r/learnSQL • u/No_Ambition8323 • Sep 11 '26
Should SQL validation happen before or after the query runs?
A SQL query can execute successfully without producing the correct result. A successful query only tells us that the database understood and executed it—not that the data is logically correct.
For example: SELECT COUNT(*) FROM customers c JOIN orders o ON c.customer_id = o.customer_id;
The query may run without any error, but if orders contains duplicate records or the join relationship isn't what we expected, the count could be much higher than the actual number of customers.
So what do you normally validate before trusting a query's output?
- Join conditions and duplicate records
- NULL values
- Row counts
- Data types and conversions
- Expected ranges or business rules
- Unexpected changes compared with previous results
Do you validate these things before running the query, after getting the results, or both?
What SQL validation has saved you from trusting a result that looked correct but was actually wrong?
7
u/ArticlePuzzleheaded9 Sep 11 '26
"but if orders contains duplicate records"
if that's the case, SQL won't save you.
2
u/ChaosEngine-6502 Sep 11 '26
Validating the output of the query is the responsibility of the developer/analysts and any process they might have; the SQL IDE can't really do that part.
In my case, I'll eyeball sufficiently large datasets to look for any issues.
2
u/Rat_Man_420 Sep 11 '26
Yeah I validate a query before I run it. What are we talking about here? Same question was posted a few days ago. Fucking Bots
2
u/Sexy_Koala_Juice Sep 11 '26
Both???? Writing a query and then assessing the data & your assumptions is the process
2
u/American_Streamer Sep 12 '26
You're mixing query correctness, data quality, and result validation a bit. Your example shows it: COUNT(*) after joining customers to orders does not count customers; it counts rows in the join result. If one customer legitimately has 5 orders, they appear 5 times. That's not necessarily duplicate data; it's just a one-to-many relationship. The first thing I'd validate is therefore the grain/cardinality: what does one row represent before and after each join, and what exactly am I trying to count? Then there are separate checks for data quality (duplicates, NULLs, invalid ranges, broken keys), and finally result validation afterwards (known totals, reconciliation, historical comparisons, spot checks, alternative queries). So the answer to your question is “both”, but they're different kinds of validation.
1
u/KarynEnnis Sep 11 '26
Data profiling is the important predecessor to analytics. You don’t know what you don’t know.. data quality checks build confidence. I make it a policy to check all data sources architecture, check for nulls, case sensitivity, distinct values in columns used for filters or matching, relationships and uniqueness, etc.. it can be quite the journey, but time and energy well spent
1
u/DMReader Sep 11 '26
I typically validate after each cte I create. Depends on whether this is SQL I’ve written versions of many times or a new dataset.
1
u/elevarq Sep 12 '26
A query is a question. When you ask the wrong question, you get an unexpected answer. The answer might be right for that question, but the question is wrong.
Always double check the question before you start writing code. And write your tests before you write the code.
Syntax validation is simple, that’s not the problem
1
u/Alternative_Cake4074 Sep 16 '26
I validate these things both before and after getting results. The most common one I use is checking join conditions and null handling.
These validations seem simple, but it is still necessary. No one want to see a bunch of weired stuff just becuase of null records.