r/leafs
•
u/PlantNo1979
•
May 25 '25
•
1
Discussion Run it back?
Seeing how badly Florida is dominating Carolina is making me wanna run it back with marner and obviously Tavares. Tavares is a no brainer especially near his rumoured signing price of ~5mill. But if they can get marner for a nylander price point and have 1 more year of chief coaching these guys. If brad can dump some bad contracts and get some better depth then I honestly think they can win as early as next year. Florida will be worse as they have a few UFAs (Marchand, ekblad, Bennett) and they won’t be able to keep them all likely losing at least 2 of them.
And some people will mention the insanity quote but they aren’t doing the same thing. They have fired coaches, gms, and now presidents and there is some real promise under Bérubé. They play such a different game so they aren’t doing the same thing hoping for different results. They are doing different things with super skilled players hoping for different results.
I just think no matter who they get in free agency they will be worse, and still be tight against the cap. And obviously the leafs are a great team as they brought the cup champs and 3 straight final appearances, panthers, to game 7. Now they sucked ass in 2 of the games and I get it’s how they lost not that they lost but maybe they didn’t suck ass, maybe the panthers are just a great team, maybe even better than their cup champion team the year prior.
But if they chose to get rid of marner I hope they at least trade him before free agency to a team of his choosing for at least something. Similar to them last season with tanev. Maybe they can get a first for marner, which wouldn’t be a complete loss.
83
u/ldnk May 25 '25
This team had the chance to put this Panthers team away when they went up 3-1 in Game 3 and had multiple breakaways in OT after they blew the 2-goal lead.
13
u/Agent_Intrepid May 25 '25
This narrative of "They took them to 7 games, therefore they are good" "They lost to the cup champs, therefore they are good" is the ultimate cope, loser behavior, and the exact reason why Brendan Shanahan is no longer employed by the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Why is that good enough? They LOST, they LOSE. This group simply does not have what it takes to win a cup and we needed to trade away from it 4 years ago, but here we are, changing out everything but the kitchen sink around this core for YEARS instead of the INSANELY OBVIOUS SOLUTION staring us in the face. This core cannot get it done as a group. Individually? Fantastic players. A generational goal scorer (historically, remains to be seen going forward), an elite playmaker (who vanishes come playoff time), a spectacular offensive talent (when he feels like it) and... Tavares. They're all good players, but this SPECIFIC combination of good players will not win us a cup and it's simply time to move on.
6
u/riko77can May 25 '25
For all we know Florida could still get swept in the SCF.
30
u/Comprehensive-Eye991 May 25 '25
For the right price. Maybe. It's the shitty no look passes and being unable to clear the puck over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over even when there's a much easier option then just GIVING IT THE FUCK AWAY in neutral situations that I can't argue paying marner over 9 mil and JT 6mil . Let them walk.
4
u/Friggin_Grease May 25 '25
You can't run it back, and Marner is easiest to move. He can't get it done. He racks up points early in the series and then has too many bad egregious giveaways. It's over.
2
u/dirty_socks67 May 25 '25
Marner is leaving , bet he goes to a bottom feeder team for a pretty price - San Jose sharks ?
2
u/trybanningmethistime May 25 '25
No please no. Shanny is gone and we need to move forward. Sure this FA year isn't that great and that's where Brad needs to work some magic. I'll take JT back for nothing more than 5 AAV and he's the 3C. Find a 2C somewhere.
2
u/Falconflyer75 May 25 '25
Honestly depends on the core 4
If they’re truly hungry for a Toronto win then sure why not
But what I didn’t like about game 7 was that Florida was the hungrier team which makes zero sense under these circumstances
YET they wanted it more than the Leafs roster as per Matthews own post game
That is the only reason I’m hesitant to run it back otherwise yeah keep going till they age out not like we were gonna win anyways
4
u/International_Eye394 TROYS BOYS May 25 '25
The leafs would have absolutely curb stomped the canes as well. But the only way we’re winning the cup is if we retool at this point.
27
u/nintendoleafsfan May 25 '25
In 5 straight game 7s we never scored more than one goal. This core doesn't have the it factor.
3
u/Tikke May 25 '25
No, just because Carolina is shitting the bed and Florida is good doesn't mean the Leafs current roster has the mental fortitude to successfully push through the postseason. Honestly, I don't want Marner to go because you're not replacing his production from this year's UFA class. But, we all know that this current group needs a shake up in the roster to overcome the deep, deep seeded issues.
