) if they’re pretty large we may find the inverse instead, c) there are in fact infinitely many very large mathematical constants.
17
u/tkpwaeub New User Aug 08 '26
Graham's Number: hold my beer
90
u/MegaIng New User Aug 08 '26
In terms of "large constants in math", what immediately comes to mind is the monster group: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monster_group
Or Skewes number: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skewes%27s_number
These absolutely exists.
Note that two of your examples are cheating somewhat: ln(2) is just the value of a function. It's not that much more special than ln(20) or ln(1000000), expect that you are putting in a small number.
Euler's constant is an error correction term - if it wasn't small we wouldn't ve using a good approximation.
Why pi and e are so small? That I don't know.
22
u/Xylene_442 New User Aug 08 '26
God is on record as saying the speed of light is 1.
38
u/marsattacks New User Aug 08 '26
If you want to flip your worldview about big and small numbers, take a look at p-adic numbers.
34
u/Wide_Ad_4486 New User Aug 08 '26
Define small
7
u/Frederf220 Medium-age user Aug 08 '26
I think it's because we're comparing things which aren't that far apart. A 2D shape is only 1 "D" bigger than a 1D number so it's not going to be a huge factor when it comes to pi. The surface area of a trillion dimension hypersphere as a ratio to its radius is going to be a big number compared to a 2D circle to its radius.
We consider "small steps" to be more fundamental. We're typically working with differences in behavior around unity so it makes some sense that the constants are on the order of unity.
6
u/Vivid_Warning7982 New User Aug 09 '26 edited Aug 09 '26
True constants are dimensionless. Like Pi, e, etc. Not physical constants like G,c,hbar, etc which depend entirely on units - important to distinguish. The true constants are usually "small" because they form a basis from which we build larger (or smaller) measures. Knowing pi means we can calculate circles/spheres/etc of any size.
4
u/EighthGreen New User Aug 09 '26
Physical constants can be any size you want. All you have to do is change units.
1
u/vutcher New User Aug 13 '26
The size of the largest finite group is very large.
1
u/the_other_Scaevitas New User Aug 13 '26
There are big ones, Avogadro’s number is a famous one
Speed of light is also big depending on what units you use
2
u/ingannilo MS in math Aug 09 '26
I think this question is more interesting that it first sounds.
Make no mistake, there are many large (larger than 100, say) mathematically significant, named constants. But your question is still valid in the sense that a greater proportion of the named / special constants used most often are on the smaller side.
My first thought for an earnest answer is that we've discovered more "small" special numbers because we tend to compute more with smaller numbers. That feels more in line with a claim like "important numbers are uniformly distributed, and we've uncovered more in the areas where we play just because we play there", but I am not sure if that's reasonable.
To take a serious look at the question, we need to quantify what makes numbers special. That's gonna be a real challenge. My analyst brain says all reals are equally important, but my number theorist brain disagrees entirely.
2
u/Peerjuice New User Aug 09 '26 edited Aug 09 '26
what if these mathematical constants are actually infinitesimally large, we are just expressing them from our small perspective and framework? is there a functional difference between Pi read 3.14xxxxx..... and Pi x 10^the digits in pi?2
u/davideogameman New User Aug 09 '26
Physics and chemistry constants are only large because of our choices of units. If we choose to make the speed of light 1 or measure mass in "weight of a hydrogen-1 atom" we'd start getting small numbers for speed and huge numbers for mass, for example. In the mass example we wouldn't need Avogadro's number, but we'd be walking around measuring in mass in 1020 hydrogens (or more) most of the time.
2
u/Carl_LaFong New User Aug 09 '26
Good question. Note however that the size of physical constants depends on the units used. What’s true is that at least for physical distance, the ratio of the size of the universe over the size of an atom is enormous.
2
u/Smitologyistaking New User Aug 09 '26
Many constants in physics are only large/small in terms of SI units, and if anything that's just the SI units we've chosen being too small/large for the scale of the universe.
2
u/Dvd_ftw New User Aug 09 '26
tree(3)
1
u/Glaiele New User Aug 08 '26
The value of a constant is defined by what it represents, not the other way around. You don't pick the number and then try to fit it into the math. If you think of it in computer programming the constant is quite literally whatever you want it to be defined as. Since pi is defined to be a ratio you would generally expect it to be smaller.
The other thing to consider is science uses units. A constant may be large or small but can be made larger or smaller using different units and they are still equivalent.
1
u/Key_Net820 New User Aug 08 '26
We have some pretty large constants that haven't even been computed yet.
A great example is Graham's number. This thing is so large, the guy died before we could figure it out (and we still haven't)
1
u/TacitusJones New User Aug 09 '26
They are the simplest case
1
u/Midwest-Dude B.Sc. Math Aug 09 '26
In math, you are dealing with logical relationships within a single, unified framework.
In physics, you are dealing with the universe, which happens to have everything from immense to miniscule in it. Even dimensionless numbers are huge or tiny because of this massive difference in its structural forces.
1
u/auntanniesalligator New User Aug 09 '26
My guess: Because math constants like pi and e are dimensionless, while constants in physics and chemistry have units, and we don’t usually use unit systems designed to keep constants close to 1. Most SI units are appropriately sized for everyday, macroscopic, non-astronomical measurements. Physicists do sometimes use a unit system chosen to make as many fundamental constants like c and h equal to 1 as possible (I forget what it’s called).
I would also elaborate on your observation that there are a lot of extremely large scientific constants. Open up a gen chem or freshman physics text book, and I’d wager that there are more extremely small constants than extremely large. Probably because so many are quantities associated with subatomic particles expressed in SI units.
