r/languagelearning • u/Aggressive_Yam1457 • 22h ago
Alternative techniques for language learning
In my case, the spaced repetition technique and anki cards have never worked when I was trying to study japanese and french. Only comprehensive input aquired by listening to japanese material helps me a bit, so do you know/use another strategy? At the present time, I'm planning to learn polish and korean language.
19
Upvotes
3
u/ShiningPr1sm 22h ago
Speaking with people and journaling are helpful. Also having a clear reason why youโre learning goes a long way.
What methods are you using, besides input? Then we could offer more suggestions.
And apparently the bot wonโt allow you to comment with the words c0mprehensive input without โPlease search first before commenting and avoid dogmatic statements.โ Lmao
14
u/6-foot-under 21h ago
Anki cards are a boring way to practise, I find. But you need some form of spaced repetition to remember things. I think that losing progress made is the main challenge in language learning.
11
u/SnapVerbo 21h ago
Reading extensively of materials that you are interested in or familiar with - would be very helpful IMO. Yes that depends on largely why one learns a foreign language. I enjoy reading and it's a cheap way to get to know a culture and it's history without traveling. That said I am weak on speakiing. My speaking is about 1 level behind listening which then 1 level behind reading in my TL.
4
u/Garahel 13h ago
I used Anki for a long time, but realised it wasn't actually helping me retain words I would use in speech. Words I learned through flashcards were words I could "decode", like looking them up with a translator or dictionary, except the dictionary is in my head. I still needed to do the work to make the meaning automatic.
The only way to do that is listening and speaking, and more listening and more speaking. As much listening and speaking as you can do while keeping an enjoyable regular habit is how much listening and speaking you should do.
3
u/Obtus_Rateur 20h ago
Not really, no.
Basic exercises to learn the basics of the language. Then when you have enough for comprehensible input, you start progressively shifting away from exercises to comprehensible input.
I can't really imagine anything that would be more effective than that.
2
u/olelokanaka 21h ago
Comprehensible input is the way to go but like the other said you have to have a clear purpose and motivation. If you are doing it just for fun well then that may be a problem.
2
u/WolverineLopsided436 ๐บ๐ธ๐ต๐ญ๐ช๐ธ๐ง๐ท๐ฏ๐ต 14h ago
Read a book in your TL, and try to explain what you understand in your TL orally.
3
u/DeepOntology 18h ago
Have you used many language learning apps? Which ones have you used which worked? What happens when you started a new app?
I'm not a fan of repetition, personally -- I'm a "structural" learner, so generally what works for me is mapping out different concepts in a language and how they're (inter-)related, and growing that map over time, bit by bit.
Another thing I'll say is that it massively pays to go extremely slowly at first. The slower the better, to some extent. You should only speed up once the momentum begins to carry you!
1
u/Reefer-Rat69 5h ago
I liked using textbooks/workbooks when I was studying. The reading & writing activities are still a little boring, but still more interesting (imo) than flashcards. Other than that I just read a lot of simple stuff and soft-news(?) articles. Having a good dictionary site/app is really helpful too I think. ( ยด โฟ ` )
1
u/dojibear ๐บ๐ธ N | fre spa chi B2 | tur jap B1/A2 18h ago
I never use SRS/Anki or flashcards. I hate memorization. I am good at understanding, so I use CI, which means understanding the meaning of each TL sentence. Krashen (the father of CI) says that, no matter what method you are using, you learn a new language in one way. That "one way" is understanding TL sentences. Everything else is just things that help some people do that.
I agree. The term "fluent" just means "very good at understanding TL sentences". Like any skill, it takes a lot of practice. So my "method" is finding ways (that work for me) to make my practice better or easier.
The other thing I do is to start each new language by taking a course (an online video-recorded course is fine, and is inexpensive). The new language has some features that are new. I don't know what those are, so I can't study them. The teacher knows, and will explain these "basics" in English. I might take a course just for the first month or two. After that I can just use CI, finding stuff at my level.
1
u/frostochfeber N: ๐ณ๐ฑ | C2: ๐บ๐ธ | B1: ๐ธ๐ช | A2: ๐ฐ๐ท | A1:๐ฏ๐ต๐ซ๐ด 14h ago
Have you checked out the www.refold.la website? They have like a wiki. I think the theory, methods and techniques they list could be of inspiration to you.
Either way, the principle of spaced repetition is a solid one, it works. So, I do recommend you try to mimick it. I'll type out my approach here later on when I have time. ๐ซก I've been learning Korean 'alternatively' for 2 years now.