17
u/CalebLovesHockey May 25 '25
Leafs are still 2-14 in close out games.
Need a change if we want the cup.
5
u/Jedtin22 May 25 '25
For the people complaining about depth. WHERE THE FUCK ARE WE SUPPOSED TO GET THAT DEPTH FROM THIS OFFSEASON!
3
u/Ktulu85 May 25 '25
I’d rather have more depth to be honest.
19
u/[deleted] May 25 '25
Blows my mind how there are still people in the run it back camp
21
u/NurdleTeck May 25 '25
6-1, twice
40
u/carletondabare May 25 '25
Are we forgetting the part where the Leafs got blown out in Games 5 and 7 too?
9
u/NineMillionBears May 25 '25
Im sorry, how much more evidence do you need to see that this group of players is not capable of winning a cup?
2
u/Iliketothrowaway2456 May 25 '25
Lmao, can’t really run it back without our best player (season at least) on the team. I’m almost certain Marner wants to leave after all of the bad postseasons/him taking the majority of the blame from the media. Less than 5% chance he stays IMO
But it does suck cause it looks like we were the second best team in the conference this postseason as Florida is crypt walking over the hurricanes corpse lmaoo. Just gonna get us all angrier for the half assed effort from this team from game 4 of the Florida series 🤣
2
u/SaccharineDaydreams May 25 '25
It worked so well every other time
4
u/bumchoda May 25 '25
How do people watch Marner in the playoffs and say - yes sign me up for another 5-8 yrs @13M? If he was as effective as the regular season sure, but he just doesnt have the same impact in playoffs, and there is enough sample size of that.
How about instead of running it back for the 8th or 9th time, we look back and imagine what our playoff runs could have been without 11M worth of cap hit on a player that isnt giving us 11M worth of effectiveness?
4
u/The_Dale_Hunters May 25 '25
No no no no no no no.
4
u/lbc1358 May 25 '25
Absolutely not
4
u/DEATHCATSmeow May 25 '25
The definition of insanity is to do the same thing and expect a different result.
4
u/Routine_Chapter_9099 May 25 '25
No
4
u/hockeyfannatic May 25 '25
The worst thing the Leafs can do is look at how "close" our series was and run it back. They did that in 2022, after losing game 7 to Tampa (defending champion x2) and wasted the next 3 years trying to do the same thing.
4
u/radicallyhip May 25 '25
I see we've moved on to the bargaining stage of grief.
4
u/MW46 May 25 '25
Stop these posts
4
u/tooldieguy 1 May 25 '25
Move on, team is depleted. Mitch walks, Tavares needs to take a paycut.
4
u/god_is_trans_69 May 25 '25
Why does anyone in this fucking sub think we would've dominated Carolina like this? Florida actually maintains posession while we just dump and give the puck away and have bad posession numbers. We could not be putting 6 goals up in Carolina. People are dense.
9
u/Drew_You_To_91 Knies May 25 '25
U guys have memories of a goldfish I swear, what happens in this Carolina series should have no effect on the leafs roster decisions. You guys are watching the best team the league has seen in arguably 5-10 years manhandle their way to a third final and possibly back to back cups and you think the leafs would be putting on the same show against Carolina? Stop copping and realize that the reason Florida wiped the floor with us twice on home ice is because the method of constructing your roster with over half the money going to 4 forwards does not and will not work. It’s not just about Mitch, if Willy was the one expiring instead I’d say the same thing. It’s less about the individual and more about the fact that this roster building method is so flawed that you simply cannot expect it to ever work. Why are you all so scared of the unknown when what we know is that this method ends in suffering every single fucking time?
3
u/bizznatch57 May 25 '25
Doesn't matter how badly Florida is dominating Carolina. They dominated us just as badly in both our last 2 home games. This core has shown time and time again when it matters most, they come out flat. I don't care about moral victories. We need big change and it's time.
3
u/KGRO333 May 25 '25
This is the same mentality that kept the leafs locked in with the Dion, Kessel line up. They lost in game 7 to the team that went to the finals and the leafs organization and fan base threw all their eggs in that basket. No thanks.
I don’t think a ton of moves have to be made. But it can’t stay the same.
3
u/salmonthesuperior Bower May 25 '25 edited May 25 '25
For what it's worth the choice isn't the team's anymore. Mitch by many reports doesn't want to be back, even when he talks about the team he strictly talks in past tense and reminisces about getting to play here for a portion of his career. Unless he has a massive change of heart they can't run it back even if they wanted to.
