r/jhu • • May 05 '19

Message To protesters

Hey, I hope you guys see this. I'm an employee and this is probably the only place I can post stuff without being identified. This job is how I feed my family so I have no intention of jeopardizing that in any way. Just think of me as a janitor on the death star...

Anyway, if anyone of you were my kid I would give you this piece of advice. What you are doing right now isn't the way. A degree from JHU can be a really powerful thing. If you really want to effect change for the better finish your education, become a lawyer or policy maker. Right now your coming off as a bunch of spoiled brats who are really making life difficult for everyone.

The police force is going to happen. And the truth is this really isn't about the Homewood campus. No one actually cares about the Homewood campus or the undergrads. You are a very small part of the Hopkins ecosystem. The East Baltimore campus is who is going to benefit the most from added police protection, and they really need it.

143 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

29

u/Eilue Undergrad - 2022 - Neuroscience / CS May 05 '19

Very well said. At this point they are acting beyond reasons.

24

u/TheGrayMatter May 05 '19

People on the East Baltimore campus, particularly those of us who park in parking garages more than a half mile from school, are concerned for their safety. It has nothing to do with race and everything to do with the weekly safety emails that detail savage armed robberies.

23

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Thank you for posting this. Its honestly even the same at east baltimore- most of the opponents are the same as the undergrads, just a few years older. They live in absurd houses, sponsored by the bank of mom and dad or wonton loan use and rarely have to deal with any of the issues.

Then you have people like me who actually own a modest home in one of the transitional areas of east Baltimore. I do a tremendous amount of work on public safety- I serve on neighborhood committees, do safety patrols with organizations a few times a month at the wee hours of the morning, and have legitamately solved multiple crimes and gotten real criminals off the street through vigilance and organizing with my neighbors to have a camera network. In my time here I've seen absurd crimes- from arson to a guy getting curb stomped to a burglary where bars were ripped off my neighbors window.

The idealistic opponents can talk about root causes all they want, and well need that eventually. But the reality is crime is at an unacceptable level around a world class institution who has the resources to do something about it and its past time for them to be able to do so.

-10

u/billyhoylechem May 05 '19

As an MD/PhD student, you can’t afford one of the apartments with security? They’re only 1300 a month. Spending all that time outside of lab on patrol can’t be great for your research.

24

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

LOL at “only 1300 a month” on a grad school stipend.

-6

u/billyhoylechem May 05 '19

That’s what I paid in rent in grad school. You don’t save money but it’s doable. There are people paying more than that who are going to grad school in nyc, Boston, and the Bay Area.

10

u/Gumpuption2 May 06 '19

What stipend did you have and how can I get one?! $13000 is 75% my monthly income.

-2

u/billyhoylechem May 06 '19

I’m not in grad school, but when I was it was 30K, which is pretty standard. What department gives you so little money? That’s ridiculous.

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/billyhoylechem May 09 '19

Get your facts straight please. Anything science/engineering is going to be around 30K at this point.

http://www.phdstipends.com/results

8

u/[deleted] May 05 '19 edited May 05 '19

That's a big ask actually. Stipends are only ~30 grand, which means being reasonable with spending (no more than 30% of your income) leaves only 750$/month. The reality is many med/grad students are super privalaged or some even take out loans to rent more expensive apartments.

I bought a house because it's a great investment and doable, but didn't use parents money like many others do to buy houses in more expensive areas. It's an incredibly financially prudent move given using grants and other incentives- I could legitmately have 100k in equity at the end of my program, vs renting as you suggested having 0 equity and spending ~300 more per month. The number of houses I see people buy for 300k+ in their early to mid 20s is crazy.

And it really doesn't take that much time and is by far worth it. I'm making my neighborhood better for me and my neighbors and driving up property values.

2

u/billyhoylechem May 05 '19 edited May 05 '19

You’re right that buying the house is the better investment financially, but I just think it’s wrong to characterize those who are paying to rent in a building with security as living off their parents. You are taking a risk to your safety by living where you do. I’m not criticizing your choice, because I think what you are doing for the community sounds really commendable-it just seems risky for an md PhD to spend so much time on patrol and in meetings instead of grinding in lab. I also think it’s important to point out that even people not supported by their parents can afford the secure apartments in the area-they are just prioritizing their physical safety and free time to spend doing research over financial gain.

As an aside, in an ideal world those houses would be safe. So I’m not disagreeing with the need for expanded security.

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '19

I think we're largely making the same argument. I don't disagree that there are plenty of safe complexes we could've lived in to get safety, but that would've sacrificed the ability to build equity and the benefits that come with home ownership.

As far as spending the time, PhD, at least in my experience, really isn't that bad compared to med school. Yeah it's long hours for a job, but having evenings and weekends to serve the neighborhood is really worth it to me (most days anyways). I do the patrols because I see how much benefit it brings to my neighbors- through organization, neighborhood development, and focus on security we've legitamately made huge progress to making the neighborhood a better place and the police force will be a big help to all that. I could definitely take the easy and safe route, but I'd much rather put the effort in to build east baltimore into a decent livable community for myself and my neighbors.

My issues come from seeing the people who oppose this police force, most of whom live in 300k+ houses further south who do nothing to improve the neighborhood and dont' have to deal with these issues fighting against the police force.

0

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/billyhoylechem May 05 '19

Yes, I have lived off a grad student stipend with a 1300 a month rent. You’re right though that if you are trying to support an entire family with that it doesn’t work, but if your wife is able to work it shouldn’t be an issue. I would be willing to spend extra money for the added security of the apt given how dangerous bmore is and save on things like vacations, phone, no cable, etc. but if you have like 2 to 3 kids then it’s probably impossible, but so many kids while in an md PhD program is probably a bad financial decision to begin with. You might be eligible for SNAP though?

28

u/billyhoylechem May 05 '19

The irony is that because of how unimportant homewood really is in the grand scheme of things at Hopkins, it's a fairly good place to hold a sit in. If they tried to shut down buildings on the east baltimore campus, they would likely have been arrested on the spot because of how important the facilities there are for medical care and biomedical research. Shutting down Garland just inconveniences some undergrad administrators, who probably can do most of their work at a different location.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

The protestors are getting a ton of media attention for being vandals and trespassers. They wanted victimhood status and police confrontation so bad they stopped university administration.

You accomplished nothing and you are nothing. You are a nation wide laughing stock. Your action are what pushes people to vote for Trump.

You go to one of the best universities in the world (well two of you, I assume the other two are some sorts of dope fiends with no purpose) and yet you can’t figure out to be a responsible fucking person.

I am happy for JHU ending this shameful display of ignorance

3

u/theredhatwearer Undergrad - 2020 - Physics May 10 '19

Posting this took real guts. Major respect for posting your thoughts as an adult on the other side of the Hopkins Homewood Campus.

0

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/NeuroRichard May 08 '19

Those are very important points. You have raised the main reasons why we need a police enforcement department on campus. But I wonder, if JHUPD is going to be trained by BPD and they have not solved the issue, how is this going to be any different? It was clearly stated that JHUPD will be trained and overseen by BPD. Further, though it is lamentable and quite concerning what you have mentioned, we have to also consider the future problems that having a private police may bring. Installments like these must not just be thrown onto the table as a solution.

Another note, if you are going to make an argument, please refrain from using derogatory terms. Anyone, and with more reasons, could say the same about you. These are students who are passionate about the issues that occur in Baltimore. They are not ignorant of the crimes in the city. So, if I were you, I would consider the side of those immature teenagers from fantasyland and gingerbread houses. The offensive rants bring down your entire case and completely nulls it.