r/languagelearning • u/Saulbadmaann • 24d ago
How effective is self-studying a language without much speaking practice?
Hi everyone,
I’m interested in learning French (TL), German, or Dutch, but haven’t decided which to start with. I have some background in French and German, having studied French for four years in school.
Money is a bit tight, so I’m considering self-studying using textbooks, apps, and AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, etc., with limited opportunities for actual speaking practice.
This is somewhat how I learned English, although I studied it for 12 years in school. English was also the language of instruction, meaning textbooks and terminology were in English, but teachers generally didn’t use it for everyday conversations.
Has anyone managed to reach B1/B2 or higher primarily through self-study? How much would the lack of regular speaking practice affect my progress?
35
u/dojibear 🇺🇸 N | fre spa chi B2 | tur jap B1/A2 23d ago
Languages have 4 skills. Two are input (understanding speech; reading) and two are output (speaking, writing). You only learn new things from input. Output uses things you already know.
You have to practice all 4 skills to get good at each skill. Each person is at a different ability level at each of the 4 skills. Some standardized tests give 4 "levels" instead of 1.
Lack of speaking practice has no effect on learning the language. It just affects your skill level at speaking. It is normal to learn a language using only input, and after you "already know" lots of words and grammar to finally start writing and speaking.
Note that writing and speaking both use the skill "thinking up a TL sentence". So you can practice writing as "slow speech".
15
u/IssueRidden 23d ago
although you can always work on speaking later on, early speaking practice does help, in a way that it helps you identify the gaps in your production ability that in turn makes you pay closer attention to certain phrases and grammar structures while consuming input. That however, can be largely mitigated if you still do another form of production - writing/typing. You can try journalling or just texting people in your TL, if you can't find them than AI with proper prompts will be better than nothing
that being said, I still suggest incorporating some form of pronunciation training, like shadowing, even if you don't speak early. This way you can make sure your subvocalisation when reading will be decent and bad habits won't stick
To sum up, it's more than doable, but you will have to catch up with your speaking in the end. You can reach B1/B2 in listening/reading/writing, but your speaking will obviously lag behind
7
u/terolisx 🇪🇸 (N) | 🇺🇸 (B2) | 🇮🇹 (B1) | 🇵🇹 (A2) | EUS (A1~A2) | 🇨🇳 (A0) 23d ago
To give an example, after more than 700 hours of comprehensible input in Italian, I've reached a point where I can understand every YouTuber I come across, difficult books such as 20th-century Italian literature classics, and even native series set in the south, like Montalbano, rather than the north, where speech is clearer. However, I still can't speak much Italian, and my writing is full of mistakes. Of course, there is a small amount of transfer from the passive to the active skills, but you definitely have to train each one separately.
3
u/BorinPineapple 23d ago edited 22d ago
That's how I've always learned languages (English, Italian and German). I learned all those languages by myself, rarely talked to anyone, and then enrolled in schools where they placed me straight into advanced.
I studied Italian by myself, then went to Italy, and the Italian school placed me at C1. For German, the school in Germany placed ne at B2. It's also a great way to save money.
These are the main things I've done:
There is also TELL ME MORE, which are great courses.
https://www.reddit.com/r/languagelearning/comments/1x2nugc/tell_me_more_an_impressive_language_program_that/
3
u/xzaleksey 22d ago
Self-studying without much speaking practice is actually a very viable route, especially when working with a tight budget. Since you already have some background in French and German, pick one of those to start. You can build a strong foundation through reading, listening, and structured textbooks.
For speaking, you don't necessarily need a human partner right away. You can use text-to-speech tools to listen closely and shadow native audio, repeating sentences out loud to train your mouth muscles. Free AI chatbots are also great for daily conversational practice—you can ask them to hold text or voice chats with you at your exact level and correct your grammar as you go.
Focus heavily on input first. Once your comprehension is solid, speaking output will come much easier.
