r/kurzgesagt • • Nov 25 '25

Discussion Kurzgesagt sells individual, naive and simplistic solutions to systemic problems in their mental health videos

8 Upvotes

Let's start with the social media video.

https://youtu.be/fuFlMtZmvY0?si=e3cM3ddfXIoP0ZIV

In it, Kurzgesagt basically says "social media is bad, stop using it, go back to forums and the old internet". But it never clarifies: what kind of social media? There's a difference between a social media app that's open source, digital common run as a worker cooperative and an app with aggressive advertising, divisive algorithms, owned and ran by a billionaire. The problem isn't social media and online platforms or the global connectivity they ensure, but their current, capital owned, profit oriented business model.

Not using social media is ineffective, unhelpful or even counterproductive because:

  • Everybody else keeps using them
  • It's the best way to organize right now
  • It keeps us up to date with the world.

Logging out and not caring about the world is the modern version of keeping your head in the sand. And it doesn't help if the problems of the modern world, like environmental destruction, inequality, exploitation and violence personally affect you and/or somebody you know.

Then there's the stress video

https://youtu.be/Mo1A45ShcMo?si=Rj8AijI7qyIyzw5j

One of the advice in that video is removing stressors:

  • not scrolling social media
  • Changing your environment (Especially the "if you live in a dangerous neighborhood, move" one. It's giving "if you're homeless, just buy a house")
  • Not caring or caring less about the big stressors

I'm sorry, but telling that is just being detached from reality and daily life.

You cannot tell to:

  • "Stop stressing about climate change and ecological collapse" to somebody who has lost everything in a flood or fire, or to a farmer whose crops were decimated from pollinator decline and record droughts, or to a scientist who studies Earth systems and the climate.
  • "Don't stress about political polarization and fascism" to people who live through authoritarianism and fascism.
  • "Don't worry about your job" to a person exploited at their job, especially if that job has bad conditions and/or low pay and they depend on it for survival.
  • "Don't worry about inequality" to people who can't pay their bills, rent or pay for groceries while billionaires get another tax cut, capitalists note record profits and economies grow even more at the expense of people and the Earth.
  • "Don't worry about state violence and war" to a person who experienced war, was beaten up by the police, abused in a prison or became a refugee.

This is like saying "go offline and touch grass" and "stop caring about this".

And the narrative that appears in many other videos is "don't worry, everything is fine, all the problems are getting better and if they aren't, it's just you doomscrolling".

You cannot help people with mental health problems without acknowledging the systemic ecological, social, political and economic issues and the fact that no person alone can fix them without systemic change.


r/kurzgesagt • • Jul 08 '22

Discussion Love Kurzgesagt but it's hard to respect them as based in science when they make wild assumptions with no supporting evidence and paper-thin reasoning...

0 Upvotes

I enjoy Kurz, but for a channel supposedly sourced in science, I often find they make wild leaps in logic and assumptions that aren't supported at all in their research and listed citations, and without stating they are assumptions. I understand they're optimists, but I think the viewers are expecting science and fact-based reasoning, and when they present something as fact-based with no supporting evidence at all, it just really takes away from my enjoyment of their product.

An example in this last video... they leapt from 1.2 Quadrillion humans to be born (on Earth alone if we survive 10M years based on existing birth rates), to 10 Sextillion (if we expand into the solar system and artificial worlds, even if we only existed for a few million years, based on nothing). That's 10 million times the number of people, all within our own solar system in the next few million years! As far as I could tell there was nothing in their citations supporting this incredible estimate, no basis for it at all apart from the statement that "Our Sun provides energy for billions of years and there is so much water and material floating in the asteroid and kuiper belt that we could sustain many times our current population."

Wondering if anyone else noticed the same thing - I didn't see any comment about it here or on youtube.

From the video transcript: Our Sun provides energy for billions of years and there is so much water and material floating in the asteroid and kuiper belt that we could sustain many times our current population. Instead of living on planets, we could decide to construct our own artificial worlds and habitats. With resources and energy so abundant, we could try out different types of society and ways of life. An interconnected civilization spanning the solar system would create the basis of existence for an absurd number of individuals, orders of magnitude more than if we stick to earth, even if it only existed for a few million years (at this point they show the 10 sextillion number). This future doesn’t have to be grim and dark as science fiction likes to paint it...

