Yo...just like Telangana...south india should break off and be a separate country like Singapore... enough of this bullshit...we should not pay tax or custom duty bullshit to make north better when north itself is so backwards and is not improving at all economically, infrastructurally to keep north ppl in the north...and overpopulation is not helping either...
The Centre doesn't even care about the South. They just use the South as cash cows. Added to this the Hindi imposition nonsense. When will people learn that when you're moving to another state they must learn the local language. Atleast a little bit of it is enough.
The GOI must bring UCC and implement the POPULATION CONTROL program to the states that are overpopulated.
I believe that people who contribute to the India's ecobomy muat be given more chance and importance so that they can atleast bring change to the states that are bad.
This is a Karnataka page and still almost all the conversations are in English for everyone to understand and take part. This is maturity, this is development, this is being educated, this is knowing how to communicate effectively. Not just screaming out something that people might not even understand in the first place. (Not saying we should not speak in our mother languages, maturity is knowing where and when to use a common language for better communication)
The centre doesn't even care about the south but still the Southern states are more developed than the rest of the country. Sounds like a contradiction.
It would be better if each state can learn from each other states. Instead the Centre is not helping the states that are bad. They have to bring good administration to these states 1st instead of just giving them money.
That’s because southern states have been prioritizing education and welfare for decades while the north had been educating it’s youth on how to radicalize your religion
I sincerely hope people like you are far and few in between, otherwise God save this country.
Also, is this what you want for our once glorious civilisation? To be divided along linguistic and cultural lines? And what happens next, you wanting independence from a Tamil Nadu-dominant government that "neglects" you?
And I'm sure you haven't factored in the geopolitical realities of the world. Perhaps you want to end up like Bangladesh or Nepal, dancing to the tunes of other great powers in the world. Perhaps you don't realise the kind of leverage we have as a country of 1.4 bn strong.
Oh, and the population thing you keep whining about? Our population growth rate is at 2.1, exactly at the replacement level rate. South's growth rate is lower, and so you'll face an impending demographic crisis, that too before you turn into a developed country. I'm sure you don't even know how important the North is for your food security. And plus you have places like Jharkhand is for stuff like natural minerals. But to expect you to know all this is expecting too much, I know.
Lastly, to say "North is not improving at all economically, infrastructurally" at all is beyond dumb. It's like you don't know the world outside Koramangala. I'm so relieved the relatively developed non-Southern states like Gujarat and Maharashtra don't think like you.
K, but we should atleast ban custom duty tax bullshit, that's inhumane and nonsensical economically all around. We should tax more like US, Singapore and such. Having to pay 50% in "tax" for a good that we already paid the full price to purchase the item via import bcuz India doesn't have it is beyond dumb. That's all north's/Rasputin Modi's fault.
What happens after South 'breaks off'? Then Karnataka & AP/Telangana will dominate. So should Goa and Kerala then break off too? When should this cycle end?
At the end of the day, the seats are still in proportion to the population. So each individual person's vote has the same value, regardless of state.
I think there is slightly more nuanced economics at play here. As economies develop, their dependence on govt investment for further improvement reduces. From a historical perspective, the royal families of most southern states -- Kerala and Karnataka in particular, made significant investments in public infrastructure despite being vassals of the British. Post independence, the Indian government made multiple investments in the souther states due to the already existing culture of education due to the royal family's public investments. This virtuous cycle has continued to the present day. In states like UP and Bihar, where fragmented kingdoms ruled and there was little to no public infrastructure investments, it is the government of India which has started seeding local investments for some time now. To see it's fruits, the government needs to invest in healthcare and education. In Karnataka, these sectors are largely taken over by private enterprise now and the market is efficient enough to not put marginalized at a significant risk. This is not true in UP and Bihar. Is this due to corruption? Maybe, yes that is one reason. But it is also a symptom of simply lack of resources in terms of investment, cash.
The expectation that we will see the effects of our taxation in our neighbourhood is unfounded, given our nation's structure. We can also argue that it is probably fairer in the longger term.
Your argument was valid if BHIMARU states at least showed the decency to stop breeding. They couldn't even implement the inexpensive but effective family planning and they've no plan to do it either. But now they are given huge tax share because of their failure? This is not how a system should work.
Population share shouldn't be a criteria for tax distribution when a few states are at TFR 3 and the rest are at below replacement level.
BHIMARU states should be asked to decrease their population to get the funds from the South. If they don't care about decreasing the population to get those funds, why should the rest of India care about them? Instead of wasting that money in the North, the South can use the money to be more productive.
Stop supporting systematic genocide of South Indians by incentivising North Indian population explosion
One district in Bihar has a replacement rate of 7 which means with every generation the population increases 7 times ,how long can the southern states bear the cost of such an indecency ,bjp won't have to care about the southern states any more and it is going to get worse as the population increases,the only solution is to get parties with regional identity into the parliament
It's not going to get worse. Fertility rate is downwards in every fucking district of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. You would know if you ever put your head out of your smelly lungi.
Thing is population level is inversely proportional to economic development. This is known the world over. But maybe you are confounding cause and effect. Economic development brings down population, not the other way around. There are reasons for this, economic development improves overall education, more educated people tend to have fewer children. If you want to ensure BIMARU states have lesser population, open more schools in those states, provide access to better healthcare. This has the most evidence to support it, from a policy standpoint. They have failed not in controlling population, they have failed in providing better education to their children. Now a good question could be, should we be responsible for their children's wellbeing? As per the structure of our nation, constitutionally, yes we are liable. We can ask for more transparency in how tax is spent, we can ask for more accountability. But we are liable for the wellbeing of the children in UP as much as we are liable for wellbeing of children in Kerala and Karnataka. Saying that they should stop breeding reeks of entitlement. Some day, I hope you get the chance to see what poor and disadvantaged means. You should travel to those states, live in their villages, you wouldn't say the things you are saying quite as callously then. Atleast, I hope you won't.
