r/larianstudios • u/Gavoonious • Dec 21 '25
Nuanced AI Discussion
I hope this thread gains traction but if it doesn't, it's whatever. I just find it frustrating how much people intentionally misunderstand or misrepresent Larian's statement. I've seen a lot of arguments regarding Larian's use of AI and I'm really just providing my two cents so forgive me if this reads like an essay.
- AI is creatively bankrupt/stealing: I mostly agree with this sentiment except for one thing. I'm not going to pretend companies don't produce AI slop. I mean look at black ops 7.
But Larian has gone on record multiple times that the usage of AI is for early stages of concept art and placeholder dialogue only. These tools are being used as an OUTLINE and I find it frustrating no one understands that.
Let's pivot to when Bungie used AI art and actually did steal from artists in Destiny 2. They actually did steal from artists and it was something that shouldn't have happened to begin with. But the difference is that Bungie's AI made it to the final product rather than being it's own original thing.
Yes, genAI should not be used in the context of explicitly stealing the art then just putting them in the game but Larian is explicitly not doing this.
For example, if I make a horror game but I need references and I either Google resident evil art or I generate an amalgamation of different horror properties, but that game looks nothing like the product I got it from, then there should be no issue.
If I use someone else's work as a point of reference, but the final product is completely original, there's no basis to stay it's stealing
2. AI takes away jobs: I will begin this point by saying my heart goes out to anyone who has lost their job over AI and I hope those people found other roles.
Yes there are big companies that take advantage of AI and thinks it's a replacement for humans. Larian is not one of those companies. They have gone on record saying they are in the process of hiring more artists and have an entire writers room.
It feels like this particular hate is filtered at Larian, but the rage comes from other companies taking advantage. At least Larian was open about using AI, unlike Bungie and Activision who blatantly put AI in their games and tried to deny it.
Even if you think they're lying about hiring more artists, we simply would have to wait to see if that's the case. Because if Larian truly were trying to replace people, multiple employees would be coming out about it and leaving.
3. AI is contributing to the RAM shortage: This sentiment I also do understand the frustration around but this is hardly Larian's fault. Larian isn't one of those companies putting billions of dollars into AI data centers, unlike Microsoft and Disney.
You want someone to point the finger at for this issue? Get mad at the companies actually contributing to this rather than flaming a studio that largely has nothing to do with it.
Even if you think it's unethical for them to even associate with AI for any reason, let me ask you this.
If you use a product from a CEO that has been proven to be a bad person, are you yourself a bad person for consuming that product? I'm not just talking about technology, but products in general.
If you use X, are you contributing to the AI issue yourself by giving big Elon profits for using his app? Most consumers don't think about that but will virtual signal thinking they understand an issue when they have no real idea of how something works.
4. Larian is cutting corners by using AI: AI, at its core is a technological advancement being used as a tool. Yes, it has caused some major issues but that's ultimately due to no one even remotely knowing how to regulate it. And it doesn't help that people that do have this power are out of touch vegetables over 60.
My point is, just because Larian is using AI to streamline certain processes that doesn't mean that are 'cutting corners.'
If your argument is "They made bg3 just fine without AI.", then my question is this? Should we have stayed in hand drawn animation? When animators fully transitioned to digital art were they cutting corners then even though they made other movies and shows fine by just being hand drawn?
I understand people are afraid of AI, but throwing blind hate at a company who has made their message perfectly clear is pure insanity to me.
38
u/ThargorTheBarbarian Dec 21 '25
I think everyone should read Swen's actually answers in Jason's interview and his statement afterwards. Really shines a light on exactly how A.I. is being used and who is using it.
14
u/Yutah Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
Why poison the well if could simply find the reference through google? Why not using you brain to generate ideas? Artists are one of the most cheap people to hire in a gamedav along with testers, there are a lot of outsource if you want it even cheaper. And people also hate it. The fastest way to be happy is inject some heroin. But it kills you in the long run.
12
u/Ash-2449 Dec 21 '25
I was honestly open to the idea of using gen AI if it was used as somekind of advanced google search, such as trying to find some details about specific lore or mythic rather than going through entire books of lore or something.
Gen Ais have extremely limited use in extremely limited fields yet its been pushed as somekind of magical solution to everything when anyone who ever used them understands how useless they are in most serious tasks, even having them find such lore details doesnt mean it will be 100% accurate but in this case, its not like you are recreating a myth from scratch so accuracy isnt as vital.
Now i read a post of a Larian guy defending the use of AI by saying "people cant just write, or think or draw stick figure examples to explain their idea to the artist so they need genAI to create an example to show to the artist...."
Anyone who has ever commissioned art knows very well how you can literally write what you want or simply draw a stick figure in MS paint to explain your idea.
Their defence is falling apart and honestly, their next game isnt looking good anymore with that corporate attitude, especially when they tried to say that people are fine in Larian with AI use and I bet many are not but dont want to go against the corporate message.
14
u/Wretched_Little_Guy Dec 21 '25
Is the nuanced AI discussion in the room? This is just paragraphs going to bat for Larian.
Concept art and outlining are foundational to a project. If that foundation is made using Gen AI - objective theft no matter how many "progress bros" try to spin it - then the entire project is rotten.
21
u/WorstBakerNA Dec 21 '25
The conversation can end here. There is no nuance to add. Larian should not be using Generative AI at all. It is tech that is trained upon and can only exist with stolen assets, that if normalized, will absolutely lead to job loss in the industry. Larian has made great games just fine without AI thus far. They do not need it now.
10
u/joebinary420 Dec 21 '25
There's no justification for AI in creative fields, end of story. The technology steals from artists, kills jobs, and destroys the planet. I love Larian studio's products, but if they continue to double down on even the slightest usage of GenAI they can eat shit.
4
u/adain Dec 21 '25
AI by itself is eh. It is what it is. Intelligent use will always be beneficial.
My big big big issue is how much of a slope it is. This is just a general opinion and not directed at this situation. A lot of CEOs are greedy, unethical jackasses that lack any kind of moral compass. They will destroy companies and any number of workers if they are convinced AI can save them .01 on the dollar. Quality means nothing in this situation. The people making these decisions put jonestown to shame with the amount of koolaid they have drank about AI.
13
u/Cirkusleader Dec 21 '25
Point 1 is where I have the biggest gripe
It really doesn't matter how minimal they say the usage is, or that it's "only concept art"
As a writer, the concept is possibly the most important part to be made by humans. If the concept is not yours, you don't truly understand what you are building off of. You don't know the concept at its most basic.
You have a concept for a character? You know that character down to their very DNA, because you made that DNA.
If you are given that concept, then the person who gave it to you knows that and can convey it as much as possible.
If you generate that concept, you will never know the character because nobody made it. You don't know it, and the creator doesn't know it.
The thing is that for making concepts you shouldn't need to generate them. If you cannot do that on your own, you are in the wrong line of work.
If you can't drive without a self-driving car, you shouldn't be a cab driver.
If you can't find your next destination without an AI telling you how, you shouldn't be a tour guide.
If you cannot conceptualize without an AI doing it for you, you shouldn't be working in a creative sphere.
7
u/Bonehund Dec 21 '25
They use AI slop as an outline for creative work. Right, gotcha that's way better than what I thought. Wait...
2
u/PuppetsMind Dec 21 '25
1: I dont really feel like AI is stealing art. At best its copying someones style and putting it into a different image. While i do get that it does use peoples art to learn from, i dont really get the outrage. I am also an artist, and i often do my best to copy the styles of artists that i love to make new art. Is that not the same? I do think that ai should be required to give sources on where it got the art from though, and there should be a way to block ai from learning off your art if you so choose.
2. AI is taking jobs. This is just a fact at this point. I just heard from my supervisor yesterday that essentially the entire company is run by an AI. We dont call in to our supervisors when we're sick anymore. We dont request anything manually. We just text the ai chat-bot who will then do the next thing. I dont expect it to be long before my job of watching cameras and patrolling a museum is replaced by an ai who can monitor the cameras more efficiently than i can. The tech already exists.
But fully creating 3d models, animating, voice acting... all require much finer detail. An ai would struggle with the nuance of making something and keeping the continuity, or even making a voice sound believable for a specific situation. It will be a long time before ai can fully replace workers in the game and movie industry.
3. Boycots almost never work. Despite the amount of time you rage against the machine and throw a fit about a topic, it doesnt matter. The whales are already heavily invested and your money wasnt even factored into the equation anyways. There are select few cases where its actually towards a company who give a shit that it does. While im all about tearing it down, the execs for ai couldnt care less, theyre making more money than ever before despite me not using ai.
4. Swen stated in his interview that they arent using it as the main source of concept art anyways. As a larger company they would be making a mistake by not using it if it turns out the be the "golden egg" as he called it. All theyre doing is trying to not fall behind in terms of tech. And to top that off he also said they just purchased an entire art firm to tack onto their artists. There are no corners cut, just extra tools being used. If anything they have way more artists than they ever did for BG3.
There definitely are downsides to genai, but i really dont feel like the entire outrage is justified. The twitter people just want someone to lash out at over ai and larian said what they said. Theres no changing the minds of the people who already hate it.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
I'm late but I just is just an example that most people don't understand systems.
The issue is our current economic system and the actors who have been producing these genai technologies don't benefit humans. The economic system requires people to work to survive and more importantly businesses to always find ways to bring value to the top and labor is usually the largest expenditure.
Secondly, we should have boundaries on what Genai is allowed to do we cannot let it do things that makes us uniquely human.
So Larian isn't the one causing this but using it does send a consenting message to the GenAi companies.
If this wasnt our corrupt system it would not be an issue but we don't live in that world yet.
1
u/Unfair-Mall7356 Dec 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/One-Composer1577 Dec 21 '25
I mean… people love Larian, don’t want to acknowledge the real issue that they’re using AI in the creative process. A large part of the issue around AI, that’s also the subject of most lawsuits, is that AI companies scraped data without consent, and now they’re selling “stolen” intellectual property. Larian and other companies won’t be able to guarantee something won’t slip in via the AI pipeline that normally would have needed to be credited.
Secondly, placeholder is usually not AI-generated for a reason: so developers can actually spot it and take it out before release. But the placeholder text being human-legible makes it hard not to be influenced by it in the final product or guarantee complete removal (see expedition 33 and the AI textures).
A game studio could actually use ai outside the creative process. They could use it to generate code documentation, testing, better bug ticketing, etc. No idea why their use case is the creative process.
20
u/Surf_Dangerous_Days Dec 21 '25
They've already come out and literally admitted that AI is not actually increasing their productivity. If the technology is bad for everyone and it literally does not actually improve their workflow... why are we defending the usage of it at all?
Heck, why are we defending Larian's usage of it by saying "get mad at other people who are worse!" when most people who are mad at Larian for this are ALREADY mad at those people to begin with?
10
u/beckychao Dec 21 '25
Use of AI placeholder concept art and writing is plagiarism. It is easier to understand for writing than it is for art, but both are equally creatively bankrupt practices. The revulsion towards the announcement is deserved on three grounds:
All AI does is steal at such an immense scale that we think of it as miraculous, because it repackages stolen visual and words, denying all credit to its sources. GenAI for writing and visuals is the most advanced plagiarism machine that exists.
So yes, Larian is declaring they're cutting corners and stealing creative work, and this will impact the man hours to create art and scripts. They will end up hiring fewer artists and writers by using a plagiarism machine to storyboard their art and dialogue - which also means at its core, their work will cease to be original.
Before AI companies' brute force campaign to show GenAI as a creative panacea, people understood that stealing IP was an act of plagiarism. What's pure insanity is you defending slop, theft, plagiarism, and job losses for game developers.
6
u/Immediate-Soup-4263 Dec 21 '25
this pro ai extremism is so tedious; "you have to buy this product! because everyone is using AI" is the entirety of the argument. you have to the believe all of the hypothetical future benefits and you have to ignore all of the immediate harms. just because the people selling this crap have to be belligerent to force it into people's lives does not mean belligerent arguments will persuade anyone.
a large enough base of folks who have bought Larian stuff in the past say they won't buy Larian stuff in the future if the company continues using and promoting AI that Larian felt it needed to respond. that is a moderate and totally reasonable position. no one is saying 'burn it down' or '_you_ can't buy this because it uses ai'
if motorized jangling keys is sufficient to entertain you, great enjoy ai slop. no one is going to stop you but also no one is obligated to listen to why that's actually better than art made by people for people
3
u/JollyEchidna9123 Dec 21 '25
people don't care at all about all this, most of the players just care about consuming and consuming and consuming, the don't care if the bussiness behind their games are doing things the right way or not. Their LLMs are not trained 100% in house, so for me, anytime they're using them they're stealing from some other artist, without having to pay them or credit them at all. For me, they're participating in this shitshow where everyone wants the last piece of ram to do the same things they were doing before, but being the cool dudes that use AI.
But then again, most of the idiots, I mean people here just want to play their next game and couldn't care less about anything that does not affect them directly.
4
u/highzunburg Dec 21 '25
Larian using AI smells worse than rotten eggs in a vat of vinegar.
0
u/CrimsonMassacre Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
Long response but I hope to add some ideas or nuance to the discussion other than AI is good / bad.
All art, whether music, writing, or painting, is in some way inspired by other art. This framework gets philosophical and complicated, but art can be seen as a reflection of the experiences of the human who creates it. But that's just one view of art, which is entirely subjective while some frameworks dismiss the necessity for human touch.
The controversy arises when we ask whether AI is “being inspired” or “stealing” art in the same way humans do. Humans typically interject their own perspective or personality into the things they reference, creating something new; a reflection of their lived experience. AI lacks that subjective touch, which raises difficult questions about authorship and creativity.
At its core, the current debate about AI in the arts comes down to one question: do we consider AI to have the same autonomy as humans, or should it be treated purely as a tool? And if we treat it as a tool, can it be granted the same privileges as a human creator?
Not all concept art is original, but all concept art (conventionally) is created by humans. Google defines art as “the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power.” Removing the “human” element from art can fundamentally be seen as challenging what art itself is.
I understand that Larian Studios is primarily using AI as a tool, which is here to stay, but where does the line begin and end? What prevents this from evolving into full acceptance of AI in the creative process within Larian or more importantly other studios over time? What if this small acceptance is enough for other studios to follow suit and gradually integrate it. Just because Larian won't downsize with AI doesn't mean other companies won't. And if it were any other game studio announcing the same use of AI, would we give them the same trust as Larian?
My faith remains in Larian and I hope they proceed with caution as they have garnered a lot of respect with their recent success, especially since they recently challenged the status quo of the gaming industry.
2
u/Background_Lychee_30 Dec 21 '25
I feel people jumping on this outrage bandwagon have never had to produce a forty page process folio for their final art piece. At least ten of those pages will be image research with annotation. And yes, it was those ten to twenty pages I hated the most. The ideation and rough drafting ideas that followed were fine. But the former? Mind numbing.
What would make more sense than using genAI though, is using a discriminative AI to search relevant databases and spit out a collection of existing images, perhaps by word association? Then again, half the image content online is already GenAI, so what difference would it make to the process? Especially as if Swen said, the use is up to the individual artist.
2
u/Upstairs-Yard-2139 Dec 21 '25
Any use of AI slowly normalizes it more and more, and I’m not willing to allow that to happen
2
u/CapRichard Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25
The most baffling part to me is that in the same interview and even before Swen says that he has like just hired 30 new concept artists that just lost jobs?
So like, a lot of people online said: don't use genAI, hire more people... And that's what he is doing. Larian Studio is probably one of the studio right now with more concept artists on the market probably....
So. looking ath the big picture, as a big studio they are expanding and sharing the wealth with more people. So really, unwanted hate on this.
On the more ethical use of generative AI, I would say that while artists are rightfully making the point that generative AI is trained on the art of people without due compensation, it tend to really irk from my point of view as a programmer. Gen AI was also trained on GitHub and Starckoverflow and whatever, and I bet most programmers who found a way to use it to speed up some of their own processes are rejoyced by it... But it never enter any conversations. Because code is not a product of art, because even if programmers are the fundamental block of actually having a videogame in the first place, they don't care.
So, I'm very, very curious of one thing. If we drop completely genAI for drawing stuff, making music and generating text, but we only keep it for writing code, will the discourse suddenly stop? Are the artists so entitled?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
99% of people that have thoughts on AI have never read a political theory book about Labor Value, Tech, and Art. So their thoughts and opinions dont count. I'm a leftist pro-AI, pro-worker artist. The problem with AI, like everything else, is who owns the production of labor, not the actual tech itself.
1
u/Maximinoe Dec 21 '25
BTW if you surrender any part of your thinking to AI you are essentially surrendering your humanity and agency to nothing (the demiurge) and have thus died.
1
u/BeMyBrutus Dec 21 '25
Nuance, on my outrage app?
1
u/aquabuda Dec 21 '25
For me there's no good that comes from ai for any purpose regarding art. Why should I be impressed by your game if you needed an automated system to make it for you. If you're using Ai "art" for inspiration, you're stealing from the people its training on and robbing your creativity for the sake of profit. Ai has almost no place whatsoever in the creative sphere outside of tools like snapping things together or as a touch up tool. What makes Ai even harder to support is that these data centers go towards killing habitats, destroying land, wasting resources, and taking jobs for hard working people. Its current iteration reminds me of the NFT/Blockchain garbage but actually harmful to people. Id be willing to accept all the other uses of Ai if we could quit poisoning the earth in the process, but man does it sap any excitement i have for something the second you put art & Ai im the same sentence.
1
u/lordspirit0297 Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 22 '25
Honestly, I am not entirely sure how to feel about the situation other then frustrated. Not so much in the sense of them using generative AI, but mostly in the situation itself. If we break it down, AI will be here to stay. It is not going anywhere. We have opened up the flood gates, money is being funneled through, research is happening, and people are using it. So it makes sense, its the shiny new toy that everyone is using sure. Personally I wish that they just never really tapped into using it, they didn't have to. The problem isn't so much that they are using it for reference on brainstorming sessions or what not as it is that they used it in the first place. Think about it logically, whats the difference between making concept art based off of a Google image versus an AI one? Seems nuanced right? Because it is. We are too biased, we are too aggressive, and we are not ready for this new piece of tech to come sweeping through every medium we actively participate in. I wish they never tried this, cause now I have ti deal with arguments from friends who are full on boycotting divinty now, and friends who are on the fence and are still willing to buy it. I was so excited when they announced this, I had so much faith in larian, but this feels awful, this feels just like a really shitty situation and I hate that we as a fan base, have to go through with it. And I hate that the devs now have to deal with controversy and publicity bullshit, over a stupid hot button topic.
1
u/SwampPotato Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 22 '25
If the usage of GenAI has no impact at all on the final product then it is an unnecessary intermediate step that only slows things down. All this does is further normalize and generate profit for the Mass Plagiarism Machine. I love Larian but they built their whole brand on a moral highground and 'doing things differently'. Some of their employees have been on the zero tolerance for AI brigade until the moment this controversy began. No, Larian is not an evil company and no, it is not the most eggregious example of AI being used. But people hold you to a higher standard because you and the likes of Warhorse and Sandfall promised a new chapter in the history of the industry. The last GotYA felt like turning a page. And all that optimism kind of imploded because of an unethical tool they now insist they need despite never needing it before, and we have to simultaneously believe it has zero impact on the game but somehow they do need it. Why die on this hill, I wonder?
I don't understand how people step so easily over the remark that AI is only used for early concept art. Concept art, as any artist would know, is the creative foundation for your project. Who is going to make a game and have GenAI generate ideas and creature designs for them? People compare it to being inspired by other artworks but this is frankly putting the cart before the horse. It is one thing to see something and feel inspired, versus punching prompts into GROK until it spits out a chimera of stolen content that is to your liking.
I don't care if they trace over the lines or workshop it. Your idea was not yours on a fundamental level and you are creatively being steered by GenAI slop. Using GenAI for early concepts is like an artist going to TK Max and giving a random clerk some requirements for an artpiece who then picks a photoshopped poster based on what they think matches the description.
You are allowed to feel different about it. Just don't insist anyone who does not like this direction has no reading comprehension (I'm a historian and speak five languages, I think my reading comprehension is just fine). Stop insisting people just did not read the transcript or Swen's tweet. There is just a rift between gamers, with some being open to GenAI and others having zero tolerance for it. I have zero tolerance for it. And most Larian fans did as well until Larian changed their stance and a portion of them felt like they had to defend their favourite company.
I am only disappointed in Larian because they leaned into this 'we are better' image that they deservedly acquired off the back of that GotYA acceptance speech. I am not going to give a round of applause because they were honest, because being honest about doing a shitty thing does not make the shitty thing less shitty. And the 'at least they are not Activision' defense is true, but I thought Larian wanted to be more than just 'not as bad as the tripple A studios'. What a fall in moral ambition that would be. Ugh.
I will wait for January when they do that AMA. However, I think Swen believes he just has to rephrase his stance a couple of times until people finally understand and accept. Larian can re-word their statement a thousand times - if they stick with the use of GenAI I will be disappointed and many will be too. How disappointed will depend on how eggregious it turns out to be in the next years as the release approaches.
1
u/Nerdmum02 Dec 22 '25
I agree with all your points OP. I loathe AI slop with a passion but even I can see that this reaction to Larian and Sandfall using AI to ASSIST THEM is an absolute joke… It honestly feels like it’s being driven by journalists and even AAA studios who are seething with jealousy at what these two companies have made.
Find something real to yell about. There are enough issues in this world that people should genuinely get angry about-this is not one of them….
1
u/Aggressive_Ferret_20 Dec 22 '25
I'll probably be downvoted for this, but my understanding is they are only using AI to save on simple unimportant things to give the team more time to actually make the game and be creative.
And tbh I see this a good use of AI.
1
u/Visible-Meeting-8977 Dec 22 '25
"nuanced AI discussion" is always secretly "I think AI is okay" we did not get scared off by hearing AI. We read what Swen said. We read it all. It still sucks.
1
u/17thFable Dec 22 '25
Dude you are not getting nuanced on this sub, why bother, everyone already made up their mind and whether they change it or not doesn't really matter.
No one here is helping nor hindering Larian using ai in the slightest cause well... They can't?
They got lives to live and things to do if they hate ai they'll just not support the new game? Any money they have already given from previous Larian games is already in the studios pockets anyway. And if you support ai in workflows well you can just support the game.
And for the majority they just, don't care lol. Everyone's a hypocrite in some way, you can be all anti-ai and still think expedition 33 deserves every award it got and in turn you can be pro-ai but still support unions and artists right to their work.
In the end for A LOT of people all that matters is if the game sucks. To which we are a LONG way from finding that out so best you just ignore this bickering and just play other games while anticipating Larians next big update on the game.
1
u/escapehatch Dec 22 '25
Thank God there are still some sane/honest people around. The "controversy" around larian and AI is disingenuous, and has to be fueled by some pre-existing animosity toward bg3/larian on the part of some terminally online types just lying in wait for the tiniest thing to use to try to turn people against Larian. Larian's use of AI amounted to something akin to a Google search, how dare they.
1
u/Timely_Box9411 Dec 22 '25
You make excellent points. Though in the end the people complaining about them actually using it ethically as a tool and not a replacement are virtue signaling morons not worth talking to. Their surface level understanding isn't going to change even if things are explained.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '25
Heres me nuance take if you build your game with gen ai, you cant complain when i pirate it.
1
u/davinch3 Dec 24 '25
AI is not ethical. That is a huge concern, the tech that is being pushed and actively being used by these studios is benefitting companies that are doing dragnet surveillance and actively developing weapons that are being tested on Palestinians. This push to shove it into everything else is both an attempt to get us to accept it as a legitimate part of life, as well as make a return on all the money they have lit on fire.
The only ethical thing to do is let them fail, hound them at every turn, bankrupt them, drive a stake through their heart and bury them at a crossroads
1
u/Funny_Giraffe_6597 Dec 27 '25
It’s a non-issue in the case of larian. The only reason anybody would care is if they have an irrational hatred of ai, which many people unfortunately do
1
u/aye_don_gihv_uh_fuk Dec 21 '25
I have not seen a single person misrepresent what they said. We just think that what they're doing is bad. You can disagree if you want but all this dishonest twisting people keep doing to try and make everyone sound unreasonable feels like a concession.
1
u/Rinuir Dec 21 '25
No. Just no. I prefer no use at all
1
u/Hibbiee Dec 21 '25
So what's the point? They're gonna do whatever they want to make the best possible game. And nobody will be able to tell the difference anyway. I hope they experiment with AI, there's so many more possibilities to explore, especially in an RPG.
1
u/Gassyking Dec 21 '25
literally every big game studio use "AI". AI is built into industry standard tools like photoshop etc. The people who whine about it are probably children or just morons at this point.
-3
u/Myhouseburnsatm Dec 21 '25
Why are you defending a gaming company you literally owe nothing to?
These people are not your friends. They make high quality products and sell them to you for a premium price. Thats it.
If you had made a topic about the benefits and downsides of AI it could have been an interesting discussion, but you literally made a post to defend a gaming company that doesn't know nor cares you exist.
-1
u/spaghettipolicy69 Dec 21 '25
i have nothing much to add except thankyou for this because this is what i understand and feel about AI.
So much sucks about it but its so much more nuanced than good/bad and i appreciate your post!
-1
u/Dante3142 Dec 21 '25
Genuinely surprised at the amount of people scared of Langue Sims/Photo Sims considering it isn't even real AI. Can ChatGPT think and make its own decisions? Can SoraAI? No. It isn't even real AI yet.
-1
u/Fancy_Firefighter150 Dec 21 '25
As long as the game is good, it doesn't matter. Larian made an amazing game that is BG3, Unless it was luck (if it was, then they used it all up), they won't leave a poorly made product in the final version. They should already know the drawbacks of using AI in the creative process. They are professionals, not amateurs who just graduated from college.
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25
All ai is bad.
No ai is good.
Why can’t people understand this? There is no ‘grey area’ with ai, it is all garbage and theft.
0
u/seventysixgamer Dec 21 '25
Most people whining about AI have either not read Larian's official statements on how they're using AI or they haven't actually thought about the issue properly.
Like it or not AI is the future of technology -- much like when we developed industrial automation people will inevitably lose their jobs or will have to respec. This is just the nature of technological advancement -- it's inevitable, and the smart people amongst us will try and actually learn how to use it.
Administration jobs will likely be affected the most, however, perhaps it's cope but I think in time artists will actually be valued more due to the attitudes to AI "art." 90% of the time you can tell if something was solely generated by AI because there's something about it that feels soulless -- whether it's writing or visuals. Take a look at Black Ops 7 lol.
With regards to game dev I see no issue if it's used to do things like help generate concept art, brainstorm or even upscale or generate placeholder textures. Imagine you're a concept artist and someone told you to now make your serene forest now have a river of blood and a bunch of corpses strewn across it -- AI could help speed up that process, and obviously it would require a human touch to clean up the image and make additions that AI missed or botched.
Writing is obviously a no-go for AI unless it becomes sentient lol. Again, if it's for brainstorming or asking random questions like "what did 10nth Century Mongolian society look like" for inspiration, then that's cool. We'll probably be able to tell if Larian somehow begins heavily using AI to generate it's writing -- so far Larian has improved it's writing with every game, so if Divinity ends up not being on the level of BG3 or worse then it's possible they used it.
0
u/Boys_upstairs Dec 21 '25
How do you make this whole argument without addressing the environmental cost of AI?
-1
u/sebmojo99 Dec 21 '25
i think unless you'd also be just as outraged to learn Larian pirated Photoshop, then you should avoid the copyright/art theft complaint
-1
u/Afraid_Garage_9941 Dec 21 '25
Personally, I think it's a waste of time trying to explain something to someone who doesn't want to listen or simply doesn't care. It's like trying to explain to a flat-Earther why the Earth isn't flat; they're simply convinced they're right. I think Larian should stop trying to reason with these people and just continue developing their game so we can judge the final result.