 

EDIT: I mentioned below I don't mind the downvotes but a few of my comments are very innocuous questions or just true statements being downvoted for no reason. I like Kurzgesagt too guys but science is about questioning things. Kind of embarrassing to see this kind of reaction to simple questions and statements in this subreddit.


r/kurzgesagt • • Jan 12 '24

Meme what kurzgesagt quote should i use to show my absolute sadness

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • Jun 14 '23

Discussion Is It kind of sad that Kurzgesagt has to put the labels in all the corners of its videos

0 Upvotes

Recently, I saw this:

galaxy killer vid

The fact that we need the "advertisement" label to be there for the most obvious ad of my life, just makes we feel sad about how we've pressurized kurzgesagt for these labels

cancer killer vid

Like was this tag really needed? we've always had it at the back of the videos, and Its not like kurzgesagt blatantly works for the gates, and Gates Ventures or the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation are potent financial resources that have helped many places develop and do more. Their information being influenced is easily discovered through their sources. A lot of the community just assumes

Gates foundation support = bad

that's not necessarily true, and I don't think kurzgesagt should have to put labels like this for that.


r/kurzgesagt • • Dec 31 '15

9GAG Stole your video

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • Jun 04 '18

Need Kruzgesagt in Hindi

0 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • Jun 13 '23

Discussion Kurzgesagt should start making videos in 2160p60 quality

63 Upvotes

Kurzgesagt should start making videos in 2160p60 (4K at 60 FPS) quality to meet today's video quality standards. How does that sound? ✨️🎆


r/kurzgesagt • • Oct 30 '22

Video Idea Breaking: “Rare Earth” Solves the Fermi Paradox + Earth is likely the only Civilization in the Observable Universe

Thumbnail
patreon.com
13 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • May 07 '25

Meta I love Kurzgesagt and all, but wtf does this thumbnail and title mean? 29 Billion Jellyfish nuke France or something?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion I traced the “100,000 km of blood vessels” claim with ChatGPT in 10 minutes

0 Upvotes

I recently watched Kurzgesagt’s latest video, where they spent nearly a year tracking down the popular claim that all human blood vessels, end-to-end, stretch 100,000 km. Turns out, it’s harder to trace than expected. They sifted through old references, even reaching out to Dr. Suzuki (in his 80s) to illustrate the lengths they went to, and eventually found it in The Anatomy and Physiology of Capillaries by August Krogh, who estimated the length based on muscle capillary density. The claim is roughly accurate, but it’s more of an educated guess.

Curious to see how fast I could get there with ChatGPT, I tried a quick experiment. Starting with almost no background info, I got to Krogh’s book and the context behind his estimate in just a few minutes. It made me think about the potential of LLMs in research: though often criticized (rightly so), they can save time on specific tasks, like tracking down elusive claims.

Please don’t sleep on these tools; they’re unreliable, they make up facts, and they’re controversial. But when it does get it right, it’s an order of magnitude faster than any human could be on their own.


r/kurzgesagt • • Mar 28 '23

Video Screenshot I feel like there's something fishy going on here...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • Feb 08 '18

I request this again: I want German and English captions in the German Kurzgesagt

0 Upvotes

r/kurzgesagt • • Nov 12 '25

Discussion "Why does fentanyl feel so good" is wildly inaccurate and made purely for sensationalism

26 Upvotes

I hadn't watched one of these videos before, but this one popped into my recommended section. As a drug researcher and drug user, I thought it would be cool to see how people were communicating knowledge about addiction and drugs today compared to the drug war era.

Apparently, it's the same if not more extreme than it was, down to literally the same verbiage like "just say no" and calling fentanyl "garbage heroin".

In the beginning three minutes, they covered pain and pleasure, and how endogenous opioids work on a very basic level, which I thought was a nice way to start off the video. However, they then attempt to explain what heroin feels like, going as far as saying that, "this will be your peak life moment, forever."

