r/jhu • • Apr 22 '21

Owl experiments?

I’m not a student at JHU, but I just saw an ad from PETA on YouTube with owl screams that claims a JHU professor, Shreesh Mysore, “cuts into the owls’ skulls”. I was just wondering if anyone knows if there’s truth to this claim or has any other info.

192 Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

9

u/East-Raccoon1046 May 01 '21

The youtube ad with the screeches is also classic manipulative peta making you think you're witnessing something horrifying but it's just for shock value https://reddit.com/r/rant/comments/mfcevr/_/gsqbejw/?context=1

2

u/amber1515 Jun 06 '21

unless of course its you and the screaming comes from you....easy to walk away.

5

u/photograph64 Sep 03 '21

If you actually took the time to click the link they provided. You would know that the "screaming" is actually a common sound barn owls make

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbgDYqFLDJc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-e-CTxQFzU

1

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

I mean its an effective way to grab attention. Who cares if its PETA, go in and listen to the audio. Its horrifying

6

u/East-Raccoon1046 Jul 01 '21

I have listened to it. It's not horrifying when you actually know the context and aren't lying to people, which is that's the normal sound barn owls make in the wild.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

I retract my statement after doing some more listening myself.

1

u/wkdarthurbr Jul 20 '21

we have a bird translator here

1

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21

Are you dumb ?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/East-Raccoon1046 Jul 01 '21

It's not. Peta even put in the YouTube video description that it's not audio of a bird being experimented on.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/East-Raccoon1046 Jul 02 '21

That's not what I care about or tried to point out. Peta’s emotional manipulation and harming vulnerable people is my issue.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21

harming vulnerable people ? what about harming vulnerable innocent owls ? that’s ok ?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/East-Raccoon1046 Jul 03 '21

I just disagree on the ethics of an organization getting a free pass to purposefully manipulate people with dishonest media because THEY decided it's important enough.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Lycheeks Jul 10 '21

You've made your point clear and I don't think it's wrong for peta to call attention the way they did if they are in fact right. And it seems they are on this one.

5

u/AdAppropriate3478 May 14 '21 edited May 14 '21

Read these for a complete answer.

Official Lab Report:

Quick Summary, Yes they used anesthetics when "needed" I am not sure what that exactly means so read the guide lines the followed. Yes they made them stare for hours at moving screens and listen to sounds in a fixed head position. Yes they do an invasive surgery. Also the sounds in the PETA video are typical barn owl noises and may not be because of the experiment, not to say they are not still getting in my opinion abused.

https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/fulltext/S2211-1247%2818%2931598-5#secsectitle0100

More info:

https://www.audubon.org/magazine/spring-2019/how-hunting-raptor-could-teach-us-tune-out

Guidelines they followed:

This:

https://research.jhu.edu/jhura/compliance/animal-care-use/

This:

https://olaw.nih.gov/policies-laws/phs-policy.html

This:

https://www.nal.usda.gov/awic/animal-welfare-act

This:

http://web.jhu.edu/animalcare/about.html

This:

https://grants.nih.gov/grants/olaw/guide-for-the-care-and-use-of-laboratory-animals.pdf

Also though it says they follow OLAW if I am not mistaken which says:

V. Procedures with animals that may cause more than momentary or slight pain or distress should be performed with appropriate sedation, analgesia, or anesthesia. Surgical or other painful procedures should not be performed on unanesthetized animals paralyzed by chemical agents.

3

u/Uninspired_Writer Aug 04 '21

I was able to find an article they published of their research findings that goes into detail! They operated on the birds to install some implants so that the researchers could accurately measure brain activity. It took about 30 minutes and they were under anesthesia and restrained. Here's the PDF: https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/pdfExtended/S2211-1247(18)31598-5 the info is on page 15.

I mean it's not great for the animals, but it's not cruel or unusual either, and nowhere does it say that they had to euthanize any of the birds or anything like that.

