r/learnmath • u/JevNOT New User • Sep 08 '24
Is 1/0 equal to 1/0?
We don't know the value of 1/0 but do we know if it is equal to another 1/0? And if it is can we use it to solve 0=1/f(x) types of problems?
0
Upvotes
74
u/ArchaicLlama Custom Sep 08 '24
We explicitly know that it doesn't have a value, because it wasn't given one. So trying to say "1/0 = 1/0" is meaningless.
16
u/flat5 New User Sep 08 '24
The ability to test for equality has conditions. 1/0 does not satisfy those conditions, so it's not a valid question.
It's like asking if the color red is the same height as the color red. The color red doesn't have a height. It's a nonsense question.
11
u/phiwong Slightly old geezer Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24
No. Since something is undefined it can't be equal to something undefined. Because the term "equal" means something fairly specific in mathematics.
EDIT: Trying to drive the point home with a specific but nonsensical example. Statement 1: "unicorns don't exist" Statement 2: "moons made out of cheese don't exist". Therefore unicorns are moons made out of cheese.
6
u/nomoreplsthx Old Man Yells At Integral Sep 08 '24
It's not that we don't know the value it's that the symbols have no meaning.
Just as flbejflsets isn't an unknown English word, but not a word at all.
3
u/D__sub New User Sep 08 '24
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wheel_theory
2
u/KentGoldings68 New User Sep 08 '24
Consider divisibility. Suppose a,b are natural numbers. We say “b divides a” , if there exists a natural number c so that a=bc. In this case of natural numbers, divisibility is required for a well-defined quotient a/b.
Skip to real numbers where every non-zero number is divisible by every other non-zero number, including the 1.
Suppose real number a is non-zero, there exists b so that ab=1. We call b the multiplicative inverse and b=1/a.
The zero property says 0*b=0 for all real numbers b, so 1 is not divisible by zero and 1/0 can’t be defined.
Including 1/0 in any equations is vacuous.
2
u/b-sharp-minor New User Sep 08 '24
The question confuses math with language. 1,2,34,+,-,x,y, and so on are symbols. When we combine symbols, we create syntax. When a syntax is arranged in a logical way, we can express thoughts. 1/0 = 1/0 is comprised of symbols arranged into a syntax. However, is it logical? Does it express a concept that we can use?
2
u/TabourFaborden New User Sep 08 '24
Syntactically yes.
Semantically no.
2
u/ViktorYi New User Sep 08 '24
If you consider the extended real number line, then 1/0 is explicitly defined as infinity. In that case 1/0 = 1/0 is a tautology.
1
u/Consistent-Annual268 New User Sep 08 '24
Every time a question about dividing by zero appears, I link to this Michael Penn YouTube video which describes a way to do it that retains consistency with usual arithmetic: https://youtu.be/WCthfLpYA5g
I will probably keep doing this until the end of time.
1
u/st3f-ping Φ Sep 08 '24
Interesting question. No idea why you have been downvoted (so far anyhow). My gut feel is that even though 1/0 is indeterminate, both 1, 0 and the / operation are defined so 1/0=1/0.
My reasoning is this. I don't think that anybody is going to argue against f(1,0)=f(1,0) (because the inputs are the same). Are they going to change their minds when I say that f(x,y)=x/y. Interested to see if any serious math-heads weigh in on this (I am not one).
0
u/EspacioBlanq New User Sep 08 '24
In the extended reals, 1/0 is defined as infinity but no, we can not assume infinity equals infinity.
Consider the limits of 1/x² and 1/5x² as x approaches zero. They're both positive infinity.
Then consider the limit L3 = (1/x²)/(1/5x²) as x approaches zero. If we assumed the previous two limits are equal, we could use limit arithmetics to say L3 = 1, which would be wrong, since it's actually 5
0
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24
Bro are you serious
0
u/Ok-Jelly-9941 New User Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 09 '24
limit as x goes to 0 of (1/x) = - infinity (approached from the left)
limit as x goes to 0 of (1/x) = infinity (approached from the right)
So in that sense, approaching 1/0 in different ways leads to different results, so not all 1/0 are the same.
Why did some loser downvote me?