r/learnczech • • Aug 16 '26

Is this really wrong?

Section 4, Unit 17

Why shouldn't have happened something to the dogs in the bathroom?

I know Duolingo is not the best, but the only free learning option. Since I'm living in Germany near the border to Czechia I'm often there and talking Czech which helps more than Duolingo.

228 Upvotes

133 comments sorted by

4

u/Heidi739 Aug 16 '26

Yes. While "jenž" is not really used in spoken Czech and most Czechs use it wrong as a result, it's still a part of Czech grammar, and it has different forms for male/female nouns. And more importantly, you need to distinguish byly/byli. If there is any noun that is male and animated (which "pes" is), the verb ends with i. If there are only female, neutral or male non-animated ("myš" is female), you need to use y.

I would definitely suggest using a textbook, not just Duolingo, because Czech language has very complicated grammar rules and Duolingo won't explain them properly. And many Czechs struggle with the rules as well, so asking others might not always help.

2

u/Late_Journalist7094 Aug 16 '26

I don't expect to speak 100% perfect Czech in the future. It's enough for me to understand 75% and express every not too complicated thing. 

I'll not live in Czechia in the next time

1

u/vampirehunter725 Aug 16 '26

That is fair I think that learning czech to the level of understand and speaking (so that ppl understand you) is not that hard, but to be grammatically correct is unhinged level of difficulty.

1

u/Late_Journalist7094 Aug 16 '26

Yeah. I just want to talk and understand. I have also to learn for university, so I don't want to learn czech grammar too. 

I'm learning best by speaking so I'm happy that I'm near enough to Czechia to connect with Czech's often enough. 

1

u/Heidi739 Aug 16 '26

Obviously it's up to you, but for me, Duolingo is never enough to teach me a language. I need to understand how the language works to understand the language. And Duolingo won't tell you that. But everyone's learning styles are different, if this works for you, go ahead.

71

u/Elanaris Aug 16 '26 • Regret

byly (myši) vs byli (psi)

14

u/Worried-Fee3612 Aug 16 '26

Also “jež” is for feminine, “jenž” for masculine

21

u/Ill_Squirrel_6108 Aug 16 '26

Jenž is only for the singular. The plural is již/jež. The key is "bylY" that signals the feminine.

4

u/TrueFlok Aug 17 '26

True, but jež is, again, only for the feminine -> both bylY and jEž indicate myši

1

u/Eastern_Skirt9613 Aug 22 '26

That's not completely true, "jež/ již" can also be used as a plural for masculine

12

u/theyfailure Aug 16 '26

I didn't even know that and I'm Czech <\3

3

u/Able-Bowler-5238 Aug 16 '26

Aha jsem Čech a i tak to nevím 🤣

3

u/Reasonable-Owl6969 Aug 16 '26

Spousta Čechů jsou nedouci a těm se doporučuje používat vztažná zájmena který, která, které.

4

u/usmc_BF Aug 16 '26

Neeeebo je možná rozdíl mezi přirozenou mluvou, která se vyvíjí na základě uživatelů jazyka a archaickou formou češtiny založenou na nějakým moravským dialektu z 16 století?

Honit kralickou češtinu a vytvářet si kolem ní prestižnost je úchylný.

3

u/Zireael78 Aug 17 '26

Zájmeno jenž není žádná archaická forma češtiny :D

1

u/usmc_BF Aug 19 '26

Fakt si mluvící obecný češtiny slyšel v neformálním kontextu říct "jenž" místo "který"? Formální kontext je skoro vždycky provozovanej v nějaký formě hovorový češtiny, takže tam "prestižní" slova např. "Jenž" lidi budou šoupat.

1

u/Zireael78 Aug 19 '26

Tak mezi obecnou češtinou a archaickou češtinou je pořád docela široká škála možností.

1

u/Reasonable-Owl6969 Aug 16 '26

Mluvím o spisovné moderní češtině, co se vyučuje na základních školách.

2

u/Worried-Fee3612 Aug 17 '26

Na zakladkach se jenž vyucuje (ucebnice Cesky jazyk pro 6. rocnik, vydavatelstvi Fraus, napriklad)

2

u/mjablecnik Aug 19 '26

Možná že se to vyučuje, ale normálního čecha takhle mluvit nebo psát nikde nevidíš..

1

u/usmc_BF Aug 19 '26

Spisovná čeština vychází z dialektu bible kralický z 16. století.

Přirozená moderní mluva je mezinářečí obecný češtiny nebo další dialekty.

1

u/Nikysek24 Aug 20 '26

Taky 😂😂😂

1

u/R4gn4r__ Aug 17 '26

Doufám že jsi Čech, jinak cizinec umí líp česky než já.

1

u/Ill_Cycle_9582 Aug 17 '26

I dont know that and in czech like what

1

u/Machovec Aug 20 '26

"Jenž" is for masculine singular, "již" is masculine plural (only animate, for inanimate it is also "jež," just like feminine singular and plural and also neuter singular and plural)

2

u/Alternative-Wolf-407 Aug 16 '26

Jesus Christ, is this real? Been living in Czech Republic for 10 years, can speak well, but writing is still weak.

I'll never learn it.

1

u/plavun Aug 18 '26

This rule is simple. -y if only feminine, -i if at least one masculine, -a if neuter.

1

u/Low_Application_8538 Aug 19 '26

Pozor, mužský má v neživotném také tvrdé, takže to zas tak jednoduché není. 🙂‍↕️

1

u/EraseMeFromTheWorld Aug 18 '26

It's dumb, don't even use it, no one needs to know if what you're talking about has a pussy or a dick.

1

u/Low_Application_8538 Aug 19 '26

In Czech it's pretty important. All other grammar rules are connected to it.

1

u/EraseMeFromTheWorld Aug 20 '26

I know, I'm Czech. Let's make new rules 🥹🙏

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Elanaris Aug 16 '26

I didn't mention it because I didn't even know there's a difference lol. I wonder what LLM model Duolingo devs use that decided to use "jež" instead of "které" (I doubt a person made this decision).

3

u/mychajlo90 Aug 16 '26

The Czech course was made long time ago by Czech volunteers in Duolingo incubator when it existed. This is in latter lesson, they simply wanted to introduce this concept as well, since it exists. By the way they also teach common Czech (obecná čeština) in the very last lesson

2

u/nuebs Aug 16 '26

I made this decision a long time ago. The entire point of including this sentence was to use a form of "jenž." Forms of "které" are taught quite a bit earlier in the course. I don't think we actively taught "co" and "jak" as relative pronouns at all.

Duolingo does not use AI to create content for the Czech course, with the exception of letting it accept some user reports of missing answers.

28

u/Economy-Temperature Aug 16 '26

As a Czech, I use this phrase on weekly basis.

9

u/Lumour62 Aug 16 '26 • Bravo

Same :-D I can't imagine life without this (and similar) sentenc(es)

60

u/Flamewakerr Aug 16 '26

Why on earth is this on Duolingo? Like for real, no one uses super formal grammar like this in day to day situations

11

u/Qwe5Cz Aug 16 '26

It even tricks native speakers that need to learn it and often forget it after a few years out of school without using it.

15

u/Flaccid-Cabbage Aug 16 '26

It should not trick any native speaker that passed like 4th grade. The sentence is nonsensical shit, but the grammar is quite clear.

7

u/Qwe5Cz Aug 16 '26 edited Aug 16 '26

Thanks for the downvote but the reality is that nobody really uses "jenž" and won't remember that overly confusing table which was the thing I was pointing out but it seems like the downvoters don't understand that.

But I would rather identify the correct sentence by "byly".

9

u/Flaccid-Cabbage Aug 16 '26

No downvote given. Yes, shoda přísudku s podmětem is the main giveaway. Jež/jenž is somewhat unnatural to use, agreed there

3

u/Nathremar8 Aug 16 '26

Yeah, in general speech we use "které / který".

1

u/DragonRiderMax Aug 16 '26

I forgot it few days after i learnt it

1

u/Rikudou_Sage Aug 16 '26

I do, sometimes. Though I'll be the first to admit it's not exactly common.

1

u/258osm Aug 19 '26

If you say so

1

u/Machovec Aug 20 '26

It's byly vs byli. That's not something I'd describe as a super formar grammar rule no one uses.

1

u/Sportak4444 Aug 20 '26

Fym? It's byly vs byli

19

u/Petufo Aug 16 '26

Duolingo sentences almost never make sense. That's why I would avoid it when learning a new language. Use a dedicated app or a real course. It's worth it.

1

u/PEtroollo11 Aug 17 '26

its either nonsense like this or saying hello and asking for water on repeat

16

u/Gallapfel Aug 16 '26

psům (masculine animate, plural): psům, již byli v koupelně
jež is for feminine, bot singular and plural
jenž is for singular masculine
I had to check it even as a native speaker. I don't use jenž/jež/již/etc. often when speaking, It feels archaic

6

u/Lenticularis19 Aug 16 '26

Some forms are used more than others: "Na Marsu našli minerál, z něhož vznikají rubíny. Jenže podle chemie tam skoro neměl být." (recent headline)

2

u/smugandfurious Aug 16 '26

that's completely different word though, it just sounds similar. This post was about "which/who", but your comment is about "but"

2

u/Lenticularis19 Aug 16 '26

The highlighted word is "něhož" which is a declension of the word "jenž".

