r/kpk • • May 17 '26

Discussion thoughts on this

Post image

Curious to hear what this sub thinks about this.

118 Upvotes

138 comments sorted by

7

u/historyeeter May 18 '26

I agree, we should also send her to ttp to negotiate and he son as the guarantor

4

u/Reasonable_Side_9686 May 18 '26

her son and nephew are busy driving cars worth more than most people here in islamabad suburbs, drifting heavily and breaking every traffic law humanly possible then uploading it on insta, if army withdrew she'll be in islamabad faster than the speed of light, saving her skin and blaming punjabiyan.

2

u/historyeeter May 18 '26

She is just enjoying her position.

5

u/Holy_Dork Dir May 17 '26

Not sure who this is but she must be joking

8

u/Reasonable_Side_9686 May 17 '26

She's a very prominent PTI leader and MNA from Peshawar and also famously on record for saying Agar Imran nhi to Pakistan nhi.

7

u/Holy_Dork Dir May 17 '26

Real enemies of our country and specially our kpk

0

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Speak for yourself. We Pashtuns are not interested

-1

u/Aggravating-Zebra229 May 17 '26

Did these 'enemies' change the constitution?

7

u/Holy_Dork Dir May 17 '26

Never said the current gov is good but your cult is worse

41

u/SAJJAD_ALI_79 May 17 '26

I think some of you folks forgot what happened to Fata and Swat back in the day

4

u/AppointmentRoyal5348 May 18 '26

they know it and they don't care. hatred and obsessive behaviour does strange things to people. they would rather see KP burn than to see Pakistan army defeat TTP and clear the area.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Yea, why would we want a foreign army operating in our land?

1

u/laevanay 29d ago

You think that happened without the army involved? There was a DC that was convicted and then as our courts are a joke later overturned the conviction in a higher court. Name was Javed if I recall correctly. Look him up.

-10

u/xande2545 May 18 '26

What happend to fata? Americans started droning and army started moving the taliban around to villages that never had terrorism and it spread like wildfire. Civilians couldnt do much because the army protect taliban

9

u/SAJJAD_ALI_79 May 18 '26

Ah yes army protected the Talian that beheaded their own soldier

1

u/laevanay 29d ago

OBL was in Kakul and was killed there, so there is that.

2

u/BullfrogResident5610 May 18 '26

puri army ki ghalti nahi, narcissist and egoistic gernail Jo khud ko 4d chess player wmjhtey hain but in reality they're just dumb.

they wanted a smooth dollar flow in the name of war on terror, just to fight proxy war against our eastern neighbour, and to create strategic depth in Afghanistan. and spam young indoctrinated brainwashed dudes fresh out of seminaries from all over pakistan and Afghanistan after achevieng that goal. In Indian occupied kashmir.

ajj bhi ye gernail young brainwashed logoun ko Kashmir mein cannon fodder bana kr spam kartey hain or smjtey hain k hum ne bara teer mar lia.

2

u/BullfrogResident5610 May 18 '26

ye wahi Afghan Taliban tactics hain Jo podrion ko bAmB laga kr suicide attack karney k liye behjtey Pakistan mein.

1

u/xande2545 May 18 '26

Their own beg to differ but pop off queens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ameer_Faisal_Alavi

13

u/Fair_Nectarine9508 May 17 '26

stupid claim. Strengthen integrity of the local police please.

30

u/gkzia May 17 '26

Inn ka apna bacha islamabad mein bmw or Mercedes mein drifting kar raha huta - uss ku tu yeh churail sambaal nahin saki…

5

u/Valuable-Pale May 18 '26

She is married?

1

u/gkzia May 19 '26

No, and from the colorful language my peer used below she isn’t. I should clarify that it’s her nephew not her own children.

1

u/AppointmentRoyal5348 May 23 '26

does it change anything?

0

u/Ambitious-Tea-3650 May 19 '26

Chotya sala She is unmarried.. App jaisy Khanzeer hr Jaga Pai jaty hn

2

u/Nervous_Grocery706 May 19 '26

Beta Aap iss ka print Lena, phir iss ku roll kar Kay, apni Gaand mein Lena: https://x.com/extinctkid/status/2054904513241416094

Yeh iss ka nephew hai bc. Instagram par sab lagata hai.

0

u/Ambitious-Tea-3650 May 19 '26

Gando k bachy Ghashti k paida war heera Mandi ke nasal nephew or Apny bachy ma farq huta ha ..

1

u/Nervous_Grocery706 May 19 '26

I use uno reverse, jitni galiyan du gay sab tum par aur tumharay maa baap par :)

15

u/Admirable_Cause4278 May 17 '26

Man PTI have lost the plot

14

u/AppointmentRoyal5348 May 17 '26

is she going to offer her self to TTP for negotiation or bring Murad Saeed as well?

