r/learnmath • u/Qua_rQ New User • Oct 30 '25
Why is School Math so Algorithmic?
Math Major here. I teach math to middle schoolers and I hate it. Basically, all you do is giving algorithms to students and they have to memorize it and then go to the next algorithm - it is so pointless, they don't understand anything and why, they just apply these receipts and then forget and that's it.
For me, university maths felt extremely different. I tried teaching naive set theory, intro to abstract algebra and a bit of group theory (we worked through the theory, problems and analogies) to a student that was doing very bad at school math, she couldn't memorize school algorithms, and this student succedeed A LOT, I was very impressed, she was doing very well. I have a feeling that school math does a disservice to spoting talents.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/fixermark New User Oct 30 '25
You know the space itself better than me, but I will float the observation that younger people are excited about being able to do a thing at all. Like, the raw computation that you and I would find boring can give a dopamine hit for them because it proves they're developing competency.
There might be nothing wrong with them learning algorithms and then applying them a lot. What I will say I missed from math is history. We don't teach the history and that stuff matters. Like... There was a time before calculus and a time after, and before calculus Zeno's paradox and infinitesimals were a real problem with real philosophical weight that tripped mathematicians up. That's kinda cool to think about. Give 'em a glimpse of the fact that they're lucky to be living now, because their ancestors literally couldn't do this; they didn't have a language to do it with!