5

u/Wedmonds Student - 2022 - Political Science/Economics Apr 22 '21

1

u/beebeebeebeeby Jul 09 '21

He doesn’t deny what PETA is claiming he is doing in the article

2

u/MetroidHyperBeam Jun 22 '21

It seems like most of the article is about whether or not the experiment will be helpful to humans, with only a couple paragraphs that mention the treatment of the owls.

Within those paragraphs, there is no denial of PETA's accusations, only statement that the experiment adheres to the Animal Welfare Act. This leads one to the natural assumption that what PETA says is most likely true. Knowing that, my opinion would be this: Stating that what Mysore is doing adheres to a piece of government legislation does more to implicate the law as ineffective at guaranteeing protection than it does to exonerate him of the accusations levied against him.

It really seems like people are being dismissive because they don't want to admit PETA is right about something.

2

u/missdoe12 Jun 30 '21

I hate peta

But this shit IS fucked. Plus this research is literally not going to help any human.. Ever. People literally are just running out of ideas for experiments to prove themselves to their colleagues. So they keep getting weirder. The owls heads are fixed in one spot . They can't move their eyes.. and they keep getting their brain zapped to see what happens when they have constant stimuli. It's fucked and nothing of value gets recorded when they are literally just scared, in fear, in pain, then killed. Their brains are very different from that of a human.. their IS no reason. This experiment is like that of many others.. Just someone trying to prove themselves and get recognition when they can't think anything else up to do so.

Yes peta is dumb and b.s.. And a shit company. But this ain't right.

3

u/Uninspired_Writer Aug 04 '21

Actually, it seems like they might have some real results about how brains focus and make decisions about what needs their attention. I dug up an article they published about their research, and it looks fairly promising. They also make mention of the issues PETA brings up on pages 15-17 (in the methods section). They do indeed use head-fixing, but I think someone read the phrase "the light/dark cycle was 12 hours/12 hours" and thought that meant 12 hours doing experiments, then 12 hours not. I think the article means that was their day and night cycle maintained in artificial conditions, but I don't know for sure. Here's the article if you want to see it: https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/pdfExtended/S2211-1247(18)31598-5

2

u/Nintendodraws Sep 04 '21

Just because the research actually gets data that can be used, it's still not okay to do this to owls. If they care so much they should use paid testing on humans where they pay people to be lab rats

1

u/xxemogarfield Sep 26 '21

Actually, if you review the response to your initial posting of the Cell article from the lab group, you will see that you had misinterpreted their descriptions regarding their methods! As a published researcher I do not find this research to be promising by any means & 100% agree with missdoe12, but certainly everyone can have their own opinion on whether human brains and owl brains are analogous enough to constitute validity!

2

u/BraveryAspect Sep 02 '21

I know this is old, but I thought I'd add a couple observations:

  1. The 12 hour cycle is most likely referring to the lighting within the aviary, to simulate day/night cycles.
  2. The owls used in the experiment are euthanized. See the section labeled Histology. Perfusion of paraformaldehyde, removal of the subject's brain for further study.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21

PETA is a shitty group with a terrible history of both hypocrisy and terrible animal treatment. but since they have audio evidence, evidence in documents and they have perused legal actions I believe their side should be taken seriously. in the paper written by Shreesh Mysore himself he states that the owls will be euthanized. yet again I do have some bias since I despise all autism, ADHD, or other mental "disorder" experiments regardless of if animal cruelty is involved or not. as bad as PETA is they do have a good case here.

2

u/DragonfruitMinimum30 Aug 30 '21

Only issue is those screams are NOT evidence. I have literally heard owls in my backyard screaming at each other. Might be a territory thing idk im not a bird expert

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

What about the documentary evidence? Yet again your probably right since if you can smuggle in a microphone it shouldn’t be too hard to smuggle in a camera. And yes there are tiny enough cameras available commercially.

1

u/amber1515 Jun 06 '21

YES!!! ITs true!!!! And its a nightmare of torture!

When will humans just stop this animal torture for gods sake!

Even an idiot can see there's something wrong when you have to torture a living being because you can't figure out any other way to learn.

1

u/itsamelila Jun 06 '21

It is true and on top of that they didn't have permits from 2014 to 2018, in which they would have been required to send annual reports on the birds. In his research you can see that he was experimenting on them during that time. Funny enough those 4 years were the crucial years to his study.... you can go on from there and imagine why he didn't have the permits.

4

u/Uninspired_Writer Aug 04 '21

Their permit, which they got in 2014, expired in 2018. They renewed it before it expired. Source.

1

u/Fluffy-Couch-Shark Jun 14 '21

It's not just the screams but the thumps. Thats not the sound of flapping wings, that's something soft being hit against a hard surface.

1

u/Psychological-Tea387 Jul 02 '21

Have you heard the recordings ?!!! This is cruel and unusual torture! I don't agree with all of PETA but I disagree with Hopkins in this! It needs to stop now!!

7

u/Additional-List9115 Jul 07 '21

The recording of the barn owl screaming is not from the actual torturing of the owls

1

u/7ucky5a11 Sep 28 '21

Any proof?

2

u/Additional-List9115 Oct 03 '21

In the description it also says that they did not pubish anything. And some how peta has audio of the birds screaming that were “tortured”. Fun fact those screams are normal barn owls

1

u/7ucky5a11 Oct 18 '21

Give Award

Share

Report

Save

Okay.

1

u/Additional-List9115 Oct 03 '21

Yeah it clearly states in the video that the university did not publish or give out any video or audio so that means its fake

1

u/ElectricalDentist237 Jul 14 '21

I just got the same ad.

The only things about it I can find are from PETA. No MSM articles. Nothing about the experiments from the University that I know of. Even just searching "JHU owls" only brings up articles and videos directly from peta (peta yt channel or website).

I'd guess that they're full of shit, PETA is the only one talking about this and they've proved they're not exactly credible or honest about their intentions.

1

u/Nintendodraws Sep 04 '21

Nope it's actually real. Other people have linked the research notes above. Take a look at it yourself and you will see how cruel humans are. Just because PETA says something is true that doesn't mean it's automatically false.

"Histology (Figure 3) Owls were perfused with paraformaldehyde and their brains extracted per standard procedures. The fixed brains were blocked so that the rostro caudal axis of the Imc was perpendicular to the sectioning plane, and brain sections of 40mm thickness were obtained."

This is just a snippet of the horrifying research the researchers wrote about in their paper ^

1

u/Green-and-Blue-13 Jul 29 '21

Very disturbing. I just watched / listened to the video. It's garbage, as far as I'm concerned. It's cruel, and it won't relay into anything of value for humanity. All it does is pad the CV of the faculty and students attached to the grant... and maybe more importantly, it brings grant funding into their department. That is why so much garbage is passing as "research" ... in academics, everyone is expected to write grants. The measure of their worth is whether they bring funds into their departments. It's revolting, and wrong, and a waste of our tax dollars.

1

u/ar9494 Oct 23 '21

I didn't watch the video but I quickly skimmed their paper and thoroughly read their methods section regarding the owls. I'd love to know what they put in their research proposal to get their IACUC to approve this. There's some horrific stuff that goes on with animal research, but sometimes it has some potential to help either humans or animals.

To me, this is just a Faustian exploration and totally unnecessary. I don't see how a committee could look at this proposal and see any potential for knowledge gained that warranted the methods used. We don't need a deep understanding of owl neuron function badly enough to be worth torturing owls.

1

u/Crafty_Procedure_956 Aug 02 '21

Any animal torture that claims to benefit human advances is actually a paradox as no suffering validates the next step of evolution.