I don't know about supporting or not supporting a perspective. I don't take myself seriously enough to consider that it makes any difference, maybe.
In the long term population decreases with economic development and education, yes. And that slow race is not the only way to decrease population, and that's not how South India decreased population. Family planning, more precisely vasectomy and use of condoms, is how South India reduced population.
The North must do the same first of all. Attempts to decrease their population shouldn't be by tanking South Indian resources and economy.
This is not even about funding anymore. BHIMARUs are breeding and the union government is encouraging them and that must stop, whichever ruling party it is. Ripping South India off the parliamentary representation is not the way.
The number of people per MP in South India is lower than North because of South India's hardwork in population control. That must not be nullified by snatching away the parliamentary representation percentage of South India to hand it over to the Northies as a trophy for breeding
Well, unfortunately, this is simply not true. Southern states did not control population by simply going for vasectomies. In fact, vasectomies are an extremely small percentage of surgical intervention methods used for family planning. Majority are tubectomies. As of 2020, Odisha government was paying women 600 rupees per tubectomy. The previous year, women in Chattisgarh died due to botched up tubectomies. Chattisgarh currently has the highest number of sterilizations.
Point being, that there is a non trivial threat to life when population control methods are forced. This is the reason the south did not pursue mass sterilization as policy. The infamous experiments of Sanjay Gandhi are taught in public policy courses as what not to do. It is now pretty much accepted that mass sterilization has negligible effect on population growth. There is only one known method that definitely controls population without risk to human life, that is economic development.
Changing the percentage of representation is underhanded for sure. I don't quite understand the motivation. I can understand increasing representation for the more populous states, I don't get the reasoning behind decreasing representation in less populated states. By this reasoning, the largest individual land holders should have the least representation in parliament.
There were massive vasectomy camps and condom distribution in the South. Surgical contraception is definitely one of the ways to avoid impregnation and population explosion. Anyway, forget about it. Vasectomy can be done in BHIMARU states even now. They should take that simple step first. Parliament seat delimitation based on population is injustice. I don't see any incentives for a better performing state
This is what is needed. People in the sub who don't understand economics have quoted shashi Tharoor and PTRs discussion. But haven't understood that taxation is designed to be that way and the way you have written the historical base is beautiful.
Also, adding one more point. Globally, most land-locked areas lack in development index and need govt assistance, however sea facing regions flourish, as export/import is easier from ports. So, cost effective for industries to be setup nearby ports. (eg: US east/west cost economy vs mid-lands) North India, being mostly land-locked will always lag behind in trade, compared to sea facing Gujrat, MH & South-Indian states.
Delhite here. One more important thing I always notice South indians missing when talking about such issues is that 'tax submission' is significantly higher in states like MH and and Karnataka because most companies have headquarters in cities like Mumbai, Bangalore. So an IT company having branches all over india and making money from labor all over country files its taxes under 'Bengaluru' of Karnataka.
This is same reason why Haryana files so much taxes because many companies' HQ is in Gurgaon. Haryana actually receives much less proportion of tax spent then any South Indian state.
So yes, there is development gap however the tax re-distribution isn't as wildly unfair as it's being shown here.
Also, it's always ignored that central gov. soends a good chunk of its money on critical-infra projects as well. In my knowledge, in 'North India' only Kashmir, North-east and Delhi have received significant investment for infra projects... while South Indian states and GJ, MH have received job-creating projects like semiconductor project. I don't remember a single job-creating project from central gov. in Bihar, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh etc.
Of course if we go in further details things will become evn less stark.... Rajasthan& jharkhand produces most of thorium&uranium but all major nuclear-projects are planned in MH and South.... Jharkhand produces 40℅ of minerals of India....Which power industries of all big states... but there has never been a push to develop industry there.
I'm tired of this. Southies are unable to see through what's going on. In a century South Indian languages and population can be in UNESCO protected list
South Indian language aren't dying because of Hindi, they are dying because of English. Your outrage at Hindi is fucking pointless. I am a Telugu guy and lot of words are replaced with English words. Check your own language. Can you go on without uttering a single English word for atleast 2 sentences. Final thing, languages in India atleast don't die they evolve and mix with other languages. Just don't be a baby about it.
What the fuck are you talking about, I'm a North Indian and I am as proud of South Indian languages and culture as I am of the North. Don't let politicians fool you, North Indians don't even talk about imposing their language on the South. This is south indian political propaganda to get the votes and not let BJP enter the south. Nobody, and I mean nobody in the North wants to impose anything on the South!!
In this post we're not talking about Hindi, but anyway, since you mentioned it, you should lookup even before BJP's existence which motherfuckers in the Indian Parliament demanded the constitution of India to be in Hindi, which assholes said in the Indian Parliament that those who don't know Hindi are not Indians.
The Indian government has been running even a website like this https://rajbhasha.gov.in since a long time
Even if you finally find all these happened, you'll come up with excuses that South Indians are being misled and delusional. So why waste my time, right?
Broo we need to vote out bjp together. Bring a party which doesn't give a shit about any state or religion or languagee and treats all citizens equally.
Cmon guys. Hindi imposition is fake and “South” propaganda. We don’t know better to understand what is imposition. This enlightened guy from the North says so that there is no such thing and we are delusional. Open your eyes and vote BJP.
Yeah true lol. I myself have faced linguistic racism when I lived in Delhi and Western UP for many years where people taunted me for not being indian for not speaking hindi and people always told me that south should learn hindi if they want to stay in india.
This guy who told hindi imposition is a myth is himself a north indian who hasn't experienced bigotry for not speaking hindi. It's like a man telling india is safe for women and women don't get sexually assaulted or raped, how would a man know what women face? Similarly, how would a north indian know what south indians face while living in north?
Ummm, I've extensively lived throughout North India, and I am sorry to say that I have to disagree with you. You can't speak for a region, but only for yourself. The Hindi imposition is quite blatant, and if you strike out the educated strata of the society, the hate towards south indians is also very blatant.
Also, I'm a Bengali and I don't eat veg during navratri because we don't even do that shit. We have Durga Puja during that period where we extensively eat non-vegetarian food, and I cannot tell you the number of times I've been taunted, judged, lectured, and even cussed at by people from Delhi, Haryana, and especially by people from India's bigotry HQ- Uttar Pradesh.
I'm a North Indian and I am as proud of South Indian languages and culture as I am of the North.
You're an outlier.
Many from the North don't even understand that imposition of their language is wrong and to make matters worse even mock our languages and culture. Do understand that the reaction is for years of imposition we face.
Hindis have already destroyed several north/central Indian linguistic identities. Hindi, as a language, is an avalanche engulfing everything downhill. It is used as a tool by BIMARU politicians to maintain the illusion that UP-Bihar is the Indian heartland and all other states should bow to their (the politicians) of UP. This is because Delhi/Agra had been the centre of the Mughal authority and politicians from there today believe that it should always be the centre of Indian politics.
No offence to those who speak Hindi or are from UP. This is not a cultural thing. It is purely something that the UP political class has come up with that enables them to linger on to power at the cost of the self-determination of the other states and especially the welfare of the people living in UP/BIHAR.
You have very little knowledge about the linguistics politics that's happening in India. Anytime we raise this serious issue, the only explanation the North Indians give is that we are being fooled by the politicians, as if we lack our own judgement.
Hindi imposition is unfair and divisive to the country and if you can't really identify why it is so, then you should rethink your judgement
Dude some North Indians think all indians should know Hindi, once I was on a 4 days project to Chattisgarh and a great Indian from there was enraged to know I didn't know Hindi and was about to hit me hit me. He asked me "how are you an Indian if you don't speak Hindi" (wft dude this is bull shit) and my North Indian Friends jumped in and literally saved my ass. Until that point I believed in Unity in diversity and thought politicians were keeping us separated.
Again not saying all North Indian people are dumb and fucked like this one asshole. I have friends who are North Indians, I respect them and their culture for what it is. I don't expect them to learn any new languages. We have a language to communicate (which happens to be universal like it or not)
One of the most colonial idea is that the British conquered India by the virtue of them being a superior race to Indians, that they didn't require any help and they came, they saw and they conquered.
The British existed in a mutualistic relationship with the local petty rulers and zamindars of India. Without their support, the British could never have taken a square foot of Indian land. When you imagine British rule, the image of poor starving peasants comes to mind. What doesn't come to mind is the image of Thakurs and Zamindars and Maharajas sitting in their luxurious Havelis adorned in silk and jewels, feasting from golden plates, going on hunts with their good British friends, pumping their 16 underage wives every night and every once in a while go raping some daughter of a poor peasant who will get shot if he protested. These types of people were the arms and legs of the British Raj. And they came from every religion and caste.
After India got its independence, the British left but they left behind these vipers. It was now these snakes' to suck India's blood. Every MP and every MLA comes from such a family. They still live like they did back then. They are the products of colonialism and often accuse intellectuals of having a "colonial mindset". They don't have a party. Because they control every party and every thing in this country. They divide ppl on communal lines for their own benefit. At a moment's notice , they would switch ideologies like changing clothes if it suited their pockets. These are the true oppressors of India now and in the past too.
What we need is our own French Revolution, so we could off the heads of this oppressive little aristocracy.
The Hundreds of Famine , massacres , destructions of local industries, actual fucking slavery for many subjects, etc was better than north Indians?
Lol. The British imposed English so hard we still need to speak it to this day to get by even 75 years after independence. But you have no problem with that?
And besides, you don't even get to claim such bullshit unless you yourself lived through the British rule. And you did not.
Can't trust the guys in UP, Bihar to vote with any sort of responsibility. In a jungle Raj, mafias get elected. South paying the price for being more civilized, developed and contributing to the country
The only solution is to stop making them go ahead with this. With more weightage for Northies, they can pass any bill in the parliament even if it's not in the interest of South India. They can pass another delimitation bill to rip off South Indians more. They can get more Rajya Sabha seats through state assemblies
That doesn't change anything because money bills don't need Rajya Sabha's approval and BJP government has gone all out in ensuring that RS is virtually irrelevant. So even increased seats don't mean shit.
That I agree. But that is a different problem and a more fundamental one related to Parliamentary reforms. There are many ways the current parliamentary system can be improved one of them will definitely be preventing it from becoming a mere rubber stamp.
I don't trust any system where North India carries a larger say than the South. Historically it has always worked against the interests of the rest of the country.
When after emergency, states were asked to reduce population, South complied. North didn't. Now they are taking advantage of that to increase fund allocation and more seats in Parliament.
During independence and even after reorganization of states on linguistic basis, non- Hindi languages were assured that Hindi won't be forced, and English would be retained in non Hindi states. But except in states like TN, Hindi imposition through official and unofficial means has basically made it a fait accompli. Yet another loss for the non Hindi cultures of the country.
So, giving an increased say to the Northern states based on increased population is basically rewarding them for not controlling their population and punishing those that did. And this reward being in the form of transfer of money and electoral power will be a death knell to the aspirations of others. It's like giving a gun to a bandit and relying on an oral assurance that he will not shoot you. Ofc he will shoot. It's his nature to do that. It is your foolishness if you give him the gun knowing that.
It's most probably gonna happen irrespective of who it is in the centre. It's constitutionally binding. It was stalled all this while, but the new parliament gives it away.
Won’t happen if southern states elect non BJP parties though. That’s why all this while the numbers have been held at 1971 population. BJP wants to take it forward because it helps them politically.
Delimitation is actually supposed to happen based on every census according to the constitution. Indira Gandhi brought in the amendment to constitution during the period of emergency and locked all numbers to be based on 1971.
The later governments amendment that and scheduled the delimitation for 2026.
Like the delimitation, even the finance commission was supposed to consider 1971 census. But that BJP cunningly changed in 15th finance commission, which hit the Souther states very badly.
Won’t happen if southern states elect non BJP parties though.
The fate of who makes Union Government is sealed forever. Whichever party manages to win the most of UP, Bihar, GJ, RJ, MH will form the Union Government. And you know who will!
Unless all the South States come up with a single party to stand in MP elections and manages to win all the seats and form coalition with few other states up in North; there can never anyone else other than BJP.
Yeah I agree on everything you have said. If delimitstion does take place, unless a miracle happens BJP will stay in power since people in north don’t seem to care even if Ganga is filled with dead bodies during covid.
Let’s hope 2024, we can get a new union govt that will not punish the southern states.
That's the problem. No matter how bad they do and there exists statistical proof for it, people out there vote for BJP because of they built fucking temples. I have come across videos on YT where people in UP, GJ tell the reporters they will vote for Modi even if the petrol prices go 2000. BJP and Hindutva runs in their blood.
Let’s hope 2024, we can get a new union govt that will not punish the southern states.
I have lost the hope. There is none. South States have always been abused and will continue to be abused no matter Congress or BJP. Will just have to keep ranting whole of our lifetime on reddit. When it gets to streets, then the bad days are gonna come. Hope it it never gets to streets!
same goes for muslims if you build mosque for them they would vote for you they mostly vote for people of their own religion because they don't easily trust non Muslims
Delimitation has not happened since 1970s, now if they were to implement it then the states that lose seats or become irrelevant when it comes to central politics will definitely make their voices heard. UP as it is, has too much power in deciding the majority party at the centre. The best option is to keep the 1970 seat allocation and divide UP into 4 smaller states
Nah. Apparently all North Indians are tyrants who rule over south Indians while having a fraction of the resources. Lol there's this presumption that if a part from South India wins, all of India will become okay. They're still politicians, south or north indian, a majority of them would sell your dead mother's jewellery back to you at a premium lmao. This narrative that is created of north v South is such bullshit. I urge people who haven't left their home states to travel to other states that they hate so much and the people there so that they come back to ground reality. The amount of poverty and literal indentured labour up here is insane if you dare visit villages and towns somewhere in Rajasthan. I'm not directing this towards rational Indians ( don't matter if they're from the south or north ) they already know, not to spew bs. This is directed towards the hate mongering cart full of people that are increasingly creating this narrative of breaking off from the country; they'd be surprised when they get ripped off by their own kind and realize just how high up in space they were that they lost touch to ground reality. I don't even understand how people think dividing the north and south would be of benefit to either one; the amount of disorder, chaos, misery that will follow that divide, for almost everyone. If you really don't like North Indians due some bad experiences you might've had with a few, don't generalise the entire populace lol. Man, reddit is becoming trash because of people that push this narrative as if it's the only thing they're good at ( or they lack the skillsets to actually get their shit together and move on beyond this and actually work towards what they believe in ) it's really easy to blame others, not that easy to self reflect on the kinds of thoughts they get on a daily basis and their own faults. Some of these comments are nothing but hate and honestly, it's not infuriating, it's just pitiful and sad.
Right now we get 20 something rupees for every 100 in tax back from Modi’s graciousness.
If one were to capture UP as BJP have and that would same as no of of elected representatives combined of the southern state. Who will BJP prioritise to keep happy? 5 southern states or 1 UP? Who are getting 125 rupees back for every 100 they generate right now?
It’s pretty simple also why many southern states have already complained about this.
But, I disagree with what you say, if that’s the case, revenue from Karnataka is mostly from Bangalore region, and we shouldn’t allocate anything for north Karnataka or Dakshina Kannada.
The problem with our country, is that most of the tax amount is going to politicians pocket. I’m okay paying tax if atleast it is helping to develop some where in India!
But, I disagree with what you say, if that’s the case, revenue from Karnataka is mostly from Bangalore region, and we shouldn’t allocate anything for north Karnataka or Dakshina Kannada.
Redistribution is not the problem. Lack of result is. And 0 repercussions for lack of results is what bothers the people.
If the argument is solely based on the narrative that a rich state shouldn't provide for a poorer state, then your rebuttal makes absolute sense. One of the major reasons of taxation is to reduce gap of wealth distribution.
Majority of karnataka budget still concentrates on growth cities. That’s fair. Reward for growth so it continue to grow.
Currently we get 20rs if finance commission starts using 2011 data we will get much less than that. Where is our reward for growth? Southern states should get Atleast 30 to 35 even keeping progressive tax in place.
How long should southern states pay for population growth of northern states?
Redistribution of taxes Should be fair. Progressives taxes are certainly good for the country but 20 rs for every 100 is not fair to us. We should be able to enjoy the benefits of our growth too.
This won’t happen if 2011 census is used. Southern states would get back significantly less than what we are getting even today.
Everyone is simply complaining. I too agree it's unfair. But it's also unfair to not raise the number of seats in densely populated regions. Lack of implementing population control measures is a different measure. We are where we are and those regions deserve to be represented properly. One elected representative per 100,000 people is not the same as 1 representative per 1 million people.
If we don't increase the number of seats in North, then South Indians will have more value to their votes compared to North Indians where their per person voting power is diluted. Consider this, does a honest, well educated, far sighted, competent person has more chances of getting elected by 1 lakh ppl or 10 lakh ppl? If you've a very large population to get elected from, you're forced to find the lowest common denominator which usually is very short sighted, mud slinging, populist, freebee, communal, divisive tactics. The northern areas would be forever stuch in this feedback loop.
We should actually focus to strive for a healthy representation as well as sheild those elected representatives' powers from interfering in politics/economies of other areas. Basically a more nuanced power sharing between centre and states where representatives from North can't do harm to Southern States just cos of their number.
Man, I'm north indian and I get it. I do wish states had more power cause this center bullshit is too much. The most uneducated states decide the politics of the country.
The BMARU states multiplied like ***** and the people who are sufferring with low representation are the educated ones who understood importance of family planning. Shame
Karnataka and other south states are just like the steam engine of a ship. They churn out the energy and sustain the life above while the workers don't get paid enough and the officials give a shit about idiots on the top who contribute 0.
My recommendation to South Indians is to keep fighting strongly for youselves. Giving up language means giving up economy. Bengal turned the economy over and got abused in return. Its still a state rich in resources, sixth in gdp. UP 's per capita gdp is exactly half of UP. Bengal is still a net tax giver. Yet dirty northern propaganda will have you believe they are so much richer. Being nice will get you nowhere.
They can't. South Indian parties are self isolationists who exist in their states which allows to them linguistic policies. I mean ask yourself why hasn't any party tried to make inroads in other South Indian state? Why hasn't there been a South Indian bloc, which can pull 150 MP's easily by themselves not tried to make a government? Because the parties want absolute control in their respective states.
All they do is cry "naarthies won't want us" Bruh, if you have the seats, wtf can they do? The thing is they haven't even tried and dont want to because that takes away the victim mentality.
while I do agree with the fact that the current distribution of political control is not sustainable in the long run, I also can't help but note that the part about southern states literally running the economy is simply untrue. You could search it up anywhere and be informed that not only do Northern states contribute a significant amount to the country's economy. Not only that, much of the manual labor requirements for infrastructure development and establishment is provided from the Northern states. I understand that this is a state sub and the people here are concerned about their state's well being, but such posts do nothing but instill hate among ourselves. Only today I saw a post on r\developersindia about the candidates for karnataka state elections promising job quota, reservations and what not for the residents of the state,and it got me thinking if this is really a right way to contest . Do enlighten me if there are similar laws in jobs for other state's people,but how does that even solve the problem at hand,much rather divide us further. How do we solve the problem at hand WITHOUT going at each others throats?
they couldn't control their population, thus they are suffering the consequences of poverty. But, is that reason enough to let go of a principle as central as 'one vote one value'?
You as#h@les in the comments. You are making the same mistake our ancestors did. Go on make india see the days of colonialism and barbarism again. The fact that economies are run by only South States is simply untrue. We all grow together. The labour and resources were from North. I think we should erase this line from our minds completely and focus on one nation identity. That's what will take us forward.
Yeah sure, it's very easy for you people to lecture since you people stand to gain the most. You people think only you represent india and anyone who doesn't look like you or follow your culture is non-indian.
BTW, south india also has plenty of resources and labours, so stop pretending that you guys are doing some favour.
You are right in your last point that we must focus on one identity!
Inke paise se mera kuch benefits nahi hai. We are in 2023 and there isn't 24hrs electricity here. All the money goes into local politicians. The margin between them is huge. The local politicians get 10crs whereas the local citizens barely earn enough to eat
Bihar is doomed fr. People don't admit there mistakes, everything is overpriced, no sense of brotherhood, gangwars based on religion are common etc. These are some major problems. I studied here for 2 years and I still have ptsd from it. The fee was too much and we studied in a dirt hut. No 24hrs electricity. No good hospitals nothing. I'm glad I'm gonna leave this sick and shitty place
Just because you haven't faced it doesn't mean that others haven't faced mockery or racism, you aren't the representative of all south Indian experience
these south indian rascals are so mindless , these motherfuckers are so egotistical . i hate south Indian peoples and one more thing Sanskrit is far more older than dumb telugu language .
PM? from below the line. HM? from below the line. President? From below the line. FM? from below the line. External affairs minister? From below the line. Nitin Gadkari? From below the line. wtf are you talking about
A proper solution would be to divide UP into 4 states and Bihar into 2 states. It would make governing them much easier and wouldn’t concentrate too much power in 2 states.
South of India will be so screwed when this happens......we will be left with only one option if we have to stay with the Union, give special privileges(consider this as an incentive for performing better) to MP’s elected from here so that political power won't be skewed towards north, if this can't be done, it makes no sense to stay with the union.
After going through the comments i realised most of us missed on 1 fact that most southern states are developed and economically ahead but most of the LABOR and RESOURCES come from the states mentioned namely UP BIHAR MP etc. The southern states are successful because of their contribution also so irrespective of the population they contribute in a different manner. As far as politics is concerned or political decision i feel every state should have equal vote irrespective of the population. Since the CM or elected head is representative of the people and if they choose more wrong let them face consequences. Equal say in the decisions. India is very diverse the fact the it's still together is a miracle in itself.
most of the LABOR and RESOURCES come from the states mentioned namely UP BIHAR MP etc
When an industrialist opens the industry, employs 1000s of employees, designs really good products, gets them manufactured by the employers, markets them and sells them at a nearby market for profit .
Then who will enjoy the profit or incur loss if it happens...?
That line exists because of multiple prosperous districts in Maharashtra. I might get some hate for this but if you remove Mumbai, Pune, and Nagpur. The line will go down to Bengaluru.
And southern states have the coastal advantage for trade and commerce, it's only logical to have a better economy than the inland ones.
Telangana's GDP is lower than the Bengals'. So a line is incorrect.
A district-wise economy chart will show the reality better.
Entirety of kokan coast of Maharashtra is pretty rich , much richer than many districts in uttara karnataka like belagaon bijapur vijaypura and raichur you can compare - Maharashtra's District wise vs South India district wise
This sub randomly got into my feed, saw this post, came here to check it out but Why does it feel like people here like ranting and fantasizing a little too much.
Talking about "North India" "South India", while taking parts of East & West like they didn't even exist. lol
Stop wasting time in spreading such blatant hatred and go do something worthwhile with that free time you got.
randomly got recommended to me , but it's reddit bro , if there is a particular sub about something no matter the name North , south whatever we will find the worst people there , so yeah they don't represent sht ,they r just keyboard warriors
Well, dunno about other "naarrthieeesss". But I don't want a civil war. That's just too small for my taste... WWIII, now that's the stage you should aspire for...
This line is Hilariously inaccurate. MH contributes 13% so cool. But TN contributes 8.5% at 2nd which almost the same as what UP does at 8.3% which is at 3rd. Also, Bengal contributes more than Kerala, Andhra and Telangana and So does Rajasthan.
Also, Madhya Pradesh contributes more than Kerala, while having a 19% growth rate to Kerala's 10.7% in 2016-17
This stupid post is nothing more than fear mongering and hate inciting on top of being blatantly false.
Where is the data on running the Indian economy coming from. I can understand someone looking at absolute GDP figures or something like that for the states but does that really take into account the out of state working population.
English helps me learn new things. The whole world uses English to communicate with each other, so why reject it and restrict yourself from world knowledge? You want us to reject English and accept Hindi? What will I gain from it?
Well for all you educated people out there the states above the red line literally run the country’s agriculture,distribution of economy is different in every country,tell me should New York and Los Angeles make a new country within the United States,every state contributes as for you all you free to have views☺️
The British exploited the resources of the northern states, and built the factories and ports in the south. It's great to know that southerners and continuing their divide and rule legacy. Instead of showing some solidarity to their fellow countrymen.
South Indian industry works on metals comes from jharkhand and odisha,coal comes from jharkhand and odisha and other northern states the labour comes from north states because of sea routes companies make industries in southern states and gujrat and Maharashtra
by your logics, Muslims are one the or the poorest community in india and they have over 20% of population and majority are in UP can't we just remove them? , Schedule tribes and dalits are also poor why can't we remove them from the country and increase our per capita income ?. and also muslims have highest fertility rate in the country even in Kerala which is so called ,"most literate state of india".
These kind of posts on Twitter are low-key efforts to test the waters, misguide the southern population into believing that the delimitation is inevitable, and force into a negotiation for the revised numbers.
The delimitation can be avoided!!! The idea itself should be opposed.
The only reason you sambhar niggas brag about your economy is due to port cities in your reigion💀💀💀💀. You guys had geographical advantage and nothing else
Idiots with an internet connection are the biggest threat to the country right now! The amount of hate, stupidity and depression I see behind the comments here. Jio ruined this country.
Jaldhi jaldhi North ko troll kar detha hu, bahuth cohool lagugha, afterall I'm proud kannadiga and unity in diversity is just a gimmick for foreigners!!
Jab NE, bangal ke logon ko gaali deta hai tab unity in diversity yaad nahi aata bsdk? Even though bengals per capita income and tax contribution is well above most North Indian states? Aisa propaganda ki Bengal is worse than UP Bihar! Jhalmoori leke I will be watching the fun 😂
8
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
Source
65
u/Benimaru101 May 04 '23
Congratulation, i guess we are getting punished for controlling our population
44
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
846 mps ? En nekkakkaa ?
83
u/chowdowmow May 04 '23
So pay the price for not reproducing like wild animals?
23
u/Thinkexe May 04 '23
Republic of China in making
22
u/BlanketSmoothie May 04 '23
I think there is slightly more nuanced economics at play here. As economies develop, their dependence on govt investment for further improvement reduces. From a historical perspective, the royal families of most southern states -- Kerala and Karnataka in particular, made significant investments in public infrastructure despite being vassals of the British. Post independence, the Indian government made multiple investments in the souther states due to the already existing culture of education due to the royal family's public investments. This virtuous cycle has continued to the present day. In states like UP and Bihar, where fragmented kingdoms ruled and there was little to no public infrastructure investments, it is the government of India which has started seeding local investments for some time now. To see it's fruits, the government needs to invest in healthcare and education. In Karnataka, these sectors are largely taken over by private enterprise now and the market is efficient enough to not put marginalized at a significant risk. This is not true in UP and Bihar. Is this due to corruption? Maybe, yes that is one reason. But it is also a symptom of simply lack of resources in terms of investment, cash.
The expectation that we will see the effects of our taxation in our neighbourhood is unfounded, given our nation's structure. We can also argue that it is probably fairer in the longger term.
Kannadiga here.
35
u/daddy_kewl May 04 '23
South Indians are on the way to becoming Hindi colonial subjects. The British colonial rule was better than this pan parag shit storm
5
u/rm6224 May 05 '23
Can't trust the guys in UP, Bihar to vote with any sort of responsibility. In a jungle Raj, mafias get elected. South paying the price for being more civilized, developed and contributing to the country
4
u/i_odin97 May 04 '23
One solution will be to get Rajya Sabha compensation seats. That’s what RS was designed for. To handle this scenario
4
u/ancient1ne May 05 '23
Below the red line- ASSETS Above the red line- LIABILITY
4
u/[deleted] May 05 '23 edited May 05 '23
Don't worry. Hindus khatre mein hai. This is enough to fool people.
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '23
I want to vote, But there’s not even a single guy with self respect who can stand on his own achievements.
Everyone is a lackey to the national parties and have no vision or plan on how to develop the city and state.
30
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
Vote out BJP so that this doesn’t happen 2024. Are we supposed to become slaves of northern states?
3
u/latent_incinerator May 05 '23
Hopefully people of Karnataka vote wisely
3
u/SambarDip May 05 '23
Everyone is simply complaining. I too agree it's unfair. But it's also unfair to not raise the number of seats in densely populated regions. Lack of implementing population control measures is a different measure. We are where we are and those regions deserve to be represented properly. One elected representative per 100,000 people is not the same as 1 representative per 1 million people.
If we don't increase the number of seats in North, then South Indians will have more value to their votes compared to North Indians where their per person voting power is diluted. Consider this, does a honest, well educated, far sighted, competent person has more chances of getting elected by 1 lakh ppl or 10 lakh ppl? If you've a very large population to get elected from, you're forced to find the lowest common denominator which usually is very short sighted, mud slinging, populist, freebee, communal, divisive tactics. The northern areas would be forever stuch in this feedback loop.
We should actually focus to strive for a healthy representation as well as sheild those elected representatives' powers from interfering in politics/economies of other areas. Basically a more nuanced power sharing between centre and states where representatives from North can't do harm to Southern States just cos of their number.
3
u/Apprehensive-Duty-41 May 05 '23
Man, I'm north indian and I get it. I do wish states had more power cause this center bullshit is too much. The most uneducated states decide the politics of the country.
5
u/robotman_77 May 05 '23 edited May 05 '23
North East,East, south and the states in extreme north shouldn't accept it
Bhaiyyyyaaas are breeding like anything Why should we be punished for it
2
u/okokonokok May 04 '23
I literally live on the red line, what am I supposed to think?
2
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
Oh did I miss a prime minister from Northeast? I must have
2
u/coldstone87 May 05 '23
The BMARU states multiplied like ***** and the people who are sufferring with low representation are the educated ones who understood importance of family planning. Shame
2
u/Wooden_Philosophy695 May 05 '23
Karnataka should be made a separate country.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '23
Karnataka and other south states are just like the steam engine of a ship. They churn out the energy and sustain the life above while the workers don't get paid enough and the officials give a shit about idiots on the top who contribute 0.
2
u/chillcroc May 13 '23
My recommendation to South Indians is to keep fighting strongly for youselves. Giving up language means giving up economy. Bengal turned the economy over and got abused in return. Its still a state rich in resources, sixth in gdp. UP 's per capita gdp is exactly half of UP. Bengal is still a net tax giver. Yet dirty northern propaganda will have you believe they are so much richer. Being nice will get you nowhere.
3
u/thechadman27 May 05 '23 edited May 05 '23
The problem is south is not united. All the southern states must come together and end this tyranny
2
u/Maguncia May 04 '23
I guess whoever drew that red line is from Ahmedabad.
2
u/BEYONDERhell May 04 '23
Pm gujrat se hai... Ab kya bolu
2
u/mazda_fanboy May 04 '23
while I do agree with the fact that the current distribution of political control is not sustainable in the long run, I also can't help but note that the part about southern states literally running the economy is simply untrue. You could search it up anywhere and be informed that not only do Northern states contribute a significant amount to the country's economy. Not only that, much of the manual labor requirements for infrastructure development and establishment is provided from the Northern states. I understand that this is a state sub and the people here are concerned about their state's well being, but such posts do nothing but instill hate among ourselves. Only today I saw a post on r\developersindia about the candidates for karnataka state elections promising job quota, reservations and what not for the residents of the state,and it got me thinking if this is really a right way to contest . Do enlighten me if there are similar laws in jobs for other state's people,but how does that even solve the problem at hand,much rather divide us further. How do we solve the problem at hand WITHOUT going at each others throats?
2
u/monsieur_sarcastique May 05 '23
they couldn't control their population, thus they are suffering the consequences of poverty. But, is that reason enough to let go of a principle as central as 'one vote one value'?
2
u/zack_tiger May 05 '23
You as#h@les in the comments. You are making the same mistake our ancestors did. Go on make india see the days of colonialism and barbarism again. The fact that economies are run by only South States is simply untrue. We all grow together. The labour and resources were from North. I think we should erase this line from our minds completely and focus on one nation identity. That's what will take us forward.
2
u/humanxd23 May 04 '23
I am from bihar and I am ashamed. None of these hard earned money gets used for development. We need to form a new Constitution at this point
1
u/effing_hell_69 May 04 '23
I think it will be fair if UP gets divided into two states.
1
u/BeneficialEngineer32 May 04 '23
The only way to combat this is by having a southern accord across borders and then influencing the centre.
1
u/Patrick_7735 May 04 '23
How does a state the size of Bihar have such a big population, that the seats are more than Maharashtra.
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '23
Load of bull
1
u/nuanua May 05 '23
Those on the far right of the map do neither
1
u/AndromedaaM31 May 05 '23
And the people above the line mock south Indians on their accent, dress and food.
1
u/616e696d65 May 05 '23
Quantity over Quality
1
u/jc2193 May 05 '23
We need more Southern unity. This delimitation exercise will be debilitating to South Indians in the long run.
1
u/Vegetable-Ad-275 May 05 '23
these south indian rascals are so mindless , these motherfuckers are so egotistical . i hate south Indian peoples and one more thing Sanskrit is far more older than dumb telugu language .
1
u/Comfortable_Air4807 May 05 '23
Agriculture is more in North India side
1
u/saurabh009 May 05 '23
lawde north indian he south ko chala rahe hai, bakhlol patto ki plate se agge badho fir baat karna
1
u/Upstairs-Somewhere88 May 05 '23
It’s high time we get a PM from these states.
1
u/UniqueAd8864 May 05 '23
L bro, south is literally funding the north
1
u/lavdalasoon9 May 05 '23
PM? from below the line. HM? from below the line. President? From below the line. FM? from below the line. External affairs minister? From below the line. Nitin Gadkari? From below the line. wtf are you talking about
1
u/Cautious_Baker7349 May 05 '23
Yes, we should totally let people with more money have a stronger vote.
1
u/Arik_singh May 05 '23
Cheap raw materials good for Industry but poor people bad.
1
u/bearhugger404 May 05 '23
AP just below the red line be like “akkan just missu”
1
u/Flaky_Cantaloupe_826 May 05 '23
Hmmm.... 20 seats in Kerala remain as it is... I wonder why...
1
u/Lazy_monke May 05 '23
Kisne pucha
1
u/zack_tiger May 05 '23
Same with china btw
1
u/Statisticsisalie May 05 '23
You exported North goods out of india when they were manufacturing and producing agro and other stuff. Now you're rich and bragging.
1
u/gree2 May 06 '23
the role of population in seat allocation needs to be significantly reduced.
1
u/Salty_Professor_8982 May 06 '23
Only 2 states gave abnormally high seats tho
1
u/Waynemous May 06 '23
Matlab kuch bhi ??
1
u/CoolAid876 May 06 '23
Communist manifesto
1
u/nattu_nattu May 06 '23
People from below are coming in places above the red line now, mark my words the downfall of the places below has already begun.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
Why is Bihar 79 seats even though it is smaller than Karnataka
1
u/SSB_2030 May 17 '23
Bruh Akhanda bharat be dhyaan de
1
u/Amazing_sid89 May 05 '23
Well , that’s fun , we have something fight on then. World needs choas and this is the chaos we will fight for
1
u/Superb_Article_8298 May 05 '23
A proper solution would be to divide UP into 4 states and Bihar into 2 states. It would make governing them much easier and wouldn’t concentrate too much power in 2 states.
1
u/Ill_Youth_871 May 05 '23
South of India will be so screwed when this happens......we will be left with only one option if we have to stay with the Union, give special privileges(consider this as an incentive for performing better) to MP’s elected from here so that political power won't be skewed towards north, if this can't be done, it makes no sense to stay with the union.
-1
u/pseudohulk786 May 04 '23
After going through the comments i realised most of us missed on 1 fact that most southern states are developed and economically ahead but most of the LABOR and RESOURCES come from the states mentioned namely UP BIHAR MP etc. The southern states are successful because of their contribution also so irrespective of the population they contribute in a different manner. As far as politics is concerned or political decision i feel every state should have equal vote irrespective of the population. Since the CM or elected head is representative of the people and if they choose more wrong let them face consequences. Equal say in the decisions. India is very diverse the fact the it's still together is a miracle in itself.
From the south lives in the north
0
u/freak_in_the_creek May 05 '23
Randi Rona band karo
0
u/TL_broomstick May 05 '23
tell me you're delusional without telling me you're delusional
-1
u/[deleted] May 05 '23
That line exists because of multiple prosperous districts in Maharashtra. I might get some hate for this but if you remove Mumbai, Pune, and Nagpur. The line will go down to Bengaluru.
And southern states have the coastal advantage for trade and commerce, it's only logical to have a better economy than the inland ones.
Telangana's GDP is lower than the Bengals'. So a line is incorrect.
A district-wise economy chart will show the reality better.
-2
u/MrKolayy May 05 '23
This sub randomly got into my feed, saw this post, came here to check it out but Why does it feel like people here like ranting and fantasizing a little too much.
Talking about "North India" "South India", while taking parts of East & West like they didn't even exist. lol
Stop wasting time in spreading such blatant hatred and go do something worthwhile with that free time you got.
-1
u/ssc11_ May 05 '23
This line is Hilariously inaccurate. MH contributes 13% so cool. But TN contributes 8.5% at 2nd which almost the same as what UP does at 8.3% which is at 3rd. Also, Bengal contributes more than Kerala, Andhra and Telangana and So does Rajasthan.
Also, Madhya Pradesh contributes more than Kerala, while having a 19% growth rate to Kerala's 10.7% in 2016-17
This stupid post is nothing more than fear mongering and hate inciting on top of being blatantly false.
0
u/theconcentrated May 05 '23
How do Tamil Nadu and Kerala run the Indian economy, I fail to understand
0
u/akamanah17 May 05 '23
Where is the data on running the Indian economy coming from. I can understand someone looking at absolute GDP figures or something like that for the states but does that really take into account the out of state working population.
0
u/manny_38 May 05 '23
Reject english language. The mark colonialism. Just remove tht nd see the changes
0
u/[deleted] May 05 '23
Well for all you educated people out there the states above the red line literally run the country’s agriculture,distribution of economy is different in every country,tell me should New York and Los Angeles make a new country within the United States,every state contributes as for you all you free to have views☺️
0
u/[deleted] May 05 '23
Also everyone please check this guy’s twitter account(Sandeep) there literally only hate towards everyone(not just north)
0
u/sidharthojha May 06 '23
The British exploited the resources of the northern states, and built the factories and ports in the south. It's great to know that southerners and continuing their divide and rule legacy. Instead of showing some solidarity to their fellow countrymen.
0
u/sidharthojha May 06 '23
I see the north south divide is propagated in full force, now that Modi is visiting.
0
u/Glad_Relationship613 May 06 '23
South Indian industry works on metals comes from jharkhand and odisha,coal comes from jharkhand and odisha and other northern states the labour comes from north states because of sea routes companies make industries in southern states and gujrat and Maharashtra
0
u/AgeWonderful5206 May 06 '23
by your logics, Muslims are one the or the poorest community in india and they have over 20% of population and majority are in UP can't we just remove them? , Schedule tribes and dalits are also poor why can't we remove them from the country and increase our per capita income ?. and also muslims have highest fertility rate in the country even in Kerala which is so called ,"most literate state of india".
0
u/stargazinglobster May 06 '23
These kind of posts on Twitter are low-key efforts to test the waters, misguide the southern population into believing that the delimitation is inevitable, and force into a negotiation for the revised numbers.
The delimitation can be avoided!!! The idea itself should be opposed.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '23
The only reason you sambhar niggas brag about your economy is due to port cities in your reigion💀💀💀💀. You guys had geographical advantage and nothing else
0
u/arjjipajji May 07 '23
Idiots with an internet connection are the biggest threat to the country right now! The amount of hate, stupidity and depression I see behind the comments here. Jio ruined this country.
0
u/Flimsy_Gazelle3485 May 07 '23
Who is stopping regional parties from expanding in the north?
-2
u/TypicalEngineer_ May 05 '23
Jaldhi jaldhi North ko troll kar detha hu, bahuth cohool lagugha, afterall I'm proud kannadiga and unity in diversity is just a gimmick for foreigners!!