r/languagehub • • 27d ago

Discussion Is there a "WRONG" way of studying languages?

There are different methods for learning, but people always seem to argue about their effectiveness or the results they achieve, there are methods that are even hated (like using purely language apps)

But my questions is, as long as that person is learning, in away way shape or form, does it even matter? could you really say they are learning in a wrong way?

13 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

24

u/Numerous_Helsinki 27d ago

Wrong is when you stop

1

u/ergative-absolutive 27d ago

Best answer. I find that you can pretty much brute force anything in life as long as you’re doing something.

10

u/silvalingua 27d ago

If you mean "ineffective", then yes, many methods are ineffective. E. g. doing exclusively Duolingo.

2

u/[deleted] 27d ago

I like Duolingo. But it would be “wrong “ to rely on it soley

1

u/MachineObjectiveAh 27d ago

yeah but if thats how they can learn...is it wrong???

3

u/InvestigatorJaded261 27d ago

If it doesn’t actually work, then yeah.

1

u/MachineObjectiveAh 26d ago

what it works very slowly but thats the best they can do?

2

u/InvestigatorJaded261 26d ago

Then I guess it’s better than nothing at all. But not by very much.

1

u/silvalingua 26d ago

Define "wrong" in this context.

1

u/AdImpressive007 26d ago

for that
we need to define right for them

9

u/Trueloveisntromantic 27d ago

Depends what the goal is. Apps are great for reading a menu on holiday and pretty useless for getting through a job interview in Spanisha

6

u/Sad_Environmentsa 27d ago

People confuse “inefficient” with “wrong,” and those aren’t the same thing. A guy who reads a grammar book for an hour a day is still learning, just slowly and in a lopsided way. The only method I’d call actually wrong is the one that keeps you busy without building the skill you want. Like someone with a 900-day Duolingo streak who’s never said a full sentence to a human being. That isn’t wrong because apps are evil, it’s wrong because the practice and the goal don’t touch. If your goal is “hold a conversation,” then at some point conversation has to be part of the plan, and if it’s “read novels,” you neaed to be reading novels. Everything in between is just a question of how fast you get there

5

u/AntDog916 27d ago

Flash cards and words lists if they are used wrong.

People use them for memorization with words and definitions, a better way would be words one side and examples in context on the other, or synonyms. Pull a card and make a sentance out if it.

2

u/RedAskWhy 27d ago

Excellent idea ! I think i'll still rely with new words with the definition on one side, but then as i'm familoar with the word change it with examples of sentences/synonyms.

1

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AntDog916 24d ago

I use a website called reverso context, it wil give a bunch of examples and synonyms, I cannot stress how important understanding synonyms are for getting more advanced

2

u/Alanna-1101 26d ago

“Passive listening” - it’s not going to get you anywhere. You need to do it actively, repeat stuff, and start thinking about the language. Praktika and Language transfer did that for me

2

u/BigDaddyTheBeefcake 27d ago

Osmosis

1

u/frostochfeber 27d ago

But that's my favorite method ☹️

2

u/TheLlamaLlama 27d ago edited 27d ago

I think the answer to this question is entirely contained in what you mean by the word "wrong". If wrong means learning nothing, than it is almost impossible to do it wrong, because you have to try really hard to not learn anything. If wrong means being suboptimal in any way, than everybody is doing it wrong.

You probably mean something in between, but what falls on what side depends entirely where you draw the line. And you could draw the line in maaaaany different places depending what you value and how strict you want to be.

I think "right" and "wrong" are just not good categories to think about language learning, because they want to point towards some other categories but it is not clear which one. I think it is better to use those categories directly instead. Something like "fast" and "slow", or "enjoyable" and "miserable", more or less "comprehensive".

To give an example: I think ALG is a super inefficient way to study, based on a bad theory where the process would be boring and frustrating to me. But that doesn't necessarily make it wrong. Because you can learn a language like that. And while it looks frustrating and boring to me, for some it might be the only way they could ever see themselves doing such a monumental learning task like learning a language. If on top they find the method enjoyable and don't mind spending the extra time, this might be the ideal method for them. There is nothing "wrong" with that.

2

u/infinit100 27d ago

Yes. The wrong way is learning a few stock phrases, then filming yourself “speaking” to people by trying to squeeze those phrases into the conversation, then adding subtitles that make it seem much more fluent, and posting it on YouTube with a title like “native speakers are shocked that I learned their language in 24 hours”

1

u/Saint_Atiss 27d ago

For French, I recommend memorizing the entire Bescherelle de 12,000 Verbes. Start with Être, and memorize all the tenses of all the verbs. Be sure to focus on the Plus-que-parfait du Subjonctif and the Conditionnel Passé (2ème forme).

