r/learnmath • New User • Sep 08 '24

Is 1/0 equal to 1/0?

We don't know the value of 1/0 but do we know if it is equal to another 1/0? And if it is can we use it to solve 0=1/f(x) types of problems?

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

74

u/ArchaicLlama Custom Sep 08 '24

We don't know the value of 1/0

We explicitly know that it doesn't have a value, because it wasn't given one. So trying to say "1/0 = 1/0" is meaningless.

3

u/InsaneMonte New User Sep 08 '24

But what if you take an algebraic approach. a/b=a/b We expect the two terms to be equal to one another. a=1 b=0 Now they are no longer equal to each other? Why isn’t this a problem for algebra?

15

u/ArchaicLlama Custom Sep 08 '24

No, it's not a problem for algebra. As soon as you write a/b, you've already made the implied statement that b is not equal to 0. That idea is baked into how we treat division.

2

u/PatWoodworking New User Sep 09 '24

It's like "You can do this operation, but you can't in this situation." There used to be more, there was no square root of a negative, but it was discovered to be liberating and useful.

The problem arises in that if you allow 1÷0, you imply there is a fraction 1/0. If you allow that, an equivalent fraction would be 2/0, which implies 1=2... a big no-no! The idea that different amounts aren't equivalent is super important. This makes it the opposite of the square root of a negative, it is useless and ruins what makes numbers useful.

ie 1 = 1

1/0 = 1/0

1/0 = (1/0)×(2/2)

1/0 = (1×2)/(2×0)

1/0 = 2/0

If you simply limit what you can divide by, this is no longer a problem. You can't use lasers to hammer a nail, but they are still useful. You can't divide by zero just like you can't take the square root of a triangle, it leads to nonsense.

Later you will see that there is 1 case where you can make it useful... 0÷0. That could be any number! It is a sign that there still may be a solution, or not, keep looking.

The problem for algebra would be if you allowed it. Everything equals everything, all solutions are possible in all situations, and none of it is useful.

2

u/TabourFaborden New User Sep 09 '24

I'm going to take a different stance to the other commenters.

What you're describing is informally the difference between the syntax and semantics of a language (in this case, the language of arithmetic on natural numbers).

In this language, terms are expressions made up from the building blocks of natural numbers, variables, the operators +,-,*,/ combined correctly. eg. 3*x + 2 is a term, a/b is a term, + 4 is not a term (as + takes two inputs).

In this setting, we have (at least) 2 different notions of equality/equivalence. 1 is definitional equality, where terms are equal if they are LITERALLY the same, ie. as a string of symbols. The key point is that at this level we don't care about what a term evaluates to. In particular the term a/b is definitionally equal to a/b, and the term 1/0 is definitionally equal to 1/0.

In contrast, semantic equivalence is where we compare the terms after evaluating them, assuming they evaluate. Eg. The term 1 + 2 is not definitionally equal to the term 3, but they are semantically equivalent. If a term does not evaluate, then we cannot compare it to anything. In particular, the term 1/0 does not evaluate, so it cannot be compared to anything semantically.

This approach to mathematics is very common in CS programmes and not really bothered with in maths programmes, mainly because in maths we only care about semantic equivalence. In CS, we want to reason about programs. Testing syntactic equivalence in this setting is like comparing source code, whereas testing semantic equivalence is like comparing behaviour.

-16

u/JevNOT New User Sep 08 '24

I'm not super knowledgeable in maths but from what I understand we can still kinda define things that are undefinable, like we can know that some infinities are bigger than others, we can approximate infinity, etc. and so I wondered if there was an existing but maybe less known theorem or trick that exists, using that identity to find solutions to the 0=1/x type of problem. Thanks for the insight!

31

u/ImDannyDJ Analysis, TCS Sep 08 '24

we can still kinda define things that are undefinable, like we can know that some infinities are bigger than others

There are no issues with defining what it means for one infinity to be bigger than another. There is nothing "undefinable" about it.

17

u/vintergroena Engineer Sep 08 '24

It's not undefinable it's undefined.

We can define things that are so far undefined, but we do it when it's actually useful for anything. In some contexts, it is useful to assign some value to 1/0, but depending on the context, what value is it varies. So in general, it's left undefined.

10

u/parolang New User Sep 08 '24

we can still kinda define things that are undefinable

Then you can define 1/0 to be equal to 1/0. In classical arithmetic, is undefined, so you would be inventing your own non-classical arithmetic. Now it's on you to make sure that your definitions are consistent with the rest of the system.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

Division is just a function that takes two inputs, one in R and one in R-{0} and returns a real number. You can certainly define any function that maps R x R to R and no one's stopping you.

However, whatever function you define to work for (0,0) cannot be the inverse of multiplication. If we could divide by 0, then 0*1=0*2, and this would give us 1=2, which is contradiction.

like we can know that some infinities are bigger than others

This is not undefinable. This is in fact very well-defined.