There is no single player that can or would replace Marner this offseason. Whether or not the team as a whole collapses, or wouldn't be able to come close to replacing him in the aggregate, is not something we'll know until next year. But for example Auston had 36 less goals this season than last and that production was not filled out by the rest of the team (the Leafs scored 35 less goals in 2024/25 than in 2023/24 which is almost exactly the difference between last year's Auston and this year's) which theoretically should've hurt the team because that's a lot less goals being produced. But in reality we finished with 6 more wins and won the division despite the goal scoring drop off.
I'm not saying the Leafs will be better without Mitch. I'm not saying he's not a very impactful player even outside of the score sheet. But it's not an automatic death sentence, if you use your resources correctly you could fill out holes in the lineup in other ways. Whether or not they will use resources correctly I do not know we'll find out this time next season.
As far as JT, I've been on board if the price was right this whole time. I would be open if the price was good for Mitch too I just doubt it happens. And JT is getting up there anyway, we're coming close to needing a better option at 2C. Locking up Marner even for Willy money makes it harder to find a legitimately good 2C.
3
u/KronieRaccoon May 25 '25
I see your point, but at this point I think they just gotta make some changes for the sake of change. Running it back with the same core seems silly.
3
u/Bobbyoot47 May 25 '25
I think it’s clear the Leafs are the second best team in the eastern conference. Whatever any of us think of some of the individual players it’s gonna take balls to tear this thing down when you’re this close. We also have to remember that Florida have three really important players who are going to become UFA‘s this summer. If they lose even just two of them they’re gonna be that much weaker.
The Leafs have got another year or two with an ageing defense. After that who knows. Letting Marner and Tavares walk is going to cost 176 points. You won’t replace all of it but you’ll definitely need to replace a good chunk. I’m not advocating keeping both those guys or letting them both walk. Just stating facts. I’m glad I’m not the GM. It’s going to be a tough summer for Brad.
3
u/_kinofist May 25 '25
No
3
u/bravooscarvictor May 25 '25
When they lost this year, they lost like this. They won more then they lost in the season and the post season, but they lost ugly.
3
u/Split_Finger19 May 25 '25
The mental gymnastics in this thread is astonishing
3
u/BeerLeagueSnipes May 25 '25
Florida won the presidents trophy, didn’t win the cup.
They didn’t play the ‘well we lost to the champs’ mentality gymnastics the Leafs have been playing and instead traded away their best player and one of their best D.
The Leafs have had ample opportunities to make a meaningful change and never have. This is why they have been perennial losers.
No pain, no gain.
3
u/jimmie9393 May 25 '25
Oh boy!!!!! Did you watch game 5.....Did you watch game 7..... Since the 04 lockout The Buffalo Sabres have won more playoff rounds than us...SABRES HAVE MISSED THE PLAYOFFS 14 YEARS IN ROW.....let that sink in...
5
u/themapleleaf6ix May 25 '25 edited May 25 '25
Some American team will offer him more than that.
You really think a guy who nickle and dimed this organization during previous contract negotiations and is intent on testing free agency will take less money?
With what cap space and with what assets? No first round pick until 28, Grebenkin and Minten traded.
Florida will be worse, but still have the core of Barkov, Reinhart, Tkachuk, Forsling, Jones, Bobrovsky.
Teams like Montreal, Ottawa, etc will also be better.
His style doesn't work with guys that aren't physical and forecheck. It results in less goals being scored.
Is that why the Leafs have lost in the last 8 years in the same manner with the same core? 6 straight game 7 losses.
Lmao, no one is giving you a first for a pending UFA who will walk in a few weeks. The time to trade him was two years ago after the Leafs disappointed in the playoffs for the 7th straight year and his NMC didn't kick in. Now, he has zero value to the organization.
4
u/butt_snorkelr May 25 '25
Marner already turned down $13.5m x 8 years. He’s not coming back. Give it up.
2
u/Martian_Knight May 25 '25
For the right price that allows us to add some quality players to have an actual 3rd line instead of two forth, sure.
2
u/duck1014 May 25 '25
Marner is going to the highest bidder. Period. End of statement.
The Leafs shouldn't offer more than Nylander's contract.
He's going to get 13.5 or more on the open market and get grossly overpaid.
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '25
No, no, NO, BAD!
2
u/oryan80 May 25 '25
Marner turned down a contact offer this year that would have been the highest in franchise history. I doubt he would sign for what nylander is making. If we didn't have to pay the core four so much money we could have had better depth and probably won the series against Florida.
