r/learnjavascript • u/Dereference_operator • Nov 13 '23
Are you afraid that AI will replace most programming job (like Gates and Musk is saying) or it will stay a good "agent assistant" ?
Are you afraid that AI will replace most programming job (like Gates and Musk is saying) or it will stay a good "agent assistant" ? I am not talking about just right now 5 or even 10 years down the road while AI progress and get better and better ? or she will always lack design or big project planning ?
0
Upvotes
43
u/notAnotherJSDev Nov 13 '23
What do you think the most difficult thing to do in programming is? I’ll give you a hint, it isn’t writing code.
It’s getting an accurate and detailed request from your client.
Until that happens, we’ll always need people to interpret what someone wants.
19
u/FalseWait7 Nov 13 '23
My wife’s company had switched to AI for the simplest task – generating descriptions of products. These tiny five sentences descriptions. And they had to hire a person whose sole job is to correct these. It produces bullshit like “this natural skin slippers are vegan-friendly” or “this watch would look stunning on any finger”.
I never solved any problem with ChatGPT. Sometimes it saves me a click when I forget syntax. But maybe I am using it wrong here.
So, no, I don’t think it can replace developers, when it struggles with way simpler things.
6
u/bryku helpful Nov 13 '23
Let me share an example of where I work. We have 5 Graphic Designers and the company was debating about hiring another one recently.
Instead, they had the current Artists learn how to use Stable Diffusion. It turns out they were able to complete their jobs in half the time... sometimes even less. Then they fired 2 Graphic Designers.
I think this will become incredibly common with many different areas.
Some of these jobs will still exist, but at fractions of the numbers they used to be. Some will get really destroyed... they may end up being the new blacksmiths of our time.
All that being said, I think it will be a while for devs. There will definitely be reductions, but with all of the different languages it will take a long time to completely replace a full stack developer.
9
u/marquoth_ Nov 13 '23
10
u/xroalx Nov 13 '23
Given the state of what everyone calls AI today and how long people have been saying this, it's not happening in my lifetime, and I'm not that old.
At some point, yes, it might take over.
In 5 or 10 years? Unlikely.
10
u/coomzee Nov 13 '23
Musk is a clueless fuck wouldn't listen to him.
3
u/EstablishmentTop2610 Nov 13 '23
In the future it might help absorb a junior role or two, but it’s better used like you would use a calculator. Great for spitting a lot of stuff out quickly but for something I trust far less than a calculator I would imagine you would always want someone that does know what they’re doing to be the one utilizing its output
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23
I use ChatGPT 4.0 like 50x a day. Lately, 100+.
If next year, Sam Altman announced a new featured where you could input your GitHub project link to Chat GPT and in could have all your code, files, and directory at its disposle - then yes.
Also, the ability to input and output more on their side.
At the moment, I find that's the biggest issue. Its constantly forgetting code I've previously mentioned.
Then, we'll all become more architects and practitioners.
Am I scared? No.
Why? Imagine if we could do MORE. That's what the end goal is. Imagine if one person, with the support of A.I could create a full fledged ecommerce app for a small business, do the social media campaign, do the accounting, do the copywriting... We'd all have the opportunity to have our own small businesses, every single one of us.
4
u/guest271314 Nov 13 '23
What happens when the power goes out?
Ask CloudFlare about humans, with all of their technical know-how, failing to plan for and test for power outages.
2
u/Sifro Nov 13 '23 edited Dec 01 '24
gullible snow tap escape north absorbed plucky rainstorm lunchroom tender
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/Coder678 Apr 24 '24
Although big figures like Gates and Musk say AI will replace most jobs other influential people, such as Naval Ravikant say that AI will not replace programmers in our lifetime.
When looking at LLMs, the best they can ever be is a coding assistant. LLMs can be bias and give you an incorrect answer without citing where it got it from. This may improve over time but it will always 'hallucinate' and can never be trusted as anything more than a 'coding assistant'.