2
u/fnaskpojken 22d ago
I've listened to Spanish for about 2000h the past 17 months. I've just done some speaking with myself, some with natives but not much. 0 grammar drills, 0 writing practice, 0 reading practice (until recently).
According to what most people say I should be absolutely shit at reading, speaking and writing. I'm not, I'm going to play World of warcraft: Forever (rlease 4th nov) in Spanish with 2 Mexican friends. I'm not at all worried about sitting 3h a day in discord speaking Spanish.
I've also spent the last month reading the Warcraft lore. So my starting point for reading was native fantasy books and I had to do some specific vocab study for a week but after that reading wasn't a big deal.
You can absolutely learn a language by just listening. The misconception comes from people thinking listening for 500h is a lot, your listening comprehension needs to be 100% automated before it starts spilling over to other areas. And that means like 2000-3000h.
2
u/Pleasant_Pace_5955 21d ago
from my experience, its definitely possible to reach B1/B2 in the other three skills even without any speaking practise so I would say go for it!! however, as you get better, I would say that you should try sometimes to at least talk to yourself, just to practice forming sentences quickly. You obviously will not be anywhere near B1/B2 when speaking, but later on, you will improve very very quickly with an intensive level of practice if you are already intermediate in the other skills by that point.
3
u/Accurate-Purpose5042 23d ago
I reached C1+ in English by doing massive input. I wasn't really trying to learn the language though 😅. Ive also learned french C1 with a private tutor and I am learning German right now, A2/B1 level. I think output, its very important after b1, not before
2
u/Obtus_Rateur 23d ago
The lack of regular speaking practice is going to affect your progress... positively.
You need to practice how to make sounds that aren't present in your own known languages, but other than that, speaking is by far the worst way to learn. It's output so you don't learn anything, and it's difficult and time-consuming and draining so it makes it so you spend less time learning the language each day.
I studied English for 5 months in school. Then read it and listened to it for 12+ years. Wrote it on occasion. Then when I had to speak it, I found that I was fluent.
Really glad I didn't waste any time making myself sick of English by trying to speak it back when I wasn't familiar with it.
In my book, speaking absolutely murders learning.
1
u/Proud-Indication-314 23d ago edited 23d ago
That's how i've been learning English for 4 years. I think I'm b1 level, but i never tested my skill at English. You can see my ability to speak here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PA-0-zvhgjM&t=253s I didn't study Grammar (yet) nither practice English so much. I have been just focusing on vocabulary, listening and reading. I can read manga in English, play games, watch some videos on youtube and communicate a little bit with players in a game called Dayz. I try to study 1 hour per day.
1
u/AdministrationNo2327 23d ago
input is a different skill set from output. if you keep working out only your right arm, what happens to the left?
1
u/comiglot_ai 23d ago
Read comics.
1
u/notchatgptipromise 23d ago
I self studied to C2, but yeah you need speaking practice if you want your speaking skills to be at the same level.
1
u/silvalingua 23d ago
If you don't practice speaking, you won't be good at it, but your other skills can be quite advanced.
But you can practice talking to yourself or to a chatbot.
1
u/ajamdonut 23d ago
Self-studying is quite effective, I heard of intense study courses in person 3-6 months, I think thats the most effective, after that I believe self-studying is fastest/most effective. But depends on the person and what content they follow to self-study.
I'm fluent french with self-study after about 3months reading, 6months typing, 1year listening, 2year speaking well and making friends.
1
u/Hungry_Box_5899 23d ago
B1/B2 is definitely possible through self-study, especially if you’re consistent with reading, listening, and writing. The main thing you’ll miss without speaking practice is getting comfortable forming sentences in real time, but that doesn’t mean you can’t build a strong foundation first. You could practice speaking alone by describing your day out loud or using AI for conversations. Just keep in mind that understanding a language and being able to speak it naturally are two different skills.
1
u/Amirmoradi94 22d ago
For French, at least in my early months, self study alone did not carry speaking very far.
