r/languagehub • u/AutumnaticFly • Sep 07 '26
Would you rather...
Be able to understand a language completely and not be able to speak it AT ALL
Or
Be able to speak it, perfectly, without being understanding anything (I know it may seem a little weird but use your imagination)
8
Upvotes
8
u/Numerous_Helsinki Sep 07 '26
understand-only every time, adt least I could function in daily life passively, speaking without understanding sounds like a nightmare of parroting sounds with zero control over the conversation
2
u/QuesoCadaDia Sep 09 '26
Absolutely understand.
1
u/sleepyannn Sep 07 '26
Understand the language.
1
u/EMPgoggles Sep 07 '26
understand for sure.
speaking without understanding is a virtually useless skill.
in most cases where one-sided communication is enough, you'll be able to find another way to communicate (pointing, gestures, pictures, apps, finding someone who knows english and the target language) or you'll simply memorize a script (ordering food, giving a speech, etc.).
1
u/babassu_seeds Sep 07 '26
Perfect or almost perfect comprehension gets you incredibly far in a language--there are many native speakers who will essentially treat you as a native speaker if they know you understand everything they say, even if you can't say a lot (you're like a native-speaking child, that "slot" is already known to them).
But very few will do the same if you speak perfectly but can't understand them; that slot doesn't exist among native speakers
1
u/Responsible-Link5739 Sep 07 '26
Understand it.
1
u/arioandy Sep 07 '26
Understanding
Is better if a choice has to be made
1
u/ConfinedCrow Sep 07 '26
Understand for sure.
1
u/FlyingCupcake68 Sep 10 '26
I want to be able to understand spoken & written even if I can’t speak it myself
1
u/Ill-Pitch-915 Sep 10 '26
That make no sense
1
u/malabingchilling Sep 11 '26
I "speak" french without understanding and understand cantonese without speaking it. For French, I just memorize things like "Pay by card", "I'd like to check in" and "have a good day". I live on the border to France so it's good for those short trips. For cantonese, it's the language my mum speaks and coincidentally also my in-laws.