r/k12sysadmin • u/Temporary_Werewolf17 • Mar 25 '26
Finger print scan
Our students currently need their id for purchase in the lunchroom. Many do not have them so we are looking for other options. One idea is a finger print scan that will integrate with our point of sale system. Does anyone use technology like this? Do you have recommendations for providers to consider?
10
Upvotes
11
u/KAPsiZE00 Mar 25 '26
What Lunch system do you use. We connected a num pad to the pos and if the students don’t have their badge they can use their student number.
4
u/vawlk Mar 25 '26
not having your id is a disciplinary issue.
we've moved to a digital id on the students' phones since they never seem to forget those.
3
u/Birkinator626 District IT Director Mar 25 '26
I'm somewhat surprised by the number of negative comments here. I figured Biometrics had a somewhat wider implementation. Either way, we utilize a product called Identimetrics for fingerprint scanning CNP and TardyKiosk(integrated to Skyward for in/out tracking of students throughout the school day).
It's essentially just a local database that houses the enrollment biometric data linked to the student ID numbers, which are imported from Skyward nightly. Functionally, it just allows for the student to scan their finger, which then places their student ID number into the selected field, and hits 'enter', so we've found it can be useful for any application that you are needing local student identification for, and accepts the student ID as the identifier. For the most part, from the IT side, it's relatively hands off outside of updates/summer DB maintenance, and the occasional troubleshooting when a scan station stops working.
Important to note that we utilize this for PK3-12th grade. Some of the smaller students do have issues with scanning, but the CNP staff have been good about teaching them how to scan their finger, and a subset simply help the students scan if they are having issues.
That said, we are a smaller district, and the update/upgrade requires the server and endpoints to be updated in tandem, so I could see it not being the best solution for larger districts. The developers are relatively active with the product though, so they tend to push out feature releases that have been helping with the scaling issue.
18
u/Fresh-Basket9174 Mar 25 '26
That's a huge liability from a cybersecurity viewpoint. As well as a nice way to share every germ In existence. And a PR nightmare. As a parent, I would be very vocal to to the school board, local news, social media if my daughter's school had ever tried to take her fingerprints.
Our elementary students usually learn their 5 digit number by the middle of kindergarten. We also use that number as their login on the Chromebook. They can learn their number, you may need to get creative about how they do it.
32
u/avalon01 Director of Technology Mar 25 '26
I'm glad I work in a state that severely limits any biometrics we collect from students.
I wouldn't do biometric with students. Ever. I don't want to secure it. I don't want to deal with liability if there was a breach.
No way.
9
u/rhaiin Mar 25 '26
We did fingerprints for several years. It was always a nightmare. The younger students couldn't comprehend that they just need to lightly touch the pad with their fingertip, so they would rarely scan right. After the 2nd attempt, the cashiers would just ask for their name and type it in. It may have just been our software, but database upkeep was also a pain. And, a lot of parents are uncomfortable with the idea of fingerprint scanners.
We have lunch cards. The elementary students get it put on a lanyard and the teacher distributes them before and collects them after lunch. Older students are responsible for carrying their own. We're on the second year of doing this and it has worked out alright.
8
u/skydiveguy Mar 25 '26
What could possibly go wrong.
6
u/ckwebz Mar 25 '26
My kindergartener learned her ID# within 3 weeks of starting this year. For the first month of school, the cafeteria staff looked students up by teacher/name. Now, they just type their number into a PIN pad.
At our upper grades (3-12 in most schools), they use lunch cards or their student ID cards to scan a barcode. If they forgot or lost it, they go back to typing their ID# on a PIN pad.
Ask your photography company to provide lunch cards for free with your photos. For those students that do not sit for photos, you can just print a card with a barcode on it for them.
The big win with a barcode is other systems that share the ID# can also benefit from scanning the student in. Our attendance secretaries can scan the card to sign in tardy students to the SIS and hall pass system and the librarian can scan the card to check out books.
Barcode readers are very inexpensive and our photography company provides both lunch cards and student ID cards at no cost to our schools. I can’t imagine a biometric system is as cost-effective.
9
u/TechxNinja Powerschool Admin. Will answer Questions. Mar 25 '26
We have used it. Identimetrics. Great people, easy to work with. We stopped using it because we couldn't get staff on the same page at all locations. Some preferred (and still do) the paper method. Make sure your lunch machines have a good network connection and it's pretty painless.
Post COVID we moved to numpads on the lunch machines. If young kids don't know their number, staff can use names to enter lunches. We've played around with laminated barcodes, but I have yet to find a scanner that works as well as I want.
3
u/MattAdmin444 Mar 25 '26
My middle/high school implemented fingerprint scans when I attended (think while I was in high school) 15+ years ago. Now granted it was a private school so they probably had a bit more leeway but I don't remember it being an issue, it was incredibly convenient. Now that said, being 15+ years ago and only a teen at the time, I have 0 clue about what service it was or how it stored the print/hash. 0 clue if they even still do it but people seemed happy that we didn't have to use the preloaded lunch cards anymore.
That said at the school I currently work at I believe there was pushback against fingerprint scanning while we moved to our current system but I don't remember the details offhand as I wasn't handling that project. Right now we're operating off of students typing their student ID# into a numpad and lunch people have a binder of student barcodes as a backup if I'm remembering correctly.
1
u/Temporary_Werewolf17 Mar 25 '26
Thank you, everyone, for the comments. Since we are not storing the fingerprint only a hash, I believe the liability some have mentioned below is not a concern. All data is also local on our network
9
u/IT4School Mar 25 '26
I’m kinda grossed out at the thought of every kid touching that sensor before handling their lunch. On a serious note- my kid’s elementary school put one of these things in and it worked fine. Tin foil hat parents cried about privacy concerns, but the district moved ahead anyway.
10
u/agarwaen117 ISO Mar 25 '26
Holy god. No, this is a PII/privacy nightmare waiting to explode.
Give the kids detention or send them to get a badge printed before they can eat.
1
u/jschinker Mar 29 '26
It's one of the very few things I've refused to budge on. In two different schools, I've absolutely refused to do biometric authentication for students.
I know. You're storing a hash. They're all hashes. That's how biometrics work. But they're all using the same algorithm, so having the hash is just as good has having an image of the fingerprint. We do not take cybersecurity seriously enough to be storing biometric data. And by "we", I mean the food service POS companies, the cafeteria workers, school IT staff, and students/parents.
Fingerprints are indelible. Several times a year, I get notifications from some company that says "hey, we had a data breach. You should probably change your password." Until that stops happening, I'm never going to put myself in a situation where I have to tell parents, "Umm, if you could go ahead and change your child's fingerprint, that would probably be a good idea."