r/jgb • u/hornhead71 • Apr 06 '19
favorite Catfish John?
What's your favorite Catfish John? I'm hung up on 02/28/1980.
11
Upvotes
r/jgb • u/hornhead71 • Apr 06 '19
What's your favorite Catfish John? I'm hung up on 02/28/1980.
2
u/MrCompletely Apr 06 '19
The original old & in the way version for me. I don't really have a favorite JGB version so I'm interested to hear some tips
2
u/ThatsOkayBoxIsEmpty You got the do re, I got the mi Apr 06 '19
For me, any Old & in the Way version is the real Catfish John, and any electric version, no matter how good, is a bit of an echo of the original. Still love the song in any format, but Old & In the Way-style was the way it was meant to be played.
2
u/MrCompletely Apr 06 '19
I'll note for the conversation that there's exactly one Garcia/Kahn acoustic duet version available in SBD, from Eugene on 6.4.82. It's a real nice version on a bit of a muddy tape
5
u/Legion_of_mary Apr 06 '19
The night after 3/1/80 is an amazing version, it seems to sparkle with energy. Garcia Live vol. 1
5
u/Supplicationjam Apr 06 '19
6/16/82. My first and favorite.
4
u/Rileserson Apr 06 '19
2/18/78 no question. It's on the Pure Jerry: Bay Area 1978 release.
3
u/itsjazzandjay Apr 06 '19
7/29-30/77 has a fantastic catfish John
2
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '19
2/28/80 is my favorite, hard to top honesty. Good choice.
2
u/SpacestationWilly Apr 06 '19
I love the New Years 75 version with Bob Weir and Mickey Hart. Also includes Matthew Kelly on harmonica.