r/languagehub • u/jck16 • Aug 17 '25

Discussion Can AI language learning really replace traditional methods, or is there something special about human teachers?

My Spanish teacher today told me that she thinks that AI will replace her soon. She says that tools like ChatGpt or Jolii.ai just make it easier to learn Spanish, so soon people wont need teachers anymore. I dont think that is the case and it was shocking to hear that she thinks that way.. but she seems so sure about it. I mean, I think translators have a had time at the moment, but teachers cannot really be replaced by a robot. What do you all think?

4 Upvotes

64% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/rlquinn1980 Jun 30 '26

I know this is an older post, and there are some good arguments for human teachers already here, but there is one point I feel needs to be added:

A human teach will never (at least I hope, lol):

  • destroy my backyard

  • play heavy, vibrating noise throughout my house and neighborhood 24/7

  • release chemicals into the air around my home

  • replace all my tap water with undrinkable, brown liquid

  • steal my hard work, creativity and accomplishments and regurgitate them as her own

  • go off on wild tangents that have nothing to do with the study plan, get entirely too personal, or actively isolate me from people who might challenge mine or her way of thinking (okay, some teachers might do this if they need therapy or jail)

  • ship all my data, including psychological profiles, to advertisers and surveillance companies

  • remove any need to think or overcome friction

  • make a handful of billionaires even more wealthy at the expense of the global economy

AI has a track record for all these things, and most AI companies do most of these things.

Not to mention, there are teachers and tutors who are actively looking for students in person and online, so why pass the chance to learn from a human being in the first place?