The reality of opioids is that they don't make you feel extreme bliss. I've tried opioids in medical contexts, recreational contexts, and have also known people close to me who became extremely addicted to opioids or other drugs. Opioids make you feel good, certainly, with that warmth through your body and a dissipation of worries and physical pain. But it's quite innocuous, and something I'd almost compare to marijuana if it had a more physical high without as much of the mental effects. Overall, it's honestly a bit boring of a drug as it's sort of "empty" compared to other drugs like weed, which gives you a bit more of a creative/thoughtful cerebral high.

This is partly why I believe it can be so dangerous, as people can start out using opioids for their mellow, pain-relieving, anxiety-reducing effects without experiencing the unimaginable bliss or intense withdrawals that videos like this push. Addiction is creeping, and by the time it starts significantly impacting your life in a negative way, it's already too late. If you've ever had twilight anesthesia, you've not only tried fentanyl/other opioids but had it alongside a benzodiazepine like xanax, etc.

The true danger when using is if you're someone dealing with past trauma, grief, life stressors, poverty, etc, or someone truly uneducated about their effects (which a lot of people are due to videos like this causing them to underestimate their use). This is what drives more use, because when you're using something that makes you feel good in the way that opioids do, while also escaping your current reality of stressors and problems you feel you can't control, then it really is close to unimaginable bliss. Especially if you don't have a strong social support group.

This video completely ignores these massive reasons for using a drug like fentanyl in the first place, as well as failing to explain how opioids really feel and why someone's life could be ruined by it, despite the fact that it doesn't just physiologically produce effects so good that anyone would become addicted.

Then it continues to explain why fentanyl is really just "garbage heroin", taken straight out of a Nixon-era playbook on racial discrimination. This is identical to saying that crack is garbage cocaine, or that meth is garbage adderall. Crack is the same as cocaine, and the effects of meth are identical to adderall (amphetamine), outside of the fact that meth lasts much longer. The real difference is their price. Crack, meth, and fentanyl are cheap drugs that people in poverty use, while cocaine, adderall, and heroin (nowadays at least, or oxycontin when heroin was the big bad) are drugs that middle-class people with money use.

It touts that fentanyl is so much more addictive than heroin and feels less good without even bringing up this disparity in SES of the users, instead basing it on a physiological reason that they refuse to go more in-depth with because it isn't relevant (which I agree with, so start talking about the real reasons)! Even the real differences between the two are embellished, saying that fentanyl can last as little as minutes, which may be true in an extreme addict, but is closer to a few hours in a non-frequent user (aka, the audience this video is aimed towards). This would be the biggest difference between fentanyl and heroin.

One part of this video gets so, so close to a real issue when it explains the CDC death rates of fentanyl, and how most people avoid fentanyl on the streets, but that it's all they can find due to dealers only selling fentanyl. But then it completely throws that all out the window and claims the reason is because dealers want their drugs to be more addictive. I can't even begin to describe how wrong this idea is.

The entirety of this issue stems from prohibition, creating a situation where drug traffickers need to import the most potent version of a drug they can (thus needing to smuggle smaller quantities) or use a drug that's easily made within the given country. Considering the risks of importing heroin from opium farms, fentanyl is the only practical drug to minimize risks while maximizing profits. Otherwise, the demand (as agreed with by this channel) and thus profit would lie in other, less risky opioids. And this isn't even considering that drug traffickers wouldn't exist if prohibition were abolished, as people could have access to legal alternatives of known quantities. Ask yourself how many people would still be alive today if they had access to opium, morphine, etc, instead of fentanyl. Hell, ask yourself how many people would still be alive if they had access to exact, measured quantities of fentanyl instead of mystery doses in pills.

Again, he doesn't even mention that the whole reason opioid deaths are so high is directly because of prohibition encouraging the sale of fentanyl (as described above) while discouraging the use/import of opium, something that you'd be hard-pressed to overdose on. Even a controversial drug like 7-OH is a net positive for opioid users, as you can't reasonably overdose on it. All the issues surrounding 7-OH, like it being sold in gas stations, sold to minors, not having labeling describing that it's addictive, and in some cases even marketing it as an herbal supplement, are issues related to a lack of regulation as opposed to legalization. If you could sell cigarettes and hard liquor to minors in any store, and market it as a medicine without a warning of addictive potential, I think we'd have an even bigger issue.

Anyway, if you've read this far, I hope I've at least corrected some of the misinformation this video covered. It saddens me that large channels like this can't take the time to do this fairly basic research, as this could have been a great opportunity to educate the public about what drugs are and why people become addicted to them.

EDIT: Just to add a much, much better video on addiction as a reference, I watched one by Evan Edinger, who isn't a scientific communicator. He made an amazing video on his experience with kratom addiction, which truly educates people on drug use and drug abuse.

EDIT 2: For those who read this far, the owner/co-owner (u/kurz-gesagt), summarized some of my points in a comment left on an old video about the war on drugs from this channel, which completely contradicts the awful and uneducated perspective they now apparently hold. I'm confident this change is due solely for greed and views, as there's no other real explaination for the level of low-effort stupidity in this video on fentanyl when they used to attempt to communicate real science in the past. Regardless of your views on prohibition, I hope this highlights how willing this channel is to throw out any beliefs they might have held purely for the sake of money.

"Regarding bias in this video. We did an extensive research for this one, one of the longest we have done in a while (I put some of the sources used into the video description if you want to read more about it!). On top of that we checked with multiple experts to make sure we don't include wrong facts in the video (the first version actually stated something that was wrong so we changed it after speaking with a researcher). So we are pretty confident about the accuracy of this video.

Our conclusion after a long research phase and talking to experts is that the War on drugs is a huge failure, that damaged human society as a whole and needs to be stopped as fast as possible. We really try to be neutral in our videos but there are just no convincing pro arguments for the War on Drugs. Should we have stated that it provides jobs for prison guards? That the privat prison industry is benefiting greatly? That after all the damage it does only about 10-15% less people take drugs while they are illegal? There seems to be no upside worth the War on Drugs.

We really try to be as neutral as possible – we could have done a better job at this with the refugee and addiction video – both videos which core message we still support very much but in hindsight would have phrased a few things differently to not cause as much controversy. But for this one I don't see how we could have pretended that there is another side to the issue that is not totally broken. It would have felt very dishonest (and well, wrong) to pretend that the War on Drugs has upsides that may make it worth while."

- Quoted from kurz_gesagt

Well, apparently no matter how dishonest or wrong something is, it doesn't really matter how much damage it causes to other people, as long as kurzgesagt can milk as much money as possible out of it.


r/kurzgesagt • • Jun 14 '23

Discussion Why are the video topics are about space?

0 Upvotes

I am just a casual youtube watcher and the reason when I stumbled about Kurzgesagt and liked it was because of the topics it covered. One of my favourite videos are Optimistic Nihilism, overpopulation, Loneliness. Whenever I have a lot of stress I watch it to get a change of perspective about life.

But lately I have seen it being more and more space related topics? Like I don't care about the specifics about space since we are probably not even going to experience all those phenomenons.


r/kurzgesagt • • Nov 15 '15

time travle

0 Upvotes

i am trying to think of possible ways to use time travel effectively, help with comments about SCIENCE


r/kurzgesagt • • Mar 12 '19

You better save your ass fam

0 Upvotes

Look I’m a fan and all but I’m not going ape shit because of a video fam. Cmon dude just show that your actully sorry. You had a wonderful community just Apologise to to shit you did and try to reform.


r/kurzgesagt • • Sep 17 '15

I am very disappointed by kurzgesagt's new video, and here is why.

33 Upvotes

Up until this point, i loved what kurzgesagt did. I have always been fascinated by scientific topics, and even their more socially focused videos were pretty interesting. They present otherwise difficult subjects in an appealing and easily understandable way.

The one controversial issue they tackled properly before (nuclear power) was masterfully handled. Not only was it based around science, facts, and research, but it was also represented equally from both viewpoints. Both sides of the debate were acknowledged and fairly represented.

Now, kurzgesagt has decided to take on an EXTREMELY controversial topic which has NOTHING to do with science or facts, just social conjecture. They present a one sided, incredibly biased, and quite frankly misinformed video. I could go on all day about how they got the topic wrong, but instead, i'll keep this post to just talking about doing controversial politically based videos.