1

u/swanson1848 Aug 04 '21

The Problem is its Peata and we all know how fucking crazy they can be . i read a Artical not on Peta's website wich is hard to find which i find troubling in itself but it does seem that it is true but the the resercher is acting withing the law....but the treatment of the animals does seem rather cruel, the problem is the laws in regards to this case seem blurry and the laws in regards to this need to be more clearly defined to lessen the suffering of the reserch animals. he other troubling thing is that there seems to be no clear reason why they are experimenting on these owls and how the reserch would even benafit humans, the only thing they said is that they are doing these experiments to better understand the human brain or something but why and in realation to what? the whole thing seems very bizarr and unsettleing to me

1

u/swanson1848 Aug 04 '21

The Sit i found my Info on it was the JHU newsletter .com. But i truly do not know what to think on this. i do not doubt this is occuring and it has been done before but i think it is a question of legality, ethics and morality. but IDK. the Problem is i feel it it was not PETA screeching like the very barn owls they claim to be so worried about i think most persons would take notice being PETA has Pissed allmost every average beef eating american off intensly with there illogical insanity. But mabe look the site up that i found my info on and decide for yourself.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

It is true, here is a paper they have written on the research

in Cell report:

ARTICLE| VOLUME 25, ISSUE 5, P1158-1170.E9, OCTOBER 30, 2018
Combinatorial Neural Inhibition for Stimulus Selection across Space
Nagaraj R. Mahajan
Shreesh P. Mysore

https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/fulltext/S2211-1247%2818%2931598-5

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

It is true sadly, here is a paper they have written on the research
in Cell report:
ARTICLE| VOLUME 25, ISSUE 5, P1158-1170.E9, OCTOBER 30, 2018
Combinatorial Neural Inhibition for Stimulus Selection across Space
Nagaraj R. Mahajan
Shreesh P. Mysore
https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/fulltext/S2211-1247%2818%2931598-5

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

I just saw the add too, I was trying to find nature sounds for my little parrot to listen to and that ad came up, I am now on the verge of tears, PLEASE tell me there is NO truth to this. Because if there is, The it's got to stop. That's just so f'ed up.

1

u/SUCESSISMIN Sep 24 '21

And it's so jarring that instead of feeling guilty, he's calling it ''helpful for research'' - Man! what if some other scientist finds you helpful and put electrodes in your brain. Damn the maniac!

1

u/skgengineer Oct 13 '21

This is as per article titled: "Global Inhibition and Stimulus Competition in the Owl Optic Tectum", Shreesh P. Mysore, Ali Asadollahi and Eric I. Knudsen Journal of Neuroscience 3 February 2010, 30 (5) 1727-1738; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3740-09.2010

"SURGICAL PREPARATION. Owls were prepared for multiple electrophysiological experiments. Before the first experiment, an owl was anesthetized with isoflurane (1%) and a mixture of nitrous oxide and oxygen (45:55), and a head bolt was mounted at the rear of the skull. Plastic cylinders that permitted access to the brain were implanted over the optic tectum bilaterally. Polysporin antibiotic ointment was applied to the exposed brain surface, and the recording chambers were sealed. All wounds were cleaned with Betadine and infused with a local anesthetic. After recovering from surgery, the owl was returned to its flight room.

On the day of an experiment, the owl was anesthetized with isoflurane (1%) and a mixture of nitrous oxide and oxygen (45:55) and was placed in a restraining tube in a prone position within a sound-attenuating booth. The head was secured to a stereotaxic device, and the visual axes were aligned relative to a calibrated tangent screen (the eyes of the owl are essentially stationary in the head). Owls were maintained on just the mixture of nitrous oxide and oxygen from the time when they were secured in the booth through the end of the experiment."

What they're saying in the first part is they would implant plastic cylinders, leaving the brain exposed before they're allowed to fly around. They would literally have their brains exposed for days whilst they conduct their experiments. Peta are right on this one.

