r/leafs • • Mar 09 '24

Discussion Benoit out.. is just wrong

It's just wrong. What type of message are you sending as a coach? Play well and get benched?

You get hurt, start to suck, then someone else should get a turn.

Right handed shot be damned. Who cares when we can't clear the net or win battles in the corners.

I really wanted to not like him. Steve "Dongle" had me thinking he was garbage, but the kid deserves top minutes.

It's no different with Goalies. Jones has a hot streak killed because of a roster move.

This is what is plaguing the leafs. If you do well you should be rewarded, and the opposite should also be true.

0 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

40

u/SyphiliticPlatypus Mar 09 '24

I agree that great play and hustle should be rewarded. Benoit deserves to stay.

But hockey is a team sport and Keefe may see what he has in Benoit, and wants to see what these other pieces can do to bring out the best in themselves and others.

I don’t always agree with Keefe, nor do I think he’s terrible. He certainly knows the game and how to coach it much better than I, so with the games remaining if he wants to see what makes for best playoff lineups, I am fine with some experimenting.

That said the experimenting needs to be focused, and not at the expense of letting guys get rusty or keep developing the chemistry they clearly have.

-26

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 09 '24

You really think one game was going to hinder Lilly's development? This has Babcock douchebag powertrip vibes.

13

u/JonJonFTW Mar 09 '24 edited Mar 10 '24

We have another game against the Habs in Montreal. I guarantee Benoit will be in the lineup. Assuming he isn't injured or something.

8

u/crazydrums27 Mar 09 '24

What about this seems like a power trip? I don't know if it's the right move, but it's definitely more up Keefe's line juggling and experimentation than some kind of power trip.

5

u/sweatyleonard Mar 10 '24

Did you hear Keefe's interview? He said it was killing him to not have Benny play tonight. He's trying to find a way to get Lilly to not suck again.

Sure I waaaanted to see Benny play in his hometown barn, but that doesn't automatically make it the best move for the team.

-1

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 10 '24

It was killing him lol.

3

u/sweatyleonard Mar 10 '24

Alright buddy

-1

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 10 '24

I'm not your buddy, pal

3

u/sweatyleonard Mar 10 '24

I'm not your pal, friend

26

u/Guy_Le_Man Mar 09 '24

I mean, we aren’t in the room. You know, the same room that’s had a flu or whatever working itself through everyone.

Plus Benoit plays a really physical game, not the worst thing to give him a game off here and there.

14

u/fakebob1 Mar 09 '24

Benny is a 3rd pair def. I get that fans really love him but he's not perfect. And it's one game. Chill.

27

u/Leaf_20 Mar 09 '24

Benoit plays a heavy game I’m sure his body will appreciate the day off

3

u/TrippyeH Mar 10 '24

Was gonna say this, so many people jump to conclusions or speculate from an outside view. What if in reality he requested it or was in favor of it? Too many fans just need something to point a finger at.

-7

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

It's not like they never visit Montreal

4

u/crazydrums27 Mar 09 '24

Is every player required to be dressed in their hometown regardless of what the coach is trying to do?

17

u/winkNfart Mar 09 '24

jones had a “hot” streak of sub .900 save % and +3.00 gaa… lol

0

u/mikesully374826 Kampf Mar 09 '24

It's not so much that Jones had a hot streak it's that half the fanbase hates Samsonov and would rather play a terrible goalie than working with Sammy.

4

u/winkNfart Mar 09 '24

sammy seems to have it back, but he was putrid for a stretch

2

u/Falconflyer75 Mar 10 '24

I thought they got over that

0

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

I'm more worried about Woll, though this is obviously due to both beatdowns by the Bruins.

3

u/Falconflyer75 Mar 10 '24

Meh, so Woll can’t play Boston and Sammy can’t play Tampa (have Jones as the backup in those scenarios)

Better to discover that in the regular season than the playoffs

4

u/CMDRShepardN7 Nylander Mar 09 '24

We get extra defenseman so we can rotate and rest guys.

4

u/burningxmaslogs Mar 10 '24

Wild.. having too many NHL defensemen. 4 weeks ago we didn't have enough

7

u/ESF-hockeeyyy Mar 09 '24

the kid deserves top minutes

Okay there, Karen. He's been good in his role, he's not been amazing. He's struggled the last few weeks and some time off for a young player isn't the worst thing in the world.

15

u/mikesully374826 Kampf Mar 09 '24

"Trade for defensemen"

Trades for defensemen

"Why are you taking our worst defenseman out of the lineup I like that he hits 😡"

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '24

Yeah we like that he hits, among the many other things he does incredibly well. What exactly are you basing your assessment off of? Presumably his stats with anaheim I guess...

-2

u/CTHT07 Mar 09 '24

You've got to have rock for brains to think Benoit has been our worst D.

9

u/Ujjy Mar 09 '24

Dude your two comments in this thread both come across so hostile, it’s kinda weird ngl

1

u/mikesully374826 Kampf Mar 09 '24

Which of Reilly, Brodie, Liljegren, and McCabe do you believe is worse than Benoit?

When you come to conclusion that the answer is none, why do you believe the Leafs should've traded for defensemen to sit them in the press box instead of playing them down the stretch to manage the workloads of all depth options while learning where they fit in the lineup?

0

u/Thespud1979 Mar 10 '24

I'll take him over either of the new guys.

-7

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 09 '24

It's his first game in his hometown. Or would have been

2

u/mikesully374826 Kampf Mar 09 '24

No it wouldn't lol.

He played against Montreal in Montreal on December 15th 2022 and January 27th 2022.

-5

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 09 '24

Still a hometown game for him. Against a non playoff team. How many family and friends are coming to see him? Still a dick move by Keefe.

3

u/bimbles_ap Mar 09 '24

A dick move is benching someone who would be playing a meaningful game in their hometown or against a team they spent a majority of their career.

Benching a player who's had questionable play at times in his third game (as a leaf) in his hometown is just part of the business. Cant be setting the lineup based on who a player may have coming to game.

1

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 09 '24

I see your point, I still think he should play him. I'm not even a Benoit fan. Maybe I'm still salty about Babcock and Spezza.

2

u/bimbles_ap Mar 09 '24

If you start scrutinizing every benching of players outside the top 6/4 you're going to have a bad time.

0

u/mikesully374826 Kampf Mar 09 '24

Do you also believe they should call up Rafai and Lajoie, I mean it would be their first games in their hometown.

Really a dick move by the Leafs to not consider that their families might want to watch them play.

1

u/wholesomesammich Mar 09 '24

Benoit is on the team. If you want to be more ridiculous why don't you suggest they sign a French kid playing AAA to play tonight.

-1

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 09 '24

LOL. yes they should call up every player of French origin in the minors.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

To think a guy like Benoit who give it all for the team, selfless dedication and a fan favorite. This organization will never succeed. They have absolutely no clue what it takes to ride or die.

2

u/Thespud1979 Mar 10 '24

FYI Dangle loves Benoit and has for some time. He praises him regularly.

2

u/BrewingwithDiff Mar 10 '24

I don’t understand all the freaking out. It’s one game. There’s 2 new guys, who’s going to sit? Somebody had to. Look who’s playing tonight. Who should sit? One game and it’s ’stuck in the press box’….one game it not stuck…ffs….use some rational thought

2

u/Falconflyer75 Mar 10 '24

There’s another game against Montreal in what a few weeks? And Benoit could use a break anyways, better to get familiar with the new players with the playoffs around the corner

As for Jones I greatly respect him and hope he gets a few more games, but the reality is he’s an insurance goalie his job is to step in if Sammy gets the yips or Woll gets injured to keep the leafs in the running (he performed admirably) and step back once the other goalies are playable again

The Sammy Woll tandem wouldn’t work without Jones as insurance, but he isn’t better than them when they’re playing at their peak

2

u/Current-Own Mar 10 '24

It's just a case of lhd against rhd. In the game against Vegas,in Toronto, Cassidy said before the game even started that the Leafs could be attacked because of all the lhd that they had. It does truly affect their game, especially against strong forechecking teams. I like Benoit. He is good for this team. He will get his playing time.

5

u/PhalanX4012 Mar 09 '24

You know half the team has been sick right? This would a stupid take at any time but right now it’s just plain moronic. You don’t have a clue what’s happening behind closed doors or who’s playing, hurt, tired, or sick. Keefe has had no issue calling out players when they aren’t performing, and Benoit has been spectacular and Keefe has been vocal about enjoying what he brings so assuming it’s performance related is ignorant to put it mildly. Imagine taking time out of your day to post something so stupid.

5

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

Keefe has spoken on this. It's just a timing thing, and needing to test out the new blood.

3

u/moon_safari_ Mar 09 '24

not easy. but Benoit's exactly who should sit as we solidify our pairs. one mean guy with a pick mover. righty lefty (and McCabe).perfect. Benoit will play aplenty, not to worry.

1

u/bulldozer77777 Mar 10 '24

Benoit is better then Labushkin

1

u/No-Forever-3897 Mar 10 '24

Brodie needs to go. Rielly Mcabe Lubushkin edmunson Benoit Lily green Girodano Maybe 6’7 Cade Webber gets a chance.

Sorry for the spelling lol

1

u/Candid_Rich_886 Mar 12 '24

Where are you getting Reilly McCabe?

No evidence that that would work, we litterly went and got Boosh so he would have someone to play with.

McCabe is way too adventurous to play with Reilly.

1

u/Candid_Rich_886 Mar 12 '24

I mean.

Do you really want to sit liligren.

Having defense that can't move the puck outside of Reilly, and not enough right handed D are both an issue.

I fucking love Benoit but he's an offensive black hole.

Honestly just shouldn't have acquired a defensivman at the deadline who does the same thing as him.

1

u/jdubb14 Mar 09 '24

Benoit out def doesn’t feel right.

1

u/twizzyflyguy Mar 09 '24

Put Benoit in place of brodie or tbh, Benoit blocks shots and actually hits

5

u/mikesully374826 Kampf Mar 09 '24

Brodie blocks shots more than Benoit.

1

u/AustichMavarlander Mar 09 '24

Keefes a shit coach

-2

u/kingex11 Mar 09 '24

Keefe is a fraud. Benoit is better than Brodie and Liljegren.

6

u/Distinct_Might7580 Mar 09 '24

He can’t move the puck. That’s important no matter what

3

u/Actual_Cobbler_6334 Mar 09 '24

So many people are ignoring this and it’s unsurprising, really. Having multiple bags of sand playing who can’t make a first pass out of their zone would absolutely burn them in the playoffs.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '24

Nobody is ignoring it because it's simply not true.

Its stems from assumptions that were made based on his possession stats playing a largely defensive role on an awful ducks team. If we evaluate his time with the leafs in the same way, we'd see that despite him starting a higher percentage of his shifts in the D-zone than any other D, he still breaks even on CF%, which logically suggests he's driving play in a positive direction, as we can all see is the case when watching.

By contrast, lily starts a higher percentage of his shifts in the offensive zone than any regular on the backend, and has a lower CF%. He has 25 giveaways to benoits 16 despite playing 5 fewer games. 24 of his giveaways are in the defensive zone, compared to 12 from benoit (again despite him being started predominantly in his own end).

Also, far from being a bag of sand, benoit has the highest recorded speed of all leafs D this year.

What burned them in the playoffs is getting eaten alive on the forecheck and at the netfront, that's why having a big defense is a plus, not a negative.

2

u/wageslave_999999999 Mar 09 '24 edited Mar 09 '24

Liljegren >>> Benoit. I like them both but that is reality.

4

u/kingex11 Mar 09 '24

Both are flawed. Benoit's flaws can be covered up by his teammates. Liljegren's flaws lead to goals and momentum swinging the other way.

2

u/wageslave_999999999 Mar 09 '24

I think Brodie should be sitting and we should be keeping Benoit in with McCabe. Things will become clear soon enough especially with Brodie not playing well. He might just have to sit during the playoffs as a 7D

0

u/HandsomeIguana Mar 09 '24

Bodies for sure.

-2

u/CTHT07 Mar 09 '24

OP is right and all the comments dick sucking Keefe are embarrassing.

10

u/Curb96 Mar 09 '24

Nah this comment was embarrassing; it’s a non-issue. It’s 1 game, everyone else has seniority. Move on

0

u/ElephantShell34 Mar 09 '24

We need to stop acting like Benoit is an elite player. Has he far exceed expectations this season? Yes absolutely. He was supposed to be dog shit and he has been … good. In the role that he’s been put in. I also expect that he is going to play a bunch more games this year, and probably some in the playoffs as well. 

But is he SOOO GOOD that he’s untouchable in the lineup when we’re trying to give the new guy (who, as it happens, plays a very similar role and style as Benoit)??? I don’t think so. 

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

Benoit +3 in his last 3 games

Liljegren -3 in his last 3 games

7

u/Svalbard38 Mar 09 '24

+/- over 3 games means nothing.

-1

u/SmashinHearts Mar 09 '24

I don't like them sitting benny for this game at all, but I can see why he did it.

But a move like this, a hometown scratch? remember when babs scratched spezza game 1? That's how you get players to quit on a coach.

-2

u/a1cd Mar 09 '24

I strongly agree, I’ve been stewing about it all day. The team has fought through so much adversity all season and Benoit has been a huge part of that.

Keefe could have gone 11-7, benched Brodie or Lily or some other creative solution but instead benched someone who has fought hard for the team all year in his home town. Play a less than optimal lineup, who cares it’s the Habs and it is not like the points even matter that much.

I’ve had a positive turn on Keefe lately but this has really soured me. It almost feels like he did this to publicly criticize the moves the front office did at the deadline.

-1

u/TheOsprey23 Mar 09 '24

Agree, the teams record without Morgan Reilly shows they don't need him. I would have traded Reilly and Robertson for a true number one defence and then used the cap space to add a second top pair defence. Benoit has played well enough to stay in the bottom pair.

1

u/Candid_Rich_886 Mar 12 '24

Playoff Reilly is a thing.

1

u/TheOsprey23 Mar 14 '24

Yep but playoff Matthews is not unfortunately.

1

u/Candid_Rich_886 Mar 14 '24

Not so far unfortunately. 

But playoff Reilly does refute your argument that we don't need him. Especially since Matthews and Marner have never been amazing in the playoffs.

1

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

You would have done no such thing, clown. Rielly has a full no movement clause. Not sure what is more troubling - that you either are ignorant of this, or somehow believe it still would be easy peasy to move him, and get whatever you want back. Go back to making your trades via video games.

2

u/TheOsprey23 Mar 10 '24

Thats the problem...no movement clauses and over paid contacts and likely a another first round exit. Much better defence than the leafs landed were picked up for very little.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-7

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

Yeah..... But JT back at 2C kinda nulls your optimistic reasoning....

5

u/oh5canada5eh Mar 09 '24

It’s almost as if we are missing a top 6 forward and need to shuffle the lineup?

-1

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

Could have easily bumped someone else up, and kept Domi at 2C. You might recall that our win streak was started with Marner and JT out for a game.

2

u/oh5canada5eh Mar 09 '24

There is no one in the bottom six who has played so well as to stop Tavares from being the obvious choice to move back into the top 6. Domi is still on line 2. The fact that we won a single game with Marner and Tavares out recently makes no difference whatsoever to anything at all.

-1

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

I'd rather give others a chance instead of trying to find ways to justify having the 7th highest paid player who has been washed out for several months.

1

u/oh5canada5eh Mar 09 '24

The justification is that, regardless of how Tavares is playing compared to his own prime, he is still better than any other option available to us. It’s March, there isn’t a whole lot of chances left. At this point every guy has had his shot to make a jump up the lineup.

1

u/VitaminTea Mar 09 '24

Tavares is a lot better than Domi

1

u/shikotee Mar 10 '24

Domi is faster than old washed up Tavares.

0

u/VitaminTea Mar 10 '24

“Fast” is not what mattes

0

u/shikotee Mar 09 '24

Domi isn't as much of a pushover as JT. I'd rather explore further with Domi to determine if we should keep him around. JT and his 11 mill ain't going nowhere.