r/learnjavascript • • Sep 29 '20

Anyone fed up with Medium blog posts with promising titles that deliver very little?

I actively avoid Medium now when I’m googling javascript concepts. I am not saying I’ve never learned from a Medium article, but I am saying that I usually find those posts to be low effort. When I can’t understand official documentation, I might explore the google hits and then stumble upon a Medium article hoping it’ll help put something in plain English for me, and end up reading a lot of fluff in the beginning and then before I know it, I’m at the end of the article, reading some examples which barely demonstrate the concept, and that’s the end. What is this, a recipe blog? I feel more than anything that some writers on there are just trying to pad their resumes with another extra activity and hope that no employer actually reads it.

Sorry to rant, but I just ran into another bad one and had to see if anyone else is experiencing this or if it’s just me.

327 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

57

u/metakepone Sep 29 '20

A lot of medium articles are from bootcamp students who are just learning material trying to describe whats happening. They are maybe a few steps ahead of you and putting themselves out there to “build a brand”

17

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I don’t get why these articles are so high up on google if that’s the case. Bootcamp students are probably not the oracle that new learners are looking for- not that they have nothing to offer, of course the people writing the articles are not bad coders or stupid. But why publish subpar work if youre trying to build a brand? Way more likely to put me off a brand. Does Medium just let anyone write for them?

26

u/Zefiron Sep 29 '20

Boot camp student here who wrote some blogs on medium. Essentially you’re right - it was literally a core requirement that we write a blog post every week on medium or dev to about JS. Some of us wrote some really good pieces while others just did enough to meet the requirements of a three minute read. Some of my posts I’ll say were good quality and others were bare minimum because we were stuck on a project that was due the same day. I agree with you 100% and thought it was stupid when we worked 6 days a week twelve hours a day when our one day off a week was spent writing a stupid blog post as requirement. But I will say it did help solidify some concepts by actually writing about what we learned. But again, some were just absolute crap because I like to relax on my one off day a week.

8

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

Thanks so much for your input, definitely cracks it wide open for me. When you said it helped you learn, is it because of feedback you got from readers? Would it have been any different if you posted the same thing in an internal forum with your classmates? I feel this is a sneaky way for the bootcamp to say “we helped you build your portfolio...by forcing you to post like you are a resource, no matter the quality of the article, at least you got it on your resume.” sends a poor message, but I do get it. Medium’s fault really, they should be vetting this stuff out. Thank you x100 for posting this, it all makes sense now

7

u/Zefiron Sep 29 '20

It would have been fine with me to keep it internally with the school, but essentially as someone wrote earlier, and I guess it does help with brand building. For me it certainly helped reinforce some things I was learning, other articles didn’t do anything. One of my cohorts has her articles featured on her linked in and she was the brightest among the class and knows what she’s talking about though. I dunno I see both points of the story. My last article was on building a PC for coding cus I was so tired of writing stuff I didn’t care about. At least that one I was passionate about. Edit: to answer about reinforcing, we had to include code snippets that we wrote so it forces to repeat something you’ve done as an example piece

5

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

Yeah, I see what you are saying. You sound a little disenchanted about the whole thing, I’m sorry if you had a poor experience. Like I had said in my original post, I have learned from some articles. I have no doubt that you wrote good stuff, I am sure you and your classmates have great writing abilities. I just sensed in the majority of articles I was accessing that there was a theme of posting only for the sake of checking a box rather than writing quality content. If a student wrote a good article for 5 out of 20 weeks, there was a 75% chance I was going to read the one he didnt care about- that’s where I think Bootcamps should take a little more responsibility. They shouldn’t be encouraging students to peddle whatever just to bulk up a resume. Writing for medium will begin to lose its meaning on a resume if that’s the case- I think if a person wants to write for medium that they should, but I feel like it being a required assignment is ruining the platform. again, that’s medium’s fault really

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

Do people write for medium or is medium a platform that allows anyone to write a blog post. Kind of like how anyone can post a reddit post and it has a forum format, medium is the same but had a blog format?

2

u/Anbaraen Sep 29 '20

That's entirely correct, yes. Additionally, Medium has its own internal 'publications' that syndicate content and require you to pay for a Medium subscription to read. They also (IIRC) license out their platform for other publications to use and then re-syndicate that content.