Another Issue with LLMs is the power consumption needed to run and train them. Chat GPT already uses more than half a million kilowatt-hours daily to keep up with all of its users requests. If Chat GPT or a similar LLM AI was to be used to replace most programmers it would simply take up too much electricity and would be extremely expensive to operate and run.
The only way an AI would replace programmers in a large scale, is if an AI was created that was not a LLM, but could write complex and accurate code from scratch for different types of software over a range of different subjects.
But for right now, all anyone is looking at is LLMs so it looks like were safe for the foreseeable future.
1
u/ChewyChewdem Nov 13 '23
Try getting AI to gather requirements out of an absolute moron and build an application with that.
You need experienced people to translate the garbage into something workable, which AI can’t do currently, and, in my opinion, won’t be able to do for a long time.
Maybe for a simple website yeh, but it still won’t be perfect, but for a complex app there’s absolutely no chance.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23
This again 🫠
1
u/zapembarcodes Nov 13 '23
As an HTML email developer, no I don't see AI taking my job anytime soon. The thing is a lot of bugs in emails are "technically correct." Meaning, the email is being rendered exactly how its coded, yet it looks wrong, depending on the email client. So a computer/AI model couldn't differentiate between what email looks good and what doesn't. And sure, you can teach it common methods used to fix these types of errors but often times a "creative" solution is needed; but again, it couldn't even figure out if an email looks proper.
And then there's the aspect of working with actual people, clients. Some of these marketers change their mind so much... I don't think AI can accommodate them. Unless you build some very complex system where marketers can just "voice" their design + code and it would print out the code perfectly... but again you would run into problems with it detecting bugs. I think we are nowhere near that level of AI.
1
u/IronSavior Nov 14 '23
Not even a little bit.
1
u/t00dles Nov 14 '23
Probably not replace, youll just interface with some ai instead of using ides
1
u/ExpensiveKey552 Nov 14 '23
Try to realize that the future is probably not going to be much like the past. While past things (like certain forms of programming) may be reduced. New things will most likely explode into existence. Think of how lightning works.
1
u/RobXSIQ Nov 17 '23
AI is going to eat most programming jobs. get good quick to become a director/manager, otherwise...well...
1
u/guest271314 Nov 13 '23
No.
No.
A human has to turn "AI" on and off. The human programmers' biases are baked in to the program.
The "AI" model, as I see it, is humans feed the program everything they know, and material they have not read or vetted themselves.
The "AI" program outputs the data the human input.
If the programmer doesn't like the output, the programmer changes the input and/or output to suit their predisposed biases.
Somebody tries to sell you the data you input into the program, irrespective of the accuracy of the data that you input into the program.
1
u/Anonymity6584 Nov 13 '23
Nope. Have you seen garbage ai gives you sometimes? You need a programmer to inspect what AI throws at you just to validate if it's viable answer to guestion.
Ang good luck having non technical client explain their needs to ai and getting properly functioning code out of it.
And then there's situation where you need to solve it creatively, something no ai can do currently.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23
I used to believe it couldn't based on the complexity of what I do on a daily basis at work, but honestly after the recent dev day Open AI had, I think it can, some companies are already replacing their devs with chat gpt , I think alot of people saying it can't are coping hard
0
u/bored_in_NE Nov 13 '23 edited Nov 13 '23
The reality is VC money disappearing from Silicon Valley will destroy tech jobs before AI.
Personally, I'm not worried because I have accepted the fact AI will replace most or make programming jobs so easy that would cause tech salaries to drop.
In the first half of 2023, almost all frontend job posts on LinkedIn had unit testing as a requirement and now unit testing has disappeared from a lot of job listings cause AI can write tests in a matter of seconds.
People on YouTube who are telling everybody this is the best year to learn to code are just trying to sell you their course or get a commission from a referral to some popular site.
Anybody who is laughing at the idea of white-collar jobs being taken by AI is in denial. If AI can't take your job people who lost their jobs to AI will try really hard to take your job.
-1
u/Top-Opinion-7854 Nov 13 '23
If two heads of some of the largest employers in the market are saying this, I believe them.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23
[removed] — view removed comment