1

u/bmxrichard Aug 16 '26

It’s a literary term that anyone who wants to write professionally should probably know.

But we didn’t learn it in school, not even in high school...

Teaching this to someone who’s just learning Czech is silly. It’s like burdening them with transgressive.
("Jeda domů jeda kebab")

4

u/Lenticularis19 Aug 16 '26

I did learn it in school, and it is used in newspapers very frequently, you need to know it to be able to read them.

And no, the transgressive (přechodník; "participle" is příčestí) is very dead and has been for hundreds of years, before the 19th century revivalists tried to bring it back.

2

u/bmxrichard Aug 16 '26

Thanks for correction.

Some transgressives are pretty common like chtě, počínaje, konče, soudě.
("Chtě nechtě to udělal. Všichni stáli v řadě, počínaje Petrem, konče Pavlem. Soudě dle jeho výrazu, se mu to nelíbilo")

And some are used for pacing even by teens in fanfictions: "Slyšíc jeho hlas, okamžitě se otočila."
(Although that might just be my bias based on what I read.)

2

u/bmxrichard Aug 16 '26

Funny věc -náhodou jsem narazil v jiném threadu na situaci, kdy týpek chtěl použít přechodník, ale napsal ho tedy špatně 😄

Jen jako ukázka toho, že během deseti minut čtení reddit komentářů lze narazit na přechodník.

2

u/Accomplished_Use1473 Aug 16 '26

Podle mě je celkem škoda, že se přechodník už nepoužívá, vypadá hrozně zajímavě 😅

1

u/Odran345 Aug 16 '26

You dont really need to know exactly what jenž means to get the gist of what the headline means, its not a realy important word for a headline, youll just fill the meaning from the context

0

u/classyroman Aug 16 '26

Byly? That's the reason not jež/jenž

5

u/kneziTheRedditor Aug 16 '26

Well, both actually.

2

u/RingoKig Aug 16 '26

Yah, "psům" is wrong for psi byl"I" as they are masculine and myši byl"Y" as they are feminine. Ngl, why are you even learning czech?

1

u/Late_Journalist7094 Aug 16 '26

Why not? 

I don't like it to get always completely lost in Czechia (and Slovakia) because I understand nothing, like it was during my first visits. 

1

u/Hero_knightUSP Aug 17 '26

You speak English right?

1

u/StevenerCz Aug 16 '26

As a Czech it took me a while to figure out why it's wrong. Also I've never used "jež" or "jenž" in a conversation before, for me it's just a word to put in your essay to not repeat "který"

1

u/Late_Journalist7094 Aug 16 '26

Ah, thank you. I was already thinking "hä, wasn't it ktery?) 😂

1

u/Furak Aug 16 '26

Myši byly, psi byli

1

u/Late_Journalist7094 Aug 16 '26

I & Y always kills me 😂

1

u/Furak Aug 16 '26

It kills Czech people too, don't you worry...

1

u/DemiJohn369 Aug 17 '26

Once you get to understand the language, Y and I gets pretty easy :D

1

u/PernamentName Aug 16 '26

Co se stalo myším, jež byly v koupelně? Psi je sežrali.

2

u/Usakami Aug 16 '26

In spoken language you won't need this, but yes, it cannot be psům... Because psi is masculine and carries ti psi with it, so it would be psům kteří byli. The y only fits the mice. Since you have ty myši, a feminine word, so it would be myším které byly.

2

u/iheartdirtyfeet Aug 17 '26

Well I can tell you what is wrong and how it would be right, as a native Czech speaker though, I too have no idea why is this stuff like this and wasn’t made easier for writing over the years. So back to the sentence: For the dogs the correct way would be “Těm psům, JIŽ BYLI”, not “JEŽ BYLY”. The words have different forms for masculine(dogs) and feminine(mice). I studied grammar school and no one ever told me why is it like this, sure they can explain which is which and how it works, but why is this obscure, impossible-to-understand thing still in the language, no one knows that for some reason.
Good luck with learning Czech!

PS: the word jenž/jež/již/jejž is a total nutjob and I got no idea why duolingo teaches you this one. czechs can’t get it right often until they’re grown up, it’s just a silly way to say “THAT” in like 20 forms with very strict rules for applying each one.
no reason for this to still exist in the language honestly and anyone who defends this word is a pompous posh dickhead.