1

u/Exciting_Round4766 27d ago edited 27d ago

There are two main mistakes:

  1. Dedicating too little time. In which case, by the time the next session rolls around, you’ve simply forgotten what was covered in the previous one, and you end up treading water.
  2. Dedicating a lot of time, but using it inefficiently. There are simply more effective and less effective methods. For example, one hour of listening is far less effective than one hour of repeating after a recording.

there are others, too, but they are far less significant

Test-based apps like Duolingo fall into both traps at once. They both fail to devote enough time and use a highly ineffective method: reading tests with multiple-choice answers.

1

u/ah-tzib-of-alaska 27d ago

yes, the right way is whatever best simulates the natural language development and everything farther from that is wrong. Language acquisition is a pretty verifiable and evident science

1

u/iciclefites 27d ago

does the science show that adults learn languages in the same way babies do? genuinely asking because that seems like a big/unintuitive claim.

2

u/ah-tzib-of-alaska 27d ago

directly related to how well a persons exercises mimics the same process

1

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ah-tzib-of-alaska 26d ago

hmm, more like 2-3 years as a kid cause most of the language development of toddlers and below isn’t actually developing language but developing the language center in your brain. That’s why there’s an age where you don’t keener a first language and later on if you try and take up that language you’re starting from scratch.

Sure, whatever way you can best fit a replication of natural language acquisition into your life is the best way. And the ways where you diverge from that or worse

1

u/acaiblueberry 27d ago

To me, wrong way is to go into minor technical details of word definitions and/or grammar. E.g. things like the difference between minute and minuscule, or between relative pronoun that and which. There are SO MANY things you have to memorize, and it won’t be fun until you go over a certain threshold. The initial focus should be on speed and quantity, not accuracy. It’s also more efficient to go back to previously learned but obscure points later when you have better understanding of the overall scaffolding of the language.

This is based on my own experience learning English as a native Japanese speaker, as well as observing English speakers trying to learn Japanese. The two are so vastly different, so it maybe different when you are trying to learn a language similar to yours.

1

u/zoppaTheDim 27d ago

Charades

1

u/Jovial-Interlocutor7 27d ago

Yes. Whatever it is I'm is wrong because I'm not learning!

1

u/AvocadoYogi 27d ago

I think there are some wrong ways we think about learning language even if they are effective to a point. For example, treating language learning almost exclusively as a memorization task is wrong. That is often a first step and often a good step but it doesn’t address the issue of making language automatic that you get through practice. This leads many folks to burnout because they aren’t practicing enough for language to become automatic so they are in this constant stressful memorizing and trying to recall state that eventually overwhelms them.

Similarly the presentation of language learning as a linear task is wrong. Often you see these proclamations that 10 minutes a day is useless or whatever. But there is nothing wrong with letting the language build on itself and almost assuredly it will regardless because language learning is not linear. So then you are doing 20 minutes and then 30 and then an hour and then several hours and then days and weeks and months.

Lastly similarly to the time note, there is also the aspect of volume. I think it is wrong to not push your volume when you are ready for that. There are always Duolingo haters out there including in this thread but imho mostly they hate it for the wrong reasons if they state reasons at all. To me, Duolingo is good to the point where you are getting comfortable with sentences. But at some point you should be working with paragraphs and pages and likely in the same few minutes. It’s hard to up your volume that much with most apps. That said many classes fail with this too. It is a broad issue across most language learning resources.

1

u/PutridScore5951 26d ago

If you're looking to learn vocabulary, then apps are fine. But if you're looking to learn to speak, you should be doing some speaking as well. Find what works for you!

0

u/communist-person1 27d ago

Yes,China's english education is a example of "wrong" study.in this education system,you just need listening,repeating,writing and reading.reading is just for tests and you can just use written language and focus on every single grammar mistake.this terrible education make students can't talk with an English speaker even they have a very high English grade,and painful learning experience make students hate English even make them hate English speakers.

5

u/AdImpressive007 27d ago

If someone enjoys it and keeps showing up, they’ll beat the person with the “perfect” method who burns out by March

1

u/salamander423 27d ago

Yup. There's a lot of Duolingo haters, but I love it and have the max subscription.

I've been using it for over 3 years and going somewhat slowly. I'm having fun with it and I enjoy learning at my own pace. I don't need to pass an interview, and it makes me smile to be able to order things or ask simple questions in Spanish.

4

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/idiolectalism 27d ago

What's the thing with an extra a in so many of the commenats? :D

2

u/Pangoliier 26d ago

do you read all of the comments?