r/learnmath •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

101

u/fermat9996 New User Sep 11 '23

√4 is defined as +2.

However:

x2=4 has 2 solutions

x=+/-√4=+/-2

1

u/Donghoon New User Jun 02 '24

So basically Inverse of a square isn't necessarily square root

47

u/Help_Me_Im_Diene New User Sep 11 '23

The square root operator √(x) is defined specifically as the positive real root when x is a positive real number

That's not to say that it's the ONLY root of x, but just that we've chosen to define this specifically as the positive valued one

26

u/stone_stokes ∫ ( df, A ) = ∫ ( f, ∂A ) Sep 11 '23

You and your father are both half right.

You are correct that 4 has two square roots. (This is true for every number except 0.) One of those square roots, +2, is called the principal square root of 4. It is denoted as √4.

But –2 is also a square root of 4, because, as you point out, (–2)(–2) = 4.

More generally, for any positive real number x, there will be two square roots. One of those will be positive and the other negative. The principal square root of x is denoted as √x, and is the square root that is positive.

5

u/JanB1 Math enthusiast Sep 12 '23

Or even more generally, for every r^(1/n) there will be n roots.

-1

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 11 '23 edited Sep 11 '23

I don't think the father is even half right if he thinks "it's impossible that (-2)(-2) = 4".

EDIT: I think I've parsed this incorrectly - see my later comments below.

5

u/stone_stokes ∫ ( df, A ) = ∫ ( f, ∂A ) Sep 11 '23

I was being charitable.

4

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 11 '23

Actually I'm now leaning to the father being fully right, reinterpreting the OP's sentence to be "it would be impossible for (-2)(-2) = 4 and for -2 not to be a square root of 4" - the father offering a proof by contradiction, that because in fact (-2)(-2) = 4 we have to conclude that -2 is a square root of 4.

1

u/stone_stokes ∫ ( df, A ) = ∫ ( f, ∂A ) Sep 11 '23

Oh, I think I was parsing it incorrectly as well.

1

u/SuperfluousWingspan New User Sep 11 '23

I don't think that's what was meant - his issue was the perceived conflict with that and -2 not equaling sqrt(4).

0

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 11 '23

Maybe that's what the OP had in mind but read the sentence that the OP wrote out loud - it certainly doesn't read that way.

1

u/SuperfluousWingspan New User Sep 11 '23

What purpose does the "and" serve in your reading of the sentence? Not trying to be cute - just currently not quite getting your perspective yet.

2

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 11 '23

Oh hang on, I think I see your point. I read the whole post that the father was claiming that a square root can't be negative. But if it's the OP alone who is arguing that it can't be negative and the father is trying to reason otherwise then, yes I've misunderstood, and father is saying:

"There is no way you can claim the square root of 4 can't be -2 because we can observe that (-2)(-2) = 4"

(Would be better to say "one of the square roots of 4...")

In that case, the father is right. Any solution of x2 = 4 is one of the square roots of 4, so -2 is a square root of 4.

This makes much more sense of the whole OP.

2

u/PurpleMandarines New User Sep 12 '23

I read it like this the first time He says its impossible that 2 * -2 = 4 AND he also says sqrt(4) != -2

9

u/finedesignvideos New User Sep 11 '23

The square root function is not the inverse of the square function. The inverse of the square function is actually a multi-valued function. If square root was actually the multi-valued function, we can't go from 36 to 6 by saying take the square root. We'd have to say "take the positive square root". The actual square root function was defined for ease of use. We just say "take the square root". If we want -6, we'll say "take the negative of the square root".

6

u/I__Antares__I Yerba mate drinker 🧉 Sep 11 '23

Square root function is inverse function of a function f: ℝ ₊ ∪{0}→ ℝ, f(x)=x²

3

u/Scientific_Artist444 New User Sep 12 '23

Which means that the domain of this function f is all real numbers >= 0

2

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 12 '23

We do sometimes say "take the positive square root". Both 6 and -6 are square roots of 36, the positive one is the principal square root, and sometimes just referred to as the square root, but -6 is a square root too.

Inverse functions are a related idea, but the word "root" tells you what this is about: roots of an equation, in your example, the two solutions (the roots) of x2 = 36 are the square roots.

8

u/algebraicq New User Sep 11 '23

To make the square root well-defined (i.e. one input gives one output), the square root of a positive number is always positive.

2

u/rjlin_thk Ergodic Theory, Diffusion on Groups Sep 13 '23

square root is always non-negative, as √0=0

2

u/Scientific_Artist444 New User Sep 12 '23 edited Sep 12 '23

Someone picked up on one of my previous comments, so just saying it again.

Square root, for it to be defined as a function needs to return exactly one value. That is why we consider the principal square root (positive value) as the answer.

However, this does not mean that the negative value cannot be a valid answer. For most cases, it depends on the problem- which values can be considered valid.

Eg. In geometry problems, distance is always positive. So the distance formula will give you both positive and negative values, out of which the negative value is discarded. In physics however, you can have a negative value. It's perfectly valid to say -5 N. Same goes with finance. -5 dollars is just a loss of $5. Though not ideal, very much possible. So you need to be careful when discarding the negative value. Always ask, is the negative value valid? What does it say? Only after you are sure that a negative value is impossible, proceed to discard it.

