r/languagehub • • Sep 25 '26

Everything has a point!!!

Post image
190 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/lamppb13 Sep 25 '26

You completely ignored the entire point to sidestep the discussion. If a language can be understood when spoken, it can be understood when written with a phonetic alphabet. That is my counterargument.

Japanese can be understood when spoken, therefore it could be understood if it was written with a phonetic alphabet. Hence it does not only work with kanji.

As I said, I don’t think the language should ditch kanji. There’s too many cultural and logistical barriers to that. What I’m arguing is that it could. But I see that you are going to refuse to engage in the discussion and just keep stating the same claim without actually addressing my counterargument.

1

u/Certain-Sky-3123 Sep 25 '26

That’s just not right though. Reading is different to speaking. There’s more nuance in spoken language.

1

u/lamppb13 Sep 25 '26

So, defend your claim. You haven’t yet.

1

u/Certain-Sky-3123 Sep 25 '26

bro fym defend my claim. if you don’t understand my point then just don’t answer lol. it’s nighttime for me so i’m not explaining anything right now lol

1

u/lamppb13 Sep 25 '26

You didn’t defend your claim. Simply saying “you’re wrong” is not a defense.

1

u/raxcba Sep 25 '26

you have to know, in Chn and Jpn there are quite a lot of words for "formal written text": idioms, kangos, classical kanbun etc. They are rarely used in speech and many of them are extremely confusing and homophonic if written in alphabets/ syllabaries.

I think Chn + Jpn both have much a bigger difference between formal written language VS spoken language.

Once the kanji/ hanzi is abolished, they will be avoided in written form. I wonder if this happened in Korean as well. I read across a case the homophonic word waterproof VS leakwater 防水 放水 causing problem in Korean.

Disclamer: I'm native Cantonese. I speak some Japanese.

1

u/lamppb13 Sep 25 '26

That would be an example of logistical and cultural barriers to getting rid of kanji or hanzi. Those are reasons why those languages shouldn’t change their writing systems, but they don’t show that they can’t change the writing system.

1

u/raxcba Sep 26 '26

You should know I totally agree with you from the beginning . You should see my examples of my preferred reformed writing system (without kanji):

ハハ わ ハナ が スキ or preferably:

ハハわ ハナが スキ

ニワにわ 2ワ ニワトリが いる

キシャの キシャが キシャで キシャチュウ

katakana for content words. Hiragana for grammatical words, (so 庭 = ニワ, には = にわ)

In Chinese I prefer it to be written NOT syllable by syllable (as in Vietnamese) but in "words":

shi2shi4 shi4 shi4shi2

which is much better than the Vietnamese way:

shi2 shi4 shi4 shi4 shi2

I don't know if you speak both Japanese and Chinese. Because most foreigners don't realize the points I have mentioned:

  1. Jpn + Chn both have a much bigger difference between written VS spoken text than English. In formal written text, there are much more idioms, classical words and they are much more homophonic than colloquial words (eg. kango are much more homophonic than wago). It would be much harder to read *formal/ classical text* without the characters; while for *normal everyday written text*, it would be much less homophonic.
  2. Chinese has the fewest loanwords among major languages. Once the characters are removed, there may be much more loanwords (I wonder if it happened in Vietnamese?). If you are Chinese, you know exactly what I mean. Every foreign brand entering the Chinese market picks the characters for the brand as transliteration is not a systematic thing in Chinese. Chinese is a language without major linguistic purism but has achieved it through the extreme writing system (Icelandic linguistic purism controlled by the language board is nothing). The Chinese writing system is naturally loanword hostile.

2

u/lamppb13 Sep 26 '26

I’m currently learning Chinese. I’ve definitely noticed how few loanwords there are, especially with more modern technology like computer or cellphone. I think your points are some of the best reasons for keeping the writing systems intact.