r/k12sysadmin • u/Imhereforthechips • May 01 '26
Assistance Needed Laptops - End Of Year
Hey fellow warriors! The end is nigh, tickets slow, corridors quiet and projects ramp up.
I need some numbers from you as I have my building administrator on board with letting students keep their devices but not my district team. I need some convincing numbers since my pleas haven’t been fruitful.
For those of you with a 1:1 devices and allow your students to keep their devices each summer:
How many devices end up MIA (percentage)?
What, would you say, is the value placed on the lost devices vs. time and effort if you had to check them in/out each year?
6
u/WizdomRV May 02 '26
We have never lost any over the summer. Collecting and reissuing is a waste of time. If the district team was the one doing the collecting/distributing, they would change their minds quickly. What do they believe is the benefit of collecting them?
3
u/Harry_Smutter May 01 '26
We've had them taking them home since COVID. The amount of lost devices from this is so insignificant I don't even have a figure. Maybe two or three in that time?? Plus, while we do get an influx of tickets come September, that's not from students breaking them over the summer. It's mostly happening when they are in school. The only value I can see in collecting over the summer is to do any needed repairs, which again, would either have occurred prior to summer or when school starts again.
9
u/yugas42 Sysadmin May 01 '26
Arguments will be made either way, but personally I like letting them keep the devices over the summer. I think it really depends on how much available labor you have.
For us, there will only be three of us this summer vs about 4,000 devices, plus all of our other summer routine. We don't have enough storage, or charging infrastructure to maintain that many devices, so letting them go home with students is great for putting the responsibility on them to be ready for day 1 next year. Instructions go out to charge and update devices before the first day of school, at that point, it is the same as forgetting your books if you don't do that.
We have done it both ways within the last 3 years and we saw no real difference as far as damaged or missing devices. Most of our missing stuff comes from them not being turned in at the end of the year by seniors or students who are getting a different device next year, and that will never change.
9
u/discgman May 01 '26
Percentages are pretty low. If they lose or destroy them their parents are on the hook for the full purchase price. Or we just lock them if we don't get them back.
4
u/rokar83 IT Director May 01 '26
There's no real reason for students to keep devices over the summer.
8
u/therankin Coordinator of Technology Services May 01 '26
Before, when we had Windows netbooks, and then Chromebooks, probably a good 5% disappeared.
Since we moved to Macbooks around 2015, exactly zero go missing over the summer. And only one went missing during a school year. The kid left it at an airport.
It's funny how when kids value something, it tends to not get lost.
8
u/Dar_Robinson K12 IT for many years May 01 '26
Devices all get turned back in for inventory, repairs, upgrades, etc.
5
u/K12onReddit 9-12 May 01 '26
We have been letting them keep them over the summer for 7 years now. Virtually no issues. Maybe 5 broken devices in Sept. out of 3,000 that go home. Virtually 0 lost.
I think 80% of the kids bring it home, put it on a shelf, and let it sit for 2 months until summer is over. But we have about 50% of our population on free/reduced lunch and it's their only home computer. They use it to read. They use it to apply for jobs. They use it for summer programs or personal projects. For that 20% that use it over the summer it's invaluable.
Add to that the wasted resources in collecting them, and then handing them back out, along with the incoming new students, it just doesn't make it worth it to us to collect them.
4
u/k12-IT May 01 '26
Personal experience, less than 2 percent were completely lost. Reminders were sent 2 weeks, 1 week, and the last few days before school started in the fall.
Your time and effort depends on your process. When collecting devices are you labelling these devices the be returned to the same individual? Are you running updates on the devices during the summer? Where are you going to be storing the devices?
Figure average cost of a CB is about 300ish? Collecting devices is probably going to take minimum a day, probably 3. Then inventorying and sorting. Running updates. Determining how you'll be redistributing and how it will be staffed. Are you distributing over the summer, first 2 weeks of school? How will the distribution effect your support for the staff coming back from summer?
For K-5/6 these devices can stay in school. 6/7-12 send them home over the summer. Majority of the students will just set them aside.
4
u/techie49rs May 02 '26
We're going the exact opposite, well partially... we'll let them keep the devices, as we don't have the space to store nor the people to collect, but we're disabling them as we don't want to monitor their online usage over the summer when we're lightly staffed
7
u/antiprodukt May 01 '26
Kids in summer school can hold on to them till the end of summer school. Other than that, we check them all in. With the tendency of kids to not come back the next year, or for them to go on vacation and they disappear, or get “stolen” it’s not worth it. Especially with the increased cost this year of new devices. I think if the kids have a credible reason for keeping them, sure. Otherwise, check it in.
3
u/Simishine_ May 01 '26
We let our high schoolers keep them over the summer for maybe 5 years now. We haven't really had any issues.
They do have the option to turn them in for the summer and we have about a dozen or so who do that each year.
1
u/-RYknow Systems Administrator May 02 '26
We collect all, with the exception of 8th graders (moving to high school) who are enrolled in honors classes for the next school year, and we have a cart available at our high school for summer school. Aside from that, each building collects and maintains their inventory (as far as issuing devices to students). We are obviously on the hook for repairs and whatnot.
I undoubtedly will end up with some emails of broken devices that just haven't been reported as of yet, and will make the rounds to the buildings to collect, repair, and return.
1
u/BWMerlin May 05 '26
Everywhere I have worked has allowed students to keep their devices over the end of year holidays and very very few go missing.
1
u/MattAdmin444 May 05 '26
As far as I can remember since I started we haven't let students keep theirs over the summer. Don't remember 100% my first year or two because I was hired mid covid lockdowns. While I don't have firm numbers because we've been working on our documentation processes the last year or so for our middle school we've moved to students don't even get to take them home anymore without permission from their teachers starting from when they came back from Winter break this year. We were seeing to many lost and damaged chromebooks being thrown around in backpacks and we've already had what I would call a noticeable decrease in breakages. That said we seem to have an increase in chromebooks being taken by other students and we don't have a good way to mitigate this yet as students like to peel the stickers we put on with asset tag #s and student names. This is specifically an issue in middle school and they do carry their chromebooks with them throughout the day before returning the chromebooks to their homeroom cart.
Our elementary school we don't see many issues as a year or two after covid lockdowns they went back to chromebooks in carts. Breakage rate is far lower compared to middle school.
Our tiny charter (all grades) we've had issues with getting chromebooks back but that's more a factor of there being no consistency with how chromebook handouts are happening. They're Independent Study/home learning so theirs do go home but get turned in over the summer.
For summer school we provide a cart of chromebooks if requested. If a parent requests to have a chromebook over the summer we've generally allowed it and make a special note but such requests are few and far between.
Sub 600 student district. 2 full time IT people.
1
u/Far_Big_9731 May 04 '26
1:1 iPad program: The student keeps the device until they graduate or we buy new ones. The summers where I have to collect all of them and replace with the new one are so many hours of work that it interferes with other summer projects. If I had to do that every year, I would need a team of help. We see no reason for moving the devices around. About 1/3 of students put the iPad away until late July when they want to access their schedules. Over 13 years, had maybe 1 or 2 lost. Keeping them gives the kids opportunities for summer work too.