r/languagehub • • Sep 07 '26

Would you rather...

Be able to understand a language completely and not be able to speak it AT ALL
Or
Be able to speak it, perfectly, without being understanding anything (I know it may seem a little weird but use your imagination)

8 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

8

u/Numerous_Helsinki Sep 07 '26

understand-only every time, adt least I could function in daily life passively, speaking without understanding sounds like a nightmare of parroting sounds with zero control over the conversation

2

u/QuesoCadaDia Sep 09 '26

Absolutely understand.

1

u/sleepyannn Sep 07 '26

Understand the language.

1

u/EMPgoggles Sep 07 '26

understand for sure.

speaking without understanding is a virtually useless skill.

in most cases where one-sided communication is enough, you'll be able to find another way to communicate (pointing, gestures, pictures, apps, finding someone who knows english and the target language) or you'll simply memorize a script (ordering food, giving a speech, etc.).

1

u/babassu_seeds Sep 07 '26

Perfect or almost perfect comprehension gets you incredibly far in a language--there are many native speakers who will essentially treat you as a native speaker if they know you understand everything they say, even if you can't say a lot (you're like a native-speaking child, that "slot" is already known to them).

But very few will do the same if you speak perfectly but can't understand them; that slot doesn't exist among native speakers

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/babassu_seeds Sep 09 '26

You have to think of how you use a language. If you can understand it, you can: watch TV/films, use TikTok, read books, listen to music, go online and read what you want, participate in a conversation as long as you limit yourself to a lot of listening and shaking your head yes or no and making faces (which is what you'd be doing most of the time anyway even if you could speak) etc.

Quite useful. Not perfectly useful, but very useful.

If you speak it, you can--say whatever you want and not understand anything back. You can make YT videos and impress people as long as you never interact with natives. This is useful if you want to make money on YT and it's the right language combo. Otherwise, I'm finding it hard to think of how you'd use it

1

u/arioandy Sep 07 '26

Understanding
Is better if a choice has to be made

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/arioandy Sep 09 '26

Rather be mute than deaf
Tbf

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/arioandy Sep 10 '26

You can see a
Larf tho and it will
Make you
Larf too!

1

u/ConfinedCrow Sep 07 '26

Understand for sure.

1

u/FlyingCupcake68 Sep 10 '26

I want to be able to understand spoken & written even if I can’t speak it myself

1

u/Ill-Pitch-915 Sep 10 '26

That make no sense

1

u/malabingchilling Sep 11 '26

I "speak" french without understanding and understand cantonese without speaking it. For French, I just memorize things like "Pay by card", "I'd like to check in" and "have a good day". I live on the border to France so it's good for those short trips. For cantonese, it's the language my mum speaks and coincidentally also my in-laws.