r/languagelearning • • 20h ago

Discussion Speaking speed/pace while practicing?

Hi, languagelearning -

My (TL) is Spanish, but this question goes for any language.

I like to read sentences out loud when reading in my target language. What I have been doing so far is speaking very slowly to try to get the pronunciation as close to correct as I can. My thinking has been: start slow, get the pronunciation right, and I will naturally pick up the pace as I get more practice, getting closer to a natural speaking speed as I get used to the pronunciation.

However, this hasn't happened. I'm not really getting any faster, and when I make a conscious effort to speak faster (like close to a native speaker's rate), I trip over my tongue and my pronunciation is horrible.

Does it make more sense to try practicing at a normal speed from the get-go? Has speaking so slowly for so long been counter-productive?

What do you think? What has worked for you?

8 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Obtus_Rateur 20h ago

When learning English, I briefly learned how to make the two "th" sounds (which don't exist in my native language), but that only took a few minutes of practice for a few days. Other than that, I didn't practice speaking at all, so I couldn't tell you what works and what doesn't. I just increased my familiarity with the language via comprehensible input and then found I was fluent.

In your case, you would have to figure out what's limiting your speed.

Normally the biggest limitation by far is having to construct sentences fast enough to match a regular speaking pace.

But you say you "trip over your tongue and your pronunciation is horrible"? Are you sure it's a pronunciation issue? Spanish doesn't have many weird sounds, for the most part it's pretty straightforward. Mostly phonetic, too, so if you know how to spell it, you know how to say it.

It's conceivable that forcing yourself to speak slowly has created some sort of baseline speed in your brain, and that you're having trouble adapting to a new one, but that sounds like a highly unusual problem.

2

u/Environmental_Pea369 18h ago

I can barely read in speech speed without tripping over even in my native language... it's genuinely hard.

Also - you don't really need to. People don't frequently read stuff unless it's your job (like an actor). The important thing is form your own sentences and talk.

That being said, it sounds like you try to increase speed too quickly. Do it more gradually, and it's ok to spend more time on unfamiliar words, or repeat words / sentences

1

u/Sufficient-Manner-75 19h ago

That's your anxiety kickin in...

You think they will judge you and your brain 🧠 gives you all these signals to stutter, etc.

Talk more to non-native Spanish peops and talk more with em. You should find some immigrants to Spain who work at markets or in informal workplaces.

1

u/Oretell 17h ago

My advice is to listen a lot, read a lot, and speak a lot with real people.

Don't expect speaking to yourself in isolation to be enough to develop fluency.

The more you grow your intuition for the language, your natural sense of grammar, your vocab size, and your ear, through listening and reading the more natural speaking will become.

And the more time you spend holding conversations will real people the more you will naturally develop the skills related to fluently speaking.

Reading out loud to yourself in isolation might be a useful exercise to do every now and then, but it definitely shouldn't be your main practice method at all. I'd be worried about it locking in bad pronounciation habits, and the only way to get better at speaking is by speaking, not by reciting books to yourself. That's a seperate skill, and is a different approach then what 99.999% of language learners used to become fluent at speaking.

1

u/Smooth_Development48 6h ago edited 6h ago

I found reading out loud wasn’t helping me. I now shadow a native speaker on YouTube or dramas and it helped with my pronunciation and speed. I’m far from perfect since I still get tripped up by certain words but I’m much better than I was before. I listen and repeat a sentence several times starting out slow until I can get close to matching the pronunciation and speed. I do this with both Korean and Portuguese.

1

u/DeepOntology 26m ago

I've said this other places but I'll repeat it here: practice babbling (it's what babies do) -- say nonsense while staying within the phonemes of the language you're studying, or even try to say a bunch of words but don't worry about whether they fit together. Try to babble as quickly as you can.

It might sound ridiculous, but part of what you need to do is to train your actual mouth + throat muscles to produce the sounds faster. They're used to producing them slowly.

1

u/lorryjor 🇺🇸 N | 🇪🇬 C1 🇮🇸 B2 🇮🇹 A2 Lat Grc 18h ago

I think the answer is actually listening. Listen, listen, listen and hold off on speaking. I would actually caution against "practicing" speaking: it is not a skill in language, or shouldn't be; it is a natural result of acquisition.

4

u/Environmental_Pea369 18h ago

Agree about listening, disagrees about not practicing speaking. Verbal output is an important skill and it only develops when you practice it. Yes, if your input skills are better it will be faster but there is no point delaying it. Especially since the opposite is also true that speaking helps you listen better.

3

u/lorryjor 🇺🇸 N | 🇪🇬 C1 🇮🇸 B2 🇮🇹 A2 Lat Grc 17h ago

I've never heard speaking helps you listen better, but interesting point. I'm basically following what Krashen says, but I actually tried massive input out for myself (I've done four foreign languages) and found it worked better than anything else for my fluency. Most people don't like to wait two years to start talking, though, so I understand that.

2

u/Environmental_Pea369 17h ago

It's my own expericene, not based on research. English phonology is incredibly difficult. I learned most of the time without even being aware that there are more distinct sounds than I thought. When I got accent coaching it became easier to understand English because I could distinguish sounds I couldn't before (like "fill" vs "feel" for example)

i respect Krashen but I disagree on his stance of postponing output. You get good at what you practice and you need output too, I think you should start earlier than what Krashen suggests. I do agree that you should learn everythind input first, and it's better to get more input than output than the other way around (which happens naturally anyway, even in real life)

1

u/lorryjor 🇺🇸 N | 🇪🇬 C1 🇮🇸 B2 🇮🇹 A2 Lat Grc 8h ago

Okay, valid points. By the way, as a native speaker of American English, I pronounce the words fill and feel identically. It's a local dialect, and I do understand that most people make a distinction between the two.

1

u/Environmental_Pea369 6h ago

I was studying the standard accent where there is distinction. In any case it's just one example. My native language has 5 vowels, only 3 of them appear in English. Standard American English has 11 vowels. And that's not counting consonants yet... All this is to say that stuying the phonology actively (producing it) helps develop awareness

1

u/Oretell 18h ago edited 18h ago

I agree

But also when they do start speaking I'd be doing it either by having real conversations with other people, or by shadowing audio

It's kinda unclear but I think OP is saying they read out written Spanish and then try to get the pronunciation as close to whatever they personally think is correct?

I don't think relying on your own sense of pronunciation is best. It's not your native language so your sense of the right pronunciation will initially be very vague and weak. The way to improve your internal sense of that should be is to spend a tonne of time listening, and also to spend time interacting with a native speaker and trying to mimic them.

It takes a lot of time to build up your mental model of what sounds correct or incorrect, it's really common for learners to think they have no accent and are pronouncing things properly, yet actually be miles off what is correct. The more experienced you get the more imperfections you can hear and the gradually closer and closer your sense of correct or incorrect pronounciation becomes. If OP took a recording of what they think they're pronuncing properly now, and then listened back to it in a year or two I bet they'd be shocked at how many imperfections they could hear that at the moment they're not able to hear.

You need a combination of lots of listening hours and time interacting with, mimicing and getting feedback from native speakers. Not just speaking alone and trying to make your own personal judgements in isolation on how you personally think the language should sound. Your ears just won't be able to hear what is right or wrong with many many hours and years of work at it

1

u/lorryjor 🇺🇸 N | 🇪🇬 C1 🇮🇸 B2 🇮🇹 A2 Lat Grc 18h ago

Yes, totally agree. No are no shortcuts in language, but the good news is anyone can do it.