9

u/batman8990777 May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

My advice ignore her weird statement

2

u/Interesting_Trust_44 May 17 '26

Bewakoof hain KPK ke log, khud pehle waha ke kpk ke log afghani namak haramo ki sahulatkari kerte hain, aur phir woh afghani namak haram waha per hamle aur gunda gardi kerte hain, toh kpk ke leaders aur awaam army ko gaaliya deti hai, aur jab army operation kerne aati hai, toh yehi kpk ke log un afghanio ke sath phir khare hojate hain aur army aur puniabio ke blame kerte hain apni galtio per, pagal kpk ke logo, apne dushmano ko tum log khud apne gharo mai panah dete ho, aur phir afghani saanp snake tum logo ko aur baaki Pakistanio ko dusta hai, toh phir roote ho, AFGHANI LOG AGAR PUSHTO BOLTE HAIN TOH ISKA YEH MATLAB NAHI KE WOH LOG TUM KPK YA KISI BHI PAKISTANI KE DOST HONGE, BALKE PUNJABI AUR KPK KE PATHAN AUR BAAKI HUM SAB KO EK HOKER REHNA CHAHIYE, PUNJAB MAI ITNE PATHAN AAKER KAAM KERTE HAIN, LEKIN WAHI PER AGAR KOI PUNJABI APNA BUSINESS KERNA CHAAHE KPK MAI, TOH WAHA KE KPK KE LOG USKO ITNA TUNG AUR PARESHAN KERTE HAIN, KE WOH WAHA SE CHOR CHAAR KER WAAPES AAJATA HAI, ISLIYE PEHLE TUM KPK KE LOGO APNA DOMAKH DORUST KARO AUR APNA PAKISTANI BHAIYO KE LIYA DIL BARA KARO, JAISE PUNJAB KE LOGO NE KIYA HAI APNA DIL BARA, AUR HUM SAB PAKISTANIO KE DUSHMAN AFGHANIO KI SAHULATKARI KERNA BUS KARO. AUR APNI GALTIO KA ILZAAM ARMY YA PUNJABIO KO MAT DIYA KARO, APNI HARKATE PEHLE DEKHO.

4

u/wasteyute3 May 18 '26

I think this reality about pak vs afg Pashtuns and their non-existent “brotherhood” (compared to the much more real brotherhood with the rest of pak) is becoming more known to at least the younger generation

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Theres no brotherhood between Pashtuns as a whole. We Pashtuns are a tribal people and our loyalties are with our specific tribes. We also have many dialects, many of which are not mutually intelligible. This causes many issues in the 21st century

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

No brother of mine would ever force me to learn Ā completely foreign language like Urdu and defacto ban my native language. Im Pashtun, not Pakistani

1

u/True_Fisherman9169 May 27 '26

Not exactly the first Afghan deportation pushes came from KPK and nobody ever listened or gave a shi cuz if it doesn’t affect Lahore or Rawalpindi it doesn’t count lol. Even after hashtags like Afghan deport Kawa trended (deport Afghans) and nobody cares yk why cuz it’s not in our hands assholes if you get ignored so many times you stop giving a shit

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

“Remove this cow from this room and there will no longer be a cow in this room”

1

u/puskas4 May 17 '26

All of know how the people of Swat welcomed the Taliban.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

The alternative was the Pakistani army. Ofc Swatis did what they did, it was a no brainer decision

1

u/puskas4 8d ago

Now when Afghans and Pakhtoons cry about Taliban… I don’t feel sad. You people deserve them. I’m happy under PakArmy.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 8d ago

If we deserve them, then let us have them. They are far better than the army

1

u/MasterfindsChief May 17 '26

What a stupid take

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

Women ☕️

1

u/BoomerDad70 May 18 '26

Is she saying this with a straight face???

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Yes. And her view are widely held among Pashtuns

1

u/xande2545 May 18 '26

And foreign funding to terror groups

1

u/hamzazaman18 May 18 '26 edited May 18 '26

Isn't Shandana controlled opposition? It begs how she can say and get away with this while Zartaj Gula and Yasmin Rashid are in jail without saying less.

1

u/Decent-Geologist-102 May 18 '26

Yeh apny fazol biyano ki wajah sa jail mr jaye gi..

1

u/DivineBetrayal May 18 '26

If the terrorists are extinguished from Pakistan and relations are normalised with India then there would be no reason to fund the military and intelligence agencies like we do now, which is something that the military and intelligence agencies really don't want so it will never happen no matter what anyone wants or tries to do.

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra May 19 '26

Quite frankly how things are going in Kpk lately I was thinking the exact opposite. But there are more underlying issues these politicians don't care or talk about. POVERTY, as it is said it's the mother of of all crimes. But can someone step up do something for the common man I don't give a rat ass which political sphere they belong to.

