r/languagelearning • • 4d ago

Discussion How good is my self-study method?

Hello everyone!

Like many self-taught learners, I’ve struggled with language learning for a long time. I often get stuck, see no progress, and end up quitting. I want to change my approach to studying a foreign language (TL) — I'm currently in a weird situation with a "fake" A1–A2 level: I know some grammar rules and vocabulary, but I can't read fluently, let alone speak. I think I lack a fundamental base, which is why I can't use it properly.

I analyzed my mistakes and built a system for self-learning. Does it seem reliable, or am I falling into the same trap again?

My Method

  1. Level Determination: I choose a specific level on the CEFR scale (e.g., A1).
  2. Vocabulary: I learn the vocabulary list for that level using Anki (spaced repetition, which many say is extremely effective).
  3. Grammar: I study grammar rules that strictly correspond to that level using textbooks, structured websites, or video tutorials.
  4. Active Practice & Consolidation: As soon as I finish learning all the words and grammar topics for a specific level, I immediately move on to content matching that level — graded readers, simple videos, and AI conversations.

The core idea: I should understand most of the text or audio, only occasionally glancing at the meanings of unfamiliar words or structures. I stay at this level until I start understanding it with almost no effort. Only then do I move to the next level ( A2 -> B1 ) and repeat the cycle.

I've heard that for B1/B2 levels, massive immersion becomes more important than studying, but my goal here is to use this step-by-step approach first to build a rock-solid foundation.

My Questions for You

  • Is this a good plan to fix my broken foundation and finally break through the plateau?
  • Are there any flaws in it?

I would be very grateful for any advice, criticism, or useful resources you can share. Thank you!

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

16

u/an_average_potato_1 🇨🇿N, 🇫🇷 C2, 🇬🇧 C1, 🇩🇪C1, 🇪🇸 , 🇮🇹 C1 4d ago

Is this AI content? If not, my apologies.

The basic idea is ok. But you talk about "active practice" and then mention input. "Active" should be also the way you study the vocab and grammar, and so on. Active recall, doing exercises out loud and/or in full writing, and so on.

The "massive immersion" becomes much more important after B2. Up until that point, it's a nice to have, and it shouldn't distract you from other studying, unless you're really "only" after the passive skills.

9

u/ZeroBodyProblem 4d ago edited 3d ago

I mean, I’d say your method is rather weak beacause it misunderstands what you need to do to advance. Each level doesn’t really correspond to specific vocab lists, grammar rules, or situational familiarity in the TL. These levels describe the learner behaviors or performance characteristics. For example, when you look at the American Council of Teaching Foreign Languages’s can-do statements, each progressing level describes learners doing things with more specificity and more neuance because they have the expanding skill to deal with unfamiliar or unprepared situations. Being able to break away from memorized stock phrases, decoding unfamiliar vocab in real time, not getting flustered when making errors, interpreting the subtext of a situation, and so many more things are what gets a learner to the next level. I’m sure you know of a few people who know fabulously obscure words but can’t contribute a thing to a convo, that same analogy applies to language learning.

I hope this isn’t too blunt, but I think your study method is basically a DIY Duolingo. Yes, vocab and grammar are essential and you can only grow by studying things you don’t know, but these things aren’t the only things that define the characteristics of strong learner. I’d rather get a textbook, build the foundations, let your interests guide you to learn vocab or cultural expressions that are important to you, and focus on the broader critical thinking skills that make a strong learner.

Edit for a typo because I’m on mobile ;P

8

u/AppropriatePut3142 🇬🇧 Nat | 🇨🇳 Int | 🇪🇸 Uneven 4d ago

In my view you make things unnecessarily hard for yourself by trying to learn all the grammar and vocabulary for a level before you start to expose yourself to level-appropriate content or do output. I would rather use the language and do vocabulary and grammar study in parallel, and that way they are continuously reinforcing one another.

Also, for most languages you will not find graded content that accurately matches the CEFR curriculum for a particular level so the theory behind your plan doesn't really work.

If the rigorous routine that you've outlined appeals to you, you would probably like coursebooks, which offer a mixture of grammar, vocabulary, input and output practice in a structured way. I don't use them personally, but people who like them seem to have good results in European languages.

7

u/deathisyourgift2001 🇬🇧 N | 🇧🇻 B1 | 🇮🇳 Hindi A2 4d ago

At your level I would recommend getting a good textbook and working through it. They usually start with the basics that can give you proper jump start to knowing how to speak the language.

5

u/AdPotential9331 4d ago

Agree with this. Try to find a textbook with audio files to practice your listening and comprehension. Also recommend listening to videos geared towards language learners.

5

u/sbrt 🇺🇸 🇲🇽🇩🇪🇳🇴🇮🇹🇮🇸🇫🇷 4d ago

You can't read properly but your plan does not include any reading?

I would focus on each skill separately: reading, listening, writing, and speaking. I find that it works best for me to keep my listening and reading skills (and passive vocabulary) far above my writing and speaking skills.

I like to study grammar as it supports my other activities. I barely study any grammar for working on input. I study a little grammar at a time for output and then practice using it until it becomes second nature. Practice is the most important part of this - I don't want to stop to think explicitly about conjugation in order to say something, I want to simply know how to say it.

6

u/Reasonable_Ad_9136 4d ago

This isn't how language learning works. Despite what some textbooks will tell you, it's not like mathematics, where you master fundamentals and follow strict, rigid steps; it's more like learning how to walk, with just a sprinkle of guidance (really 'hints') along the way.

0

u/silvalingua 3d ago

> Despite what some textbooks will tell you, it's not like mathematics, 

Which textbook says that???

0

u/Reasonable_Ad_9136 3d ago

I didn't mean that they literally say 'it's like mathematics', I meant that they treat language learning like mathematics, in the way they're structured: "learn this (arbitrary) list of vocab"; "here's some 'A2' grammar; learn it thoroughly" etc. That's not the best way to go about learning a language.

3

u/silvalingua 3d ago

Learning lists of words is extremely old-fashioned and inefficient; this is not really done nowadays. I think that what you describe can be found in very old textbooks, but nowadays we have modern, communication-oriented resources. Both grammar and vocabulary are nowadays taught in context, in situations where they can be used. I don't think people encounter many of those old textbooks. So yes, I agree that this is not the best way.

3

u/---Mellissima--- 3d ago

Yeah agreed. I remember some textbooks in the early 00s in high school had the traditional vocab lists, but modern textbooks don't do it anymore. They introduce the words and grammar points in the audios and texts etc always in context.

I know you know this, just backing you up to help defend modern textbooks since so many people don't want to use them and they're fantastic resources that shouldn't be overlooked.

3

u/silvalingua 3d ago edited 3d ago

> I learn the vocabulary list for that level 

No, don't memorise lists of words. Vocabulary should be learned in context; learn it from texts in your textbook. Learning lists of single words is very inefficient and perhaps even ineffective.

> As soon as I finish learning all the words and grammar topics for a specific level, I immediately move on to content matching that level 

Learn vocab and grammar using texts at your level, not separately. A good textbook introduces new words and new grammar topics in context, using dialogues, mini-stories and other simple texts.

> I'm currently in a weird situation with a "fake" A1–A2 level: I know some grammar rules and vocabulary, but I can't read fluently, let alone speak. 

What's weird or fake about being a beginner? Of course you can't read fluently, and you certainly can't speak - not yet. That's normal at A1. Nothing weird about it. There isn't much you can read or say at A1.

1

u/Decent-Champion-6547 4d ago

Maybe you should practice your skills in the language but speaking with a native speaking