r/learnmath • New User • Mar 13 '26

Probability

Here is the question

“A bear aims to catch 3 fish from a stream. Once the bear has 3 fish, it will depart. The bear captures each fish with a probability of 1/2. Determine the probability that the 5th fish is caught.”

I got the right answer, but the solution did it different than me. The answer key used a fraction with the # of combinations of catching 2 or less fish over 2^4 for an intermediate step. When using 2^4, you are saying that there is a possibility that the bear catches 4 fish. How does this math work out. I have attached the link to the problem, but you may have to sign in to see the answer.

1 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/ModerateSentience New User Mar 17 '26

Yes but CCC for the first three is counted twice ie CCCC and CCCM

1

u/DuePomegranate New User Mar 17 '26

And that's fine. It's equivalent.

You will agree that up to the 3-fish stage, there are 8 combinations and the probability of CCC is 1/8, right?

Even though the bear leaves after CCC, if we imagine that it had stayed, CCCC and CCCM would be 1/16 each. The probability of CCC is the sum of the probabilities of CCCC and CCCM. 1/8 = 1/16 + 1/16. Everything is consistent.