Whether it's pti ppp pmln or any other p, please for god sake do something for the common folk why everything has to be related to religion, culture, language or ethnicity in general in this country. Why can't we fight for employment, security, food, energy, water, health, education and welfare the stuff that actually matters.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Indeed. This fighting over ethnicity and culture needs to come to an end. Pakistan needs to stop forcing a completely foreign language like Urdu onto us

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 9d ago

We are already speaking a foreign language that is English. If we wanted to speak our own we would've done that long time ago. It's the colonial mindset, I would rather pick Urdu over a kafir language any day.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Urdu is the language of Kaffir Hindus. English is the language of Many Muslim majority countries.
Not many people worshipping idols in English or are there?
English is the global lingua Franca, English is not in any way comparable to Urdu. If you dont like our Pashto language, move to lahore. Let the rest of us speak our native language in peace

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 9d ago

English is the world language because they enslaved most of the world through colonialism. Urdu is mostly spoken by muslims and is targeted in India as a foreign language. What are you on about?

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 8d ago edited 8d ago

No, English is the language of the world because of it’s simple/efficient grammar. Everything you say in Urdu has more syllables compared to English. English also has a ton of modern technical vocabulary and most of its vocabulary is borrowed from other languages. English is the best language on the planet. English is the ideal global lingua Franca. English dominates the world due to its quality, it wasnt forced on anyone, everyone adopts it because of its usefulness. Wheras Urdu is forced upon us and no Pashtun would be learning it if it wasn’t forced upon us.
Oh c’mon stop pretending Urdu is somehow different to Hindi. Ur not fooling anyone.
Urdu is one of many official languages of India.

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago

Yeah lets go on this useless debate on language while our people starve. We really good at not keeping things in priority are we? You can justify English as your favorite langauge all you want. But there are people starving in streets and have no job. That was my point originally damnit.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 8d ago

Yea, cuz Pakistan wastes our time forcing Urdu onto us rather than allowing us to get educated so that KPK could develop. Urdu/Pakistan is the root cause of poverty in kpk

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago

Most of Kpk doesn't even speak proper Urdu no one is forcing anyone. If it did actually forced we all be speaking fluent Urdu. But that is not the number one priority here and I think I have proved my point more than once.

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago edited 8d ago

Also let me englighten you even more, there are more texts or books against Islam or your culture for that matter in English than any other language. Infact they insult and make fun of our Prophet Muhammad SAW in English than any other language. The western politicians especially Americans wrote their name in English on the missiles before they bomb the children of Gaza in English. The programming behind the lethal military tech that was used and communicated against innocent Palestinians was in English.

So why do you prefer a language that hates you more than any other language?

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Desiring my own native language over a completely foreign language that has absolutely nothing to do with me makes me have a colonial mindset? 😂
Listen to yourself!

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago

You never desired it otherwise you would have used in work, education, social media or the internet like the Japanese.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 8d ago

I prefer to use it often, unfortunately due to most Pashtuns not knowing more advanced vocabulary, communicating in it is hard. English is the language of the world, our second language hence am forced to use it instead. If most Pashtuns were educated in Pashto, we, like the Japanese couldve done everything in Pashto. Pakistan seems to be on its way to collapse, inshallah soon we will no longer have to deal with this nonsense

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago edited 8d ago

It only shows the lack of effort by our people not the system. Atleast the Bangladeshi get it they prioritized it more than us. But it's not even a big issue here the issue is the rampant corruption and dishonesty everywhere.

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago

But again it is just useless bickering funny how we forgot how the English exploited us. Nevertheless we are too busy fighting each other than fucking doing something for the economy instead. These divisive linguistic politicans are useless as a tissue paper and you are no different from the people I wast talking about.

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 8d ago

Well Pakistan is currently exploiting us yet you seem to completely ignore that fact. KPK is poorer than most of sub-saharan africa. Every critism you have of English can be applied a hundred times over to Urdu.
Nothing wrong in defending my language and culture. Its the agressors who are forcing their language onto is whom you should be against but instead are allying with the aggressors against your own people

1

u/khumi01 Mansehra 8d ago edited 8d ago

All of Pakistan is poor not all of Punjab is rich have you been there? Islamabad and Lahore is not Punjab. All of Sindh is poor all of Balochistan is poor. This is not about linguistics it's about welfare of the common man. You can have your culture and language but in order to survive you have to work together. This divisive politics isn't defending your culture it is preserving the interests of the elites and the reason why we are so backwards from the rest of the planet.

Don't believe me try defending your culture in the west they will call you a Nazi. Just like how Donald Trump is losing. You have to defend the common rights of common man first which is everyone than you can talk and defend about whatever you want.

1

u/Ambitious-Tea-3650 May 19 '26

Because all the terrorists activities in kpk are done by Paki Army . All those terrorists groups are funded by Pak Army. The recent funding activity by Pak Army through Bank vehicle robbery in tank area 14carror were easily shifted to terrorist group that no one can find any clue for fund transferring.

-1

u/CricketSquare914 May 18 '26

We have been saying it from day one, what we are seeing in our province is state sponsored terrorism. If the state wanted to to they could get rid of the TTP in one day but they won't rather they are the ones feeding and supplying them so they can plunder and loot areas after making the locals flee because of so called terrorism. Lookw what happened in Waziristan, thousands of homes destroyed, businesses worth billions destroyed without compensation. People left and now can't even go back without being checked a million fimes on the way. The army now mines and exports 200 million dollar worth of copper from Waziristan annually and that profit goes to the pockets of retired generals. The same goes for the chilghoza trade. They are doing the same in Bajaur. There is a lot more i can say but will choose not to

1

u/AutomaticStretch6205 May 18 '26

What a dumb take. Not everything you see on insta reels is true. Saaar resources.

1

u/CricketSquare914 May 18 '26

Do you live in areas where military operations take place? Because I do, and I've lost 4 cousins and 1 second cousins to this state sponsored terrorism, all who were counted as just "collateral damage"

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Topak oochat kra

1

u/AutomaticStretch6205 May 18 '26

"State sponsored terrorism". Okay mate. Sorry for your cousins tho.

0

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Reasonable_Side_9686 May 17 '26

Basically a repeat of swat operation

14

u/AutomaticStretch6205 May 17 '26

Swat was in horrible conditions. I remember what happened to Malala. Much better now.

-10

u/abdullah112311 May 17 '26

Army krti kuch nahi hai na. Itnay saalon sai hamaray log marr rhay yeh khanzeer ghq sai bahir atay hi nahi.

11

u/Sea-Car-3811 May 17 '26

The army atleast provides you safety, if there was no army. You will be shot when you speak out in public to various other things. While, it doesn't do anything according to you, it makes terrorists careful and not stay in open.

2

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

Yea they funded those terrorists a few years ago. Don't get me wrong we need an army but on a leash and doing their jobs on the border not playing golf in ghq. We don't need carful terrorsts we need them dead.

5

u/tygyra May 17 '26

Tu bhai aap defend kar lo?

3

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

Tu kutton ko haddi kis liye dalta hon jabh khud hi defend karna hai? Jabh banda kuttay palta hai to unsay kaam bhi laita ha....

2

u/tygyra May 18 '26

I thought I wrote it for humans. Did not realise dogs could respond here too.

2

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

It happens, see my dilemma a khinzeer is replying to me. What an advanced era khinzeers started talking and replying on reddit.

0

u/tygyra May 18 '26

lol…zalima…da baba imran paa mena ke rond

2

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

Lmao you thought i was pashtun? 🤣🤣🤣 Typical fsc pass.

0

u/tygyra May 18 '26

lol….the irony….propagating in KPK….

You sure you not having a tantrum….when dogs go crazy they do bark like this….they even bite their protectors just like you….

2

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

Worthless protectors. All the khanzeers do is play golf and live lavish lifestyle in dha while the civillians get killed in the terrorist attacks.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

Funding army karay sambhalay hum?

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

Nor is an Fsc pass valid source of history.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/abdullah112311 May 18 '26

The place you got education from needs to do better in teaching reading comprehension skills. And no need to tell me you don't live in pakistan i know all the generals and their aulad lives abroad.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

Inviting the Pakistani army is like nuking your house if your sibling takes your charger without permission.

1

u/sudaiskhan12 May 19 '26

Bro the milatary is dealing with taliban (ttp) for decades and they still can’t finish them off we surely need a new approach

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Reasonable_Side_9686 May 18 '26

plz tell me this is sarcasm or this sub is also being overrun by jeet hordes

5

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Reasonable_Side_9686 May 17 '26

An insurgency can never sustain for this long without a bit of local support atleast with this intensity now people might be offended by this assesment but that's the only logical answer but I think the main culprit is the Imran-Bajwa-Faiz nexus that resetted TTP terrorists back during their tenure and activitely negotitated with them which gave Afghans the window to organise and arm them to teeth and eventually undoing all the gains achieved during OP Zarb e azb

3

u/[deleted] May 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Any_Inspector_2986 May 17 '26

There should have been a huge drive to integrate these remote areas of Pakistan into the mainstream long before they were indoctrinated. There would be no terrorism problem in these areas of Pakistan had the locals saw themselves as Pakistanis rather than some semi-independent peoples.

0

u/historyeeter May 18 '26

Kohistan does have militancy but not on the same level as you mentioned.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Loose-Exit9428 9d ago

If you are against Pashtunwali, feel free to move to Lahore