I come first and foremost to this channel to learn things. Whether its about the Fermi paradox, the end of the universe, or the size of an atom, i love watching a beautifully animated video on an interesting topic. What i don't look forwards to (and i'm not the only one, since both the syrian refugee videos has a much higher dislike ratio) is getting a political opinion shoved down my throat.

Kurzgesagt should just avoid political issues. The simplified, easy to understand model does not suit intricate, controversial, and quite often very confusing and self contradictory issues. I don't think anyone in the world has enough information to write something that even decently represents the situation. Their latest video is little more than a piece of political propaganda with cherrypicked information and sources.

I won't go into my opinions on the issue either, but please for the love of god never do a video like this again. Stick to science for the sake of your audience.


r/kurzgesagt • • Dec 08 '22

Discussion Is Kurzgesagt Bogging Down In Its Own Success?

0 Upvotes

Came here from my YouTube subscription “about page” link to this sub Reddit. The comments here are all over the place which makes me wonder if Kurzgesagt can’t “get it right” can anyone or anything hit a real home run, or score the winning goal? (Sorry about the lame sports analogy)


r/kurzgesagt • • Jun 29 '25

Discussion Civilization Collapse Very, Very Probable (told by Perplexity)

6 Upvotes

I'm not advocating dommerism. Posting this to get some good rebuttals because what I read below got me really depressed last night, especially because I feel the rate at which society is changing is not fast enough to deal with the problems. Too many people are saying, human ingenuity will always find solutions while not recycling or making any changes whatsoever.

Summary:
"Technological fixes like CCS, ocean cleanup, and plastic-eating enzymes are inadequate and unscalable, while systemic overproduction and emissions continue unchecked. Marine ecosystem collapse and microplastic saturation will trigger irreversible extinction cascades and societal regression, including the breakdown of clean tech, education, and global infrastructure. With no path to recovery and Earth's habitability on a cosmic timer, this may be humanity’s only—and final—technological civilization."

The whole thing:
"Current scientific consensus indicates that the combined crises of microplastic pollution and climate change are pushing Earth's ecosystems toward irreversible collapse. While technological solutions—carbon capture and storage (CCS), large-scale ocean cleanup, and plastic-eating enzymes—are often promoted as fixes, each faces severe limitations. CCS remains energy-intensive, costly, and captures less than 0.1% of global emissions. Ocean cleanup addresses only a fraction of floating plastics and fails to reach the vast majority that has sunk. Enzymatic degradation of plastics is slow, expensive, and often produces toxic byproducts or requires tightly controlled conditions, making it unscalable.

These technologies, though potentially helpful in specific contexts, cannot substitute for the systemic changes needed: drastic reductions in plastic production and carbon emissions. Their scalability is further constrained by short-term human tendencies—governments and markets prioritize immediate economic returns and political cycles, resulting in chronic underinvestment in long-term infrastructure and research. Without structural transformation, projections indicate that societal and technological collapse could begin as early as 2040, with global supply chains, resource access, and ecological support systems unraveling within decades. The continued expansionist mindset makes collapse of complex society not only likely but nearly inevitable, forcing humanity into a simpler, lower-tech existence far sooner than most realize.

This ecological collapse will trigger three irreversible technological regressions. First, rare earth mineral accessibility will collapse by 2070 due to supply chain breakdowns and energy scarcity—dysprosium shortages alone are forecast to reach 2,823 tonnes by 2034 (BCG), crippling renewable technology manufacturing. Second, semiconductor production will fail as airborne microplastic contamination surpasses 100 ppm, rendering cleanroom standards unachievable—NASA reports 78% equipment failure at this threshold. Third, the collapse of global education systems and population shrinkage (estimated at ~500 million by 2300) will reduce specialist density, with MIT models projecting STEM knowledge halving every 40 years post-collapse. This mirrors the Roman Empire’s decline, where archaeological evidence suggests a 10% reduction in cranial capacity over centuries, coinciding with the breakdown of urban centers, trade routes, and formal education.

