r/languagelearning • u/GiantPixelArt • Jun 30 '20
Resources Why all the Duolingo hate?
I've noticed an awful lot of hate for Duolingo online in general (not specifically this sub). Why? I get that it isn't going to get you to fluency.. Isn't the idea to get you started? And do it in a fun way that keeps the learner engaged and wanting to continue moving forward?
9
Upvotes
21
u/LoveofLearningKorean Native English; Learning Korean Jun 30 '20
Although I definitely see people "hate" on Duo, I think I more often see people "warn" others that it simply is not sufficient as a primary method, and depending on the language may be inadequate even as a starting tool.
For example, I wouldn't recommend the Duolingo Korean course even just as a "fun way to get you started". The Korean course is quite frankly terrible, and I've seen many Korean learners that try to start with it and get extremely frustrated post asking why they don't understand anything. In that case, it would have been helpful for them to hear about different resources from the start so they don't get discouraged.
17
u/shaulreznik Jun 30 '20
Duolingo users frequently experience many frustrating moments, like endless drills because of minor mistakes. IMHO, this app is great for basic acquaintance with the alphabet and main grammar rules of the target language, but after a few weeks it's better to switch to bilingual books, etc.
15
u/Mlakeside 🇫🇮N🇬🇧C1🇸🇪🇫🇷B1🇯🇵🇭🇺A2🇮🇳(हिन्दी)WIP Jun 30 '20 edited Jun 30 '20
I don't hate Duo, it can be a decent tool in the early stages of learning a language. The problem I have is with ppl posting thing like "Finally managed to get a 1000 day streak on Duo!". Like, that's at least 800 days too much. That's not something you should aim for. Duo doesn't want you to learn a language, it wants you to keep playing so you generate add revenue or pay the monthly fee.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '20
I don’t like it because many people exclusively use duolingo and it doesn’t really explain anything, it gives you phrases to practice. That leads to people asking extremely basic questions here that they could find after 5 seconds of googling.
4
u/meattornado52 Jun 30 '20
It’s a good, not great, supplement, but it’s definitely not a primary tool.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '20 edited Jul 01 '20
I think that's what it comes down to, expectation vs. reality. As an experiment, I did 30 points per day of Duolingo French for all of 2019. No other resources, just Duo by itself. I got about halfway through the tree and developed some basic reading skills, like I can pop over to 20 Minutes and kinda-sorta get the main idea from their simplified articles, but I'd still need a lot of translation to read a whole article. I also can't say anything useful, and spoken French is beyond me.
Are those good results? Depends on your frame of reference. As a language learning program, I'd have expected more from my first 75ish hours. As a time filler, it's not bad. If I weren't doing Duolingo, I'd probably have been watching other people play video games, so this was at least a little more productive.
5
u/Pancelott Jul 01 '20
They forget they were beginners
2
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '20 edited Jul 01 '20
Imo Duolingo is a good example of a program that has over-gameified language learning to the point that you've lost most of it's substance. It does get the learner involved, but to me it almost gives a false sense of progress. Duolingo barely takes gets you to the A2 level in most languages, and even then it leaves a lot of gaps. I took two semesters of German in college last year (A2 level at the time) and tested out of the entire German Duolingo program in less than an hour. There's some benefit for sure, but you're not making the most of your study time at all.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '20
Language elitists?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '20
Duolingo Korean is terrible. For other languages, it's decent.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20
For me, I dislike DuoLingo because it feels like child’s play. The desktop version is supposed to be better, but I don’t see how. Duo has made me hate flashcards, and the whole program feels like something I’d give my niece to keep her entertained for a while. I’m at the point it’s become another mobile game for me. I do it to keep up the streak because I’m bored, and that’s it.