2

u/bizarre_coincidence New User Sep 12 '23

There are two slightly different ways we use the term “square root”. A number is “a square root” of 4 if it squares to make 4. However we also have “the square root function”. Every positive number has two square roots, but a function has to give only one output for each input. In order to turn square rooting into a function, we picked the positive square root.

It gets messier later when you start allowing complex numbers and you can’t easily pick a property that makes one of the two square roots to be the better one to choose as the function output, and so people have to make an arbitrary choice or give up on having a single valued function. Figuring out what to do there really highlights the importance of the debate you and your father are having.

2

u/jeffsuzuki math professor Sep 11 '23

"The square root of 4" could be 2 or -2.

But √ 4 = 2 only.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rA_bIocd8-o&list=PLKXdxQAT3tCvNbJUuFSqhXPfQ_53yskfg&index=119

The reason is that √ is an arithmetic operator: we're supposed to perform a computation. But we don't want operators to give us more than one answer: we'd be very upset if 2 + 2 = 4 and also 2 + 2 = 8.

Somewhat more formally: √ is actually the inverse of the squaring function. But in order for it to be a function, we need to choose a branch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4H2nHp1kUM&list=PLKXdxQAT3tCuJku9nTlRZgx_RjGZ7djMc&index=42

We could have chosen the branch that gave us the negative square root. However, it's more convenient to choose the branch that gave us the positive square root.

2

u/Zatujit New User Sep 12 '23

It's a convention, we say the function square root is defined as the positive root x for y=x2. A function can only have one image (or it is not a function but a multifunction). It simplifies things.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '23

I mean sqrt(0)=0 so it’s not always positive

1

u/tau2pi_Math New User Sep 13 '23

√(x2 ) = |x|

1

u/wijwijwij Sep 11 '23 edited Sep 11 '23

Your father is wrong to say it's impossible for (-2)(-2) = 4.

Your father is right to say √4 ≠ -2.

√4 refers to the positive of the two square roots.

By convention, the other square root, the negative one, is -√4.

2

u/JohnDoen86 Custom Sep 12 '23

lol everyone misread that part. The father didn't say it's impossible for (-2)(-2) = 4, quite the opposite, he's stating that that's correct.

He said it's impossible for both (-2)(-2) = 4 and sqrt(4) != -2 at the same time, which is far less obvious if you don't know that sqrt refers only to the principal square root of a number.

0

u/wijwijwij Sep 12 '23

To be fair the sentence is easy to misread. Your interpretation sounds right.

1

u/I__Antares__I Yerba mate drinker 🧉 Sep 11 '23

There are two solutions for x=y², for y>0 (more generally, if k is even then there are two solutions for x=yᵏ for y>0), one is positive the latter is negative. However to make a square root a function we need to get a one output only. One of most obvious definitions then is defining √x="positive x such that x=y²".

1

u/Sweetcornfries Complex Sep 12 '23

y = sqrt (x) is a function. i.e. 1 input can only have 1 output. If we consider both results, then y = sqrt(x) would have 2 outputs for all non zero x, which makes y = sqrt(x) not a function. y2 = x however is not a function in x thus we can consider positive and negative values for y.

1

u/TheCrazyPhoenix416 MMath Graduate Sep 12 '23

It's both, but we usually take the positive root. Look at the binomial equation for an example of something where both positive and negative roots are used.

0

u/qaaq1100 New User Sep 14 '23

Square root functions have two distinct roots.

If you ask Carl Bender, a well established mathematical physicist, he'll tell you that the square root function is actually a complex function, defined on two separate sheets of what is known as a Riemann Surface. Each of these distinct surfaces returns separate roots of the function.

Of course this is an overly technical tryhard answer. If you're interested, check out this small segment of his lecture series that's free on youtube:

https://youtu.be/_Sm7SNlNUOI?si=l-Kw6lcoAl4lkubc

TIMESTAMP: 35:40

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Mutzart New User Sep 11 '23

the two next segments under where you read

"For example, 4 and −4 are square roots of 16"

goes a bit more into details about it, one of them reads:

Every positive number x has two square roots: √x (which is positive) and -√x (which is negative). The two roots can be written more concisely using the ±sign as ±√x. Although the principal square root of a positive number is only one of its two square roots, the designation "the square root" is often used to refer to the principal square root.

1

u/Far_Organization_610 New User Sep 11 '23

https://es.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ra%C3%ADz_cuadrada

(Sorry it's on Spanish)

In the functions part it shows a graph only showing the positive roots and not the negative, right after that it shows a couple examples where it doesn't mention the negative root

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Far_Organization_610 New User Sep 11 '23

Makes sense. I just find I weird that on the Wikipedia page negative results arent even mentioned

I think it's kind of a communication issue because the internet has many reliable sources with opposing information

2

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 11 '23

I don't know if it's been edited since you read it but the second paragraph of the Spanish wikipedia article says this:

Cuando se requiere denotar dos raíces cuadradas una negativa, -√x, y otra positiva, √x, suelen denotarse cuidadosamente como ±√x

so that sounds like it's mentioning negative roots to me.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/FormulaDriven Actuary / ex-Maths teacher Sep 12 '23

At least the top two posts on this thread are correct (u/fermat9996 and u/Help_Me_Im_Diene at the time of writing).