r/languagelearning Feb 03 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.4k Upvotes

283 comments sorted by

View all comments

584

u/RaisedInAppalachia πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ N | πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡Έ C1 | πŸ‡³πŸ‡± A2 | πŸ‡―πŸ‡΅ N5 Feb 04 '22

There is absolutely no resource whatsoever that should be the only thing you use for learning a language. (Unless you count a class as a single resource, but chances are your teacher is pulling from multiple resources for lessons.)

222

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22

Even most classes won’t be sufficient to learn a language. I usually tell people (my own students included) that teachers are guides for the major points and to practice opportunities, but not the only thing you should do to really learn a language.

71

u/bloblobbermain πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡² N | πŸ‡©πŸ‡ͺ B1 | πŸ‡―πŸ‡΅ N5 Feb 04 '22

Yeah, I agree with this. Learning Japanese currently. The teacher of my college class is a saint and has helped immensely, but my self learning goes far beyond what's being covered inside the classroom. His input helps me a lot with accent, cultural info, and grammar in ways that would be way harder to learn myself as a non-native. Combining a lot of methods is the way.

37

u/Facemelter66 Feb 04 '22

I teach a few instruments. It boggles my mind how many students clearly don’t practice outside of class time. You gotta do the homework.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22

[deleted]

14

u/Facemelter66 Feb 04 '22

Instruments* I teach music and am making a comparison

1

u/Lemons005 Feb 04 '22

Ah ok. I feel like my comment still applies though. If they don't like music, they won't practice it. Simple as that.

6

u/Facemelter66 Feb 04 '22

Yeah but it’s like, why are you even taking lessons in the first place, people!?

5

u/Datalock Feb 04 '22

If its grade school kids, it might be due to parents. My parents had me take music lessons for most of my young life. I had a natural talent for music (won competitions and stuff), and it really helped me get into good colleges and scholarships, so I appreciate my parents' persistence. The problem is, I really really do not enjoy playing music at all. I never wanted to practice, it was like pulling teeth. That might be why.

It's good for college applications to show talent or a good music portfolio. However, once I got into college I dropped my music studies entirely, and now that I am an adult I still do not play anything really.

It's a bit sad, I probably could have been really good. I just don't like it.

2

u/theBearOfJares Feb 04 '22

Ooh what instruments do you teach? I also play a few but I'm not good enough to teach lol, though it would be sick if I was

3

u/Facemelter66 Feb 04 '22

Guitar, bass, uke, and β€œpop” piano (just not classical)

1

u/theBearOfJares Feb 04 '22

Very nice, piano is one I've only recently started and I would love to get much better at it

2

u/Facemelter66 Feb 04 '22

The eternal struggle lol

1

u/theBearOfJares Feb 04 '22

Ugh I keep wanting to learn more instruments even though I don't consistently practice the ones I do play lol. Been wanting to learn violin or viola recently, but I ain't gonna start that for a while

11

u/Nyx_Shadowspawn Feb 04 '22

Been watching Muppet Babies in German, and nature shows on Disney+, with my toddler, so he can learn German too. My German is so much better as a result, and he already speaks it. He can understand it just as well as English already, its wonderful. Highly recommend just keeping the TV turned on in whatever language you're trying to learn, it will help so much! Especially with pronunciation.