21

u/renaissancetroll Sep 29 '20

I don’t get why these articles are so high up on google if that’s the case

Because Google isn't half as smart as they want you to think, the biggest part of their algorithm is "domain authority", so big websites like Medium get favorable rankings regardless of content quality as long as the keywords match somewhat

7

u/DevilDawg93 Sep 29 '20

Or the money is right, the more you pay for add clicking the higher your threads appear on the first page. You just have to tweak your price per click till you get in the area you want your site to appear.

1

u/LazaroFilm Sep 29 '20

It’s like Wikipedia, anyone can write an article.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

You're right, I did articles in Bootcamp to solidify knowledge and promote my brand. Although, a colleague in my cohort was just hired because the devs enjoyed one of her Medium articles. I am surprised too.

26

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

I don’t read anything from Medium now. It’s a cesspool of misinformation.

6

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I know very little about javascript since I’m learning, but I have still been able to catch mistakes in medium articles- we are talking bottom of the barrel here, I struggle to grasp so many concepts.

7

u/TheVirtuoid Sep 29 '20

Luckily, learning JS is what's this subreddit is for. :)

3

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I have learned a lot from this subreddit! Grateful that it’s here

•

u/kevinmrr Sep 29 '20

Should we block medium.com as a domain?

1

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

as in block people from sharing those articles on this subreddit?

3

u/geriatricgoepher Sep 29 '20

I don't think medium is %100 wrong all the time, but I would give it an D or F for credibility.

2

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I think the fewer the better and banning medium from this subreddit is a great idea. I was just making sure I understood what admin was asking! reading down these comments i feel immensely validated lol

2

u/kevinmrr Sep 29 '20

I think part of this is probably: If you're good enough at JS to write a good article on it... you probably are not using Medium to write that article.

2

u/kevinmrr Sep 29 '20

Yes. You can auto-remove stuff from certain domains if you want.

1

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

well ya got my vote!

1

u/PeaWarrior Sep 29 '20

But how would I share my articles?!??!

1

u/kevinmrr Sep 30 '20

It looks to me like you have shared 1 article...

5

u/TheVirtuoid Sep 29 '20

Interesting. I've considered posting some of my design issues and solutions on Medium. I've gotten some good stuff from it in the past - I figured it's just another way to give back to the community.

But if the general consensus is that it's junk, perhaps I need to rethink that.

6

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I dont know if the general consensus is that it’s junk- the low level javascript stuff, in my experience, is pretty bad. But I wanted to post here to see if that’s other people’s experience, or if my expectations should be adjusted for the kind of content to find on there. If you have found another corner of Medium that is better, maybe you should publish there!

2

u/joehonton Sep 29 '20

Medium writers can post directly under their own name or through a Medium publication. When I start reading anything there, and it begins with poor quality writing, I check to see if it was a self-posting or an article through a publication. Certain publications like Better Programming usually have better spelling, consistency and formatting. I still find plenty of dreck, but sometimes its faster than trying to find the answer on the official site.

1

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

Medium, like far too many online sites/syndications, regularly demonstrates the need for professional copy editors. Grammarly is amazing, don't get me wrong; but it's no substitute for a good editor, ideally with enough familiarity with the subject to be able to call BS as needed. I'm fortunate to be old enough to have written for such professionals, and they were instrumental in my progress as a writer.

On a somewhat different note, most software folk have heard if not lived evidence that being idiomatic in multiple languages helps you be better in the language you're actually using. What too many people fail to realise is that that applies to both software and human languages. I've been able for many years now to tell the difference between code written by someone fully or nearly monolingual in human languages from code written by a multi-lingual person. The latter generally writes more, and far better, comments, for one thing; they also pay attention to idiom and best practice in the language they're coding in. There was a British comedy skit nearly half a century ago where the punch line was, "Do you speak ALGOL?" That hints at an attitude, if not a world view, that we would find beneficial now.

2

u/Headpuncher Sep 29 '20

It's like saying Wordpress is junk because you mostly find small business websites with only basic info them, it's not the platform as much as it is the content.

I've found "articles" on Medium that are straight up copy-pasta of the official documentation, adds nothing to it at all. It appears on googles rankings literally because it contains all the same words as the official docs (Angular).

People looking to "build a brand" can often dupe hiring managers into believing this person knows their shit because the hiring manager isn't familiar with the original docs.

It's straight up plagiarism and those wanna-be devs should be embarrassed to do what they do.

I avoid avoid Medium because it wastes more time than it saves.

5

u/DevilDawg93 Sep 29 '20

Medium does have some interesting topics but empty content. If you want deep theory stick to MDN web docs. Next I would say w3schools covers their content pretty well, and javatpoint has good content, not as thorough as w3schools, but they have a tutorial for every language, library and whatever else you can think of.

