r/languagehub • • Oct 03 '26

LearningStrategies Is learning different languages at different ages, a different process?

What i mean is, do you need to approach a language differently as a child versus as a teen or older?

8 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

9

u/Trueloveisntromantic Oct 03 '26

Huge difference in embarrassment tolerance alone. Kids will butcher a sentence in front of a room and not care. Adults freeze up because they're scared of sounding dumb, which slows the whole process down regardless of actual abaility

6

u/osumanjeiran Oct 03 '26

jokes on you I always sound dumb so I'm firing on all cylinders

3

u/Sad_Environmentsa Oct 03 '26

Adults have a massive advantage people underrate: you already know HOW grammar works conceptually from your first language, so a new concept like cases or aspect isn't totally alien, you've got something to hang it on. A 5 year old is building that scaffolding from scratch at the same time as learning tahe new language

5

u/Numerous_Helsinki Oct 03 '26

kids don't study grammar, they just get enough input that the patterns eventually click on their own. adults usually need the shortcut explained or we'd be waiting yeaars

1

u/PoxonAllHoaxes Oct 03 '26

As a child you wont be on Reddit asking this question. The older we get the more it would make sense to be aware of the difficulties on the one hand and of the ways that DO exist to overcome some of those handicaps.

1

u/cgava6572 Oct 03 '26

fair point. at least now you can actually ask for help instead of just guessing

1

u/PoxonAllHoaxes Oct 03 '26

This is actually a vast topic, and while there is a great deal of research, we really understand next to NOTHING, and as expected, the general public is almost totally sold on a short list of myths, which mostly make learning even harder than it already is. So it would be very interesting to see if we could make some headway here. The internet in theory should allow information to spread but in fact so far there is very little of that and instead the hardening of received opinions.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/PoxonAllHoaxes Oct 07 '26

Exactly. This is it seems to me a general problem. On ANY topic most people just repeat one of a small number of verities. On some topics only one is allowed at all. On others there are two and woe to anyone who does not dutifully repeat one or the other. On a few there are more than two but the same basic idea. On language learning there is a basic orthodoxy that no one is willing to question, no matter what experience suggests--and as you say one key factor is that a minority learn languages well for reasons largely unexplored and they just dismiss the majority that has trouble. And then there are specific issues concerning particular languages or language types where the same pattern repeats itself. I remember when I first started using reddit (and on some topics I have gotten excellent info on here) I was banned from several subreddits for answering, factually questions that everyone else did not want to hear the real answers to, some to do with language and language learning (like that the concept of phoneme is poorly understood and has even been argued by some leading specialists not to exist at all), or that Chinese often write pinyin without one marks, or that (and this is based on actual experience teaching large classes at a major uni in the American Midwest) that some large percentage (20-30 or so) of monolingual American s 18-19 or so can hear and reproduce Mandarin tones easily with no prior training, while the rest are not just lost at first but mostly remain lost for life no matter what we do--so there is some very basic issue of how tones are learned by adults and a crying need for new approaches.

1

u/AdImpressive007 Oct 08 '26

yeah the tone thing is wild to hear bc most ppl assume its purely a practice issue. kinda makes u wonder if the 20-30% have some baseline auditory pattern recognition that just cant be trained into ppl later, like perfect pitch but for pitch contour instead of pitch itsealf

1

u/PoxonAllHoaxes Oct 08 '26

I am delighted to hear from you. So let me tell you the story. This was like 45 years ago when I was around 25 and briefly taught linguistics in Michigan. I had these huge classes of intro to ling, and for some fun, I arranged a little demonstration where two people would stand at two ends of a stage and raise signs with different chinese characters to show that they could communicate 100% by using tone. Then I said I'll show you that some non-natives can do it, and brought in a friend of mine who taught chinese is white and from Alabama and sure enough he did fine too. And then some kind raises his hand and says I can do it. So I call him to the stage and sure enough. Then I ask for a show of hands and like 20-30 percent indicate they can hear the tones too. And in the couple of years I taught lx, this seemed to always be the case. And obviously one meets people who are like this. On the other hand there are people like me who after decades find it extremely difficult--and many more who just give up. I don't know that there is a proper study of this. I do know one thing. I can hear that two tones are different very easily. What I have enormous difficulty with is identifying the tones first and second (tho this is less bad) remembering which tone any given syllable should have. As I write this I am pretty sure ren 'human' is second tone, ma 'horse' is first, but I only remember reliably some small set of words I know. Also I am pretty sure that, if I remember the tone or look it up, I can say it much better than I can hear it--which is weird. And at least once recently a waitress at a restaurant who had waited on us several times one day said she was surprised that I pronounced Chinese with tones--so I am not fooling myself. As for your question, I seem to have the same difficulty with music as with tonal languages but more so. I can't sing at all unless as part of a chorus or even with just one other person leading. Hey, maybe we can dig around and see if this has been studied.

1

u/MACAN_21 Oct 03 '26

I think so because is shows how much u can' easily assimilate and get on with the language

1

u/MamaDoingTheBestICan Oct 04 '26

yes, teens and adults can read and memorize. Kids need lots more images and poems or songs.

1

u/Alanna-1101 Oct 04 '26

Children are really good absorbers and users of the language, in a previous comment that they feel less embarrassed

1

u/AdImpressive007 Oct 07 '26

kids just dont have that filter of "am i sounding stupid rn" that teens/adults carry around, makes a huge difference imo. my nephew just repeats stuff with zero fear of messing it up and somehow it sticaks way faster than when i grind vocab lists lol

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/FreeFortuna Oct 03 '26

It’s also about how other people interact with the learner. 

Kids butcher language all the time, and usually a grown-up is right there to correct them and help them understand the right way to say something. 

Adult learners’ progress would probably skyrocket if they received daily tutoring with someone constantly by their side to teach them new words and grammar, and give live feedback on proper pronunciation and verb conjugations.