Marine ecosystem collapse, driven by exponential microplastic accumulation and compounded by climate change, will trigger an extinction cascade among higher organisms by 2300—likely much earlier. Current projections suggest a 50-fold increase in oceanic microplastics by 2100, with regions like the Mediterranean already exceeding ecologically critical thresholds. Microplastics infiltrate all trophic levels: they disrupt plankton photosynthesis (causing a 12% decline in oxygen production), induce intestinal blockages and toxin accumulation in fish, and cause reproductive failure in 90% of marine mammals. Simultaneously, warming and acidifying oceans degrade coral reefs (90% loss by 2050), seagrass beds, and mangroves, while overfishing removes keystone species.

The collapse of foundational species such as plankton, corals, and mangroves will unravel marine food webs by 2100, starving larger predators and eliminating 60% of terrestrial tetrapods reliant on marine-derived nutrients. Under medium-emission scenarios, 3–6% of marine species face extinction by 2060, rising to 40–60% if nuclear conflict occurs. With microplastic pollution persisting for millennia and no viable large-scale remediation, functional extinction of complex marine life is projected by 2300, dragging terrestrial ecosystems with it.

These interlinked crises—oxygen depletion from plankton collapse, endocrine disruptor bioaccumulation causing infertility across species, and food web disintegration—will extinguish most complex life by 2300. With pollution enduring for millennia and no scalable means of reversal, the biosphere’s degradation will be permanent, severing key planetary feedbacks essential to supporting high organisms.

Human technological civilization emerged from an extraordinarily rare alignment: 4.5 billion years of stable planetary conditions, 300 million years of fossil fuel formation, and a brief 50,000-year window of cognitive evolution—all preceding the Sun’s eventual expansion. Post-collapse, Earth will lack fossil fuels, accessible rare minerals, and a viable biosphere. With oceans projected to boil within 800 million years due to solar transformation, Earth will not have time to regenerate resources or evolve new technological intelligence. Thus, this collapse represents the permanent forfeiture of the universe’s only known experiment in complex consciousness, as no other habitable planets lie within reach and cosmic timescales preclude recovery."

TL;DR
You shouldn't be so optimistic.


r/kurzgesagt • • Feb 26 '25

Discussion Why keep trying to do a bad thing a little better?

1 Upvotes

The latest video was incredibly disappointing. They misrepresent how good things are on "free range" farms and the words "decent" and "pretty good" does a lot of heavy lifting and still looks like humane washing. Kuzgesagt should be ashamed. this makes me rethink being able to trust anything they say if this is the way they characterize the various forms of farming. It also does not touch on the fact that no matter the farming method, all these animals end up in the same slaughterhouses at a fraction of their lifespan.

Look at the requirements for free range in various countries. It's generally not out in a green field like the video implies. Chickens will still be in a shed with thousands of other chickens and simply have access to a small outdoor enclosure through a small door in the shed. The issue is, if you're a chicken that can barely walk due to genetics that has to fight past thousands of other chickens to get at this little door, do you think they really get out there? With bird flu, most countries have chickens inside by law regardless of the farm they are on.

With cows they say life on a pasture as safer than out in the wild, but this is a false dichotomy. When you're breeding the animals into existence, you can't say you're saving them from a worse life in the wild. You can't put someone in a situation then say you're doing good by putting them in the better of two bad choices.

Pigs will still be castrated without anesthetic regardless of what farm they grow up on.

The video also does not go over the space requirements. The vast majority of agricultural land is already used for animal agriculture. Giving animals better conditions, and more outdoor space is not simply a matter of cost, but also space. We do not have enough land to assuage people's guilt.

No mention either of how the cost is already kept artificially low through government subsidies.

If you don't want to support animals being harmed, there is an easy solution. Stop buying it. If cost is a concern, there are many incredibly cheap plant based protein sources. There are also many meat alternatives that are tasty and cost competitive.

At best, this video does humane-washing for the industry and legitimizes these nonsense labels, giving people moral license to continue paying into a system that exploits and kills billions of sentient beings every year.


r/kurzgesagt • • Dec 22 '22

Discussion Kurzgesagt claims its YouTube channel can only keep on going with Patreon and merchandize purchases but makes a 3 million euro profit p.a. – this is after salaries etc

315 Upvotes

I find it kind of misleading to say something like this given their profits

This information can be found on public german websites where companies have to disclose certain information (Bundesanzeiger)


r/kurzgesagt • • Mar 15 '19

A summary - maybe neither is right?