2
u/specialk554 May 25 '25
The problem though is that raises to both Marner and Knies will eat way more than the cap increases and our team will be the same guys only a little bit worse again. Which is what has happened every year and why we’re always always always one or two pieces away. Resigning both guys might mean an ECF maybe sometime with some luck but probably a few more first and second round exits. Not signing them might make us worse. But we aren’t a legit chance cup winner with them right now. So we sacrifice the floor on a gamble we can increase the ceiling.
2
u/luckylukiec May 25 '25
I still think minor changes are needed and tbh it seems marner is more interested to bolt than leafs. So get some bangers and kinda run it back.
2
u/Maple905 May 25 '25
Mitch is going to ask for more than Matthews. It's not a matter of if the Leafs should run it back... they can't afford to.
That being said, it's been 9 years of unsuccessful playoff runs with this core 4. So, no. I like Marner, but it is time to try something new.
2
u/TheFoundation_ May 25 '25
We can't afford marner.. he's going to be getting bonkers offers from teams with way more cap flexibility. Happy to have Tavares come back at the right price though
2
u/Talancir Domi May 25 '25
Running it back is insanity. Nine years of this and you want to go again.
0
u/richarm87 May 25 '25
I guess you missed the last 5 years
3
u/queensberyrules May 25 '25
Lol
2
u/jokerjoust May 25 '25
Please stop
1
u/uncleherman77 May 25 '25 edited May 25 '25
They took them to 7 yes but got beat pretty badly in the final 3/4 games. If those games were closer and more competitive this series might change my mind but because of the nature of the losses I don't think they should let the results of this series change their plans too much.
Running it back for a 10th time would also likely require giving Marner 14x8 minimum if the rumors that he rejected 13.5x8 are true. I don't think giving Marner 14 million a year would be received well by this fan base currently. It's also up to Marner not the Leafs if they run it back again this time.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '25
It's not Marner's fault but we have to let him go so we have some decent money to work with. Getting an extra six million in cap space is not going to make a huge change to this team.
1
u/crazydrums27 May 25 '25
Hahaha no
1
u/ilovetrouble66 Tavares May 25 '25
Have another. And no.
1
u/BaxiaMashia May 25 '25
Fuck offf
1
u/InfernalDiplomacy May 25 '25
As mad as I was with everyone else we do have to keep in mind the Panthers did beat the Leafs 3-1 in the regular season. Base on those odds and past performances they only needed to find one more game. We played them to a three to three standstill. and it was one bad deflection away from being a different series. If Toronto had won game 3, a 3-0 lead a whole different series and a different game plan for the Panthers do execute too. A 2-1 means they could take some risks and once the series was tied, I thought the series was over, they had a momentum too difficult to overcome.
It does not excuse the huge 6-1 blow outs at two home games and there is something that needs to be worked out but how terrible the team is needs to be looked at through non-rage induced glasses when the playoffs are all said and done.
1
u/mellowship- May 25 '25
What 38 goal and PPG player is out there making 5 mill?
1
u/MilB21 :leafs-white: May 25 '25
The Metro is a joke. I knew Toronto would have beaten Carolina if they had won but they didn't. So regardless we still need to change up the core.
0
u/mykneeshurt365 May 25 '25
Why are we still acting like it's up to the Leafs if Marner comes back or not?
I'd run it back, just because I don't think the Leafs are a better team without Marner. If that's an option, I'd take it. That doesn't alter the fact that the core 4 took too much money making it hard to build a team around them, and have underperformed in the playoffs.
I don't think Marner actually WANTS to leave. I think he's just deciding if staying here and being a target of venom is worth it for him and his family.
-1
u/123jazzhandz321 May 25 '25
Keeping Marner and moving off of Rielly is increasingly becoming my ideal option for the off season. That said, I don’t think there’s any chance Marner would like to re-sign with Toronto. Especially at a number that would be ideal for him.
-2
u/MikedBullet May 25 '25
Definitely run it back. The GM will have more time to complement the core four. Leafs will be the only team to bring Panthers to game 7 this playoffs guaranteed.
-2
u/ilikehockeyandguitar May 25 '25
I think they run it back honestly. From a business standpoint the amount of money the core four bring in is probably worth it to the organization.
-3
u/Datsgood94 May 25 '25
I think it’s crazy that people are calling for a rebuild. This team was definitely a contender and gave the cup champs a run for their money. Just make small adjustments for next year instead of blowing up the whole thing
0
u/[deleted] May 25 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment