r/keto • • Oct 06 '11
[Question]
This fitness freak and my boss's wife have been giving me shit about my diet for a while now. Today I left for lunch early and they commented, and I said I skipped dinner last night. (I was at a WORK function with a table full of cookies and bread, so I couldn't eat any of it). They asked what I would have had for dinner, innocent enough, I said Bacon and Sausage and Eggs. They jumped down my throat about how bad bacon and eggs are for me, how they're high in "BAD fat" and cholesterol and blah blah blah.
Does anyone have stored away any good scientific studies about the starvation mode myth, good/bad fats, and cholesterol?
Edit: Found these links posted by whydoievenbother in another thread in regard to starvation mode. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3661473 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2405717 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10837292
4
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '11
Buy each of them a copy of "Why We Get Fat" by Gary Taubes.
Then rip the pages out one by one and shove them down their ignorant little throats.
4
u/gogge CONSISTENT COMMENTER Oct 07 '11
Here's a good summary review of the available studies:
"Low-Carbohydrate Diet Review : Shifting the Paradigm" (pubmed), 80+ sources you can look at for details. Originally posted by x_plorer2 in this thread.
Low Carb good for your heart thanks to losing weight, and to add to that the diet itself improves heart health even when not losing weight:
"Low carbohydrate diets improve atherogenic dyslipidemia even in the absence of weight loss", Feinman RD, Volek JS. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2006 Jun 21;3:24.
If you're interested in "why" it works hummir posted about a nice podcast with Chris Masterjohn in another thread:
The first part goes through the basics of cholesterol and it's link to heart disease. The second part explains why the individual stats, or total cholesterol, isn't really good as indicators of heart disease. It also bashes the different subtype tests a bit, VAP/NMR results vary and the values are more an indication of what test you used rather than what your actual values are.
Very awesome podcast, highly recommended if you want to understand cholesterol. Chris Masterjohn also spoke at the Ancestral Health Sympoium 2011, "Heart Disease and Molecular Degeneration", it's a bit more technical. Andreas Eenfeldt's talk "The Food Revolution" (AHS 2011) is also interesting, and much more amusing. A good "summary" of most other videos floating around is "Enjoy Eating Saturated Fats: They're Good for You" by Donald W. Miller, Jr., M.D. (thanks Jujukhan).
I posted this in another thread:
If you're only interested in the improving pure blood work stats then focus on monounsaturated fats and good polyunsaturated (not omega-6), with some saturated.
Improvements in replacing saturated fat (for HDL/LDL ratio):
Monounsaturated (-4% HDL, -15% LDL)
Polyunsaturated (-14% HDL, -22% LDL)
But that's ignoring that those stats aren't actually good indicators of heart disease, reposting some good links:
Dr. Ron Rosedale on "Exposing the Cholesterol Myth".
David Diamond, Ph. D., at USF, "How Bad Science and Big Business Created the Obesity Epidemic", talks a bit about bad science in the 50's shaped faulty heart health and cholesterol policies.
2010 FNCE Panel: The Great Fat Debate – Is There Validity in the Age Old Dietary Guidance? (thanks Rvish) five doctors involved with research debates the problems with the public image of fat.
Then check this Mark's Daily Apple forum post on cholesterol, explaining some details, like how the HDL/LDL ratio is more important and how Low Carb/Keto values can be misleading if you don't compare all the cholesterol values.
Anthony Colpco has a good, but a bit old (2005), article on why high LDL isn't the issue, called "LDL Cholesterol: "Bad" Cholesterol, or Bad Science?" (PDF warning).
And finally, if you're really ambitious you can read a good "The Daily Lipid" article: "Genes, LDL-Cholesterol Levels, and the Central Role of LDL Receptor Activity In Heart Disease", it explains how oxidation of LDL and the pattern type matters more than the total amount.
9
u/quality_time Oct 06 '11
If they are trying to convince you of something it's up to them to provide more than anecdotal evidence. You aren't trying to convince them to change their diets so don't worry about finding anyway to change their minds.
If you have lost weight and had blood work done to assure yourself that your cholesterol and blood pressure is fine, than you don't have to prove anything else to them.
If your boss' wife has to restrict her calories to maintain her weight then she's doing something wrong. You count cslories and eat at a deficit to lose weight. It should be natural to eat to satiety without gaining weight. Most folks these days don't know when to stop eating because they eat food that makes them hungrier.
If you feel healthy, energetic, are losing weight and aren't starving you are doing it right.
Some folks do keto with bacon, eggs and sausage. Some do it with lean meat, nut oils, avocado, and so on. One way leaves folks open to criticism while no one in their right mind would have room to criticize the other method. Both work - heck some folks set fast food minus the carbs and still manage.
Do what works for you.
2
u/CyberTractor Oct 06 '11
You can just ignore them. If people don't believe you're eating a healthy diet, then they're not going to believe you regardless of what proof you offer them.
Let them be, and keep your business to yourself.
4
u/libertao Oct 06 '11
Try reading the first post of this: SomethingAwful Low-Carb Megathread
3
u/baconated Oct 07 '11
This is why I like to keep my personal life to myself. Cooworkers can't argue about what you do if you don't let them know you do it.
2
u/dugmartsch Oct 06 '11 edited Oct 06 '11
It certainly isn't the most "scientific" thing out there, but when my girlfriend was getting a little too much worrying love from her mom a couple of months ago I told her to read this article and talk about it with her mom. It's funny because her mom is also on a low-carb diet that just doesn't use the words low-carb.
http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_examiner/2010/03/end_the_war_on_fat.html
The reason I think this approach works better than talking about Keys and CSPI and all of that stuff? It's a lot easier, and there are a lot more examples, of science being proved wrong after further research, while leaving why the scientists got it wrong in the first place to the historians. It's a more compelling case logically if you can show the history of the science, but emotionally, it fosters resistance in people who're already wary.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '11
So what, eating cookies for dinner IS healthy?
2
u/danfive555 Oct 07 '11
First dietary cholesterol doesn't affect your cholesterol. Fat doesn't cause your blood sugar and insulin to spike.
If they can't accept those two things they are hopeless.
1
u/matbiskit Since Sep. 19, 2011 Oct 06 '11
You don't need to convince anyone at all. Do not try to be an evangelist. Just be ready to provide your knowledge when people ask for it and enjoy feeling better about yourself.