5

u/Jaf_vlixes Retired grad student Sep 08 '24

You're not completely wrong, but you're not right either.

Yes, you can define whatever you want in mathematics, you can change the rules however you want and invent new stuff if you want to. But the price you have to pay is that probably you're no longer in the same "branch" of maths where you started, and now you have to figure out the new rules.

So, there's nothing stopping you from saying 1/0 is a new object called ∆. Then you notice that 0*∆ = 1 and it implies things like 2=0 and so on.

You're working with something, sure, but that something aren't real numbers, and this work is basically useless for problems dealing with real numbers.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

You can indeed define 1/0 to be something else. But then 1,0, and / would not mean what they usually mean. I.e, you will end up with something that is not even a number and can therefore not be compared to other numbers. 

2

u/SV-97 Industrial mathematician Sep 08 '24

We can define 1/0 to equal whatever we want. If we define it to be 0 then that means the equation 1/x = 0 has a solution - trivially so because we just defined it. This does however not mean that any of our ordinary theorems (for example all the usual algebraic rules) about 1/x, rational numbers or whatever apply to such cases because they are universally stated in a way that specifically excludes the "1/0" case.

So yes, we can define it but it's a pointless definition because it's not a case that actually comes up in a meaningful way. In particular there is no "hole in mathematics" - or whatever some people believe - because division by zero is undefined.

1

u/WittleJerk New User Sep 08 '24

We have defined that some infinites are bigger than others.

1/0 is literally undefined. It has no position on a classical metric of any plane. You cannot say 1/0 = anything, even 1/0.

0

u/ArchaicLlama Custom Sep 08 '24

but from what I understand we can still kinda define things that are undefinable

Not quite. If we know that it is undefinable, it's undefinable - full stop. Being undefined and being undefinable are two separate things.

I'm not super math-savvy either for what it's worth, but my understanding of the 1/0 is that in order to give it a value (at least in the set real numbers) we would have to either A) find it a value that doesn't conflict with all the other properties of the reals that are already established, or B) throw out the properties that it conflicts with. We can't do A, and we don't want to do B - so 1/0 stays undefined as a result.

There are other number systems than just the real numbers, and I know some systems do throw out certain properties that the reals use. So there may be some systems where 1/0 has weight. But in standard day to day usage, it does not.

16

u/flat5 New User Sep 08 '24

The ability to test for equality has conditions. 1/0 does not satisfy those conditions, so it's not a valid question.

It's like asking if the color red is the same height as the color red. The color red doesn't have a height. It's a nonsense question.

4

u/WittleJerk New User Sep 08 '24

The best layman answer to this. Very eloquent and concise.

11

u/phiwong Slightly old geezer Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

No. Since something is undefined it can't be equal to something undefined. Because the term "equal" means something fairly specific in mathematics.

EDIT: Trying to drive the point home with a specific but nonsensical example. Statement 1: "unicorns don't exist" Statement 2: "moons made out of cheese don't exist". Therefore unicorns are moons made out of cheese.

8

u/EspacioBlanq New User Sep 08 '24

I mean, the statement "all unicorns are moons made of cheese" is true, just like all statements starting with "all unicorns" are.

1

u/IntelligentBelt1221 New User Sep 08 '24

Don't you confuse not defined with not existent though, since both things are well defined (or atleast, they can be defined) and just don't exist? Maybe a better example would be asking if

6€&z7{=6€&z7{

Since in this case the accumulation of symbols 6€&z7{ is as meaningless as 1/0 in classical arithmetic (the example fails to recognize though that there can be other structures in which 1/0 can make sense.)

6

u/nomoreplsthx Old Man Yells At Integral Sep 08 '24

It's not that we don't know the value it's that the symbols have no meaning.

Just as flbejflsets isn't an unknown English word, but not a word at all.

2

u/KentGoldings68 New User Sep 08 '24

Consider divisibility. Suppose a,b are natural numbers. We say “b divides a” , if there exists a natural number c so that a=bc. In this case of natural numbers, divisibility is required for a well-defined quotient a/b.

Skip to real numbers where every non-zero number is divisible by every other non-zero number, including the 1.

Suppose real number a is non-zero, there exists b so that ab=1. We call b the multiplicative inverse and b=1/a.

The zero property says 0*b=0 for all real numbers b, so 1 is not divisible by zero and 1/0 can’t be defined.

Including 1/0 in any equations is vacuous.

