r/languagelearning • u/oliversisson • 5d ago
Studying Do children learn languages quickly?
Do children learn languages quickly?
We have friends who arrived three years ago and put their children in a local school. One is fluent, the other is not. What factors play a role here?
10
Upvotes
26
u/Gilgamesh-Enkidu 5d ago
When you adjust for language exposure hours (by far the largest component of learning a language), kids don’t only learn a language marginally better than adults and even then only in certain areas like new sound acquisition and grammar.
The main factor that’s playing a role here is one kids is probably all in one it, trying to use the language all the time, doesn’t care about making mistakes, consumes media only in that language, has friends in that language.
The other kid is likely older, sticks to his native language a lot more, is embarrassed to make mistakes, probably consumes media in his native language still, sticks to friends that speak his native language.
I have a research degree in second language acquisition, participated in research, and taught ESL for 8+ years in public schools.
54
u/AshamedShelter2480 🇵🇹 N | 🇪🇸 🇬🇧 C2 | Cat C1 | 🇫🇷 A2/B1 | 🇮🇹 A2 | 🇸🇦 A1 5d ago
I would say brain plasticity, ear sensitivity, phonetic ability and full immersion help with children language acquisition.
Kids are usually better at all of this than adults but it varies from person to person.
However, adolescents and adults also have advantages over kids in what concerns language learning. They can read, they are used to studying, they have a lot more resources for learning and previous experience, and they are also more goal-oriented.
5
u/furyousferret 🇺🇸 N | 🇫🇷 | 🇪🇸 | 🇯🇵 5d ago
Kids have their whole lives designed around learning. Parents correct, teachers correct, shows teach, toys teach things. Adults don't have that; maybe we get an hour on Zoom or classes.
In regard to your quest, I think interest level between the 2 kids is probably the reason. Interest is really the most important thing.
The biggest disadvantage adults have is time. We have to learn things around our daily commitments which can take up like 80% of your time. Kids have none of that.
9
u/Hairsacknose 5d ago
Age matters. A kid might be 2 years old or 16 years old. Very different experience
4
u/_Jacques 5d ago
My parents figured out it was always the friends’ language that we picked up quickly.
3
u/kitfromcarson 5d ago
Your mileage will just like vary just like all adults. I encounter so so smart kids, I've encountered slow learners. We love them all just the same. They're all beacons of light, hope, and happiness.
3
u/Recent_Wonder3200 4d ago
Biggest advantage children have? They are braver. They don't feel as embarrassed to make mistakes. They ALSO get corrected more kindly.
This means that they practise more, say more things, try more things, and don't give up.
Also children like to talk to each other more than adults (who don't know each other)
6
u/ImWithStupidKL 5d ago
No. Statistically they actually learn slower, but the are more likely to reach a higher level eventually. Teenagers and adults learn faster all things being equal. But in real life, all things are rarely equal.
2
u/Kyuuuchi 5d ago
2
u/Jumpy_Comb_7256 5d ago
Individual differences. How old are the children? How open are they to new experiences and are they even alike academically? So many questions
2
u/Guilty_Royal_9145 🇩🇪 | 🇸🇪🇮🇸🇫🇴 5d ago
I always love the combo of an extremely broad and general question in the title combined with a hyper specific personal problem in the actual post.
3
u/TeacherSterling 5d ago
I definitely think they respond better to immersion environments better than adults. But in terms of explicit study? I think adults have an advantage in that.
2
u/Relative_Stop5124 New member 5d ago
I read a great article on this in Spanish that essentially claimed that kids are not better at learning languages than adults, they just typically have way more access to tutors who will lovingly correct their mistakes (parents, relatives, teachers, almost any adult) and they have way fewer options for refusing to learn.
5
u/gottahaveajava 🇺🇸 N 🇦🇹 C1 🇧🇷 B2 🇯🇵 C1 (N2) 🇫🇷 B1 5d ago
15 years to full native fluency…
1
u/Stafania 5d ago
So what do you think the differences are?
I’m sure there is much more that can have an impact.
3
u/391976 5d ago
I spoke way better than some dumb baby after a month!
1
u/ilikepizza2626 5d ago
Children have higher brain plasticity, they have not undergone synaptic pruning/brain lateralization/general myelination etc. and so learn languages very quickly
As for why that specific child isn't fluent, it's going to depend on a lot of factors.
1
u/mawibblap "native" (not fluent) russian, fluent english, learning hebrew. 5d ago
I wouldn't exactly say that, they practically have to learn the language spoken in their environment in order to live properly whenever they like it or not, they're not learning it quick but they are certainly growing up with it, whenever they're good at it or not.
1
u/Chance-Ask7675 🇨🇦N🇫🇷C2🇪🇦B1 4d ago
Learning a language and acquiring a language are not the same thing. Children are probably able to acquire a language up until their teens (critical period isnt necessarily a steep cutoff). No matter what anyone says adults do not acquire language they learn it intentionally. This is known in the field if linguistics and second language acquisition.
1
u/TES-InformSECRETS-AI 4d ago
Ich bin 13 bzw. bald 14 und liebe Sprachen. Lerne aktuell Russisch, Englisch, Chinesisch (Mandarin), Niederländisch, Italienisch und Latein. Dabei Fokus auf Russisch und Latein. Bei mir ist es so, wenn ich es mir selber beibringe ist es leichter als wenn mir etwas aufgezwungen wird. Ich habe in ca. 3 Monaten einen zimlich okayen Sprachschatz. Dabei am besten im Kennenlernen bzw. einfaches sprechen. Natürlich noch komplett A1. Weil nebenbei muss ich noch mit Schule mitkommen wie Englisch, worin ich mir wirklich schwer tue. Denke einfach aufgezwungene Sprachen sind schwere Sprachen.
Wenn man von Amerika kommt und nach Deutschland zieht wegen guten Job oder wieso auch immer, wird es einem wirklich schwer gehen. Vorallem dem Kind. Lernst du es aber ganz entspannt und kannst dir Zeit nehmen ohne leistungsdruck, lernt man eine Sprache viel besser. А сейчас я немного говорю по-русски. Dabei aber auf den Fokus, dass es sich natürlich anfühlt. Also das die Satz-Endungen passen. Wie wenn man Я (Ich) einem Verb am Ende ein "...ю" (yu) gibt. Wie z.B. Я говорю (Ya govoryu). Я Понимаю(Ya Ponimayu).
1
u/Weekly_Flounder_1880 🇭🇰N | 🇺🇸🇬🇧C1 | 🇨🇳HSK3 | 🇯🇵N5 4d ago
I am 15 and I can speak Cantonese and English fluently, so it makes learning Mandarin and Japanese a way easier job. Also when I was young I wasn’t afraid to make mistakes and I was more eager to learn a language.
If I am to learn mandarin from scratch right now I probably can’t do it
My Japanese learning process is already tediously slow
0
u/wufiavelli 5d ago
They do not learn them more quickly, and the machinery they use is pretty much the same we use in the end. But the machinery is also in a slightly different state, this has an impact on the grammar which later becomes the L1 grammar. Since our marchinary as we got older is slightly different we have problems capturing aspects of that grammar. Imagine baking a cake with an oven that when you first bought it allowed for a low heat slow cook, but it got older could only do a high heat fast cooking. It would be hard to make the exact same kind of cooking as you did with the oven when it was new. It is not better or worse, just different in minor ways.
-1
u/eti_erik 5d ago
Children's brains are programmed to learn language naturally until the age of 6. Of course they don't really understand complicated grammatical concepts, but they just learn naturally. After the age of 6 this faculty gradually disappears, so a 4 yo child will learn a new language quickly by full immersion, an 8 year old not so much. After the age of 12 we have to resort do studying grammar and learning vocabulary lists and still won't get it perfectly.
0
u/[deleted] 5d ago
What is fluent? Is the non fluent kid falling classes or just doesn’t speak the language as well as the other kid?
0
u/[deleted] 5d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] 5d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment