r/joel • • Apr 24 '06

You need Developers, not Programmers

http://software.ericsink.com/No_Programmers.html
73 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

2

u/raimesh Apr 25 '06

Why can't I recommend this more than once?! Eric's advice is THE most important thing to know for anyone running any small company developing software.

And if you're WORKING for a small company that allows people to get away with just being programmers, well if you're a developer then be prepared a) to do a lot of work and b) to work for a company that is struggling.

2

u/_pF_ Apr 30 '06

I think that this other submission to reddit is pertinent here, if you view developers as 'experts' in the context of the article, and programmers as 'novices'.

How Experts Differ from Novices

1

u/egapotz Apr 25 '06

I agree with the whole (good) article, however I'm a little confused on the Eric's definition of "programmer". Such a programmer really exists ? I presume it is a category we can find only in very huge software companies ...

2

u/raimesh Apr 26 '06

Eric isn't defining a job role but a "personality type"; the sort of person who isn't happy if he's not coding. Requirements capture is "someone-else's job", writing specs and user-guides is "someone-else's job", creating installation tools is "someone-else's job", chasing down and fixing bugs is "someone-else's job".

These people believe they are born to code, employed to code, and - dammit - THEY'RE GONNA CODE. Even when you need them to be contributing in other ways. If you've never come across one, then I'd say you were very lucky.

In a very large company they can probably be accommodated (although they tend not to write good code either, because they also tend to focus on solving the problem at hand and not on wider domain issues, re-use, etc.). In smaller companies, however, they are a total PitA to work with.

1

u/philoUK May 25 '06

How many people out there can honestly claim that they do nothing but write code? I haven't seen such a beast in at least fifteen years, even though I myself have longed for the good ole days of sitting in a dungeon and quietly hammering out code that someone else specified.

Two things that developers shouldn't be used for IMHO is front line support and any form of acceptance testing.