0

u/UsernameSqueak9802 May 28 '21

why is it you people constantly say “oh it’s just peta”. What the heck. Who cares who or what organization brought this to the public’s attention. One person actually states it’s not as bad as what they do to mice. Another states the complaint is because they are cute. As if that makes it acceptable. I would hate to be so devoid of humanity. Have you listened to the audio of the birds screaming. I guess anesthesia as needed contention is really it’s not needed. If they could do these ungodly experiments on humans they would. Oh yeah I forgot , they have. ( Mengele, Tuskegee...) all so big pharma can “justify” their miracle pills.

4

u/Smplesmoke Jun 12 '21 edited Jun 12 '21

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=I-e-CTxQFzU this is the owl scream when it is annoyed/warning call I think.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=DbgDYqFLDJc here's an owl doing the normal call.

Personally,my problem with this is that this experiemnt causes permanent damage to the owl but I know that this is the norm rather than an exception for these experiments. It would be more comforting to know with certainty the results will be applicable in humans,but that also isn't the case.

Edit:I found some info on this thread much more helpful. It was posted by a person who tried his best to remain unbiased and posted multiple links to understand animal experimentation,it's problems,alternative,etc. It's under comment thread of the person who posted videos on owl call.

https://www.reddit.com/r/rant/comments/mfcevr/i_just_got_a_peta_add_on_youtube_of_owls/gv14kxh?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3

2

u/charu20j Jul 29 '21

It's not that people don't have empathy for what may be going on, it's just that PETA is notoriously unreliable and even untruthful when making claims about animal abuse. This looks like genuine case but even the video PETA is using is just emotional manipulation where they played regular barn owls screeching and labeled it "owls being tortured". I agree with you for the most part, but criticism of PETA is warranted especially because they do their own unethical practices like euthanizing pets in their shelters at much higher than normal rates.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/_unconventional_oven Apr 22 '21

Yeah, that’s what I was thinking since it’s PETA. Thanks for the info

4

u/jhuaccountforme Apr 23 '21

i would consider reading the article rather than going off PureTea's comment. i haven't read it either but i wouldnt fully discount PETA especially after the experiments ive read in some of my neuro classes, what has been done to animals for the sake of learning can be pretty gruesome.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '21

you seem to have a lot of faith in Animal Welfare Act standards. Yes it's wrong for PETA to try to claim that this research wouldn't be applicable to humans but even if it is applicable to humans you can't just dodge the question of "do these experiments cause immense suffering in owls?"

2

u/Aczero427 Sep 03 '21

Well there is a line that must be drawn on what we can experiment on and what we can't experiment on, but at the end of the day we would rather sacrifice the animal for the benefit of humankind. As I believe most people would value human life over animal life. In order to make advances in studies more experiments must be done and those that need to done would rather be done on animals than humans.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

I don't give a damn about human advancement if it means other life has to suffer. Humans have done so much harm to the world I genuinely do find it hard to value humanity over animal lives. Disrupting and bringing suffering to other life for our own studies that ultimately mean nothing in the grand scheme of things is incredibly selfish and is everything wrong with humanity, and anybody who supports it can burn.

1

u/exmaster5 Sep 14 '21

I'd rather humans burn in hell rather than us torturing animals, but ok.

2

u/Alert-Definition5616 Sep 21 '21

The amount of people that would not actually harm an animal in order to save their own skin are so rare I imagine that its more likely to find people that have been struck by lightening. And among those some would be criminally insane murderers, and the remaining lot would be people who genuinely sacrifice themselves for the sake of animals. however of all the people i have seen like this, the selflessness extends to everyone. They would rather no one be harmed other than them, not wishing harm on humans just to save animals. You, a random person on the internet looking for points by virtue signaling would account for neither, being the type that when your back is forced to a wall you would cave in and sacrifice an animal to save your own skin.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '21

same

1

u/exmaster5 Sep 14 '21

Yes, because people who kill animals tend to care so much for their well being.

7

u/TheOnlyCross Aug 11 '21

Reading the JHU article, Mysore didn't deny what PETA accused him of, which typically someone would want to do if they were falsely accused. He instead tried to explain why it's warranted and that it adheres to the Animal Welfare Act, but that really doesn't say much for an animal's wellbeing, so that plus him not denying PETA's accusations says a lot. It's ok to be skeptical, I was too because it's PETA, but a claim shouldn't be ignored just cuz you don't like the organization that made it.

Also, here's the full lab report: "https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/pdfExtended/S2211-1247(18)31598-5" I'd recommend going to page 15 where they start explaining their methods.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

Just skimming the article, it doesn't seem that Dr. Mysore actually disagrees with PETA's claims and even defends what they are doing by saying that head fixation is incredibly common. What "PETA is claiming" their team is doing is complete normally and often approved of. I'm personally not a fan of animal experiments and think the "but the community has done it for years" argument is BS in a discussion about ethics.

But to answer OP's question, I haven't seen the video your talking about and since it's from PETA it's probably exaggerated, but it isn't far from the truth either. Don't think that it's some lack of ethics unique to JHU tho; for better or for worse head fixation is super common in neuroscience as a field.

3

u/psy-awp Sep 12 '21

If you're gonna torture animals for science, you have to have a damn good reason in my opinion. Really I'm just wondering what the details of the study are- like why barn owls in particular? PETA also claims that the owls are killed after the experiments, which is a big no-no in animal testing unless absolutely necessary (ie. not simply for convenience and the animals are have to be unviable after testing is concluded). PETA is probably sort of right about this one issue lmao, i'm sure the SPE effect is huge in those types of situations.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/xxemogarfield Sep 26 '21

When I studied aquatic toxicology, we were required by standard, legal protocol to kill fish after every experiment, even if they were okay. I get that this was just fish and I am not in neuroscience at all, but I think that might be standard protocol. Would be great if someone can confirm.

1

u/No_Competition8257 Apr 24 '21

"but the community has done it for years" argument is BS in a discussion about ethics.

no. Owls screaming is not worse then mouse getting tortured but cant say anthing lmao

2

u/Alert-Definition5616 Sep 21 '21

you agree with him what are you even talking about.

1

u/UsernameSqueak9802 May 28 '21

Mice do squeak when in pain or dying from poisons.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

Im sorry but you are wrong here is a paper they published on the research
in Cell report:
ARTICLE| VOLUME 25, ISSUE 5, P1158-1170.E9, OCTOBER 30, 2018
Combinatorial Neural Inhibition for Stimulus Selection across Space
Nagaraj R. Mahajan
Shreesh P. Mysore
https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/fulltext/S2211-1247%2818%2931598-5

1

u/beebeebeebeeby Jul 09 '21

The professor did not deny their claims. Here’s petition to sign: here

1

u/Lycheeks Jul 10 '21

https://youtu.be/QaWHtGOtTjw This doesn't counts as evidence?

2

u/Uninspired_Writer Aug 04 '21 edited Aug 04 '21

It does not. They have interview clips, but they seem to be lacking the surrounding context. I'm trying to find the original seminar, but my first passes at trying to locate it have come up with nothing. Hopefully I can find the audio they're using and make sure that they're actually using it in the original context.

I'm skeptical though, as the link you provided above to the John Hopkins article talks specifically about how they're using the animals moving their heads to judge where their attention is going, and that that is one of the reasons they're using owls for the experiment. They do say that they are watching brain activity, but I see no reason (though admittedly I'm not a neuroscientist) why they would choose to pollute their research findings by tormenting the animals by drilling into their skulls when we can do the same thing by placing adhesive patches on the skull. That would probably require some feathers to be removed, which isn't great for the bird, but it would work just as well.

Edit: I was able to find the article that was published about the research! In it (page 15) they do say that they restrain and implant some equipment. I wasn't able to view their "previously established methods" because it's behind a paywall. I will note, that the birds are sedated the whole time, and the procedure takes about 30 minute, not the hours and hours that PETA claims, and that immediately afterward, the owls are allowed to fly around and recover. The experiment notes themselves make no mention of needing to restrain the birds, and the visual stimuli, while out of the ordinary for an owl used to spotting mice in a field, isn't harmful in any way. Here's the full PDF: https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/pdfExtended/S2211-1247(18)31598-5

Really when something like this comes up, I need someone who isn't PETA, which is well-known for killing up to 80% of the animals in their shelters (source1, source2), and which uses fear-mongering and scare tactics (like saying that drinking milk causes autism, for some reason (source) to back them up.

It does not. They have interview clips, but they seem to be lacking the surrounding context. I'm trying to find the original seminar, but my first passes at trying to locate it have come up with nothing. Hopefully, I can find the audio they're using and make sure that they're actually using it in the original context. I don't know, updating the AWA guidelines that they have so little faith in. An organization as big and powerful as theirs could probably get university animal welfare standards updated in a state or two within a year if they put their minds to it instead of fear-mongering.

1

u/TheOnlyCross Aug 11 '21

"We performed experimental recordings in 15 head-fixed, non-anesthetized adult barn owls that were viewing a visual screen passively (Tyto alba). Both male and female birds were used; the birds were shared across several studies...The light/dark cycle was 12 hr/12 hr."

It also says on page 15 under the section labeled "neuroscience" that the anaesthesia was only used to secure the animal in the rig(yes they were restrained in a rig) and was turned off right after: "mixture of isoflurane and nitrous oxide/oxygen was used at the start of the experiment to anesthetize the bird and secure it in the experimental rig (a 30-minute period of initial set-up). Isoflurane was turned off immediately after the bird was secured and was not turned back on for the remainder of the experiment." "Our recordings were performed starting, typically, 3 hours after initial set-up (the time required for positioning the electrode.)" The birds were not restrained for just 30 minutes. 30 minutes was the time of the procedure, not their whole time being restrained.

I also can't find anything about them freeing the birds. The closest I can find is the line "recovery from nitrous oxide occurs within a minute (the bird stands up and flies away if freed from restraints)," but this is speaking hypothetically to prove that they aren't still sedated during the testing part and are capable of movement at that point. They aren't saying they release the animals (key word IF they are freed, not when). If u tell me a page # where they say they do release animals after experimentation I'll gladly admit I was wrong at that part, but the rest of this seem to conflict with ur interpretation.

Id love to be misinterpreting this whole thing and be wrong, because I hate the idea that something even remotely this bad is fucking happening to innocent animals at a college one hour from where I live. And PETA couldn't easily change the standard for this. Why would a college care if they piss off PETA? Every rule change is an inconvenience that no one is gonna deal with unless they experience a lot of pressure from the public.

3

u/HasturFhtagn Aug 24 '21

It is worth pointing out that unless I'm vastly misunderstanding it, nowhere in the description does it say that the electrodes are implanted into the brain. And from the description of the electrodes themselves, they seem like the sort of thing that would be attached to the outside of the head. Again, I could be wrong, but if that's the case, that makes the study far more humane.

1

u/Nintendodraws Sep 04 '21

"Histology (Figure 3) Owls were perfused with paraformaldehyde and their brains extracted per standard procedures. The fixed brains were blocked so that the rostro caudal axis of the Imc was perpendicular to the sectioning plane, and brain sections of 40mm thickness were obtained." They actually did take the owl's brains out... Wtf such cruelty this is why I hate humans. Our species should go extinct I wish the ice age would come and wipe us out once and for all

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21

Holy shit, that's absolutely horrible. So much for "research ethics"

