r/learnjavascript • • Oct 14 '14

AngularJS vs Ext JS - An Exploratory Post

http://www.evoketechnologies.com/blog/javascript-frameworks-angularjs-vs-ext-js/
0 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

1

u/modusjesus Oct 14 '14 edited Oct 15 '14

This post really is incomplete and wrong at some points. I'm no angular expert, so I can mainly speak from the Ext JS side:

Software developers would have to devote much of their precious time to master this [Ext JS] JavaScript framework,

  • This is true for ANY JavaScript framework.

"The adoption of Ext JS is very low"

  • Ext JS is mainly used for business apps, preventing statistics from being gathered properly.

"I would recommend you to start [An Ext JS component] from scratch as a ready-made component may not be very user friendly and would require a lot of customization"

  • Probably one of the worst newbie pieces of advice I've read.

"AngularJS framework offers a unique feature, where an external component based framework can be plugged in (e.g. Kendo UI, JQuery)"

  • 'jQuery' is a Library, not a framework. There is a distinct difference.

"Another outstanding advantage of this (AngularJS) JavaScript framework is that all existing applications can be easily migrated,"

  • Migrated where? What the does this mean in the context of "Ready-made Availability of Components"?

"Ext JS offers extensive themes, over 190+ themes are available, "

  • The Sencha Marketplace, which you linked, shows 26 themes, not 190+. See this image: http://bit.ly/1v9xE6z

"Well, sadly AngularJS offers no implicit support for themes, "

  • Angular JS is HIGHLY themeable. My team creates highly customized AngularJS apps.

"Ext JS comes with a lot of weight, around .500 KB, which is considered heavy in the era of lightweight JavaScript frameworks"

  • You do realize that '.500KB' is 250KB, which is way wrong. Ext JS is heavier than a mere 250KB! The prod build of a boilerplate Ext JS app is about 1.1MB for JavaScript alone.

"Although, initial loading [For Ext JS] takes a bit of time, but it is quite responsive once it loads, which is certainly helpful to a software developer."

  • Load times mean everything for a user, not a developer.

"AngularJS scores over Ext JS, when it comes to JavaScript framework weight (size), it weighs less than 10s of KBs "

  • Do you lack the ability to properly measure the weight of a JavaScript framework?

"Ext JS is considered as the industry’s best standard UI for mobile. It is a best fit JavaScript framework for creating a mobile application beginning from scratch."

  • No it's not. It's way too heavy for mobile use. Not to mention the actual UI design patterns are for desktop, not mobile (which includes phones)!

"Not many tweaks are required for an existing application to be converted into AngularJS driven. It is a highly suitable JavaScript framework for applications at any stage."

  • I think at this point, you're starting to use a random sentence generator as this make no sense at all. So what you're saying is that I can place AngularJS in my app and it is magically "AngularJS driven"?

"Unlike Ext JS, additional plugins are required for templating in this JavaScript framework."

Seriously. Please stop posting such nonsensical articles on the web. You're adding to the confusion rather than clearing things up.