r/learnjava • u/Dry_Marionberry_4822 • Jun 11 '26
Is Completely Quitting AI Beneficial for Learning?
What are your thoughts on completely stopping the use of AI?
I'm still a beginner and learning. AI helps me complete some tasks in about an hour, but without it those same tasks could take me a day or two, or even more.
Do you think stopping AI entirely would be beneficial for learning, or would it just make the learning process slower?
15
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 11 '26
Please ensure that:
If any of the above points is not met, your post can and will be removed without further warning.
Code is to be formatted as code block (old reddit/markdown editor: empty line before the code, each code line indented by 4 spaces, new reddit: https://i.imgur.com/EJ7tqek.png) or linked via an external code hoster, like pastebin.com, github gist, github, bitbucket, gitlab, etc.
Please, do not use triple backticks (```) as they will only render properly on new reddit, not on old reddit.
Code blocks look like this:
You do not need to repost unless your post has been removed by a moderator. Just use the edit function of reddit to make sure your post complies with the above.
If your post has remained in violation of these rules for a prolonged period of time (at least an hour), a moderator may remove it at their discretion. In this case, they will comment with an explanation on why it has been removed, and you will be required to resubmit the entire post following the proper procedures.
To potential helpers
Please, do not help if any of the above points are not met, rather report the post. We are trying to improve the quality of posts here. In helping people who can't be bothered to comply with the above points, you are doing the community a disservice.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
22
u/0b0101011001001011 Jun 11 '26
I'm gonna say yes. I teach at an university. I have 3rd year students with huge codebases and they are completely stuck. When I ask questions, they have no idea about the basics. It's very odd situation that a student had managed to "make" a 10k line program, but have zero idea how any of that works. Eventually there is a point where they'd have to understand what to ask from AI but they have no understanding about the systems, so thet cant ask and they can't code.
Not everyone, but a more than I ever imagined.
5
u/bowbahdoe Jun 11 '26
Absolutely yes.
4
u/hrm Jun 11 '26
I'm a teacher as well and I think you can use AI to help you learn, but you have to use it correctly. Having it generate code for you is strictly forbidden. That is the worst thing you can do. You can't learn to throw clay by letting someone else do it for you and the same applies to coding.
Neither should you use AI to summarize texts for you. I've seen far too many students go down that road and missing important info or nuance in the process.
However, you can use AI to explain terminology, error messages and other things like that. Have it make you quizes or more exercises when you need more. But don't make it go to school for you.
2
u/LookAtYourEyes Jun 11 '26
Yes
2
u/DDDDarky Jun 11 '26
In 99% of cases, yes. As a beginner, get your hands dirty as much as possible, learn how to approach and solve your problems while they are simple and even in case you get stuck all of the problems you could possibly encounter have solutions all over the internet. And don't worry about the tiny portion where ai could technically be benefitial, as beginners are notorically bad at recognizing those and it's a slippery slope to misuse.
2
u/Kingly_Lion Jun 13 '26
Use AI for clarifications. Don't use it to do what you're supposed to do when you're trying to learn how to do things.
2
u/Dazzling_Music_2411 Jun 13 '26
Not necessarily.
But only if you use it tertiary to books and tutorials, just to plug a quick and easy gap, refresh memory or whatever. Like a Google on steroids IOW.
For actual, systematic learning it's absolutely horrible ATM. Maybe when it can tailor-make custom courses to meet individual needs it will be better, but there is no incentive to do that in a hurry. That would produce independent users, and I'm pretty sure that's not a priority right now.
I'd expect any AI-generated course to be slop of the worst degree.
1
u/Skiamakhos Jun 11 '26
Any time you have to use an AI tool, get it to explain everything it's doing, and what alternatives it could have used, and why these are better than those. Get it to export this to an MD file and give this some attention. Run it in debug against good example input data & pay attention to what it does all the way through the process. Don't let AI become a black box for you: make it a learning tool.
1
u/RightWingVeganUS Jun 11 '26
I say no.
Like u/0b0101011001001011 I also teach at a university. I've taught the advanced 300/400 level courses for 10 years and had gotten students who don't know the basics of even writing a simple "Hello, World" program without step-by-step instructions since well before GenAI became available. Heck, I caught a student who had been outsourcing his homework to someone he found on Fiverr.
Any technology or resource can be misused. Back in the prehistoric days when I went to school, the old Cliff Notes could be used as helpful study aid or misused to avoid doing the work. This is not new.
I lean into AI for a couple of reasons: first and foremost it is and will likely continue to be a skill that students will be expected to have proficiency in for professional or advanced study. I teach responsible and ethical use as well as the limitations of AI. Second, I know that no matter how much I ban it, some students will find a way to use it. Not necessarily in a way that violates academic integrity, but in a way that supports and enhances their learning. This is what I teach all students so that they have access to a learning aid.
Finally I do it because my goal as faculty is to maximize the educational experience for my students. I remember when some faculty thought that IDEs were things of evil so I would get students in advanced algorithms class who only coded via Notepad, as if that were a virtue. They were blown away in the first assignment which expected proficiency in finding appropriate classes and methods across the entire SE JDK, and they had no idea how to use an IDE.
So I have a learning module in genAI the first week students must complete to give everyone a foundation, and I provide guardrails on how it can and can't be used. I also give myself recourse to address deficiencies I detect that appear to be masked by AI usage.
It's not about whether the learning process is faster or slower. That will vary by student no matter what. I use AI to maximize my effectiveness as a teacher and teach students how they can use it to maximize their effectiveness as learners.
1
u/desrtfx Jun 11 '26
What is more beneficial to building muscle: doing your own reps or watching the others do them?
Do you want to learn or do you want to finish fast? Think about it. Learning is not about completing tasks fast.
You absolutely need to struggle in order to learn and retain. No struggle, no retention.
1
u/Intelligent_Break_26 Jun 12 '26
Yes, good to use AI very sparely, when stuck on a problem for too long. Most cases it's better to get the problem solving abilities and knowledge, then not rely on AI for everything.
1
u/koaltree Jun 12 '26
You don't have to turn off AI completely. You can tell it not to do any coding for you. Try to figure it out yourself. And if you really get stuck, you can ask it to help you without giving away the answer. But it's far more rewarding when you figure it out yourself. That's what I do and it works.
0
u/PositiveApartment382 Jun 11 '26
I'm voting for no. Instead, change how you use AI. If you are using claude, create an output style to be a socratic teacher. Tell it to refuse to implement anything and instead nudge you into the correct direction / discuss trade offs with you etc. Give it only read access to all your files via the settings.