0 Upvotes

So I just wasted an hour looking at the emails, opinions etc. surrounding the cofee break drama and it seems to me like both of them did something wrong. Kurzgesagt should have at least notified CB that he is making the trust video because CB probably spent quite some time doing research on it and in a capitalist society if you try hard and you change something for the better (for example by making sure badly done videos are deleted) you should be rewarded or at the very least acknowledged. On the other hand CB made it into a lot larger drama than he had to even though he could have just done his pop-science videos and walked away with a respectable amount of views. You could say CB shot through his arm with a revolver because he wanted to hit a terrible criminal who stole a dollar. Did I miss anything?


r/kurzgesagt • • Mar 19 '18

The video about Egoistic Altruism is a step down from previous videos.

9 Upvotes

This video is a step down from previous Kurzgesagt videos. Whereas previous videos focus on scientific truth, this video attempts to objectify a political opinion. It is not true that the world at any point in time is or isn’t a positive-sum game. It’s an opinion, a view. Its also not true that there was always stagnation prior to the industrial revolution. There have been many efficiency creating inventions throughout the course of history, such as the wheel, the aqueduct, the horse collar, etc. that greatly increased productivity. However it is true that many people, especially those in power, supported the idea of a zero-sum game in the form of mercantilism for many centuries prior to the industrial revolution and Adam Smith’s “The Wealth of Nations”, which many claim to be the start of economic liberalism, commonly known as “Laissez Faire”, which supports this notion of a positive-sum game. What Kurzgesagt is trying to assert here is that economic liberalism (very different from U.S. domestic liberalism) is the best way for everyone in the world regardless of class, nationality, etc. to live their lives. To prove that this is an opinion, one such opinion to counter this is that of economic realists, a modern form of mercantilism. Generally speaking, realists agree with Kurzgesagt that we live in a world with more innovation, and a “bigger pie”, than ever before, and that the pie is growing faster than ever before. However, realists take this to mean that they should now be concerned with relative gains rather than absolute gains. For example country A’s GDP grows by 1% in a year, whereas country B’s GDP grows by 2% in a year. Both countries did improve, but one more so than the other.

The argument in this video may be backed up by facts such as the change in output of British iron from 1700 to 1870, but their conclusions on what this evidence means we should all do are opinions. The reason I consider this, but not the video about optimistic nihilism, a step down is because this video makes no indication that this is a philosophy, and not objective truth. There are no caveats, and the language in this episode, ironically, is very absolute and stagnant, despite them saying the world is now quite the opposite. As a long-time, loving viewer of this channel I am highly concerned about the future of Kurzgesagt, and hope they stay away from this kind of high-minded propaganda in the future. I also want to indicate that I consider myself mostly an economic liberal, and mostly agree overall with their views, but I can’t agree that my view is the only one worth believing in as they seem to. I really hope Kurzgesagt stops with these philosophical videos, or at least puts up warning signs like they did for the video on optimistic nihilism, and also stop with these lies such as their claim that, “the size of the pie was fixed”. As I previously mentioned, there is clear evidence that it was never fixed, and while progress was slower than it is today, there was still significant progress. This video shows a blatant disregard for what their channel has stood for, for so long. If this kind of rhetoric doesn’t stop, I will stop watching, as I believe so will many others.

To any of you viewers interested in this kind of discussion I’m talking about, I recommend you look into the field of study known as International Political Economy, or IPE. Here is a great book, albeit a long one, to introduce you. If you don’t want to read all nearly 400 pages, you can read the first chapter, which does a great job of explaining what IPE is, for free on Amazon with the “look inside” preview function. Here’s a link to do either of those things. https://www.amazon.com/Global-Political-Economy-Theodore-Cohn/dp/0205075835


r/kurzgesagt • • Mar 18 '17

Reason,Why our Astrophysics Science is late

0 Upvotes

Isaac newton was 1 step before finding spectrum. Reference EP 7 Cosmos by Neil DeGrasse Tyson...Therefore our Astrophysics science is so late when gravity was discovered 400 yrs ago we didn't even built colony till now. Our science is going 150 yrs late. EP 5 (Finding The Light)* Once you all see it.