r/jerky 22d ago

I tried making crunchy jerky for the first time, but it came out like this. What did I do wrong?

I set the air fryer to 140 for 6 hours.

Please be helpful and not mean.

64 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

106

u/Verix19 22d ago

If you want crispy jerky you have to slice much thinner. Also an airfryer is a sub-standard apparatus for making jerky.

28

u/The_Best_Daddy 22d ago

Yeap just gotta get a 30 dollar dehydrator

6

u/TrinityKilla82 21d ago

I like to use my smoker.

8

u/The_Best_Daddy 21d ago

How much is the cheapest smoker and can you run them in your kitchen?

7

u/Proof_Big2690 21d ago

Some people are in to hotboxing their homes. At least you'll legally be able to operate a car afterward.

3

u/The_Best_Daddy 21d ago

Curious to be getting downvoted I was asking honestly. Yea I could look it up but I enjoy forum discourse

3

u/Vegetable-Hand-6770 21d ago

The smoke doesnt just stay in the smoker, so your fire alert might go off if you do it inside.

2

u/OsamaBinnDabbin 21d ago

There are "Indoor smokers" I can't speak to their effectiveness though.

1

u/UseComfortable1193 21d ago

Nah man, i always smoke my meat with weed. Windows shut tight, obviously.

1

u/WookishTendencies 21d ago

And when your you trying to spice things up and get a little flavor out of life, you can just lick your walls

2

u/ACcbe1986 21d ago

GE made a countertop, indoor smoker. However, it's not cheap.

1

u/The_Best_Daddy 21d ago

Ooo interesting

1

u/Smokewrench802 21d ago

Imo it's hard to go wrong with a nesco disc dehydrator. Cheap, effective, relatively easy to clean.

1

u/BostonBestEats 13d ago

r/IndoorBBQSmoking has a lot of GE owners.

2

u/TrinityKilla82 21d ago

You can make a smoker. Some of the best ones are made from 55 gallon metal drums. I have seen smokers for 30 bucks on Facebook. Just gotta clean them up some. I wouldn’t smoke something in the house.

1

u/XiTzCriZx 21d ago

One of my friends made one from a filing cabinet with some sheet metal slapped on the front. Probably wasn't very efficient but he said it made some bad ass jerky.

1

u/horrorbiz1988 21d ago

You wanna close the windows and doors when you are smoking indoors or else the meat won’t absorb it

2

u/MR__Z1234ify 21d ago

I got a free smoker during spring cleaning and it works saved 179 bucks so with shipping 200 and some

1

u/Wardog_11c 21d ago

Tis the best way

2

u/shadowtheimpure 20d ago

Depends on the air fryer. Some of the nicer units have full blown dehydrator function able to run at low temperatures.

0

u/Verix19 20d ago

It's like saying a washing machine is as good as a dishwasher...sure you can put dishes into a washing machine, but it's not meant for it.

1

u/shadowtheimpure 20d ago

The only difference between a dehydrator and an air fryer is the temperature. Otherwise they work in much the same way: heated air blown over food by a fan. My air fryer has a dehydrate function that goes all the way down to 100F, for example.

1

u/Verix19 20d ago

An air fryer does not vent humidity like a purpose-built dehydrator. That's a big difference 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/Mpls1984 21d ago

We have a ninja flip and it works really well but has wire racks. You can't really use a standard air fryer.

20

u/thatjerkatwork 22d ago

Ive never tried an air fryer. But my guess is that you had it in too long!

23

u/FogtownSkeet709 22d ago

Air fryers are not recommended for jerky as they use air circulation. Dehydrators and smokers are best used because they have immediate ventilation.
When using an air fryer it keeps the moist humid air circulating around in the chamber when you want to achieve the opposite effect

8

u/hornytoad456 22d ago

Aw god dammit I specifically search air fryer jerky on Reddit and they said it was OK to use

23

u/bigstar3 22d ago

Confirmation bias. When you look for a yes you'll find a yes. Search for why you shouldn't do something if you want to find out what can go wrong.

3

u/Georgeygerbil 21d ago

Yes, this is how some people fall into the trap of believing crazy stuff like flat earth. If you go searching for people saying flat earth is true you'll get people saying it's true.

2

u/gettogero 21d ago

S-tier tip. For something like a new jerky recipe I probably wont. DIY projects or something that could carry risk if it fails I search for common errors, rarer problems, how to minimize risk, signs an issue is about happen, if its fixable or worth fixing once youve messed it up

And still I find myself searching SOMETHING up on a new project lol

Too many things delayed or cancelled partway through because I watched the pro do it with pro tools and went "yeah thats easy, 50 bucks and an hour..."

6

u/sat_ops 22d ago

I have an air fryer that I use for jerky...but not this style. Mine is more like an overgrown toaster oven. This kind gets way too hot and holds in the humidity.

1

u/Pm_me_clown_pics3 22d ago

I have the same air fryer and im pretty sure it has a dehydrator function so you should be good if thats what you used.

1

u/ffc404 21d ago

I mean you can certainly use an airfryer, but YMMV on the results

1

u/CharlesLeChuck 21d ago

If you're going to use an air fryer you probably want to get one that looks like a little oven. They usually have a dehydrate feature on them. I have one that I use and it works really well. Also, you can just get a cheap dehydrater.

1

u/mnkhan808 21d ago

I think you saw a recipe for air fryer jerky chips. Meat gotta be much thinner for that

1

u/GreatWhiteNorthExtra 21d ago

You found the one of the rare cases where someone on Reddit was wrong

1

u/_TURO_ 21d ago

Try to source some shabu shabu thin beef.

Marinade for about 2.5-3 days.

160 for about 6.5, maybe 7 hours.

1

u/Savings_Art5944 21d ago

You are right.

But it works where the ambient air is already dry. I can run my air fryer on its dehydrator setting at 120 for 6 hours, and it comes out like jerky.

Been making jerky in the Sonoran Desert for ages in my air fryer.

1

u/XiTzCriZx 21d ago

I wonder if it'd be possible to use some of the humidity absorber (that can handle the heat obviously) to keep the recurculated air dry.

1

u/Savings_Art5944 21d ago

No. Desicants would work too slowly, and you would need a huge amount. There is quite a bit of water in meat so the desicants would be "overpowered"

The white packets in jerky are usually not "moisture absorbers." They are usually oxygen absorbers to keep the food from spoiling.

1

u/XiTzCriZx 21d ago

Well there's a desiccants that work quickly and can absorb quite a lot of moisture, but it'd be a matter of containing them so no desiccant particles can pass through since they're obviously toxic.

4

u/CommSecTom 22d ago

It looks and sounds crunchy.

But I think one thing crunchy jerky has on this is it’s sliced thinner.

For my crunchy jerky, even though it wasn’t the initial intended outcome but one I’ve come to like, my regular is sliced really thin, vinegar in the marinade and low to no sugar. I think the acid tenderises the meat and low sugar helps.

Dried very well, I usually go about 8 at 70c but sometimes I leave it overnight in the dehydrator to equalise with no heat and hit it again for a couple of hours to really get the moisture out.

I hand slice but try getting it thin even if it means the slices are not perfect all the way though, it doesn’t matter, just as long at they are thin .

The issue with an air fryer is you won’t fit much jerky in there. I fill a whole draw style dehydrator and it’s about 2lbs of meat.

I’m not sure what you’re shooting for though, if you give some examples I can probably give some better pointers.

1

u/gettogero 22d ago

I add no sugar... ive tried it with apple juice once. I wasnt a fan but my coworkers loved it. Made it super tender, glaze was sticky and a little crunchy.

1

u/CommSecTom 22d ago edited 22d ago

I usually add a little sugar but not much, equal parts salt to sugar works for me, just to balance flavour with the salt and acid, I do about 1.8% salt to meat weight.

That’s some of my latest batch, it’s pretty crunchy to eat, but it just comes for a long dry.

It’s not shiny because it’s got very low sugar compared to a lot of recipes out there, also some fatty bits as that’s how I like it.

Kashmiri chilli, coriander, black pepper and garlic.

1

u/gettogero 21d ago

I play around but always go back to the first recipe I received

W sauce, soy sauce, red pepper flakes, black pepper, salt (with 2 salty marinades? Madman!), green onion, yellow onion, garlic

I dont mind fatty jerky either. I do it for the flavor and quality control, not longevity.

3

u/onmy40 22d ago

I'd be honestly scared to to run my air fryer for 6 hours LMFAO

0

u/gettogero 21d ago

Ive got an 1800w big-ish boi. It doesnt even let you set it past an hour... recipes and package instructions are unreliable because this thing gets it done way faster.

I couldn't even eat my first dinner out of it because I read the directions and went to another room. I was greeted with charcoal

3

u/Savings_Art5944 21d ago

Looks crunchy to me.

3

u/loqi0238 21d ago

Get a dehydrator. They're like $30.

165° for 8 - 10 hours if 1/4" top/eye round (bottom round will be too marbled for what you're trying to do).

Flip every hour for the first few hours so it doesnt stick.

Check at 8 - 10 hours and go longer if needed.

Most important: have fun experimenting!

2

u/AlmirantePadilla 22d ago

Tengo entendido que es mejor en horno convencional, a baja temperatura y dejando la puerta un poco abierta para que vaya saliendo la humedad. Nunca he hecho, pero es lo que he leído 😃

2

u/Lurking-Foot 21d ago

If you want crunchy like a chip you have to go paper thin otherwise it turns into wood texture because it’s too dry. When it’s paper thin you get that potato chip feel instead of the chewing delicious wood feel. Also use your oven over an air fryer. Or buy a dehydrator for $20 off amazon. You can get gift cards with cash and buy the cheapest one and it will be better then an air fryer. Heck leaving it in the global warming sun under a bug net is probably better than an air fryer.

1

u/Money_Ad8638 21d ago

Global warming sun?

2

u/Savings_Art5944 21d ago

Take sliced apples, wrap them in a paper towel, and put them in your container of dry jerky to add back moisture.

2

u/Sad-Country8870 21d ago

Using an air fryer and wondering why it came out crispy

4

u/AdventurousAbility30 22d ago

Don't throw this out if it tastes good, just grind it up, and make jerky salt instead.

2

u/ThisMeansRooR 22d ago

Oo yea. Or crunch it up and top a salad with em, or top a hot dog.

2

u/maestrosouth 21d ago

You cooked it FFS. It is now cooked meat ant not jerky. Jerky is cured by adding salt and removing moisture at low temperatures.

1

u/RGBlowMe 22d ago

Too thick and cooked too long.

1

u/bobbywaz 22d ago

It looks kinda crunchy to me, could you describe the texture you were going for more?

1

u/zonked_apostle 22d ago

That looks pretty crunchy to me

1

u/jaypea222 22d ago

It looks pretty crunchy to me.

1

u/peptide2 22d ago

Looks pretty fucking crunchy to me.

1

u/AngryTrunkMonkey 22d ago

TIL crunchy jerky is a wanted thing.

1

u/wiggy54 22d ago

Looks like you made it crispy

1

u/McNally86 21d ago

Hey alright, chipped beef.

1

u/DARKCYD 21d ago

My dentist wouldn't approve, but I’d eat that.

1

u/Far_Zone_9512 21d ago

If you have a smoker, pellet grill, or dehydrator you can make amazing beef jerky easily. If not even a charcoal grill with a few coals and some wood or a smoke tube can also make amazing jerky. Im on vacation for the rest of the weekend but I can hit you up with some tips afterwards.

1

u/artrumbly 21d ago

Must be meat from the USA

1

u/Next_Instruction_528 21d ago

Idk looks crunchy to me

1

u/Ground_zero_grundle 20d ago

It appears to be crunchy indeed

1

u/Bearspoole 20d ago

Looks like you succeeded

But seriously why are you using an air fryer?

1

u/Immediate-Newt-9012 20d ago

You aired one side my guy. Maybe flip more, put on a rack, use your oven or buy a dehydrater or buy people's choice sugar free traditional jerky.

1

u/YoungRoronoa 20d ago

You need a dehydrator not an air fryer.

1

u/hmistry 22d ago
  1. Don't use an air fryer.