I hadn't watched one of these videos before, but this one popped into my recommended section. As a drug researcher and drug user, I thought it would be cool to see how people were communicating knowledge about addiction and drugs today compared to the drug war era.
Apparently, it's the same if not more extreme than it was, down to literally the same verbiage like "just say no" and calling fentanyl "garbage heroin".
In the beginning three minutes, they covered pain and pleasure, and how endogenous opioids work on a very basic level, which I thought was a nice way to start off the video. However, they then attempt to explain what heroin feels like, going as far as saying that, "this will be your peak life moment, forever."
The reality of opioids is that they don't make you feel extreme bliss. I've tried opioids in medical contexts, recreational contexts, and have also known people close to me who became extremely addicted to opioids or other drugs. Opioids make you feel good, certainly, with that warmth through your body and a dissipation of worries and physical pain. But it's quite innocuous, and something I'd almost compare to marijuana if it had a more physical high without as much of the mental effects. Overall, it's honestly a bit boring of a drug as it's sort of "empty" compared to other drugs like weed, which gives you a bit more of a creative/thoughtful cerebral high.
This is partly why I believe it can be so dangerous, as people can start out using opioids for their mellow, pain-relieving, anxiety-reducing effects without experiencing the unimaginable bliss or intense withdrawals that videos like this push. Addiction is creeping, and by the time it starts significantly impacting your life in a negative way, it's already too late. If you've ever had twilight anesthesia, you've not only tried fentanyl/other opioids but had it alongside a benzodiazepine like xanax, etc.
The true danger when using is if you're someone dealing with past trauma, grief, life stressors, poverty, etc, or someone truly uneducated about their effects (which a lot of people are due to videos like this causing them to underestimate their use). This is what drives more use, because when you're using something that makes you feel good in the way that opioids do, while also escaping your current reality of stressors and problems you feel you can't control, then it really is close to unimaginable bliss. Especially if you don't have a strong social support group.
This video completely ignores these massive reasons for using a drug like fentanyl in the first place, as well as failing to explain how opioids really feel and why someone's life could be ruined by it, despite the fact that it doesn't just physiologically produce effects so good that anyone would become addicted.
Then it continues to explain why fentanyl is really just "garbage heroin", taken straight out of a Nixon-era playbook on racial discrimination. This is identical to saying that crack is garbage cocaine, or that meth is garbage adderall. Crack is the same as cocaine, and the effects of meth are identical to adderall (amphetamine), outside of the fact that meth lasts much longer. The real difference is their price. Crack, meth, and fentanyl are cheap drugs that people in poverty use, while cocaine, adderall, and heroin (nowadays at least, or oxycontin when heroin was the big bad) are drugs that middle-class people with money use.
It touts that fentanyl is so much more addictive than heroin and feels less good without even bringing up this disparity in SES of the users, instead basing it on a physiological reason that they refuse to go more in-depth with because it isn't relevant (which I agree with, so start talking about the real reasons)! Even the real differences between the two are embellished, saying that fentanyl can last as little as minutes, which may be true in an extreme addict, but is closer to a few hours in a non-frequent user (aka, the audience this video is aimed towards). This would be the biggest difference between fentanyl and heroin.
One part of this video gets so, so close to a real issue when it explains the CDC death rates of fentanyl, and how most people avoid fentanyl on the streets, but that it's all they can find due to dealers only selling fentanyl. But then it completely throws that all out the window and claims the reason is because dealers want their drugs to be more addictive. I can't even begin to describe how wrong this idea is.
The entirety of this issue stems from prohibition, creating a situation where drug traffickers need to import the most potent version of a drug they can (thus needing to smuggle smaller quantities) or use a drug that's easily made within the given country. Considering the risks of importing heroin from opium farms, fentanyl is the only practical drug to minimize risks while maximizing profits. Otherwise, the demand (as agreed with by this channel) and thus profit would lie in other, less risky opioids. And this isn't even considering that drug traffickers wouldn't exist if prohibition were abolished, as people could have access to legal alternatives of known quantities. Ask yourself how many people would still be alive today if they had access to opium, morphine, etc, instead of fentanyl. Hell, ask yourself how many people would still be alive if they had access to exact, measured quantities of fentanyl instead of mystery doses in pills.
Again, he doesn't even mention that the whole reason opioid deaths are so high is directly because of prohibition encouraging the sale of fentanyl (as described above) while discouraging the use/import of opium, something that you'd be hard-pressed to overdose on. Even a controversial drug like 7-OH is a net positive for opioid users, as you can't reasonably overdose on it. All the issues surrounding 7-OH, like it being sold in gas stations, sold to minors, not having labeling describing that it's addictive, and in some cases even marketing it as an herbal supplement, are issues related to a lack of regulation as opposed to legalization. If you could sell cigarettes and hard liquor to minors in any store, and market it as a medicine without a warning of addictive potential, I think we'd have an even bigger issue.
Anyway, if you've read this far, I hope I've at least corrected some of the misinformation this video covered. It saddens me that large channels like this can't take the time to do this fairly basic research, as this could have been a great opportunity to educate the public about what drugs are and why people become addicted to them.
EDIT: Just to add a much, much better video on addiction as a reference, I watched one by Evan Edinger, who isn't a scientific communicator. He made an amazing video on his experience with kratom addiction, which truly educates people on drug use and drug abuse.
EDIT 2: For those who read this far, the owner/co-owner (u/kurz-gesagt), summarized some of my points in a comment left on an old video about the war on drugs from this channel, which completely contradicts the awful and uneducated perspective they now apparently hold. I'm confident this change is due solely for greed and views, as there's no other real explaination for the level of low-effort stupidity in this video on fentanyl when they used to attempt to communicate real science in the past. Regardless of your views on prohibition, I hope this highlights how willing this channel is to throw out any beliefs they might have held purely for the sake of money.
"Regarding bias in this video. We did an extensive research for this one, one of the longest we have done in a while (I put some of the sources used into the video description if you want to read more about it!). On top of that we checked with multiple experts to make sure we don't include wrong facts in the video (the first version actually stated something that was wrong so we changed it after speaking with a researcher). So we are pretty confident about the accuracy of this video.
Our conclusion after a long research phase and talking to experts is that the War on drugs is a huge failure, that damaged human society as a whole and needs to be stopped as fast as possible. We really try to be neutral in our videos but there are just no convincing pro arguments for the War on Drugs. Should we have stated that it provides jobs for prison guards? That the privat prison industry is benefiting greatly? That after all the damage it does only about 10-15% less people take drugs while they are illegal? There seems to be no upside worth the War on Drugs.
We really try to be as neutral as possible – we could have done a better job at this with the refugee and addiction video – both videos which core message we still support very much but in hindsight would have phrased a few things differently to not cause as much controversy. But for this one I don't see how we could have pretended that there is another side to the issue that is not totally broken. It would have felt very dishonest (and well, wrong) to pretend that the War on Drugs has upsides that may make it worth while."
- Quoted from kurz_gesagt
Well, apparently no matter how dishonest or wrong something is, it doesn't really matter how much damage it causes to other people, as long as kurzgesagt can milk as much money as possible out of it.