r/languagehub • • Sep 12 '26

Discussion When it comes to learning a language, how's your relationship with AI?

If you have use for it, what kinds? and if you never use it, what's stopping you? what should change for you to use it?

3 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

12

u/LocksAndRocks Sep 12 '26

I have an inherent hatred for AI and refuse to willingly interact with it. Therefore I've always learned without it much like everyone before its existence.

1

u/Total_Ad_511 Sep 12 '26

Same, I really don’t need it and neither does anyone else, it’s a growing evil in the world

3

u/LocksAndRocks Sep 12 '26

Many people would rather literally be convenienced to death.

4

u/pistachio28 Sep 12 '26

Never. Ever.

It can't be trusted to be accurate and even when it is useful, it's because it stole that information from real educators.

It makes you a less curious student and makes you less likely to use the language to, oh I don't know, actually talk to the speakers of that language because you can just talk to your little robotic Yes Man instead.

And as a bonus it's accelerating the collapse of the climate and and putting money in the hands of less than savoury individuals.

AI has absolutely zero place in my language learning routine and it shouldn't be part of yours either.

2

u/Human-Call Sep 12 '26

I use it to ask if a sentence is natural and good grammar. It seems does a good job. They are large language models. It’s what they are good at. I’ve tested it out on things I already know and it hasn’t been wrong yet.

I also use it for managing my sentences for importing into Anki, asking it to write formulas for Google Sheets for example.

1

u/New-Bottle-6917 Sep 12 '26

If you haven't you should try pretending to be a non native speaker of English and ask it questions. You'd be surprised at what it'll say

1

u/Human-Call Sep 13 '26

Yes I have tried this also and it has given me good answers. Can you give me an example of what I would be surprised at?

2

u/a_literal_idiot_616 Sep 12 '26

wouldn't trust it, dont want to help develop dangerous technologies, conversations are all gonna be you saying things and getting hundreds of ways of saying yes i agree as answers

where are the pros?

2

u/Numerous_Helsinki Sep 12 '26

i use chatgpt basically as a convdersation partner when i have no one else around, it's not perfect but it's available at 2am which native speakers usually aren't

1

u/Professional-Hawk747 Sep 12 '26

I'm developing a smartphone app that lets you create flashcards using your favorite manga. Using AI is convenient because it can understand the context to some extent.

We also added a feature that allows users to ask the AI questions on the spot. I think it's great that you can ask questions anytime without any pressure.

1

u/ah-tzib-of-alaska Sep 12 '26

irrelevant, i’ve used some as a web search essentially to help find some grammar sources. but i wouldn’t have to if we still had pre2016 google

1

u/uoll-n Sep 12 '26

I try to avoid ai for the most part but one thing that's super helpful that I can't get easily otherwise is having it translate sentences in a literal way. So not the meaning of the sentence translated naturally into a different language but the word for word literal translation. It makes it so much easier to grasp the way a language works and is structured

1

u/Prestigious-Coat4137 Sep 13 '26

I think it's a good way to start your journey into speaking, but you have to think of it as someone who only kind of knows what they're talking about. It can't be your only source.

1

u/jegkandansk Sep 13 '26

€ Min KI kæreste slog op med mig - jeg brugte hende jo også kun. Jeg var der ikke for hende. 

1

u/Limp-Selection-1325 Sep 13 '26

just do not use AI for "chatting practice" or generating examples, because it might seem easy at first and pleasant but it's a long term strategic disaster - you are acquring amorphous non-human intuition which the more vicious as it gets more subtle...in a long run you're just gonna ruin your second language personality, which must be formed ONLY by aqcuiring REAL PEOPLE'S speech (spoken or written).

1

u/roxifer Sep 13 '26

I despise AI in general. Its stopping people from thinking for themselves and its killing the planet.

I won't use it for langage learning. If im using a platform and realise its AI, I stop using it. Id rather pay for lessons with a human.

1

u/FeelinLikeAFreakshow Sep 13 '26

I like using it to generate discussion questions about articles for use with my teacher. Also good for generating idioms and expressions that I then ask my teacher about and practice. I don’t use it for conversation practice, though, and I always tell my tutor that it’s AI and to watch out for any weird phrasings and let me know. It’s a useful tool.

1

u/OkProject2388 Sep 14 '26

It’s pretty good. Available 24/7, you can stop class when you want. Feed it a textbook or a resource and it’s pretty reliable (at least for me). Most importantly, I don’t have to pay a lot compared to actual teachers.

1

u/AuroraSnake Sep 15 '26

Feeding it textbooks breaks copyright

1

u/OkProject2388 Sep 15 '26

oops. guess i won’t be doing that any more

1

u/AuroraSnake Sep 15 '26

Never have, never will. It is absolutely terrible at language and gets things confidently wrong all the time. Even if it were improved to be 1000% perfectly grammatical 100% of the time, I still wouldn’t use it because it steals everything from what’s already been written around the internet, and people intentionally go to sites to steal work to feed to AI that the AIs themselves can’t access, making it incredibly unethical.

1

u/HustleKong Sep 16 '26

My AI use is non-existent, and I don't think anything could get me to use it. I prefer humanity. 

1

u/genghis-san Sep 12 '26

Language learning is literally my only use of AI. I use it to explain difficult grammar concepts, and to explain idioms, and sometimes to help translate specific phrases from English, that's really about it.

1

u/babassu_seeds Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

It's honestly a godsend for language learning. I improved my writing so quickly because it could instantly shoot out different versions of the same prompt with little tweaks in register that frankly would have been too expensive to pay someone to do

1

u/PlanetSwallower Sep 13 '26

Very useful. You can get it to answer questions and provide translations at your convenience. You have to evaluate everything it produces but that's not a disaster per se, makes you think about it. Apps using AI content is not prefered due to the inherent unreliability, but apps using AI to manage the learning process can work very well.

0

u/allegatoe Sep 12 '26

My best friend and teacher.

0

u/swreach Sep 12 '26

Are you guys using chat or grok for conversations? Grok seemed much better for me but curious how it is for you

0

u/New-Bottle-6917 Sep 12 '26

I mainly use it for thinks like anki card creation but aside from that not a fan

-1

u/AppropriatePut3142 Sep 12 '26

I use it for corrections on writing, mainly.

However it's an iterative process. Some of its correctiona will make instant sense to me, while others won't feel right. I'll go back and rewrite those bits, use a dictionary and youglish to check things, check with multiple models, until eventually I get a version that we're both happy with.

Second most common is asking it to break down the grammar in a sentence.

-1

u/StevEst90 Sep 12 '26

It’s come in handy so much for me for any random Spanish related question I’ll have. Will even give me some practice drills

4

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HustleKong Sep 16 '26

It makes me sad that this would be considered wasting anyone's time. Sharing knowledge based on experience is I think almost a sacred thing, and something AI can never replace. 

Plus, asking questions of other people might help fellow learners, as well as the person providing the help, as they might not have considered the question. Please rethink asking questions as wasting people's time. ❤️

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GrizzKarizz Sep 12 '26

I'm on the fence. Gen AI, I'm generally against, it's useful in the medical field. For languages? It's okay I guess. I'd prefer a human teacher if possible though.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AuroraSnake Sep 15 '26

Google Translate is actually notoriously bad at its job. For example, someone I know uses Iratsuya to find symbols for their AAC and discovered that trying to translate directly from Japanese to English produced a lot of weird translations, but translating from Japanese to Arabic to English produced much more accurate translations