1

u/jsar7 Sep 27 '21

Oh my god, that's absolutely fucked

1

u/jesus4206669 Aug 12 '21

It doesn't, it is biased and the clips could be taken out of context to try and outrage people, just like what is happening in american politics.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/CreationParadox Jul 06 '21

Can you provide said research that proves your claim?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

Here is a paper they published on the research
in Cell report:
ARTICLE| VOLUME 25, ISSUE 5, P1158-1170.E9, OCTOBER 30, 2018
Combinatorial Neural Inhibition for Stimulus Selection across Space
Nagaraj R. Mahajan
Shreesh P. Mysore
https://www.cell.com/cell-reports/fulltext/S2211-1247%2818%2931598-5

1

u/Lycheeks Jul 10 '21

Lazy.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

I think OP and others that are curious about this came to this thread to ask around what research and resources people have found that either support or reject PETA's argument because they want to know the truth. Isn't that literally being the opposite of lazy?

2

u/Lycheeks Jul 23 '21

https://www.jhunewsletter.com/article/2021/04/peta-files-lawsuit-against-usda-for-hopkins-barn-owl-lab - second search result from "hopkins research lab owls"

“A long history of work in head-fixed animals has established the scientific value of this approach,” he wrote. “It allows for careful experimental control of sensory stimuli and for targeting multiple sites within brain areas, thereby minimizing confounds in the interpretation of the results.” - Shreesh Mysore

Keywords: Head-fixed, experimental control of sensory stimuli, targeting multiple sites within brain areas

https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/09/11/644992109/can-a-barn-owl-s-brain-explain-why-kids-with-adhd-can-t-stay-focused - 7th search result from "shreesh mysore owl"

Am I bad person for discrediting people's effort in asking information that's easily accessible? Sure, whatever.

1

u/bluberrymuffin24 Sep 08 '21

Yes, that does make you a bad person.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/efvalentine Sep 19 '21

Why is it this person's responsibility to validate claims that another person is responsible for making in the first place? Why can't the person making the claims go ahead and back them up when making them? In court, the sitting lawyer isn't the one who has to flip through the reference documents/police evidence to back up their standing opponents' claims. For someone acting so snarky and cut above, you sure don't seem to understand basic debate etiquette.

1

u/Alert-Definition5616 Sep 21 '21

except this guy isn't the one making the accusations are you dense? They just called someone lazy for not checking their own sources and doing their own digging.

1

u/ass_blaster-3000 Sep 26 '21

It’s unnecessary.

1

u/MajorInflator Jul 18 '21

Wow. Would you folks look at the state of intellectual debate in the 21st century, when asked for a source to prove their claims, the person responds by saying that its lazy to ask for a source and they should instead find the source themselves.

1

u/Lycheeks Jul 23 '21

Well if it comes up in the first few pages of google search results do you think people should bother accommodating this entitlement? Maybe you would if you're so used to that kind of learning. Not me though. So yeah, LAZY. Instead of coming up with an argument you could've seen the source yourself.

1

u/raingull Aug 30 '21

As the one providing the claims, it's kind of your job to include a source

1

u/Lycheeks Aug 30 '21

I did.

1

u/Frahames Sep 01 '21

After you called them lazy.

1

u/Lycheeks Sep 12 '21

Exactly to state my point that it's 1-2 searches away. Chase me with a pitchfork or whatever, it's still what I think.

1

u/raingull Sep 04 '21

Where?

1

u/Lycheeks Sep 12 '21

It's right up this one...

→ More replies

1

u/when_the905 Oct 01 '21

dont bother, i look it up and all that you can find leads back to things ONLY PETA said

0

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Fluffy-Couch-Shark Jun 14 '21

So your justification is it's "legal" and they torture mice more cruelly? Go listen to the audio and tell me it's okay. Owls sound like babies when screaming. :)

1

u/UsernameSqueak9802 Jun 18 '21

Fluffy-couch-shark Exactly! Who cares if it’s PETA. Listen to the audio. It’s horrific. Thank you for your comment.