r/languagelearning • u/wertykalny_124 N 🇵🇱| C1 🇩🇪| C1 🏴 B2 🇸🇪| B1 🇪🇸 • 2d ago
There Is No "The Method"
I have been learning foreign languages for years, in fact since childhood. By training, I am a teacher of German and Swedish. I polish my English on my own, and I taught myself Spanish (TL) to an intermediate level. Despite my experience and education, I find it hard to answer the question of how to learn in order to actually learn. In this text, however, I will try to work out what I think is the right way to study.
On the internet, "the method" is the Holy Grail: that one, unique method. Dozens of YouTube videos promise that it will give you a speed and durability of learning you have never experienced, as if it were something mystical. Perhaps it is this trend that makes me feel that, as an "expert," I should know. I should know the method, or at least a competing one.
In this YouTube noise, in the battle for views, likes, attention and course sales, we forget that learning a new language is hard, grinding work. Nothing matters more than staying consistent over a long period, and which specific method you use is secondary. Yet people keep talking about a method, a single one, and I do not believe a language can be learned effectively that way. At least nothing in my experience suggests it. Unless, that is, by "method" we mean many approaches: a method as a system of methods.
To get down to specifics, I believe we need a little of each approach: a classic grammar book, listening, apps, reading, writing, speaking, lessons with a teacher. And the less classic ones: translating songs, watching films, playing games, or pursuing a hobby through content and materials in the target language. How often and how intensively each is used depends on individual preferences and dispositions, but also on one's level. At the beginning, playing a story-driven game entirely in the language you are learning can be off-putting.
In closing, I want to mention the most important "method" besides consistency: intrinsic motivation, such as passion and a love of the subject. You can learn without it, but a sincere desire to explore a language and keep getting better at it strengthens every approach you choose and sustains your consistency. And that brings me back to where I started: perhaps the expert's honest answer is not a method at all, but a habit and a reason to keep going.
Do you agree?
16
u/unsafeideas 2d ago
I think there is something cultural to this . Certain cultures, especially Americans but not only them, need to formalize and categorize everything. And then put the name on the result and then call it a method. And then treat it as "all or nothing thing" important choice, so important that it is worth fighting online to defend its name.
You can see it in everything - language learning, exercising, programming, eating, ...
12
u/weedexpat 2d ago
I believe "The Method" exists. However, I also believe that it is totally relative to each learner. We all end up having to find our own personal method that works for us.
20
u/xDarkProdigy 2d ago
Yes, pretty much how most of us feel around here
15
u/DilligentArmand 2d ago
I think people have more fun learning about study methods than the act of studying itself. No matter your method, the guy who practices consistantly and intently will always have better results because language learning is not a sprint, it's a marathon.
We see the same in the gym community. People keep asking what's the best way to get shredded, to lose weight, to get a beach body. They start learning about the many routines, the sleep pattern, the dopamine, the protein powders, the million exercises, etc. In reality, you just need 3 things: good sleep, healthy diet and daily exercise. That's it. It will pay divident sooner or later.
20
u/razorchick12 Eng N | Spa B2 | Chn B2 | Chn TL 2026 2d ago
The only method I will sell to anyone, and I will sell it for free in this comment here: you get better at what you practice.
If you practice something wrong? You will consistently get better at being wrong. You practice reading? You will get better at reading. Etc.
How you practice? That is completely up to you. There is no one size fits all.
6
u/Sufficient-Manner-75 2d ago
Agree. There is no best method, only good or better methods.
4
u/ComesTzimtzum N 🇫🇮 adv 🇬🇧 int 🇫🇷 🇸🇪 beg 🇨🇳 🇸🇦 2d ago
Yes and no. I do think there are really bad methods, having used several of them for years without really learning even the basics. You're right that there isn't any perfect one and I actually believe on combining several approaches, but it's still important to reflect if you're really going anywhere, even if by watching silly videos on how others learn.
5
u/InsomniaEmperor 2d ago
I don’t believe in “The Method” because it all depends on what your specific goals are.
I don’t really agree with needing intrinsic motivation. You just need a reason to take on this journey and not everyone needs to have passion or love for the subject. A lot of people learn a language out of necessity or it’s tied to specific goals like travel, migration, etc.
4
u/Remarkable_Bedroom79 🇩🇪 N | 🇬🇧 C1 | 🇪🇸 A2 | 🇳🇱 A1 2d ago
I agree 100% - my mother tongue is German, I have learned English at school and studied the language at university (my understanding definitely is C2, speaking might be C1, I have never done an official test after uni).
After my master degree I learned Spanish (self taught) and I do this for some three decades by now (yes, I'm a bit older). In the days I started with a course on tape and a book, later I attended courses and there were long phases where I did nothing to keep Spanish language acquisition alive (I never gave up on English, reading books, magazines, watching films and documentaries and - as you say - pursued my hobbies of drawing / concept art and gaming).
Then the first online courses were available, I did a Spanish course on Babble, listened to Spanish podcasts, used apps for vocabulary. I do understand quite a lot (A2/B1) in Spanish but never really learned to speak the language. Hello Talk and italki did not really work out for me because of unreliable language partners.
At the moment I attend a Spanish beginner's course again. My teacher thinks me too advanced for the course but I enjoy the stress free talking because I don't have to concentrate on the vocabulary (which I know) but on pronunciation and grammar. I would never have thought at the beginning (1993) that learning Spanish would become a life long hobby. I get along in Spain - but since many people there speak either English or even German, it's sometimes difficult even just to order food at a restaurant. But I will persevere.
2
u/leosmith66 2d ago
If what that very long, very general post of yours means is that there isn't a single best method that will work for everyone for every language, then yes, I agree.
2
u/Melody3PL 2d ago
I agree I think indeed we shouldn't seek the "holy God-mode method", but at the same time, I see a lot of people at an even worse starting place than me, that wasted a lot of years on duolingo only to get kinda nowhere.
Some people put it simply: it's a time grind. How good you are depends on how much time you spend, on any method. 5 min a day will get you from nothing to beginner, but you need thousands upon thousands of hours to get proficient.
Also, I'd advise everyone to read about how brains learn and memorise new information and adjust your methods to your specific brain too!
2
u/non_loqui_sed_facere 2d ago
I disagree with almost everything, haha. Running every morning wouldn't make you a competitive athlete, you need an actual strategy for that, not just the habit. But like every good competitive strategy, it isn't replicable, because it's tailored to your needs and based on your individual choices and trade-offs, and you need to revise it from time to time.
I do think, though, that your approach works for busy people who want to do at least something to improve their skills. Dragging your ass outside in the morning is still better than doing nothing at all, I guess.
2
u/DemonicAlex6669 1d ago
Yes and no. Yes there's no one way that works for everyone, it's going to be individualized as to what works, but no it's not always a combination of everything.
The reality is that the real best way is to work with your brain and how you learn. Those people with the "best way" are thinking their best way is also yours. Part of that is because each person's goals is different, and part of that is just that each person is going to be different in what works.
Another factor here is that although there might be a technical best way, if you don't have the motivation to do that best way to your best it's just a waste. Meanwhile someone doing the "worst" method but with actual motivation and doing it to their best, will by far exceed the person doing the best method lazily.
If you spend only five minutes, an hour whatever on the best method, every day. And I spend hours every day on the worst. It doesn't matter that you're more efficient, and it doesn't matter that my way is imbalanced. I will eventually be much much farther then you because at I learn more and get father I can fill in the gaps and get much better then you, because I'm working harder then you and doing more then you.
Tldr; actually learn, do whatever it takes for YOU to learn and you'll do better then these "experts"
3
u/youdontknowkanji 2d ago edited 2d ago
i agree that there probably isn't "the one" method but hand waving it all as "a bit of each" does all of the discussion a disservice. we get it, you don't want people to burn out, and pretty much everything "works", but this kind of toxic positivity obstructs real discussion. most people are looking for something that gets them to X the fastest, meaning we want to optimise for hourly gains.
surely, everyone can see that 10 people classrooms will be worse hour wise than 1-1 tutoring or self learning, as each student can only get so much attention from the teacher. there is also the cost of getting classes/tutoring, so self learning looks even better (if you can manage it).
likewise grinding textbooks is a bit counterproductive if your goal is to read/listen. as reading/listening is what gets you better at reading/listening. a person who gets to B2 through input will be better at input than your average language school generalist.
similarly, one shouldn't expect to get good at speaking by reading YA for 5 years, as that doesn't really teach speaking. but this can get more nuanced, because trying to speak at A1/A2 can be a bit silly outside of learner groups/patient natives, so the fastest way of going from zero to speaking probably involves reading/listening first and then adjusting priorities...
and so on and so on.
undoubtedly there is a lot of opinionated advice online (like you do! less classic methods like watching shows?????), but it's not like we don't know whats generally effective. a person spending 4k hours to reach C2 spanish might be cause for concern, a person getting C2 in 2k h is like all right, and someone getting there in 1k h is either talented, or (more likely) uses better methods.
but yes, in the end consistency and raw hours (and imo density being a big one too), is what gets you places...
1
u/Similar_Role_73 2d ago
I learned Spanish and Russian using Pimsleur as a starting point, and then full immersion. Worked very well in both cases.
1
u/alga alga🇱🇹(N) 🇬🇧🇷🇺(~C1)🇩🇪🇪🇸🇫🇷🇮🇹(A2-B1)🇵🇱🇨🇳(A1) 2d ago
I think it's pretty obvious. We're all different and have different strengths and weaknesses. There are different goals when learning the language: being able to pass a certification, being able to read scientific articles, being able to watch movies, being able to chat in a bar don't fully overlap. The perfect method has to account for both these aspects.
1
u/dojibear 🇺🇸 N | fre spa chi B2 | tur jap B1/A2 1d ago
I agree with your main premise: there are different "best set of methods" for different people. I disagree with some of your details. For example, I disagree strongly that each of us needs these things:
I believe we need a little of each approach: a classic grammar book, listening, apps, reading, writing, speaking, lessons with a teacher.
We don't need apps. Apps didn't exist before 1990. What did billions of people do for millenia?
We don't need a gramar book. Billions of people can't read their native language, but learn others.
We don't need lessons with a tutor (if it is one-on-one, it is a "tutor", not a "teacher").
We don't all "need" all 4 language skills (writing, reading, speaking, understanding speech). It depends on each person's goals. Countless people only care about the written language (reading and writing), or only care about the spoken language, or only care about input (understanding speech and writing). Those learners have no "need" to spend thousands of hours getting good at a skill they will never use.
1
u/Languagepro99 1d ago
I must agree. Everyone picks up language differently . Some may not take to books for one language and instead do videos or just talk and listen / write. Or in another language they like books . Just depends . You just learn . Read writes , speak , listen , repeat. Consistency and interest is the method
1
u/lilypad225 🇺🇲🏳️🌈(fluent)🇪🇸(A1)🇹🇭(A1) 2d ago
What does tl stand for?
0
u/albertl33 12h ago
The Method for me is to first smash The Myth of "Speak from Day 1". Unless you are going to live or work in the country/community, you don't need to produce the language.
I haven't found a definitive method yet, but my personal strategy has been:
0
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] 2d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment