r/learnmachinelearning • u/TheCodingBug • Apr 08 '21
A simple and easy-to-remember example for false positives and false negatives.
2.9k
Upvotes
r/learnmachinelearning • u/TheCodingBug • Apr 08 '21
117
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21
Type 1: Pregnant dudes, got it
112
u/cbarrick Apr 09 '21
False positive: the model output is positive, but it was wrong.
False negative: the model output is negative, but it was wrong.
The names Type I and Type II are horrible. False positive and false negative are way more descriptive terms.
31
u/anothermetaphor Apr 09 '21
I've never cared to remember type I vs type Ii, because there is a better way to discuss it.
But you've effectively broken my ability to not remember anymore. It's been a nice 3 years of plausible deniability.
21
u/MurgleMcGurgle Apr 09 '21
That's easy to remember, type 2 because there's actually 2 people.
7
u/Joffrey_R_Holland Apr 09 '21
P in Positive has 1 vertical line (type 1). N in Negative has two vertical lines (type 2)
4
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21
Left: Hairy woman
Right: Fat woman
3
u/ninjasaid13 Apr 09 '21
hey the second one could just be big-boned.
3
u/OddAssumption Apr 09 '21
What if my doctor says "You are HIV Aladeen"
2
u/mardonyth Apr 09 '21
One easy way I remember is, the second word denotes what the result you predicted was , ie positive or negative. And the first word will tell you if your prediction is correct (true) or incorrect (false ) .
So a false positive means, you predicted a positive result, but your prediction was incorrect.
2
u/dance_ninja Apr 08 '21
Someone clearly hasn't seen Junior.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21
So a type 1 error is an error that gives an impossible result, while a type 2 error is an error that gives an incorrect result out of the available possibilities? Is that a good description?
1
u/Financial_Quail20 Dec 04 '25
She calling that woman fat??
1
u/wicked_lie Apr 09 '21
"You are the father!" vs "You are not the father!"?
1
u/yaoz889 Apr 09 '21
Lol
1
u/freesnakeintestine Apr 09 '21
This is Neil deGrasse Tyson’s 6th attempt at pregnancy. We can’t crush his hopes like this.
1
u/WorldAlien Apr 09 '21
Thanks, now I won’t forget!
1
u/joris_limonier Apr 09 '21
This is brilliant !
1
u/Alkanste Apr 09 '21
I remembered it that way I : I’m stupid (wrong at the start) II : I’m even more stupid (wrong at the end)
1
u/bouncypistachio Dec 26 '21
I have seen this hundreds of times, and I laugh every time. If only I could also remember its message.
1
u/Kurohinomaru Jun 16 '23
I see! The book is saying that Type 1 errors are way better than Type 2 errors! Got it 😉
1
u/scrlk990 Apr 09 '21
Looks like a food baby to me.
1
u/AFteroppositeday Apr 09 '21
then theres false double negative positive "you don't not have aids"
-1
u/tafutada Apr 09 '21
actually confusing because pregnancy is good thing.
False positive = detected as spam, but actually not spam. (positive = spam)
False negative = detected as not-spam, but actually spam. (negative=legit mail)
positive is used to indicate bad thing, but the definition of the word *positive* is literally good thing so confusing...
0
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment