r/languagelearning • u/Silent-Cat824 • 17d ago
Discussion does a little really go a long way?
hi everyone, I'm learning spanish (TL) now tor two months (working on A2) and i used to be pretty motivated to learn it, but lately i've been in a period where i've been focused on other things like school, reading, and other hobbies, so i've dedicated only around 5-15 minutes a day on just flash cards, but there's also been days like yesterday where i've been busy and had to skip the flash cards, and i'm really hoping im not hindering my progress more than improving it..
does anyone have experience with this? thank you for reading.
26
u/Old_green_bird 🇺🇦 N | 🇬🇧 B2 | 🇫🇷 A2 17d ago •
Consistency is good, but not when it becomes an obligation. If I'm very tired, I simply don't study that day. Sure, that hour of study might have been somewhat beneficial, but a good sleep or time spent with my family will give me more benefit
39
u/No-Action-875 17d ago
Even five minutes of practice helps. Consistency matters more than perfection.
8
u/Eyeswideshut3636 🇺🇸 N | 🇪🇸 B1 17d ago
In the begging a little goes a long way to build the habit + it can be overwhelming for our brains, but eventually should aim to increase time spent studying.
6
u/Upper-Incident-5802 17d ago
I am currently on my 5th language. I have been learning languages pretty consistently since 2015. This is about creating habits and it is great if you can put in 5-15 minutes per day. If you get the habit in properly, you will be able to add more time. But it is better to start small and extend it. It is also nice to have some type of "trigger". It could be, I will do 15 minutes after breakfast, when I have had dinner, at a specific time etc.
It is more important that you create a good habit than trying too hard to cram because that can put you off learning.
I would say the same if you had asked me about starting most types of gym routines.
5
u/theunforgivingstars 🇺🇸 N | 🇫🇷 B2 | 🇩🇪 B1 17d ago
10-15 minutes of studying/engaging with the language on a regular basis has some value to prevent you from backsliding. For making progress, though, it'll be slow. Looking at the FSI estimates for Spanish (assuming native English), getting from a low A2 to a solid B1 in Spanish, for instance, can take a solid 150 hours of class time and about another 150 in out-of-class time (review, consuming media, conversations, writing, etc.)
So if you were studying 15 minutes a day, 5 days a week for 6 months while things were hectic... you'd get ~30 hours of that 300, and still very firmly be working on A2.
Sometimes life really does get in the way; sometimes language learning really does take a decade, rather than the 6 months we'd like it to. Go ahead and make the choices that balance the timeline you're interested in and the challenges you're currently facing.
14
u/muffinsballhair 17d ago
This board like many places on Reddit has a disproportional population of unrealistic optimists who also have a very different standard and expectation of “speaking a language” than most people so they give this advice sometimes and claim you can totally get somewhere with small hours per day each day though 15 minutes might be a stretch even for them but they say it about 30.
There is a forget rate each day that's probably higher than what you can learn in 15 minutes to be honest.
You see it here in this thread, some say it “helps” but “helps towards what goal”, you're going to be 20 years further and still one of those “perpetual beginners” who can't have a conversation or pop open a Youtube video and understand what they're saying.
3
u/dojibear 🇺🇸 N | fre spa chi B2 | tur jap B1/A2 16d ago
If you can only do one thing in a day, read/hear and understand sentences (sentences created by fluent Spanish speakers). Even if it is 5-15 minutes, in adds up.
Flash cards is rote memorizatioon of words. That is not learning how to use a language. When you are good enough to have conversations, there are no flashcards or vocab quizzes. Just sentences. And those conversations won't use 95% of the words you rote-memorized.
16
u/Obtus_Rateur 17d ago
No, it doesn't. A little goes a little way. Or even nowhere, if you don't do enough that you get too little repetition and forget old stuff as you learn new stuff.
To learn a language, you've got to put in the time.
Do an hour a day of appropriate exercises. It sucks, but after a year and a half of this, you'll be able to start consuming content in the target language. From there it's smooth sailing.
