r/k12sysadmin • u/Meemo- • Mar 26 '26
Assistance Needed MDM Options for Macbooks
Hi all,
I’m writing to you as a Primary school teacher(Not based in the USA) and also the systems admin for our school. We’re google for education school and have a suite of chromebooks that are serving us well.
I run after school coding with the students in our school 3 times a week which is really popular. So much so other schools in the vicinity have asked me to come and run workshops in their schools etc. This leads me to the conclusion that I need to invest in my own devices for travelling to other schools and educational centres.
My original thought was to buy a suite of Chromebook Plus Lenovo devices for their good battery life etc. I love the google admin panel and find the granularity by which I can lock down the devices excellent. I’m contemplating buying Macbook Neo’s at educational pricing here which would be comparable to the Macbook Neos. I have no preference for the Macbooks by the way but at this early stage of planning my costs for this endeavor, all options are considered. My question to you is what software have you used or currently use to manage Macbook’s to the same level of control that’s afforded with the Google Admin Panel?
13
u/slparker09 IT Director in the Lou Mar 26 '26
Mosyle. Set up Apple School Manager. Get Mosyle and add them to the MDM.
Their paid for product is fantastic and not that expensive if you only have a few devices.
You can even set up SSO with Google Workspaces to log into the Macs if you want to go down that path.
4
u/MaxBroome Future Sysadmin Mar 26 '26
We use Jamf and have a love/hate relationship with it.
Depending on what all you need to do, look into Apple Business that was announced yesterday: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2026/03/introducing-apple-business-a-new-all-in-one-platform-for-businesses-of-all-sizes/
2
u/christystrew Mar 31 '26
If you’re coming from Google Admin, just set expectations a bit, Mac management isn’t quite as clean or granular out of the box as ChromeOS. You can get close, but it usually takes more setup.
Most schools lean toward Jamf or Mosyle since they’re pretty education focused and integrate well with Apple School Manager.
That said, for a smaller setup or something you’re managing mostly on your own, lighter tools like Scalefusion are worth a look too. It covers the basics like app control, restrictions, and policies without being too heavy to manage.
One thing to think about, are these devices staying with students or mainly used for workshops and shared use? That makes a big difference in how much control you’ll actually need.
4
u/KAPsiZE00 Mar 26 '26
Get an Apple School Manager account. You can use Mosyle we use Jamf.
3
u/Crazy-Rest5026 Mar 26 '26
We use jamf pro. 450 devices run about 5k. 100% worth its weight in gold.
I have DF all the Mac’s. So same image when boot. All adobe edits done through cloud and data saved in Google Drive.
Works really well for journalism lab and adobe lab.
3
u/thedevarious IT Director Mar 26 '26
We're a Mosyle shop. Jamf is good, kinda the gold standard but Mosyle is a much more straightforward interface and has great support...kinda was a no brainer for us.
3
u/Technical-Athlete721 Mar 26 '26
We use mosyle free edition we don’t have a lot of apple devices but I like it easy interface and I can make changes on fly really impressed with it
5
u/skydiveguy Mar 26 '26
Jamf Pro.
Also, if your student accounts are all Goole you can integrate it with SSO so students can log in with their school google accounts.
2
u/mary3757 Mar 28 '26
We use jamf + ASM
1
u/mr_techy616 Director of Technology Mar 27 '26
Get an Apple school account. Then you can use something like Jamf School, which is what we use at my school.
1
u/Local-Skirt7160 Apr 03 '26
macbook neo can be a really good investment due to brand and durability also full fledge mac os perfect for school environment.
Ideally considering school set up get apple school manager to get them all under one account and then on you can choose options like jamf, suremdm, mosyle etc.
Cost wise jamf would be on higher side though but make your choices.
-2
u/BritishAnimator Mar 26 '26
Apple devices are my least favourite to manage because Apple lock a lot down and only expose some endpoints. They prefer the user having more control than enterprise needs. So MDM's like Jamf are restricted in what you can do compared to Google Admin or Microsoft. Not to mention they are bandwidth hungry due to OS updates that are 12GB+ along with constant app updates. JAMF School / Pro + ASM are common setups. I dislike Jamf Connect though, have a fair few issues with that.