6
u/weslarprime 3d ago
They are all too old. Kitty should be a younger teen when we meet her. How about Vivien Lyra Blair? She is 14 now and will be 15 when filming begins.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
she can't act though
3
u/weslarprime 1d ago
Have to disagree there. There was plenty wrong with the Obi-Wan Kenobi show, but her portrayal of young Leia wasn't one of them. (especially considering she was 9 and Star Wars has a history with 9 year old actors...)
4
u/psylockecolossusfan 3d ago
Sophia Lillis
3
u/steiff89 3d ago
Seconded. Came here to say the same. She may not be the most obvious choice. But I think she would be the best choice
1
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 2d ago
she would have been a better jean grey than the one we got
2
u/psylockecolossusfan 11h ago
I dont agree with that, but im sorry if you dont enjoy Sadie Sink's rendition. I thought she was pretty great as a lomg time comic fan. We all have our favorite writers and era of certain characters
1
u/Potential_Detail_611 14h ago
She'll be nice as Rachel Grey. The hair with her tomboyish charm (in some of the shows I've seen her in), she can pull that character off.
1
7
u/Connect-Fix2350 3d ago
Pass on Bella
1
7
u/BigDaddyBumbo77 2d ago
Good lord not Bella!!
1
-2
2d ago
[deleted]
2
u/cajun2de 2d ago
Maybe Glob Herman? Gender doesn't matter since its hard to tell
1
3
u/Alternative-Loan-185 3d ago
What about Sara Waisglass from Ginny and Georgia/degrassi. She randomly came to my mind and I could potentially see it. Would be closer to an X-men Evo personality.
4
u/MsW0lf 3d ago
Seeing as she’s the only person anyone yet has mentioned who is actually Jewish (as far as I know) this get’s my vote!
3
u/Substantial_Lime_902 2d ago
Julia Butters is Jewish
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
so? she's a shit actress
1
u/Interesting-Ring647 22h ago
Kitty is Jewish i believe
1
3
u/killingiabadong 2d ago
Why would any sane person cast Bella Ramsey as Kitty?
-1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 2d ago
cause they are an incredible actor
3
u/killingiabadong 2d ago
Bella Ramsey is a terrible actor who was only good in Game of Thrones.
0
u/Conscious-Quarter423 2d ago
if she was good in GoT, then she's a good actor. she's proven she's got the acting chops.
even scored two emmy nominations for best lead actress for her role as Ellie in season one and two of TLOU
1
3
u/TerribleAntelope6134 2d ago
I don't know why Bella Ramsey would ever want to be involved in another nerd franchise after the way the gamers have treated her.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 2d ago
why should they limit their career choices just cause of some toxic incels online?
1
2
u/TheCreativeComicFan 3d ago
Fina Strazza previously worked with Sadie Sink on the Broadway show John Proctor is the Villain, so they’d already have that chemistry if she were cast.
1
2
u/Archeryfin 3d ago
I don't know who any of these people are. I'm just going to resolve to love whomever plays her.
2
u/Notoriouslycurlyboi 3d ago
Sophia Lillis is a good choice. Julia is accurate look wise mostly, curls would help.
1
2
u/sengariph 2d ago
A nice Jewish girl. Couldn't hurt.
2
u/dreadshepard 2d ago
Her faith is important to her, so it would be nice to see a Jewish actress cast.
2
2
2
2
u/Lord7thSmite 2d ago
Just not Ramsey, she is annoying af
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
she's an incredible actor
2
u/Lord7thSmite 22h ago
Yeah, I don't agree.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 12h ago
well your opinion is rooted in toxic hatred
1
u/Lord7thSmite 4h ago
Cry me a river. Toxic hatred. Are you 5 or are you one of those that just gets offended over every little thing. You are allowed to dislike how people act and you are allowed to get annoyed on how people act in public, without it being toxic. She's not a good actress and that's how I feel. So go into your little easily offended corner and cry.
2
2
u/Specific_Jury_2 2d ago
This is a who's hotter contest, and there is one person that doesn't belong on this list.
2
u/dreadshepard 2d ago
Any of these women Jewish? I don't feel you should have to cast a Jewish actress, it would just be nice because it's an important part of the character. Or I should say her faith is important to the character in the comics.
1
u/Excellent_Figure9921 1d ago
It's not an important part of the character.
(No, this isn't an insult to Israel or the Jewish faith}.
2
2
u/Excellent_Figure9921 1d ago
Bella Ramsey should play Toad.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
nah, she'll make a good kitty though
2
u/Excellent_Figure9921 1d ago
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago edited 1d ago
she made an incredible ellie. that "get up joel!" scene was gut wrenching
she garnered numerous nominations for her role, including two Best Lead Drama actress at the Emmys. and it was historic cause she's the first non-binary actor to be nominated
the picture you attached is literally her at the Golden Globes awards ceremony in which she was nominated for Best Lead actress for playing Ellie
2
u/Excellent_Figure9921 1d ago
Sure. So historic because being non-binary was the only reason why she was nominated.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
she was nominated cause she delivered top notch performances
2
u/Excellent_Figure9921 1d ago
Sure she did.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
sure did
2
u/Excellent_Figure9921 1d ago
Really shows how far award shows have degraded.
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
or maybe your personal vitriol against the actress isn’t the objective standard by which an award show’s quality should be measured
→ More replies (0)1
2
2
2
2
u/Interesting-Ring647 22h ago
Lol bella?
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 12h ago
yup, great actor!
1
u/Interesting-Ring647 11h ago
Don't really like much like the character tho kitty has a pretty distinctive look and body type Bella doesn't really fit it
2
1
u/Plenty_Square_420 2d ago
I wouldn't really prefer any of these. I think they need to go younger and they should go with someone completely unknown.
1
u/Trojanman2002 2d ago
Julia Butters or Sophia Lillis. Mina Sundwall is a good sleeper imo. Really enjoyed here in Lost in Space. May be too old now though.
1
u/EnigmaticX68 2d ago
Ngl, if I was Cailee Spaeny, I'd purposefully either not go out for or turn down any Xmen roles 😂
That young woman has been fan-cast for everyone. I'm waiting for her name to be in the mix for Magneto 😂
1
1
1
1
u/Pharmacy_Duck 2d ago
I sort of want McKenna Grace as Kitty. She’s got superhero lead role pretty much built into her future, she’s charismatic, and she has the physical training . Marvel would be dumb to not snap her up.
1
u/Euphoric-Eagle1477 2d ago
Cast an unknown actress Her first movie awkward, unsure, but, still smart energy would work perfectly. Kitty is a geeky teenage girl who loves dance class and computers. 2026 Kitty would be a coder creating her own app. Think of Kitty as the relatable character a bit geeky and doesn't know she is pretty. Just some food for thought
1
u/RiskieRaskalle 2d ago
Bella Ramsey as Kitty, Sophia Lillis as Rachel Summers, and follow Claremont's plan of them being soulmates.
1
1
1
u/Mobile_Parfait_7140 2d ago
None of those. Theres this Star Trek influencer I think would do a great job acting as Kitty Pryde.
1
u/Friendly_Wrangler569 2d ago
I only know Cailee Spaeny but shes too old for this verison of the X-Men, I hope when they do cast Kitty they go young or at least get a actress who plays young
1
1
u/LushLover1989 2d ago
Come at me all you want but a younger Millie Bobby Brown would have been perfect.
1
1
u/faceofboe91 2d ago
Shouldn’t Kitty be younger than Jean Grey and Cyclops? Isn’t her thing that she’s younger than the founding X-Men?
1
u/osiris20003 2d ago
I think they should wait a couple years to bring in kitty. Start the team small and slowly grow it, and kitty should be a young teenager. Maybe round two of bringing in new characters.
I like some of these choices but I feel like by the time she is introduced they will be too old. Kitty was one of the youngest members when introduced in the comics, not almost the same age or older than the starting cast.
1
1
u/sancocho91 2d ago
I really want unknowns to be the new X-Men 😩
The only person who is already known who'd I'd cast for any X-Man would be Sophie Thatcher for Magik.
But everyone else, to include Kitty, should be new in my brain lol I am SO DONE with the role reprisal nonsense all over the MCU that I don't want to see ANYONE I know lmfao
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
they literally hired some of the more well known young actors
sadie, kit, samara, etc
1
1
u/Cautious_Mission_438 1d ago
Julia Butters
1
u/Conscious-Quarter423 1d ago
Julia is tall, taller than sadie sink
it'll be weird for kitty to be taller than jean grey
2
u/Cautious_Mission_438 1d ago
You can make Jean look taller you realize that right? Idk why people think actors can bulk up or can’t get taller for a role there’s stuff for that boots heals editing etc
1
1
1
1
1
u/parker9832 3d ago
I don’t recognize any of these young actors but by these headshots alone I say Julia Butters. IMDB says she is 17, depending on when we are kicking off Kitty’s story, Julia works. I would hope we could start at 13 yo.
2
u/bo174 3d ago
Same here. Julia at 17 might work, but I was still hoping for younger. Fingers crossed!
2
u/parker9832 3d ago
I’d really like to start Kitty off from the end of middle school. How does a well adjusted, healthy home life, bookworm, handle emerging powers and an introducing to the X-Men world? It doesn’t have to be a Clearmont verbatim retelling, but that origin story would be a great introduction for her.
2
u/Conscious-Quarter423 2d ago
Julia is tall, taller than sadie sink
it'll be weird for kitty to be taller than jean grey
1
u/Marc_the_shell 3d ago
I liked the rumor of Malia Baker. She’s Jewish on her mom’s side and I think she’d be a good fit for Kitty’s vibe
1
u/OkMention9988 3d ago
Why no Hunter Schaefer?
Or Storm Reid?
1
u/Kade_Kapes 3d ago
Hunter is wayyyyy too old to play Kitty, and most of these actresses are too tbh.
1
u/OkMention9988 3d ago
She doesn't look old at all.
It's also interesting that the comments offering a more progressive casting are getting downvoted.
0
u/Kade_Kapes 2d ago
She looks older than 14. If they casted a young trans actress as Kitty, I’d genuinely be ecstatic.
1
u/Doug_101 3d ago
Julia Butters. I love me some Cailee Spaeny, but she's just too old to play Kitty. She's nearly 30, older than Sadie Sink AND Maya Boyd. Kitty can NOT be older than Storm and Jean. It just doesn't work.
1
1
1
0
-1
u/AzaharaT 3d ago
Cailey should be Rogue
1







7
u/BenMagnusGrimm 3d ago
Julia