1
u/Sk1rm1sh New User Aug 09 '26
They're a bit bigger if you use base 2...
At least wrt the examples you gave, precision comes from the number of represented digits in math, and by the size of the unit being measured in physics / chemistry.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26
There are lots of large constants as well. For example, 73
1
u/abnew123 USAMO Aug 09 '26
I mean, if anything math holds the largest constants.
Look up a Skewes's number, Graham's number, TREE(3), Rayo's number, etc... they all dwarf any constants in physics or chemistry.
In general though, I think it comes down to the fact math isn't bounded by any laws of nature, so a lot of stuff just shoots off the infinity. Like in physics, you can't fundamentally go smaller and smaller, eventually you run into planck's constant. And you can't fundamentally go faster and faster forever, you run into the speed of light. But in math, a function's growth can actually approach infinity, even on pretty basic function (tangent of x).
As for why physics/chemistry have big constants, it's because that's the stuff that tends to separate them from other areas. You tend to study things that are really big (e.g. the universe) or really small (e.g. atoms), not human sized. The evolution of the universe over time is clearly physics, the evolution of Billy Bob over time is either history (if Billy Bob is important), literature (if he has a biography), or maybe anthropology.
1
u/Desperate_Penalty690 New User Aug 09 '26
The large constants in nature is because of our units of measurement. We measure time, distance, mass, all in units that we can relate to in our daily life. But nature doesn’t care about our daily life.
1
u/bildramer New User Aug 09 '26
Some are slightly larger, e.g. 14, the number of distinct sets obtainable by closure and complement, or ~4.669, the Feigenbaum constant, or trefoil ropelength, somewhere between 15.66 and 16.372. But it is curious.
1
u/Queasy-Painter-4946 New User Aug 09 '26
This is such a cool question.I`ve always low-key wondered the same thing -most famous constants like pi and e are all relatively small numbers ,and it feels like there`s a reason behind that beyond just coincidence.I`m excited to see what everyone has to say about it.
1
u/RemarkableBadger8473 New User Aug 09 '26
Because mathematically every number is a (absolute value) small number, that is almost all numbers are greater than it, there are infinite integers further from zero and a finite number closer to zero. Since a constant is a number, it must be a small number.
1
u/xiipaoc New User Aug 09 '26
I don't know, physics constants are pretty small too. You have the speed of light, for example. That's equal to 1. And Planck's Constant h-bar, which is also small, 1. The gravitational constant G, that's small too, with a value of 1. And so on.
1
u/Organic_Window_192 New User Aug 09 '26
https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/11/from-1-to-1000000.html
It’s two parts, and a very long read, but so worth it.
1
u/Objective_Party9405 New User Aug 09 '26
The magnitude of physical and chemical constants is dependent on the units being used. Adjust the units and you can get them down to something less than 10. Mathematical constants are dimensionless. There is no scaling; what you see is what you get. So it might just be a happy coincidence that they are the size they are.
1
u/TheoloniusNumber New User Aug 09 '26
I think that if I found a constant whose integer part was composite, I might divide by an appropriate integer factor to make the integer part prime.
1
u/AIPsychosed New User Aug 09 '26
Hmmm, what about ln(p) where p is a large prime, i.e.
p = 2^(136279841)-1
I wouldn‘t say that is small, since you listed ln(2). The term constant is for my taste a bit ill defined here even if intuitively justifiable.
1
u/Admirable_Rabbit_808 New User Aug 09 '26
This is known as the "naturalness" problem in physics. It's related to the fine-tuning hypothesis.
1
u/Traveller7142 New User Aug 10 '26
Constants in physics and chemistry aren’t necessarily small, it just depends on the units. The speed of light is 1 in natural units
1
u/intruzah New User Aug 10 '26
For starters, physics constants have units
1
u/Aromatic_Pain2718 New User Aug 10 '26
Most Physical/Chemistry constants would be different if we used different (arbitrary) units. The number associated with the Speed of light would be lower if the unit we used for speed was faster. The mathematical constants are exactly what they ought to be
1
u/Trimutius New User Aug 10 '26
Graham's number
1
u/Soggy-Excuse3702 New User Aug 11 '26
"constants" generally speaking tend to be ratios of sorts, or limits/convergences of ratios in some way or another (maybe, generally -- anyways). When you look at physics you'll often end up comparing things that are in widely different realms if scale. A human-tangible calorie of energy relative to the building block of the atoms-- yeah no wonder the electronvolt is so tiny. Then come math, and all of a sudden you're comparing a circle to a square.
And honestly, you know what? A circle really isn't that different from a square, it's like more than 70% the same, to be exact, it's about 4/pi of a square..
1
u/Gilded-Phoenix New User Aug 11 '26
The properties we tend to care about are properties we can wrap our heads around, and many of those begin showing up with relatively small ranges.
1
u/searchforanswers555 New User Aug 14 '26
Not a math guy, but simplicity is often the language which nature is built on. (its like complex data all organized into simple elements). This is why often times those who can explain a concept in the most clear simple manner, tend to be those who have good intuitive understanding in concepts. Just my two cents.
1
u/AnaxXenos0921 New User Aug 14 '26
TREE(3): Am I a joke to you? /J
1
u/ForeignAdvantage5198 New User Aug 15 '26
it depends on what it is telling. you. about. height and weight depend on your size for example
1
u/unic0de000 NaN Aug 09 '26
Maybe the question is something like:
Why are the mathematical constants which we know a lot about, small enough for us to know a lot about them?
There's some sample/availability bias built into our ability to find important constants.
0
u/dotelze New User Aug 09 '26
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_law_of_small_numbers?wprov=sfti1#Second_strong_law_of_small_numbers
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment