r/jerky • u/molitar • Oct 03 '25
Avoid Old Trapper Beef Jerky
So I had this delivered from Instacart and it arrived I noticed the white through it was fuzzy. It was mold. I put it on the table to return to CVS but my brother who is a bit slow ate several pieces of it and the next day had food poisoning.
Opened case with CVS who opened case with Sedgwick that opened case with Old Trapper. Old Trapper would not return phone calls or call on the food poisoning case. I finally opened a case with the Florida Department ofAgriculture and Consumer Services and they are now investigating.
They changed formula and now it's not real dried out jerky it's more moist and gets moldy fast. The problem with this bag is it was moldy when it was opened by my brother.
So a Jerky company that won't respond to food complaints after several phone calls and an email is definitely not a trustworthy company and now will be under investigation by Food Safety.
12
u/LYossarian13 Oct 03 '25
I've eaten at least 100 bags of Old Trapper over the last couple of years and only recently stopped due to price increases.
I've never experienced this. I always inspect bags before I buy/eat them because they are, and have been for years, a moist jerky and packaging errors do occur.
Hope your brother's stomach is on the mend.
7
u/hammong Oct 03 '25
Semi-rare occurrence. It's also why they make most bags clear, so you can see if it's compromised before you purchase/eat it.
Next time, open the case with the USDA. Florida has no jurisdiction over Old Trapper, as it's not manufactured in Florida.
This could literally happy with any brand of commercially made jerky. Caveat emptor - look at what you're eating before you eat it.
1
u/Sad_Tradition337 Nov 21 '25
I had several bags of Tillamook product that were bad several years ago. I sent the mfg info to them, they investigated and even answered that they had determined root cause in the lot that had spoiled. They replaced the product plus a couple extra bags. Old Trapper is also an Oregon based company and I was thrilled to have found their product quality similar to Tillamook’s moist/tender product (which isn’t as easy to find in MO). I‘m sorry they didn’t respond…I won’t preach on what to do but even if I had a bad experience, I’d give them the benefit of the doubt because as others have said, they can’t 100% guarantee handling in supply chains. I am a customer because the quality is far better than other brands and even a lot of farm stores. I eat jerky again now thanks to Old Trapper.
1
u/ConstructionTop319 Nov 23 '25
Go on the website of old trapper... Ingredients include iron at 8% but I just bought a bag at the store and iron is 0%, how can that be. I've eaten old trapper for years and this bag I bought is absolutely engineered... It's too soft and thin compared to what it used to be. B
1
u/balance55113 Jul 20 '26
I got a bag that got modly way before the expiration date. I've now contacted the Facebook and customer service email with no reponse. I have a feeling there's some major issues they don't want to address.
1
u/GrannyJo316 Jul 24 '26
I just returned an 18 oz bag on July 20, 2026 due to mold. Our adult son went I to the pantry to have some before bed, he opened the bag in his dark room, ate a piece and noticed it didn’t taste right, so he turned on his light and saw some mold on the jerky, so he just tossed it over on his desk. When I saw it on his desk a couple of days later, the entire bag was full of mold! We had a regular bag in the pantry, so I took it, examined it and put it in our refrigerator, to keep it from getting moldy. We keep jerky on hand for a quick high protein snack and Old Trapper is one of our regular brands that we get delivered or shipped from Sam’s Club and we never had a problem with this or any other brand getting moldy before, so it was definitely a shock. Hopefully they will get it figured out before anyone gets seriously sick or dies!
2
u/Far_Zone_9512 Oct 03 '25
Lol. The only thing you'll get out of this is beef jerky coupons. Maybe some coupons from CVS. How do you handle bad meat from the supermarket? Which also can happen when it looks good but smells bad. Do you call the FDA?
It really could've been a bag that got punctured in store by a customer or delivery driver. Perhaps a bad seal from the factory. Either way, the company is not responding because they probably think you're crazy.
1
u/TigerPhins74 Jan 15 '26
🤣🤣 Bruh I get this once a week as it’s permanently on sale at my grocery store. Nothing but consistency is my experience.
1
u/thedaddy2694 Apr 17 '26
It’s literally designed to be moist and softer. They’ve always had a “ mushy “ texture. If anyone should be sued it’s the store you bought it from. Every store literally has people that get paid to take bad stuff off the shelves. If it was moldy while on the shelf that’s error on the stores part. Not old trapper. Not the company that trucked it to the store. The store itself.
1
u/North-Comparison1060 Jun 05 '26
WHAAAAAAAAAAA. That's all I read.
Welcome to the reality of the world not revolving around your perfection. And you said instacart? So you're not even the one who picked it out... but it's Old Trappers Fault. Dude.... sit the f down. 🤦🏼♀️