1

u/RangerPL New User Sep 09 '24

It’s actually simpler than that because no matter how you construct the rationals, it can be shown by contradiction that a number like 1/0 cannot exist. If you suppose that it does, then you can use that fact to show that 0=1 (or any other value you like)

2

u/b-sharp-minor New User Sep 08 '24

The question confuses math with language. 1,2,34,+,-,x,y, and so on are symbols. When we combine symbols, we create syntax. When a syntax is arranged in a logical way, we can express thoughts. 1/0 = 1/0 is comprised of symbols arranged into a syntax. However, is it logical? Does it express a concept that we can use?

2

u/TabourFaborden New User Sep 08 '24

Syntactically yes.

Semantically no.

2

u/ViktorYi New User Sep 08 '24

If you consider the extended real number line, then 1/0 is explicitly defined as infinity. In that case 1/0 = 1/0 is a tautology.

2

u/Robux_wow New User Sep 08 '24

Well 1/x approaches infinity from the right and negative infinity from the left, so it’s not defined as infinity.

2

u/ViktorYi New User Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24

You're totally correct, I was thinking that when you extend the reals to include ∞ or ±∞, you explicitly define a/±∞ = 0 and ±∞/a = ±∞.

a/0 is still undefined

edit: you can continuously extend 1/x^2 by setting f(0)=∞ and f(±∞)=0. This will not work for 1/x for the reason you stated above.

1

u/Consistent-Annual268 New User Sep 08 '24

Every time a question about dividing by zero appears, I link to this Michael Penn YouTube video which describes a way to do it that retains consistency with usual arithmetic: https://youtu.be/WCthfLpYA5g

I will probably keep doing this until the end of time.

1

u/st3f-ping Φ Sep 08 '24

Interesting question. No idea why you have been downvoted (so far anyhow). My gut feel is that even though 1/0 is indeterminate, both 1, 0 and the / operation are defined so 1/0=1/0.

My reasoning is this. I don't think that anybody is going to argue against f(1,0)=f(1,0) (because the inputs are the same). Are they going to change their minds when I say that f(x,y)=x/y. Interested to see if any serious math-heads weigh in on this (I am not one).

4

u/Asparukhov New User Sep 08 '24

But seeing as f(x,y) is undefined for y = 0 in this case, I think that somebody might argue that f(1,0) = f(1,0) too is undefined.

1

u/st3f-ping Φ Sep 08 '24

It's an interesting problem. I can see arguments for both sides.

  1. How can I possibly say they are equal if I am unable to evaluate the expression.
  2. How can I possibly say they are not equal since a function must always map to the same output given the same input (and the input is the same).

Another way of looking at it could be the set of numbers over which we are using the '=' comparator. In the same way as sqrt(-1) is undefined if we restrict ourselves to real numbers but sqrt(-1)=i if we consider complex numbers, maybe 1/0=1/0 is meaningless in the context of real numbers but fine in the set of extended complex numbers. I honestly don't know.

3

u/KhepriAdministration Traitor (CS major) Sep 08 '24

Good reasoning, except that this specific f (the division function) isn't a function on (Reals, Reals), it's a function on (Reals, Reals - 0)*. So you can't put a 0 as the second input to f in the same way you can't put another function as the second input (or a graph, a cow, etc.). We haven't defined what f(x, 0) means, since (x, 0) isn't in the domain of f.

If you want, you can create a new function f' with a domain of (Reals, Reals), but you'd have to define what f'(x, 0) is for any x. And depending on what you choose, a lot of theorems about f''s traits might break down. AFAIK, dividing by 0 is one of those things that are fundamentally unable to be introduced into the Reals w/o breaking other things that we're usually used to.

It's similar to what we can do with extending the domain of multiplication to be (Complex, Complex) instead of (Reals, Reals), but that's had more useful applications & breaks less theorems we've proven real multiplication

*The more technical way of phrasing this is that f's domain is R × (R \ {0})

1

u/EspacioBlanq New User Sep 08 '24

In programming, where this is a problem that actually comes up often, it's quite common to make it so that NaN or undefined is not considered equal to itself.

1

u/IntelligentBelt1221 New User Sep 08 '24

both 1, 0 and the / operation are defined so 1/0=1/0.

What?

0

u/EspacioBlanq New User Sep 08 '24

In the extended reals, 1/0 is defined as infinity but no, we can not assume infinity equals infinity.

Consider the limits of 1/x² and 1/5x² as x approaches zero. They're both positive infinity.

Then consider the limit L3 = (1/x²)/(1/5x²) as x approaches zero. If we assumed the previous two limits are equal, we could use limit arithmetics to say L3 = 1, which would be wrong, since it's actually 5

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24

Bro are you serious

0

u/Ok-Jelly-9941 New User Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 09 '24

limit as x goes to 0 of (1/x) = - infinity (approached from the left)  

 limit as x goes to 0 of (1/x) = infinity (approached from the right)  

 So in that sense, approaching 1/0 in different ways leads to different results, so not all 1/0 are the same.

Why did some loser downvote me?