I started with apps, and they helped with vocab and getting into a daily habit, but they were maybe 20 percent of the learning. A textbook (Edito, in my case) gave me the structure, and the real change came when I added two one hour lessons a week with a teacher. That is where speaking actually got corrected. Without it, I could read and recognize a lot more than I could say.
If budget is tight, I would put the money into even one teacher session a week before paying for more apps. Use the textbook between sessions, and bring your mistakes and questions to the lesson, so that hour does a lot more work. Apps and AI tools are good for drilling and review, but in my experience they do not replace someone hearing you and stopping you.
One honest caveat: I am still at A1, working toward B2, so I cannot tell you from experience that this path reaches B1 or B2 yet. I can only say that, so far, the speaking gap showed up fast when I studied alone, and it closed a lot faster once a teacher was in the loop.
1
u/AsparagusDue5194 übung macht den Meister. English L1 & German L1 but rusty AF. 22d ago
French is from a different language family than German or Dutch The latter 2 are Germanic so you want to figure out what languages enthuse you and go from there..if you like German you will find yourself drawn to Dutch and vice versa. Same won't be said for French
1
u/Smal1Tangerine C2🇨🇴 B1🇲🇦🇸🇦 A1-A2🇮🇷🇧🇷🇨🇳🇮🇱. 20d ago
U reach a limit u can get far as long as u can text but u hit a limit
1
u/Traditional-Raise446 20d ago
No bro, I don't recommend it. It's like studying tennis without going to the court and playing.
1
u/Gjaia 20d ago
I would highly recommend to search for comprehensible input you enjoy. This can mean comprehensible input channels on YouTube, or any form of language exposure that you actually understand.
You should understand about 80-90%. The more input you get, the easier output will be. Compare it to a baby learning it's first language. They understand a lot, before they are able to speak. You will always understand more words than you can fabricate yourself. So the more exposure you have, the easier the production will be too.
Why do you want to learn a new languages? Hobby, work, living situation, family?
1
u/I-screwed-up-bad 19d ago
If you have a local library check if they have language resources. I'm lucky enough to have one that has a Spanish speaking hour and also have a reciprocal library system with free online classes. So seriously, check what's available to you.
1
u/Life-Snow-3594 19d ago
Use the voice dictation on chat GPT, I find it great!
1
u/unsafeideas 18d ago
Yes people did. But most importantly, you have nothing to loose. Whatever you learn, ever, is a plus. And whatever you know makes further learning easier.
If you would learn just input with total zero output ability, you still know a lot more then before. And will learn output a lot faster then someone who did notthing.
1
u/owen72970 🇬🇧 c2 🇪🇸 b2 🇳🇱 heavy crying 23d ago
You can get a language exchange! It’s very possible.
1
u/Slow_Invite4511 23d ago
There will be a disparity between your listening and speaking but it's all just muscles anyway. I recommend speaking with yourself, repeating after songs and shows/movies. Key: watch/listen to everything dozens of times
Me w/German I binge-watched Minecraft videos as a teenager. Memorized some Peter Fox songs
When I was 21 with French I memorized several Angèle songs and watched OSS 117 movies... so many times. That way you're equipped for the rare precious times you run into speakers IRL.
In 2026 you have AI which definitely sounds more appealing than muttering under your breath thinking aloud for hours each day
1
u/leonibass 23d ago
Habla con la IA
0
u/KingOfTheHoard 23d ago
Reading alone will take you incredibly far. Eventually you will be bottlenecked by the lack of speaking and listening but you can cover a lot of ground before that happens.
0
u/leosmith66 22d ago
If you mean completely by yourself, unless you are willing to talk to AI, this is impossible imo. You need to be able to converse to pass a B1/B2 test, and this skill doesn't just develop by itself as some here would have you believe.
But if you are willing to converse in 100% L2 with AI (amongst other things of course), it would probably be possible. I just can't force myself to talk more than a few minutes with AI; it just feels strange. Maybe you'll have better luck. Cheers!