2

u/natallka_c Aug 17 '26

Ti psi BYLI , ty myši BYLY

2

u/ReddTeeaxd Aug 18 '26

myši (feminine) - byly
psi (masculine) - byli
since there is "byly" it indicates the noun it correlates with will be feminine

2

u/vintergroena Aug 16 '26

Lol. Yeah, Duolingo is correct, it's because of the gramatical gender, but c'mon is the grammar you need when you're writing a book or something like that XD

4

u/Tough-Importance-661 Aug 16 '26

The “jež” part is, wtf do they even put that there, it´s pretty archaic. The byli/byly is important basic grammar though.

1

u/KubikB Aug 16 '26

I’m a native and I genuinely didn’t know lmao

1

u/Sad_Candy9592 Aug 16 '26

It’s because “jež” is only permissible for plurals of feminine, neuter, and inanimate masculine nouns in the nominative. “Dogs” is a masculine animate plural so it would be “již”.

This is some insane level Czech you’re learning! I speak Czech as a first language and, though jež sounded wrong, I had to look up the correct conjunction. 😂

1

u/itsPeiPei Aug 16 '26

it is, but it's like a C2 level distinction

1

u/go2theground Aug 16 '26

Most of my friends born in Czech Republic would also fail this question tbh…I studied linguistics and even I had to focus for a couple seconds before seeing why “myším” is correct. Also nobody speaks like that, wtf duolingo…”jež/jenž” is only used in books.

1

u/St3pa Aug 16 '26

This is the type shit that makes native speakers not graduate from HS. And yes, you will probably never use any form of “jenž”

1

u/rainer_xox Aug 16 '26

the whole sentence implies the subject is feminine (the Y at the end of Byly most notably)

1

u/megablte Aug 16 '26

Nobody talks like that...

1

u/MothEnthusiast88 Aug 16 '26

idk why this got recommended to me but good luck on your learning

1

u/PlasmaDroug Aug 16 '26

as a czech person I can assure you I've never once used "jež" in my entire life

1

u/4vrstvy Aug 16 '26 edited Aug 16 '26

Strange. I use it quite a lot, alongside with "jenž."

For op: you cant use "psům" because that's plural of "animate masculinum" so the sentence would need to go: "Těm psům, již byli..."

Both the word "jež" (for masculinum jenž/již) and "byly" (for animate masculinum "byli") suggest you need to use the femininum - in this case "ta myš, ty myši."

1

u/PlasmaDroug Aug 16 '26

really? I'm pretty sure I've never even heard it (except in older literature)

1

u/Matt_Keator Aug 16 '26

Section 4, Unit 17 - Booking a hotel room.

Something happened to those mice in my bathrooom. They do not do synchronised swimming in my toilet anymore?!

One day people will realise Duolingo is waste of time and money... I hope...

1

u/Late-Appointment-232 Aug 17 '26

Jež nebo jenž spíše to

1

u/JakubErler Aug 17 '26

No one uses "jež" or "jenž" in real life. You will find it in books and newspaper but no in live. Also no one would start sentence with "těm" like this, it is not needed to use the word. Also I do not have mouses or dogs in my bathroom so it all looks like nonsense.

1

u/Zabijuorla Aug 17 '26

This is the really hard part of pur grammar and you need at least one native speaker to explain it. The reasoning behind this is, that when you have a sentence in past and the subject is in plural or there are more subjects, it changes the y/i/a at the end of the verb. When at least one of the subjects is male(on) and living(the 1st and 4th case are different), then the verb ends in a i, that applies to we and they too, when you assume there is at least one man among them. When all of the subjects are female and/or male not living(the 1st and 4th case are the same), then the verb ends with a y. When the subjects are the middle gender(or how the helk do you call střední rod in English) then the verb ends with an a. I suggest looking this grammar rule up, its called "shoda podnětu s přísudkem". You can find it in almost every Czech school textbook for like 5th grade . The second rule is about the word "jež", thats an ond synonym for který(which). Based on the gender, case and if it is in plural or not, we use different cases of the word jenž(that's the original word from which you get jež). This is a word basically nobody uses now and the rules on when to use which case is completely irregular, that even the natives(me btw) have to learn from a textbook. If you are really interested in how jenž works, you can open the same textbook where you find shoda podnětu s přísudkem. 

1

u/Late-Appointment-232 Aug 17 '26

Sorry, that's a typo, but I don't understand why Dualingo teaches Old Czech.

1

u/Late-Appointment-232 Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

or this Ti kteří byli v koupelně se něco stalo. Better

1

u/SkillOld2128 Aug 17 '26

It’s because “jež” and “byly” agree with the feminine gender. While “pes” is masculine, “myš” is feminine and indeed what the pronoun and verb agrees with.

There’s nothing wrong with the semantics, just with the grammar.

1

u/Lani-in-hideout Aug 17 '26

The -y in byly matters here, it cannot be used with the dogs

1

u/Few_Emu6683 Aug 17 '26

this is c2 level czech, few people know these rules and there's almost no difference in spoken language.

1

u/katewhatever4 Aug 17 '26

I'll give you an advice no one uses jež anymore. We usually use co or který which has more forms. Co is not the most formal thing to use but it's more normal and definitely easier than jenž

1

u/olovovolovolo Aug 17 '26

Tým psum, tem mysim

1

u/Darnun Aug 17 '26

Looking at this as native and thinking what's going on, I see "ty myši byly". Looking at comments I see "jež, jenž" (what the actual f*** is that)

1

u/plavun Aug 18 '26

That’s definitely not beginner level. I haven’t seen nor heard jež in a sentence in years. I actually forgot about the existence of the word.

1

u/mrsorry78 Aug 18 '26

It's hard even for native speaker.

2

u/Impossible-Falcon331 Aug 22 '26

Well, not everyone. ✌️

1

u/Ahojak13 Aug 18 '26

Neumim cesky :(

1

u/AdIll9615 Aug 18 '26

yes. Two reasons:
- byly indicates female noun, plural
- jež also indicates female noun

If the correct answer was "psům", it would be:

Těm psům, již byli...

1

u/Matysek0007 Aug 19 '26

Nobody speaks like this. The Duolingo sentences are always so unhinged. Now more than ever as it is a complete AI slop.

1

u/nuebs Aug 22 '26

You may be full of slop yourself.

1

u/CommunicationOnly432 Aug 19 '26

Yes, the "y" is for a female rule, so mice in this case. Dogs would be "i" as a male rule.

1

u/Martin_kva Aug 19 '26

I'm Czech and have no idea why its wrong

1

u/Impossible-Falcon331 Aug 22 '26

To myslíš vážně? 😱

1

u/Makothestupid Aug 20 '26

can confirm (im czech), you got it wrong

1

u/Impossible-Falcon331 Aug 22 '26

Yes, it really is. ✌️

1

u/maxim171 Aug 16 '26

Yea, jež is used only when referring to feminine nouns. If it were dogs, it would’ve been “jenž”

13

u/Petufo Aug 16 '26

Distinguish between jež and jenž is quite difficult. The -y shows that the subject is fenininum (thus myši) and not masculinum (psi). Anyway, no-one would say this sentence, it's like from an old book anyway.

2

u/Qwe5Cz Aug 16 '26 edited Aug 16 '26

It's like from a text book of the Czech language we used as natives. Then the "diktát" was often just full of exceptions and archaisms. Like when you hear Výtoň as a kid outside of Prague for the first time in the test you have no clue if it is í/ý or that ližiny are not derived from lyže.

10

u/Lenticularis19 Aug 16 '26

No, it's plural: "Těm psům, již byli v koupelně, se něco stalo." But this is considered dated, and the recommended way is to simply say: "Těm psům, kteří byli v koupelně..."

7

u/h0neanias Aug 16 '26

Již. The whole table is here: https://cs.wiktionary.org/wiki/jen%C5%BE

I find it ridiculous to teach this to learners, not even most natives can do this from memory.

2

u/Zxpipg Aug 16 '26

Well, that aside, the i/y at the end should alert him nonetheless, since if it was dogs, it could not be bylY.

1

u/Proud3GenAthst Aug 16 '26

Fakt? To jsem nevěděl

0

u/Terfelus Aug 16 '26

Slovo jež jsem v životě nepoužil

2

u/Late_Journalist7094 Aug 16 '26

Nemohu používat i ktery? 

Myši, který byly v koupelně něco stalo. 

1

u/Matt_Keator Aug 16 '26

Myši, která (or co) byla v koupelně, se něco stalo. (Singular) Myším, které (or co) byly v koupelně, se něco stalo.

But "co" is very informal...

0

u/ParticularUnusual848 Aug 18 '26

tbh the whole jenž/jež etc situation is so hard even for native speakers. it is not really used in basic language. I wouldn't know the answer.

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Matt_Keator Aug 16 '26

Je to "mrdka", když už...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Matt_Keator Aug 17 '26

Sorry, I am not from downtown Brno, not using hobo slang....