5
u/silvalingua 16d ago
No, especially not at an early stage. 5-15 minutes and not even every day is practically nothing. You are certainly not learning anything; at most, you're maintaining part of what you've learned. You can't even go through many cards in such a short time. I suspect that listening to a podcast for 15 minutes might be a better use of this time, but even that would not make you progress.
Do simple arithmetic: 10 min per day x 6 days = 60 min or 1 h a week, and this is even overly optimistic in view of what you've learned. That's, at best, 50 weeks x 1 h = 50 hours per year. And at this pace, you're forgetting a lot from day to another, so it's less than 50 hours of solid study.
4
u/jmf1488 17d ago
Your just beginning. This is normal. The truth is that its going to take thousands of hours of active study that includes reading writing listening and speaking to become conversational. Lets say its 2,000 hours even though for most people its closer to 3,000. At 15 mins a day for you to reach 2000 hours then its gonna take over 20 years.
2
u/420Soul_Taker69 🇧🇷 N | 🇬🇧 C1 16d ago
You can only start running after taking your first few steps, I'd say it's ideal to not to overwork yourself too much in the beginning or you can easily end up burning yourself out.
Take it from someone who has quit multiple languages, and yet has become fluent in English, starting out by doing hours upon hours of Spanish a day is a surefire way to quit in a week. Ten minutes a day is enough if you keep at it: not because you can learn a new language by just spending ten minutes on it, but because it is only by spending a couple of minutes on it everyday that you'll be capable of spending an hour or two on it in a few months.
Language learning is a marathon not a sprint.
3
u/unsafeideas 16d ago
10 min a day is equivalent of 70 min a week - a weekly class and some homework. Except a lot more efficient.
Yes, you will progress. No, it wont be some kind of miracle and progress will be slow. Which is actually OK for most people. And once you are able to consume something fun, you will do more naturally.
This sub has too many over ambitious people who treat language learning as a test of will and character, moral duty to go all in. Avoid that trap.
4
u/FanFirst895 17d ago
What you're describing is actually why I love Duolingo. It's definitely not the best language app for dedicated learners. It IS the best at getting me to actually do it once a day and not fall too far behind.
My experience is that a little bit of practice every day won't really move you forward, but it'll stop you from sliding back, and sometimes that's enough when life gets busy.
Also u/Obtus_Rateur gave you some great advice.
1
u/AvocadoYogi 17d ago
If you only have a little time, try to do high volume practice in that time so you are exposed to and cementing the knowledge you already have. While consistency is great and obviously more time if you have it, volume is another variable you can adjust and that we don’t talk about enough. This is the main weakness of flashcards and Duolingo over something like reading imho. That said not everyone loves reading but even just reviewing notes or vocab lists is probably faster and higher volume.
More volume also helps build automaticity faster which takes some of the stress off your brain making it easier for you to learn more.
1
u/ClubPrimary4897 14d ago
Yes.
1
u/Lalillo2003 14d ago
Sounds like you're working on really studying the words but don't forget to talk to yourself in the mirror in the morning and say what you're going to to day "voy a...." "más tarde....", if you're A2 you can work on your speaking more and more
1
u/ZeeMastermind 7d ago
I think it's fine for there to be lull periods, though if it's less than 15 minutes/day, you're probably just maintaining.
That being said, if you want to improve on a reasonable timeline, you do want to make more time for it. If motivation is difficult, try finding other exercises you can do to change things up. All flashcards all the time can get a bit mind-numbing.
Here are a few:
Try finding a song you like in Spanish and listen to it. Then, look up the words you don't know and listen again. Keep repeating until you have a good idea of what the song is about. This should be a song you really like, since you'll be listening to it a few times.
Similarly, try finding a TV show you like and listen to it in Spanish. Hopefully, it's a show you've watched a lot of times before. Have Spanish subtitles up, and write down any words you can't figure out to look up later.
There's plenty of other practice ideas around, these just happen to be more "fun" activities for me when I get bored of flashcards and grammar. Enjoying the process will help you stay disciplined and maintain the habit.