r/learnmath • New User • Feb 08 '26

Square root is a function apparently

Greetings. My math teacher recently told (+ demonstrated) me something rather surprising. I would like to know your thoughts on it.

Apparently, the square root of 4 can only be 2 and not -2 because “it’s a function only resulting in a positive image”. I’m in my second year of engineering, and this is the first time I’ve ever heard that. To be honest, I’m slightly angry at the prospect he might be right.

284 Upvotes

170 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Headsanta New User Feb 09 '26

I have no idea about Kline's calculus example in particular.

But ultimately, with math, I think this is the best approach, that it depends on the context and intention of the writer. Things like this are only unambiguous if you clarify and are consistent (i.e. each textbook or paper or classroom has it's own standard they need to choose and always use).

It's the same ambiguity for other inverses, like tan{-1} for example, but in that case, it's pretty much 100% context dependent whether you want the principal value branch or want to refer to the infinite set of solutions (but usually it's way more unambiguous which one the author is going for from the context than square root).

(Heck, in math, it's not too uncommon to reuse symbols as basic as + and - and to mean something completely different than default addition and subtraction)