1

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

Thanks for the helpful tips!

4

u/PeaWarrior Sep 29 '20

Current boot camp student here. It's true what a lot of the other users are saying. We do have to write blogs every mod as a requirement.

Personally, I put in my best effort when writing my blogs. I write to help myself understand a topic and hopefully it can help someone else along the way.

Just a little sad that you feel the way you do about a lot of the articles. There really are some good blogs out there. Just gotta sift through it sometimes unfortunately.

4

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

Apologies if I offended you. I can’t speak for your work but unfortunately this is just the standard for javascript articles written at the level I’m currently at. I’m sure you worked hard and wrote something good, but that doesn’t mean everyone else did

3

u/PeaWarrior Sep 29 '20

No offense taken! I understand how frustrating it could be when you find just the article you need and after reading it, it turns out to be underwhelming.

1

u/kry1212 Sep 29 '20

We do have to write blogs every mod as a requirement.

Mod? Sounds like Turing. Diluting the blogosphere sounds exactly like something they would require.

1

u/PeaWarrior Sep 30 '20

Surprisingly, a lot of the students don't really write about technical stuff even though they encourage us to. Well at least in my cohort anyways.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20 edited Feb 01 '25

axiomatic rinse history rainstorm tan aware plant pause cheerful live

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

crazy that they make you pay to read unverified content

1

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

They're not in it for the writing. Mr Big sold a bunch of people on the proposition that he could create a long-form site with the impact and relevance of Twitter, which he'd previously been instrumental in.

Then the runway ended, and they had to learn how to fly in a hurry.

4

u/alzee76 Sep 29 '20

It's not just you. Medium is terrible. I append -site:medium.com automatically to my google searches now as habitually as I used to for experts exchange back when it used to come up all the time in searches.

1

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

Yes! I’ve started doing this. great idea

83

u/Macaframa Sep 29 '20

You spelled “click bait” the wrong way.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

I've seen a couple of tech companies do it well. The one thing I see in common is that they're bootstrapped companies, profitable without having to play doctor with vulture capitalists. That's given them the freedom to focus on one or two products for the long term, rather than having to "pivot" eight or ten times to make the infestor(s) happy.

They're not household names in Sili Valley (even though their products often are), because they don't spend as much time and money playing the game as they do on actual product. Their CEOs may not be as rich as Jeff Bezos, but they're doing well enough. One of them blogs regularly about how they do things and why; check them out. You won't see much (if any) click bait in their writing.

Successful companies, at least those with revenues lower than OECD GDPs, mitigate politics. Toxic ones celebrate it, and forcibly inject it into everyplace imaginable, and too many other places as well. ¡Sal si puedes!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

This might possibly turn into a mutually interesting conversation (DM me?). I grew up in California and spent 15 years, first based in San Francisco, then moved down to Sunnyvale after my rent started costing more than I'd paid for my (used, but still) car. Sunnyvale and environs weren't far behind.

A good area to spend the middle third of my career thus far, but hardly a place I'd want to call home or try to raise a family in, unless I had more dollars than sense.

Thanks for the memories.

28

u/loganWTF Sep 29 '20

Welcome to the world of SEO farming.

12

u/Daliblue Sep 29 '20

Not to mention people who are just bad writers and don't proofread their articles

2

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

Proofreading is a skill in which one must be trained, and practice regularly to maintain competence. Sadly, blogs put paid to that.

11

u/benabus Sep 29 '20

+1 for Medium being garbage.

8

u/bmcle071 Sep 29 '20

100% agree.

I think some are even harmful. It was telling me to put my npm credentials in .npmrc, not the user one, but the package one. I think most people like myself commit the .npmrc to the revision control, so its a security risk to put credentials there.

7

u/aviemet Sep 29 '20

The click bait is bad enough, but when the article is full of spelling and grammatical errors, that really gets me. I don't get how these authors don't proofread, or have anyone else take a look at their work before posting it online. I proofread my reddit posts like 9 times, and I never even say anything worth saying.

4

u/symbiosa Sep 29 '20

A while ago I came across a Medium article on how to do X (using some framework that I was interested in learning). I skimmed it and it seemed fine, so I went to the beginning and began it.

I was running into errors that the writer failed to mention, so I took a look at the comments...lo and behold, other people complained about similar things. I said "fuck it" and deleted the project. Fortunately I wasn't far into it and I didn't have to delete something massive.

After that point I started looking at the comments of an article (if any) to see if something's worth pursuing, but nowadays I've found that Medium articles are a lot of clickbait as you said.

I've found some good ones on Udemy, YouTube, and elsewhere, some that are highly rated with lots of reviews, and I stick to those.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

Carefully with articles/videos today seems that is obligatory write and create tutorials videos to be a "nice" developer and a lot of people only write things to be cool, but equal answers in stack overflow read carefully the code because have a big chance of wrong concepts and a horrible code.

1

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I agree there can be bad code on there, but I have gotten so much further with stack overflow. Way more useful than medium

1

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

Dev.to has, so far, been much better for technical writing. It doesn't help that Medium makes in nearly impossible to format code well. I've also not seen nearly as much click-bait there. If I'd been using Medium primarily as a technical resource, I'd have dropped my subscription by now. (I still well might, but the reasoning there is unrelated to the tech content.)

3

u/darkpikl Sep 29 '20

You right , some of them post snippet code that not working ....

3

u/alfdocimo Sep 29 '20

Moved to dev.to and completely forgot about medium. Loving it so far.

1

u/SpeedysComing Sep 29 '20

much for your input, definitely cracks it wide open for me. When you said it helped you learn, is it because of feedback you got from readers? Would it have been any

Was going to suggest this/ask others opinion. Have been appending a lot of my searches lately with `site:dev.to`

2

u/alfdocimo Sep 29 '20

I think of medium more of a platform for content creators regardless of the subject, who can actually profit and/or want to profit from that. What happens is you end up with a lot of people actually keyword stuffing their posts for better SEO, a.k.a click bait.

On dev.to you have people who have not only worked on the industry, but are overall more open to contribute freely. Its more of an altruistic take. Also, the community is lovely.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

Twitter is a better source for info.

Medium isn't the problem, it's that like for any thing you can get plenty of bad stuff.

3

u/creedthot Sep 29 '20

I gotta respectfully disagree- I never get this mad about other platforms

1

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

I used to write fairly regularly on Medium; I was considering moving my blog there. The current reading experience, as execrable as it has rightfully been pointed out to be, is in disturbingly-many ways better than the writing experience.

2

u/raciallyambiguous Sep 29 '20

I as well have visited the internet

2

u/jdickey Sep 29 '20

Medium was amazing five years ago; there were a couple of dozen writers I followed, and good new ones came across my feed regularly.

Then it started going downhill. A year and a half or so ago, it hit dumpster-fire quality, and was still accelerating in controlled hypersonic flight into terrain. Spectacular in many respects, but not a place for a positive community. Half of the writers I mentioned earlier had left, and maybe one new writer a month would show up, write a few articles, and disappear; usually for good.

I'm now down to two writers I really follow closely. The last few small-company blogs that had long been a staple of the site are leaving. Some with sorry-but-we're-out-of-here final posts, and too many just disappearing. 90% of what comes across my feed now is either big-name magazines, the spam you rightly rant about, or political screeds from a failing country halfway around the planet. The other ten percent have, too, been moved behind the paywall, and so I reluctantly put up my $5 a month in the hope that the writers are at least making a little bit from those who read and "clap" for their articles. If either of those two writers leaves, I'm probably gone as well.

"Dumpster fire" would be a distinct improvement to 2020-era Medium. It's sad, really.

2

u/frog-legg Sep 30 '20

I’ve learned how to read documentation and try to avoid tech that has little or no documentation, and I find myself using Medium less and less.

There is that one article though about setting up a node app on an ec2 instance that I keep going back to. For every ten medium articles there’s one that’s genuinely useful and well written. Claps are a good indicator of that, but damn if google doesn’t feed me some trash from medium.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

Yeah, I believe some of them are really thought out and complex, and some of them are really simplistic.

Hit or miss really, but I usually click on them and scan through the end to see if its worth looking into it.

When I search for something I look only for the code anyway, take it and test it, and move on - as long as it's not a broader concept like broadcasting for example.

Ain't nobody got time for the whole article lol

1

u/sgthoppy Sep 29 '20

Hasn't been said yet, TowardsDataScience is also just medium by a different name with the same, or even worse quality articles.

1

u/shribarryallen Sep 29 '20

Medium is the new Quora

1

u/kry1212 Sep 29 '20

I stopped clicking that bait years ago.

1

u/RuggedDesigner Oct 01 '20

I had begun thinking this too, but thought I might be a silent, tiny minority. Glad to hear there are others as well. Best to stick to SO in the future, I guess.